so we had james carville's voice under tim ryan's face. learning from the team now what went wrong there and let's move on. nearly a month after election day the harris campaign is still sending emails asking donors for cash. kamala harris's campaign spent $1.5 billion in 15 weeks. there are countries on the planet that can't do that. the emails notably don't mention the campaign's reported current debt. former clinton advisor james carville voice and face together watch. >> these fundraisers, they are really pissed now. the damage that the 2024 campaign has done, the damage this decade has done to the democratic brand is almost unfathomable. >> harris: maybe some people needed to hear that twice. one headline democrats try to figure out where they go from here. here is a quote. every aspect of the democrat's political project, who will lead the party? how they will counter trump and what adjustments they need to make to insure defeat like november does not get repeated it? it is all in flux. cassie, former rnc deputy communications direct

is james carville right?ala done this unfathomable damage in terms of -- is it because of her as a candidate to the democrat party, or is it because of the money that she wasted and is still trying to raise? >> jessica: out to get her to put it on kamala when biden was clearly part of this. the timeline goes back a year ahead when he could have bowed out. she might have been selected but i don't think it's fair to crusher with this. it's always always bigger than just one person, the kind of messaging. >> judge jeanine: trump was all about trump. >> jessica: yes, he was, and continues to be, and i wish him well on his second term. [laughter] i understand what tim ryan is talking about. sherrod brown has been extreme and successful statewide in ohio until this last election. i know that he lost, but these are people who have genuine working class bona fides and ways of talking about it. every demographic group, democrats underperformed with, except people with a college degree and a postgraduate degree. so tha

we'll joined by james carville in the flesh, in the gear. lsu, usmc. welcome back. >> thank you, ari. >> let's start straightforward. there's a range of serious allegations against hegseth. we do journalism, we report that his lawyers and others have denied them, but they seem to be causing enough concern that unnamed senators say they don't support him. >> the bottom of it is alcoholism and sexual harassment. these people never had one drink and never harassed one woman. you know what they got to know, and what the "wall street journal" knows, there's more coming. when jane mayer is on the case, she's on the case. i don't think she's through with this, but it feels like from your reporting and the reporting on this network that his nomination i'm sure is in serious jeopardy, but watch out because the next one up is not going to be much better, i promise you. there's always there, when it comes to alcoholism, when it comes to any kind of sexual issue. you don't do it once. >> what does it tell you about the world we're living in, your party went throug

our video of the day comes from the louisiana lizard man, james carville., we're going to give him some more. fired up after warming his belly on a hot rock, the cajun chameleon went off joe biden for blowing the election. >> if he would have in september of 2023 or august said that he wasn't going to run, [bleep], damn, we would have won this election. wouldn't have been that close. we would have so many fricking talented people that were running. all of this is [bleep] self-inflicted. it's tragic, it's sad. what is so sad, it didn't have to be this way. he bought it all on himself. at the bottom of this joe biden is and will continue to be the most tragic figure in modern american politics. actually feel for biden. he knows that he [bleep]ed up. it's a [bleep] shame. >> tyrus: are we sure he knows he [bleep] up? i think -- [applause] speaking of presidential call-outs, trump recently gave one to yours truly. >> i have so many friends. there's one. he was calling me earlier on. he was saying why are you going through this process? you know he's going to wi

james, does james carville have a point?make a difference to us when we find out it was spent? i don't know, 10 million boxes of wine? i mean, does it really matter at this point? well, first of all, where was he before? like he's saying this now after the fact, which is kind of lame. it was obvious all along. and he was defending kamala. they ran a terrible candidate. they ran a terrible campaign, and they mismanaged their finances. they had j-lo, beyonce, oprah, meryl streep and they still lost. yes, it was a terrible campaign. and yes, there needs to be an audit. you can't just spend money willy nilly. but what did anyone expect would happen? this is a party that thinks men can get pregnant. do you really think they can run a disciplined campaign and a decent candidate? i mean, they deny like, factual reality. yeah, because $1 billion, you didn't just lose a billion, you lost a billion. 20. i don't even know how to say that. a billion, $20 million. i don't know, and i don't care, i honestly don't and i don't think anybody

and i say that lovingly. >> raymond: my love to you and all the carvilles.istmas we will get together soon. new orleans is the only place you can see mary matlin, romero and donna brazile all at the same table. >> donna is in town this weekend. you will see her. she is in for the sugar bowl. you will see her for all of this on this holiday. >> raymond: sign me up. okay. coming up, there is an all-out assault on religion this christmas season. and the angle is fighting back. stay for that ♪ have you ever thought of getting a walk-in tub for you or someone you love? now is a great time to take a look at getting a safe step walk-in tub. with safe step's standard heated seat and new fast fill faucet, you can enjoy a nice warm bath up to 20% faster! safe step walk-in tubs are built to maximize safety. so you can stay in your home and enjoy the comforts of bathing again. call now to receive a free shower package plus $1,600 off! >> raymond: just in time for christmas. faith is increasingly under attack across the culture. if you open your social media feed you mig

