. >> chair peskin: good morning. welcome to the rules committee meeting of the san francisco board of supervisors for monday, june 27. i am the chair aaron peskin joined by vice chair mandelman and remotely by committee member supervisor chan. our first meeting in this room in a couple of years. our clerk is mr. young. do you have any announcements? >> yes, the board of supervisors are now going to meet at hybrid meetings. while providing remote access by telephone. public access is essential. we will take public comment as follows. first will be taken on each item on the agenda. those in person will speak first. then we will take those who are waiting on the telephone line. those watching 26, 78, 99 and sfgovtv, the public call-in number is on the screen. the number is 415-655-0001. id24958144568. pound and pound. when connected you will hear the discusses and be in listening mode only. when your item of interest comes up, those joining in person line up to speak. on the telephone dial star 3 to be added to the speak

you, chair peskin.have questions. i do have comments to make why i came to this decision of cosponsoring early on. i want to be transparents. i did vote for prop p believing we can move our -- prop b. we can keep our streets clean. in conversation with city administrator and we have a committee as a whole hearing on that at that team. supervisor roman expressed frustration. how do things work. voters have to mandane. since then i have learned a lot more information that lets me make a decision. they needed time. we want to streamline staffing and al locate our resources and funding. >> chair peskin: thank you for your cosponsorship. anything on behalf of the city administrator, an expert in this matter. >> thank you for inviting me up higher. i think the interim director short covered a lot of the key points. i note one of the tricky things from awestruckuring perspective. the street cleaners are working with the cap stall burrows, building repair and street and sewer repair. they work closely with the

. >> chair peskin: good morning. g of the san francisco board of supervisors for monday, june 27. i am the chair aaron peskin joined by vice chair mandelman and remotely by committee member supervisor chan. our first meeting in this room in a couple of years. our clerk is mr. young. do you have any announcements? >> yes, the board of supervisors are now going to meet at hybrid meetings. while providing remote access by telephone. public access is essential. we will take public comment as follows. first will be taken on each item on the agenda. those in person will speak first. then we will take those who are waiting on the telephone line. those watching 26, 78, 99 and sfgovtv, the public call-in number is on the screen. the number is 415-655-0001. id24958144568. pound and pound. when connected you will hear the discusses and be in listening mode only. when your item of interest comes up, those joining in person line up to speak. on the telephone dial star 3 to be added to the speaker line. turn down your tv and listen

chair peskin. >> aye. >> motion passes without objection. >> could you return to item 1? >> yes item swon hearing consider appointing 7 members terms ending november 28, 22 to the urban forestry council. >> thank you mr. young. colleagues,s awe i'm sure are aware of the council advises estate departments and board and mayor on how to develop tree care standardses and city strategies to maintain and increase our tree canopy. majority of the members of this body seats expired during the pandemic but conditioned serve as hold overs and now is our time to appoint and reappoint individuals we have 5 applicants to 7 seats. the rules committee will hear applicants for the remaining 2 seats seats 2 and 4. at a future date. pamela for seat 3 who wants to condition to serve is actually out doing a tree survey today in the cents ral valley. she is qualified. and has served currently on the council. with that, why don't we take the individuals in the order this nay appear on the agenda. starting with morgan vi

chair peskin. >> aye. >> motion passes without objection. >> could you return to item 1? >> yes item swon hearing consider appointing 7 members terms ending november 28, 22 to the urban forestry council. >> thank you mr. young. colleagues,s awe i'm sure are aware of the council advises estate departments and board and mayor on how to develop tree care standardses and city strategies to maintain and increase our tree canopy. majority of the members of this body seats expired during the pandemic but conditioned serve as hold overs and now is our time to appoint and reappoint individuals we have 5 applicants to 7 seats. the rules committee will hear applicants for the remaining 2 seats seats 2 and 4. at a future date. pamela for seat 3 who wants to condition to serve is actually out doing a tree survey today in the cents ral valley. she is qualified. and has served currently on the council. with that, why don't we take the individuals in the order this nay appear on the agenda. starting with morgan vi

