criminalizing something like cellphone unlocking, even if larry is exaggerating that has been exaggerated for the practical effect of the copyright decision, criminalizing helps people the lanais the system. it certainly helps to demonize a system that is really great for artists in content creators. i am someone who thinks the librarian has gone way too far. do you want to respond to larry? i hope when you say unbalanced was presenting one side. that is what the book was meant to do. i do not think that the book says anywhere that i saw that copyright infringement is a victimless crime. when it says is you do have costs. at the same time, there are cost of over regulation where you can go too far. burglary.xample we could get rid of this if we had the death penalty. we do not do that. we have a sense of proportionality. the cost would be too high. what we need to do is strike the right balance. i believe in copyright. i believe it should be protected, but i do think in some cases we have gone too far. we get unintended consequences as a result. what we need is a balance. we need to strik

and to criminalize cellphone unlocking will get stronger overtime. second, we don't need to give the fcc any additional authority. recognize it is not ordinary for the commissioner to asked not to add to its power but they did not to -- create the mess and we're not in a position to clean it up it is of copyright law in congress should fix that problem directly. third, we should not interfere with the freedom of contract. consumers can choose from a wide variety of providers providers, plans, fell as. we should not restrict the carrier's ability to offer better faster and cheaper options. for, we should protect those to help consumers on lock their phone it can be as simple as dialing a code on your phone cahow. and i could not hold my phone at of a pocket to unlock it and i think others are in the same boat. helping consumers exercise their right to unlock the fund should not be a crime five. this debate was inspired by cellphone unlocking but there is action and much wider swath -- swath applying to pta, and a book, a tablet any mobile device. cons