our video of the day comes from the louisiana lizard man, james carville. just looking at him makes me want to reach for some moisturizer. oh, we're going to we're going to give him some more fired up after warming his belly on a hot rock, the cajun chameleon went after joe biden for totally blowing the election. check it out. >> if he would have in september of 2023 or august, said that he wasn't going to run. would have won this election and it wouldn't have been that close because we'd have had so many freaking talented people that were running all of this is self-inflicted. it's tragic. it's sad. with so sad. it didn't have to be this way. he bought it all on himself at the bottom of this, joe biden is and will continue to be the most tragic figure in modern american politics. i actually feel for biden, and he knows that he up. it's a shame. >> are we sure he knows he up? i think that's a. and speaking of presidential call outs, trump recently gave one to yours truly. check it out. >> i have so many friends sitting right here. there's one that i he was

bloomberg's olivia carville is here with another grand breaking story.me one of the leading causes of death among teenagers, killing more than 1600 people. all social media platforms are implicated. why is snapshot singled out? olivia: drug sales can be found on all social media platforms. what differentiates snapshot and why law enforcement is singling out snapshot is the platform was really built on the idea of disappearing messages. it thrives on evanescence. if you send a message within 24 hours, it is gone. unfortunately while the company was not designed for this what has happened is teenagers like using the platform when they do not want their parents to know what they are doing and drug dealers like using the platform because evidence of crimes is immediately deleted by default. caroline: in the story, the extent of use for drug sales becomes clear. we understand snapshot has removed two point 2 million pieces of drug-related content in 2023 and blocked many dealer accounts. we want to focus on snapshot's response. we are committed to fight again

. >> judge jeanine: by james carville fears it may be too late for a makeover and kamala harris blowingrable damage. >> these fund-raisers are really piston now, and the damage 2024 campaign has done, the damage this decade his dad is almost a battle for the campaign, the audit, the dmc pick so people should now, i'm telling you, without complete transparency, $2,005,000,000,000, do you haveh any ideaav where that money went >> judge jeanine: jessica, he says to .5 billion dollars -- 2.5. is he right, has kamala harris done this unfathomable judgement unfathomable damage because of c the party, or because of the money she wasted,? >> jessica: a thing there are a lot of factors that contributed to the loss, when joe biden was clearly part ofka it, the template goes back aen year ahead when he could have bowed out and said i was was to be a bridge, we have a primary or many primary and maybe kamala harris win hergott it is feasible, she has experience asb vice president, she may have been selected. >> judge jeanine: she was a candidate. >> jessica: i understand, it's always baker just one

i think carville is right. realize and this is what happens when you have a party not brought together by a philosophy. they are brought together by this weird identity politics thing where you put together a bunch of people based on gender, or race or whatever it is. like the tower of babel. it falls apart. the good thing about the maga movement there is a philosophical argument and republicans all along i think there has been a philosophical thing that joins them. makes things difficult sometimes. >> dana: they knocked on 2,000 doors in a half hour. [laughter] >> that number first election since 1932, it really is amazing. barry goldwater goes to a smashing defeat and flips counties, 1936 lon don loses badly. takes two states and flips counties, including two in texas. it is like this is just absurd that they could not break through. i think it is -- i think the problem is not necessarily they don't have an ideology. it's that the ideology they have depicted themselves as is d.e.i. and it is out of touch. it

james carville's point, we're going to need to 5:ed audit -- audit you, dnc. rye.e going through our show, transparency. whether it's in government, in these campaigns -- will: whether it's in hhs, what we're eating, take, medicines, transparency. sunlight. joey: the need for it is all of the distrust. that's really the root of this evil. will: on to a fox weather alert. millions get blasted with arctic air at dangerously cold temperature it is on one of the busiest travel weekends of the year. but the faa saying there was a record number of flights this week. rachel: upstate new york also getting slammed as the northeast gets hit with its first real cold front of the season. joey: yeah. fox weather storm specialist mike seidell is outside buffalo, new york. he's in the elements as he always is. mike, what you got? >> reporter: good morning, rachel, joe by and will with. we have moved off of dunkirk to get back in the snow band. the big story is the buffalo bills-49ers game, and the bills' mafia will be are over there, they're probably there right now, shoveling th