>> chair peskin: oh, city controller. go ahead. >> good afternoon, chair peskin.m with the controller office. this charter amendment do likely in minimal to moderate saving to city government to the extent that the proposed measures will result in future amendments. >> chair peskin: if i had to write it, i would strike to moderate. >> i will take that into consideration. we can all update the letter to reflect comments. i can also provide a little bit of context to your office with what our thresholds are for determining that and some of our thinking. >> chair peskin: happy to take offline. when you have a payroll and pension the size of this city, i can't imagine. why don't we open up item 2 up to public comment. >> clerk: members of the public who like to provide public comment you can line up to speak. for those listening remotely please dial (415)655-0001. enter the meeting i.d., 2491 588 6137 # #. i do not see anything in -- see anybody in the room. we have one caller on the line. >> chair peskin: first speaker. >> caller: this is david pilpel. it will be gre

thank you, chair peskin. the accountability proisz, for any rules violations get can and will initiate a personnel complaint investigation. that is handled by internal affairs division the other per of this because of 19 b and the report thanksgiving goes with this, is that the logs and anything having to do with surveillance by design of the ordinance you weigh on. is -- logd and it is transparent to the public. the impact reports a part of was explained by the part of the process. but for if a member of the public believes a violation occurred there is i process internal and ecsternally in terms of bringing that to light and the investigation internal low will be done by internal affairs. this process is only as good as the systems we put in place to make sure that we don't wait until there is an incident to address it all the forms that have been created and some need to be developed, if this gets passd and we see what it looks like, there will be a strict reporting process for this the last thing we want

thank you chair peskin. good morning vice chair mandelman, supervisor chang. peskin, supervisor peskin thank you for your commitment of diversity always in the commission as long as well as in community organizations throughout the city. this waver is just for a over abundance of transparency and caution and the work we do in the community. started in the pandemic, part of the latino task force coalition and what it does is provide direct service to latino and lutina entrepreneurs throughout the city and like supervisor peskin said, i'm from the community, so as a small business owner myself, that is how i can relate to my community because i can't preach what i don't know. i appreciate and humbly request that you approve this waver to bring forth to the full board. appreciate you and i have a great day. >> thank you commissioner carter. >> good morning supervisors. i am tiffany carter and serve on the small business commission. i appreciate your consideration and support of the advance written determination before you today so i can continue to represent women

thank you, chair peskin. the accountability proisz, for any rules violations get can and will initiate a personnel complaint investigation. that is handled by internal affairs division the other per of this because of 19 b and the report thanksgiving goes with this, is that the logs and anything having to do with surveillance by design of the ordinance you weigh on. is -- logd and it is transparent to the public. the impact reports a part of was explained by the part of the process. but for if a member of the public believes a violation occurred there is i process internal and ecsternally in terms of bringing that to light and the investigation internal low will be done by internal affairs. this process is only as good as the systems we put in place to make sure that we don't wait until there is an incident to address it all the forms that have been created and some need to be developed, if this gets passd and we see what it looks like, there will be a strict reporting process for this the last thing we want

thank you so much, chair peskin and we can go to public comment. thank you. >> >>supervisor aaron peskin: thank you. why don't we open to public comment. >> supervisor # mendleman, >> thank you, i'm very excited for all the work and to director and ms. lamb and the providers and would like to be added as a cosponsor. all right. now why don't we go to public comment on item no. 2. let's go to your right and my left. yes, members of the public who wish to speak on this item and joining us are invited to join us. please call (415) 655-0001 enter the meeting no. 2950080. >> once connected you need to press star 2. >> that are be your queue to begin your comment. >> we have our first speaker. public speaker: good morning, my name is -- the director of early learning. our organization of the children and families and educators of family system and dozens of # community based organization and would like to thank you and mayor london breed for this important piece of legislation. as you know as you mentioned the years 0-5 are critical in a child's life and

thank you so much, chair peskin and we can go to public comment. thank you. >> >>supervisor aaron peskin: thank you. why don't we open to public comment. >> supervisor # mendleman, >> thank you, i'm very excited for all the work and to director and ms. lamb and the providers and would like to be added as a cosponsor. all right. now why don't we go to public comment on item no. 2. let's go to your right and my left. yes, members of the public who wish to speak on this item and joining us are invited to join us. please call (415) 655-0001 enter the meeting no. 2950080. >> once connected you need to press star 2. >> that are be your queue to begin your comment. >> we have our first speaker. public speaker: good morning, my name is -- the director of early learning. our organization of the children and families and educators of family system and dozens of # community based organization and would like to thank you and mayor london breed for this important piece of legislation. as you know as you mentioned the years 0-5 are critical in a child's life and

thank you chair mandelman. >> thank you vice chair peskin. and and well, staff can think about whether we need to pull this piece out and think about it or make a change here or -- commissioner melgar. okay. thank you. chair mandelman. i wanted say thank you so much to staph for the inclusion of the increase in the paratransit allocation. i then and there is something the communities requested. we -- i was very luck tow have been in communication with jodi who was active in this conversation. and there are so many seniors in district 7 whop live up the hill who rely on paratransit. having the foresite to see that other funding extremes or making up for the prop circumstance funds is great. thank you for taking care of our seniors and disabled. >> thank you. commissioner safai. no clean city from the w than i do in my district they are district 11 based small contractor i think they do good work i see them out in district lefrn we planted more trees than any other part of san francisco over 2,000 trees. they other main water approximate contrac