strategist james carville says that won't be easy, because democratic donors are still fuming. is going have trouble raising money. these fund-raisers are burnt. there really [bleep] now. the damage that the 2024 campaign has done, the damage that this decade has done to democratic brand is almost unfathomable. >> kayleigh: only one beep for james carville. normally there more. tim ryan agrees his party needs big change. >> you start with a complete reset. we need to rebrand. you and i have been talking about this since 2016. our brand is toxic and so many places. and it's like, you're a democrat? that's the stuff we get in ohio. we need a complete reboot. we need a complete reboot with the dnc. we need a complete rebranding. >> kayleigh: the question is, will they do that postmortem, harris? >> harris: i think it's fascinating that it's tim ryan doing that. remember when he ran against nancy pelosi and became readilyy apparent that they didn't want a new generation? they clamped down on him and mistreated him so much he might've thought he was bernie sanders. i think it is iro

a lot of media hand-wringing going on about why the democrats lost, and carville is saying the partyre identity politics now to blame for the democrats' demise? let me just say, let's put this in context. you know, democrats have won most of the popular votes in presidential elections going back to the clinton years. howard: not this time. >> not this time. but, again, if there's a line, a narrative coming from the trump people that says, oh, he won a mandate, in fact, he didn't even win the majority, just under the majority, 50%. so he won a plural till. -- plural i. you stop and think about it, the democrats are not exactly, you know, out of game. they're still a legitimate part. howard: they have no power in washington, juan. >> right. that's the key point, that they won the house, senate and white house, but they are not, in fact, like a goner. it's not like you're saying we don't know how democrats reconstitute. what they are is a party in december array, and i think -- disarray, and i think they are disspiritted. we saw after the 2016 victory, it looks like they are at sea this

i made jimmy carville democrat.ost: what does a blue dog believer folks who may not be familiar. >> we are working class democrats. we are not elitists. we are union people. you know, we have dirt under our fingernails. and sadly, we've been diminished -- it's a litmus test. she finished 20 on 20 and i still believe that biden, biden did a good job. building bridges around here as well. sam graves takes credits for it, he did not vote for it. but the thing is it was just too much. and it will be a guy like fedorman who has to bring it back. and you know what, i wish i had a dollar for every republican that called in on the independent line and you have a great day. howm about 10 -- host: 310 minutes left in open forum. caller: good morning. i just want to say, protect our troops, home and abroad. thapg them for their service and what not. we're coming to the end of a tumultuous year. i've lost a lot, i've learned a lot, i've been blessed a lot. we all have a lot to say and a lot it add and i think that's very import

bill from arizona, can we get carville a new hat?he the lsu tiger thing off his head. jean, what is the favourite christmas movie at the watters house? >> we don't watch movies around christmas time. i have never seen the famous christmas movie. what is the one that everyone watches? i have never seen it. never seen the wonderful life. never, ever seen it. jim from venice florida, jesse, you didn't give cat the hat. i forgot to hand it to her. she got it when she left. terry from kentucky, what is the deal. first you are against orgies now bubble bath and best friends, who hurt you jesse? i have issues. will kane definitely takes bubble baths. oh, yeah, and he takes two ounces lathered up. a sick man. >> welcome to the special edition of hannity, i am tammy

. >> reporter: james carville coined the phrase "it's the economy stupid."el palestine it's the settlements stupid. >> reporter: asaf sharon is a professor of political and legal philosophy at tel aviv university. >> we've spoken with settlers who say i didn't take anyone's land, no one was living here before me. >> well, of course it wasn't done individually. occupying a land doesn't mean you have a house on it. it can be grazing land. it can be land reserves for a future building. and it can be just the area that is reserved for self-determination of a people. >> settlers make a security argument, that israel is safer with the settlements. >> the security argument is completely bogus. the settlements are not a scurity asset. they are a security burden. because defending, protecting scores of civilians deep in densely populated palestinian territory is one hell of a burden for the military. number two, the best way to ensure israel's security is to have partnership with a state or state-like entity that has an interest in preventing precisely this kind of h

liz: bill clinton saying you're too finger wage and preachy and james carville said the same.on the far left. trump stopping dei throughout government and military and refocus agencies on day jobs. what do you think? do you think the period is over? >> i think dei should stand for didn't earn it, liz. not before but after and he got it all and bill clinton of 1995 talking and guy that passed down budget amendments and welfare reform and declared ere arrowhead of big government was over and threw out more people illegally than any other president. if more candidates like bill clinton and more competitive in elections and woke stuff and she supported u.s. taxpayer dollars for people in prison and effective in the campaign and can't run on this stuff and america doesn't like it one bit and bill clinton get it is and hopefully democrats as well. liz you're always really smart. thank you, joe. i'll wait for the check in the mail. >> venmo, my friend. it's coming. liz: good to see you, joe. thank you. >> they're grately impacted with what happens to the climate. >> we have to do mor