. >> chair peskin: good morning. he rules committee meeting of the san francisco board of supervisors for monday, june 27. i am the chair aaron peskin joined by vice chair

. >> chair peskin: good morning. welcome to the rules committee meeting of the san francisco board of supervisors for monday, june 27. i am the chair aaron peskin joined by vice chair mandelman and remotely by committee member supervisor chan. our first meeting in this room in a couple of years. our clerk is mr. young. do you have any announcements? >> yes, the board of supervisors e

. >> chair peskin: good morning. e to the rules committee meeting of the san francisco board of supervisors for monday, june 27. i am the chair aaron peskin joined by vice chair mandelman and remotely by committee member supervisor chan. our first meeting in this room in a couple of years. our clerk is mr. young. do you have any announcements? >> yes, the board of supervisors are now going to meet at hybrid meetings. while providing remote

thank you chair mandelman. >> thank you vice chair peskin. think about whether we need to pull this piece out and think about it or make a change here or -- commissioner melgar. okay. thank you. chair mandelman. i wanted say thank you so much to staph for the inclusion of the increase in the paratransit allocation. i then and there is something the communities requested. we -- i was very luck tow have been in communication with jodi who was active in this conversation. and there are so many seniors in district 7 whop live up the hill who rely on paratransit. having the foresite to see that other funding extremes or making up for the prop circumstance funds is great. thank you for taking care of our seniors and disabled. >> thank you. commissioner safai. no clean city from the w than i do in my district they are district 11 based small contractor i think they do good work i see them out in district lefrn we planted more trees than any other part of san francisco over 2,000 trees. they other main water approximate contractor. i think they do ste

. >> chair peskin: good morning. e to the rules committee meeting of the san francisco board of supervisors for monday, june 27. i am the chair aaron peskin joined by vice chair mandelman and remotely by committee member supervisor chan. our first meeting in this room in a couple of years. our clerk is mr. young. do you

i am chair mandelman and supervisor peskin is our vice chair and today we have our new clerk and welcome and to angela for being the acting clerk the past several months and also i want to thank michael at sf govtv. mr. saunders could you please call the roll. >> yes chair. commissioner chan. >> present. >> chan present. commissioner supervisor dorsey. >> present. >> commissioner mandelman -- excuse me chair mandelman. >> present. >> mandelman present. commissioner mar. >> present. >> commissioner melgar. >> present. >> commissioner preston. >> present. >> commissioner supervisor ronen. supervisor ronen absent. supervisor safai. >> present. >> commissioner stefani. absent. commissioner walton. >> present. >> thank you mr. clerk. and actually i am -- i have been requested to excuse commissioner stefani which i'm going to do. and i believe you have public comment announcements. >> i do thank you. for members of the public interested in participating in the meeting we welcome your attendance in presence in room 215 city hall or may watch capable channel depending on the provider or stream t

surprise chan. >> aye. >> mandelman. >> aye. >> chair peskin. why aye. >> the motion passes without objection. >> thank you, good work supervisor ronnin. item 6. >> yes. charter amendments second draft amend the charter of san francisco to set forth a >> reporter: that when the city admins the planning cold for density or height the developer agrees to subject the new residential units in the development other than affordable house to rent control and election to be held on november 82022. there is a request to sends this out as a committee report. >> thank you. mr. young and colleagues. you are in receipt of a change to the findings set forth on page 6 that references -- a steady on rent control in new york called rent regulation myth and facts. and i would like to amend that finding into the legislation. and not sends this as a committee report but continue the item as amended to our meeting of the 18th. this is all i are to say about this item that we have discussed. over a number of meetings. with that why don't we open this up to public com

thank you chair mandelman. >> thank you vice chair peskin. and and well, staff can think about whether we need to pull this piece out and think about it or make a change here or -- commissioner melgar. okay. thank you. chair mandelman. i wanted say thank you so much to staph for the inclusion of the increase in the paratransit allocation. i then and there is something the communities requested. we -- i was very luck tow have been in communication with jodi who was active in this conversation. and there are so many seniors in district 7 whop live up the hill who rely on paratransit. having the foresite to see that other funding extremes or making up for the prop circumstance funds is great. thank you for taking care of our seniors and disabled. >> thank you. commissioner safai. no clean city from the w than i do in my district they are district 11 based small contractor i think they do good work i see them out in district lefrn we planted more trees than any other part of san francisco over 2,000 trees. they other main water approximate contrac