james carville is so -- james cowgill is so miserable he could barely unhinge his jaw to eat his morningthe outcome left barack obama so victor he vowed to move back to kenya. [applause] finally michele it was so she changed her name back to mike. [applause] live by the hoaxes? it is true, kamala harris got shellacked like a hardwood floor on this old house. and instead of an evening concession speech she avoided her supporters like hunter biden dodging child support. for the first time she was not laughing. although you have to admit this is pretty hilarious. watch. >> are there any places where kamala harris over performed from where biden did? >> we can show you that as well just bring that out there. harris over performing. >> holy smokes. literally nothing? >> literally nothing. >> by 3% or more. [laughter] >> greg: this is called a mandate. he won the popular vote by over 5 million. that cannot be explained away. the dems cannot give their usual ask -- excuses with more brought to fight but then a family reunion of the kardashians. migraine gains -- gangs might have to get a new re

james carville, my pal mary matalin. mary give me your thoughts on this.ple allowing ideology to intrude on family unity. >> i can't. i mean, raymond, come on. i mean, it's just, it's part of the larger problem, which is why i don't do tv anymore and i'm not a republican strategist, i never was a strategist, i was a utility player and i may become a republican again i'm so happy with what's being talked about and discussed and we want to see some outcomes and results. but politics is not a religion. it's like a cult. i bet those people who are saying you should avoid your family at holidays over politics don't have families. and if they do, they must be extremely dysfunctional. we have to get through -- listen, i came from a loud family, you married into a loud family, i created a loud family. we have a thousand things to shout about. everybody in the family disagrees with me. but we never -- we don't fight about politics. how does that. >> raymond: no. >> bread and circuses people have really lost their way but i think they're going to have to figure out

people like david axelrod and james carville raising questions about his fitness to run for office ar and a half before the election, joe biden had leaked to the major newspapers and ugly comment about david axelrod because david axelrod raised questions about his fitness. these people were being selfish starting with the president, his wife and his sister and close aides, they were involved in something bad for the country and bad for the democratic party and bad for the office of the presidency and bad for our country in a dangerous time where great challenges wait on us abroad to. it was not up to it. the scary thing is one of my favorite quotes out of the article, every time he went into the situation room, he was at the top of his game. no, he wasn't. he might have had a better moment in the situation room that a previous or the day after, but the i did this man was capable of serving president of the united states during this dangerous time is ridiculous and the idea able to run for an elected to serve another four years as we now know just underl. these people facilitated that

they became the party to quote james carville, the faculty lounge and coastal elite.s run against being a democrat they win. it's like i don't support my own party, are you crazy? john fetterman is a great example. how many times did he have to come out and defend israel and say we should have a secure border and while we're at it shouldn't destroy the jobs of the hard working people working energy in pennsylvania. all across the country the same message. democrats care about college educated white liberals. when they pay off their student loans the guy and gal in the truck working for a living turns around and says what about me? you can't do that. that's completely unfair. democrat party cares about impressing professors, republican party cares about impressing plumbers and that's the difference. >> julie: rich and joe, that's all the time we have. thank you both for coming on. i was only kidding. you are like a rising star, joe. you know how much i love you. i'm not sure about the suit but i love you. >> this is a great christmas. >> julie: rich and joe, thank you.

james carville hyperventilating just thinking about it. >> the fund-raisers are burned.issed now. the damage that the 2024 campaign has done, the damage that this decade has done to the democratic brand, is almost unfathomable. i would say policy number one, we are going to audit everything. we are going to audit the campaign. that's two and a half frickin' billion dollars. do you have any idea where that money went to? anybody have any idea where that money went? i have some places i'd start looking. the amount of money and the amount of lobbyists that were involved in this campaign is staggering. >> jesse: host of "the sage steel" show, sage steele. first of all, happy thanksgiving and merry christmas. i guess we are just saying it now, now that it's december. i've got to check my advent calendar. >> we are allowed to say it again. >> jesse: that's right, they are allowed to say merry christmas again, sage. wasn't a very happy holiday for some of the democrats. now they are all accountants and they want to know where the money went. how do you think that's going to go?

if james carville and the democratic party want to dive into this and find out where the money went inho stole it, god bless. go do what you want to do. it there is a country to run there is a new president in town and he is getting us on the right track. all of the stuff weather it is pardons or where the money went i do not think that anybody cares anymore. we have been force-fed so much b.s. for four years that we are ready to get back on track. [applause] >> tyrus: i am with bully, but i think for those who wrote the checks, the donors, they care. would you agree? >> i care because i want that to you. i did not write a check but i am kind of curious because everything we find out is interesting. i mean the amount of money that was just paid to celebrities, the amount of money spent on the call her daddy set. why not? i always want to see what money goes wear. and you know who probably wants to see the audits more than the donors of? jerry nadler. >> tyrus: why did he not get any? >> blaming jerry nadler for all of it. i would be pistol. >> tyrus: i get it if your kid is missing you

. >> bond markets are going to crush you and let james carville to say, when i was growing up, i thought next life i want to be like the bond market. because i think if you talk to carville now, you'll think a lot of democrats listen too much to the bond market. >> so, the question now is, is there the same sort of fiscal straight jacket going into the new term with the $36 trillion debt. the debt then was like, 3 trillion, $4 trillion, sympathy it spiked over the past few years. >> i will say musk, when he gets into focus demon mode, he really goes after things and he is worried about the deficit. he just thinks that this is going to kill the united states. and he -- i watched him. in my book, i talk about him going into spacex and lowering costs ten fold so that it is almost 100 the cost to get something into orbit that takes boeing or nasa to do. cutting 80% of the people at twitter, the big thing is when he does that at twitter, when he took it over, he owned twitter. he doesn't own the federal government. i read ed's piece and i turn to him and say, or i ask, at least, i think musk

and one quick programming note, earlier this week on the beat, james carville said that kash patel wastionship. coming up next, snl stars spilled the secrets about those legendary after parties. uragin nt you'll definitely want to hear. depending on the plans available in your area, you may be eligible to get extra benefits with a humana medicare advantage dual-eligible special needs plan. most plans include the humana healthy options allowance. a monthly allowance to help pay for eligible groceries, utilities, rent, and over-the-counter items. the healthy options allowance is loaded onto a prepaid card each month. and whatever you don't spend, carries over from each month. plus, your doctor, hospital and pharmacy may already be part of our large humana networks. so, call the number on your screen now, and ask about a humana medicare advantage dual-eligible special needs plan. and remember, annual enrollment ends on december 7th. humana. a more human way to healthcare. do i smell okay? [sniff] mhm. why are you shimmying? oh! unstopables now has odor blocker so i'll feel fresh all day,

nobody listens to james carville.on reduction act is going to cause inflation. they didn't want to listen to anyone. oh, this drives me crazy. it's better now, but think about ten years ago when ways was first coming on board and you got in the car and put in the address where he wanted to go and you were in ways and looking at, and you know, you've been to the grocery store 100 times, you know you just need to go this way but ways is taking you this way. >> jesse: why does it do that? >> dana: and why do you listen to it? this was the campaign, the harris campaign had all of these people saying no, no come over here, this is the way, this way, and they were like, nope, we are following ways, this is the way we are going. at the end of the road, okay, we got nowhere, telling you to go this way the whole time. karl rove had an interesting piece today in "the wall street journal." he listens to this thing harvard does every four years, the institute of politics, and as a campaign manager you go in and do an interview an

. >> james carville has been on the air with my colleague ari melber, saying the person who has a lot of influence over the trump administration right now is tucker carlson. elon musk, jd vance, kash patel, they are straight from the mind of tucker carlson. do you have any sense of the role he's playing behind-the- scenes? or do you have a thesis, or a hypothesis, on who is pulling the strings right now? >> you know, when you think about right-wing media you basically have fox news and rush limbaugh. he had a worldview, and he was a storyteller. when he died few people stepped into that void. the two that stepped inward tucker carlson, he had a narrative that he was driving that would filter down to the others. the other would be steve bannon. to james' point he's right about one thing, and that's tucker carlson's worldview, his narrative, and the story he's telling about america and the rest of the world, and it's not a good story, but a lot of the picks and personnel in the policies, and sort of the vibe of maga, what has become the professionalization of maga is coming from tucker'

because james carville is saying audit the campaign now, they wasted donor money. >> so good to see you, unfortunately for a lot of democratic donors. all the money in the world could not buy this election because there's something money can't buy. they cannot buy authenticity, and the connection with the voters based on the issues. donald trump didn't need billions of dollars to win this election. he went in with a strong message addressing the border, the economy, ending wars and ending the rise in crime. so kamala harris, unfortunately for the democratic donors, went ahead and spent crazy amounts of money for oprah a, beyonce and call her daddy podcast, and it resulted in her getting trounce thed not just in one battleground state, but all serve. elizabeth: yeah, she lost all seven. that's incompetent campaigning. to this new controversy hitting msnbc. by the way, the parent of that network is moving to sell it off, even possibly change his -- its name and split it away from the nbc division. the biggest u.s. coalition of black church leaders, the national black church initiative, no