i am chair mandelman and supervisor peskin is our vice chair and today we have our new clerk and welcome and to angela for being the acting clerk the past several months and also i want to thank michael at sf govtv. mr. saunders could you please call the roll. >> yes chair. commissioner chan. >> present. >> chan present. commissioner supervisor dorsey. >> present. >> commissioner mandelman -- excuse me chair mandelman. >> present. >> mandelman present. commissioner mar. >> present. >> commissioner melgar. >> present. >> commissioner preston. >> present. >> commissioner supervisor ronen. supervisor ronen absent. supervisor safai. >> present. >> commissioner stefani. absent. commissioner walton. >> present. >> thank you mr. clerk. and actually i am -- i have been requested to excuse commissioner stefani which i'm going to do. and i believe you have public comment announcements. >> i do thank you. for members of the public interested in participating in the meeting we welcome your attendance in presence in room 215 city hall or may watch capable channel depending on the provider or stream t

>> >> transportation authority personnel i'm mandelman our vice chair is peskin, commissioner ronen will be here shortly the clerk is angela tsao and michael with sfgovtv. can you call the roll. >> yes. want to make sure that the we can hear the mics and teams. was i -- so -- one moment here. roll call. commissioner mandelman. >> present. >> commissioner peskin. >> present. >> commissioner ronen. present. we have quorum. >> great. i think you have public comment announcements. >> yes , sir. >> for members interested in participating in this board meeting we welcome your attendance in person and the legislative chamber room 250 and city hall you may watch channel 26 or 99 depending. and stream live on sfgov.org. wish to whent remote dial 415-655-0001 enter code 24928793483. and press pound and pound again. you will listen in role time. when comment is called for the item you wish to speak on press star 3 to be added to speak. don't press it again or you will be removed from the queue. when the system says your line is unmuted the operator will advise you you will be allowed 2 minutes to s

i'm rafael mandelman i chair the vice chair is aaron peskin the clerk is angela tsao. and then before calling the roll i want to note that

. >> chair peskin: good morning. lcome to the rules committee meeting of the san francisco board of supervisors for monday, june 27. i am the chair aaron peskin joined by vice chair mandelman and remotely by committee member supervisor chan. our first meeting in this room in a couple of years. our clerk is mr. young. do you have any announcements? >> yes, the board of supervisors are now going to meet at hybrid meetings. while providing remote access by telephone. public access is essential. we will take public comment as follows. first will be taken on each item on the agenda. those in person will speak first. then we will take those who are waiting on the telephone line. those watching 26,

. >> chair peskin: good morning. lcome to the rules committee meeting of the san francisco board of supervisors for monday, june 27. i am the chair aaron peskin joined by vice chair mandelman

i am chair mandelman and supervisor peskin is our vice chair and today we have our new clerk and welcomeing clerk the past several months and also i want to thank michael at sf govtv. mr. saunders could you please call the roll.

i'm rafael mandelman i chair the vice chair is aaron peskin the clerk is angela tsao.n before calling the roll i want to note that supervisor

i am supervisor melgar chair joined by supervisor dean preston and supervisor aaron peskin. we have the honor of welcoming president walten here today. the clerk is erika major and i would like to acknowledge and thank the folks at sfgovtv for staff thanksgiving meeting. do you have announcements >> the board of spreerzs and committees are convening hybrid meetings. provides remote access and public comment i have phone. board recognizes equal access is essential and taking comment first from the agenda in person will be allowed to speak first and move to the remote public call line. watching channel 26, 28, 99 and sfgovtv the public call in is streaming across the screen. 415-655-0001. ern id24824688356 and pounds, punld. you will had been but mute exclude in listening mode. when your item come up dial star 3 on the call in line and in person line up near the curtains. if you are on your phone turn down your tv and all listening devices. we be taking comment for those in person first. and then go to the public comment phone line. you may submit public comment in writing and

peskin. welcome. >> chair lee, commissioners, staff, to the ethics commission, my name is aaron peskin. i am the primary author of what became proposition e on last month's ballot and-sorry, was that last month? it was last month. and, am pleased to be before you today. the staff report gives the history of behested payments. when i first started as a supervisor 22 years ago, it was a completely unregulated field of ethics law. there was no behested payments reporting. the word behested payments didn't even exist, but over the succeeding 20 years it is now regulated at the state and local levels and appropriately more and more so and as the staff report indicates in the wake of the 2020 revelations about corruption by in one case a department head, we heeded the calls of the ethics commission and the controllers public integrity report and my then colleague supervisor haney drafted legislation, which ultimately became law in december of last year, with many modifications made along the way. by way of candor, i became concerned that there were efforts to revisit that law and brought prop