but this actually is an homage to our friend, the carville man, who oftentimes comes on -- >> casual.. >> but we want to show georgetown love and pride. we have johns hopkins in the corner so we're good. >> do you have an all-time favorite georgetown player? >> me. >> there you go, baby. there you go. the ultimate player. sports is out of my realm. i just do the news, i just ask the questions, michael. i want to say, i want to say maybe patrick ewing played there in college, but i don't know. >> he did, he did, but you know. patrick, come on, seriously. steele. >> michael steele, can he dunk? we'll find out by christmas. good to see you. >> i'm going do pay for this one. >> great to have michael steele, speaking of players, the one and only snoop dogg is on "the beat" tonight. you'll hear from him by the end of the hour, and jacob soboroff, the documentary, trump's immigration plans past, present, and future. and authorities putting out new information about a person of interest in this horrific ceo murder in manhattan. n manhattan. you know, when i take the bike out like this, all my

. >> and we have james carville, paul begala, julian zelizer with us now. james, you say that the popular notion that carter was an unremarkable president, but a great post-presidency is not only irritating, but untrue. tell us about that. >> well, pick up the paper. >> what do you read about the middle east? there's no war. no one in egypt and israel is shooting anybody. why? because president carter, not now. trump has started this idiotic panama canal thing that will go nowhere. we forget that president carter did this if you fly it was president carter deregulated airlines. if you get goods by trucking, it was president carter that deregulated the trucking industry. now, i think it's just become too convenient a thing for people to say, well, he he was just an okay president, but he was a great man. he was actually a very significant president. he started the military build up. everybody remembers that reagan was the guy that had the military buildup that contributed to the end of the cold war. it was actually started under carter. so, yeah, it does kin

. >> and we have james carville, paul begala, julian zelizer with us now. james, you say that the popular notion that carter was an unremarkable president but a great post-presidency is not only irritating, but untrue. tell us about that. >> well, pick up the paper. what do you read about the middle east? there's no war. no one in egypt and israel is shooting anybody. why? because president carter, not now. trump has started this idiotic panama canal thing that will go nowhere. we forget that president carter did this. if you fly, it was president carter deregulated airlines. if you get goods by trucking, it was president carter that deregulated the trucking industry. and i think it's just become too convenient a thing for people to say, well, he he was just an okay president, but he was a great man. he was actually a very significant president. he started the military build up. everybody remembers that reagan was the guy that had the military build up, that contributed to the end of the cold war. it was actually started under carter. so yeah, it does kind

. >> reporter: james carville coined the phrase, it's the economy, stupid.ken with settlers who say, i didn't take anyone's land. no one was livng here before me. >> of course, it wasn't them individually. occupying a land doesn't mean you have a house on it. it can be grazing, land reserves for future building. it can be just the area that is reserved for self-determination of a people. >> reporter: settlers make a security argument that israel is safer with the settlements. >> the security argument is completely bogus. the settlements are not a security asset. they are security burdens. defending, protecting scores of civilians deep in densely populated palestinian territory is one hell of a burden for the military. number two, the best way to ensure israel's security is to have partnership with a state or state-like entity that has an interest in preventing precisely this kind of hostile activity. >> we have ideologues on both sides that are determined to thwart any accommodaton. >> reporter: this man is a fellow at the washington institute for near east

. >> so one wishful thinking would be, for example, james carville saying that trump was going to be a no show at the debate. right. and also those predictions like kamala winning, like biden winning based on the economy and things like that, and then the downright lies category, which were things like, oh, biden will never pardon hunter. at the end of the day, this is what democrats hoped for. and that's why at the top of this politico list is this symbol at the top. it was crossed fingers because this is what they wanted to happen. and about that predictor model, the whole point is that you cannot predict the human psyche, the human emotion, the fact that americans rose up had the end. their patience was totally spread thin. they said no more to this opaque, lying, treacherous administration that has destroyed our entire way of life from the economy all the way down. no more. no, no predictor model can ever say, oh, it's going to be based on these factors. no, the human emotion is far too strong. so is america. >> leo, what's on your list? >> well, i'll tell you right now, in addit

can we get carville a new hat? something red with white letters. he's close.ll got the lsu tigers thing. you can't take that off his head. gene or gene from etters, pennsylvania. what's the favorite christmas movie at the watters house? we don't really watch movies around christmas time. i've actually never seen the famous christmas movie. what's the one that everybody watches with the kid gets the shotgun or the christmas? i've never seen it. never seen a wonderful life. never ever seen it. jim from venice, florida. jesse, you didn't give kat her hat. i forgot. i couldn't believe how excited she was, and i just forgot to hand it to her. she got it when she left. terry from lexington, kentucky. what's the deal? first, you're against, now bubble baths. and best friends who hurt you. jesse, i have issues. brittany from saint louis, missouri. will cain definitely takes bubble baths. oh, yeah, and he takes two ounces each. lathered up. what a sick man. i'm watters. this is my world. >> welcome to this special edition of hannity. i'm tammy bruce in for sean. breaki

and even james carville, one of the democrats, warned what was going on.t these people still don't get it. trump is not a racist. he is trying to help the country out. he does not need this aggravation. they tried jailing him. they tried assassinating him. who knows who is behind this? i would say obama is behind it. he never considered himself american. he always considered himself a victim like these black liberal democrats. host: ok, we will leave it there. that is the end of open forum. we will continue on with guests for the majority of our morning today. first, we will hear from the tax foundation's erica york. a new analysis from her about how much wealthy americans pay in taxes in the united states. that is coming up next. later in the program, we hear from democratic representative paul tonko. he will talk about the upcoming deadline for funding the federal government and how democrats will navigate the 119th congress next year. that conversation is coming up on "washington journal." >> are you a nonfiction book lover looking for a new podcast? th

. >> the thing is, you know, save james carville's name and twitter explodes but it comes back to, it's the economy, stupid. you were out on the campaign trail throughout most of the year reporting from swing states across america. we would talk about the things that used to be judged in presidential races. we talked about job numbers being so good. talked about all the positive things that my professor in the one economics class said. there is an interview of a hispanic and he said he was angry because he could not vote for bernie sanders. this year he voted for donald trump because of the price of groceries, gas and everything. it didn't really matter if inflation dropped 2%. he is looking at the cumulative impact over the past four years and things were just not as good for him economically today as they were four years ago because of inflation. >> that connects to what i was righting about -- writing about about the dissonance people feel about giving up this idea about the party norms in democracy. people found out that this is a very low trust when it comes to politicians country.

james carville gave kamala credit for not leaning into her gender and ethnicity, but the party had become e , radiating the idea that identity is more important that humanity. we can never wash off the stench of it he said calling defund the police the three stupidest words in the english language. it's like when you get smoke on your clothes and you have to wash them again and again. now people are running away from it, like the devil runs away from holy water. what do you think? >> i think we could talk about this for four hours. i'm looking at this. it's stuff we have talked about, the trans add, which of course we have talked about time and again. rick wilson came on and showed an opposing ad. 30,000 times on nfl they showed kamala harris saying that she would support the funding of transition surgery in prison and taxpayers would pay for it. and it of course was law at the time during the trump administration, but they refused. despite bill clinton and everybody else saying you have to respond to this ad, it's impacting black men, white working class men. willie said after the electi

you might recall back in the early days of clinton, he was warned by robert rubin and james carville he had to play kate the bond vigilantes. he couldn't annoy them. you had to have fiscal discipline. i think the bond vigilantes have pushed bonds up 100 basis points on september 18th. so the fed fund rate is down 100 points and the ten-year is up 100 points. i think that's a pretty strong message from the bond vigilantes -- >> when you say bond vij lan tis, aren't you referring to the investors that are pushing fiscal discipline? >> yes. >> that's what you think is happening here? since the fed raised -- since the fed cut rates, hasn't it been that the economy has done really well, better than expected? that inflation outlook has gone up in light of the election and in light of the easing monetary policy? >> it's unrelated. i mean, inflation and fiscal policy and monetary policy are all clearly related. i think what the bond vigilantes were saying, we've gone through a couple of years where monetary policy was tight and yet fiscal policy was so loose that it triggered inflation. and

. >> by the way, james carville told me after the election he thought the biggest issue was a sense of disorder, which you just echoed here. there has been a couple of fleeting references and i want to go straight to that. i think it is fair to the consensus was vice president harris did well in that debate. won is a strange term to use for a debate but the consensus was that she won the debate. there was an expectation that would move the needle in a significant way. maybe it did briefly, but not substantially. for the group as a whole, why didn't that matter more than it did? >> i will say that i think it mattered. i think that what we often do, i did this discussion, in politics is, it mattered if the vote moved. that is how we measure if something mattered. did it devote move? it is correct that this debate did not move the vote. the assassination attempt's move the vote. that does not mean it did not matter. i contend her performance in the debate mattered a lot. in two areas. one, that was at the moment really where there was no more oxygen for the incompetence claim they wanted

. >> carville, winning is everything stupid. now streaming on max. >> this is not a drill.ce on all their subs. 20% off any sub, any size. >> subway did what? any sub. yep. >> for a limited time, you get 20% off when you order in the app. hurry and get this deal before it's gone. >> your best defense against erosion and cavities is strong enamel. nothing beats it. i recommend pronamel active shield because it actively shields the enamel to defend against erosion and cavities. i think that this product is a game changer for my patients. it really works growing old is part of the journey. >> even when you have heart failure. but when he had shortness of breath, carpal tunnel syndrome, and lower back pain we wondered, could these be warning signs of something bigger? >> thank goodness we called his cardiologist because these were signs of atcm. a rare and serious disease that gets worse over time. if you see any of the warning signs, don't wait. ask your cardiologist about atcm today with straight talks real unlimited data. >> say yes to unlimited streaming. yes. unlimited gif

. >> on fire on the left, james carville and paul begala.the right, robert novak and tucker carlson. >> in the crossfire. >> i remember when jon stewart went on crossfire, it was 2004. >> john kerry was the democratic presidential nominee, facing george w. bush. >> and i thought, you know, i was watching it. and i said, well, this is going to be a funny show. >> can i say something very quickly? >> uh, why why do we have to fight the two of you? can't we just say us? say something nice about john kerry right now. >> i like john, i care about john kerry. >> and something about president bush. >> he'll be unemployed soon. >> i think anyone who enjoyed paying attention to the news and watched the daily show will forever remember jon stewart going on crossfire and reading those guys. >> the riot act. >> you're doing theater when you should be doing debate, which would be great. no, it's not honest. what you do is not honest. >> what you do is partisan hackery. >> and i'll tell you why. >> i come on your show and you sniff his throne and you're a

years ago and worked in the clinton administration and i heard james carville, you me for my head and [indiscernible] taxpayers get more then money worth from somebody who is a trained lawyer and former prosecutor, department head, accomplished law maker, but when you throw your heart in for free, that is what makes you a extraordinary leader on gun violence, reproductive rights, domestic violence, public safety and so many priorities we share. grateful san francisco is going to continue to benefit from your leadership. you will continue to hear from me when i have ideas about legislation for the priorities we share and i know we will have opportunities to work together but i'm going to miss you and want to say congratulations and good luck and you will be hearing from me. >> supervisor mandelman. >> thank you president peskin. cathlen stefani, i feel so fortunate and lucky to have worked with you the last 6 and a half years. catherine told me on any number of occasions how many people warned her how crazy i am, and how difficult i would be to work with. and are what a pleasant surpri

carville winning is everything stupid now streaming on max the best part of the party snooping in the not listening to your dentist. make the sonicare switch for a champ. be gentle, be effective. >> be you i love you lowe's knows when it comes to the holidays. >> everything has to be seamless. save on lg's first ever zero clearance refrigerator that has near flush installation for the ultimate built in look. don't miss our best deals of the season during black friday in-store and online. >> remember when they said you've got your whole life ahead of you at unitedhealthcare we say you still do wouldn't it be nice if people older than we wouldn't have to wait so long? >> and wouldn't it be nice to live together in the kind of world where we belong? oh it's nice to know you're free to focus on what matters with reliable medicare coverage from unitedhealthcare your parents have given you some amazing gifts celebrate the ones you inherited with ancestry, dna explore the detailed family roots, cultures, and traits that shaped who you are today. >> for only $39. >> everyone's running to subw

i made jimmy carville democrat.hat does a blue dog believer folks who may not be familiar. >> we are working class democrats. we are not elitists. we are union people. you know, we have dirt under our fingernails. and sadly, we've been diminished -- it's a litmus test. she finished 20 on 20 and i still believe that biden, biden did a good job. building bridges around here as well. sam graves takes credits for it, he did not vote for it. but the thing is it was just too much. too much rainbow. we have to get back to our roots. host: what does that mean? caller: well, it's -- you know, men in girls bathrooms. men competing in women's sports. that kind of thing. that just doesn't fly here man. it just does not work. and -- we have to get back to the basics man and it will be a guy like fetterman who has to bring it back. and you know what john. i wish i had a dollar for every republican who called in on the independent line. and -- you have a great day john. host: about 10 minutes left an open forum. 202-748-8001 for r