because the server was in chappaqua, new york. so we have placed since the 1970s and the presidency of jimmy carter, immense significance on open government and the access to public records. this system was designed to deny access to public records, for four years, records that belonged to the people of the united states, not mrs. clinton. >> the next call, christina in rochest rochester, michigan, independent. go ahead. >> reporte >> caller: yes, mr. digenova, i have been aware and watched you and your wife for years now. you and your wife are very, very republican. i've got a couple things i'd like to ask. do i have a right to know, as a citizen, what cheney and jill aby were talking about? how come we still haven't found out who cheney met with way back in 2001 for energy? we weren't allowed to find that out. so when it comes to republican things, i want to know where have you prosecuted or given all your wonderful experience when it comes to anybody republican? >> and just to add on to what she had to say, this tweet from jack

guest: why was the server put in chappaqua?is put there and there were no records of a government account. here is how we know. when people file freedom of information act request to the state rep armen -- to the state department, they got a no records response. weregot back saying there no records. no records from the secretary of inte on any e-mail accounts the state department. alarm bells should be going off everywhere in the state department. yet they did not. the state department filed affidavits under oath there were no records. at the same time, there were people in the state department who knew mrs. clinton had no government account but that all of her e-mails were going through a private server, unsecured, in chappaqua, new york. this server was set up to do exactly what it accomplished. it was designed so no records would exist at a state department. so when freedom of information act requests were filed there, the record -- the answer would be we have no record. judge sullivan just issued an order allowing judicial

senator and has lived in chappaqua for nearly two decades. sanders was born and raised in brooklyn and needs a lead to cut in to clinton's big lead in delegates. when new yorkers go to the polls in just a few weeks there will that's the second highest number of any state other than california. the sanders rally set to start at 7:00. rob nelson, channel 7 eyewitness news. >>> as we continue with eyewitness news at 6:00 on this thursday night, some teenagers in our area accused of passing very expensive counterfeit bills. and getting central park ready for warmer weather. what does it take to mow all those hundreds of acres of lawn? >> 15 acres, looking great. supposed to open this weekend weather permitting. we're really warm to end march here. fourth warmest march on record. we're at 67. got showers and stormy weather to tell you about to end the week. then we'll have your accuweather fios is not cable. we're wired differently. we are a 100% fiber optic network... and fiber optics move at the speed of light. over the last 10 years, our cable

immunity by the justice department helped set up the e-mail server back in '09 at clinton's home in chappaqua, new york. a spokesman added yesterday there's no evidence whatsoever that the server was hack sno snood -- hacked. >>> clinton and bernie sanders will meet in flint, michigan, and then next tuesday, voters will head to the polls. sanders is seizing on the issue of trade. arguing that clinton's policies in that area have hurt michigan and the country. >> was she right to support nafta? was she right to support permanent normal trade relations with china? the answer is she was very, very wrong and millions of families around this country have been suffering as a result of those disastrous trade agreements. >> now the sanders campaign posted this collage of pictures along with caption, the people of detroit know the real cost of hillary clinton's free trade policies. but the clinton camp has fired back to sanders' criticism. on a conference call yesterday, jake sullivan said that sanders has been quote sanders has been awol when he could put up proposals. >>> kim jong-un is urging his m

he helped to set up the server in 2009 at the home -- at the family home in chappaqua and he was paid as a consultant. the justice department declined comment as did pagliano's attorney. as for the clinton campaign, a spokesman said they urged him to give evidence in 2013, instead, he invoked his fifth amendment rights. top senate committee chairman also offered him immunity to testify at the time. since the discovery t server has been at the center of headlines. a federal investigation and a political tug of war between both parties. new york times reports that the fbi could seek to question the former secretary of state and top aides and that the investigation could be wrapped up by may. the campaign told the paper they have been cooperating and offered in august to meet with justice department if needed. earlier this week, the state department released the last trove of the more than 50,000 pages of clinton's personal e-mails. more than 2,000 were marked classified retroactively. 22 were the highest level of sensitivity, top secret. clinton and the state department have said that n

pagliano worked on a clinton campaign and helped set up the server in 2009 in the family home in chappaqua and was paid as a consultant. the justice department declined comment as did pagliano's attorney. a spokesman said he is pleased pagliano is cooperating with the doj noting they urged him to give evidence in september of 2015. instead he invoked his fifth amendment rights while appearing before a closed-door meeting of the benghazi committee. top senate committee chairmen also offered him immunity at the time to testify, something has changed. since its discovery, the server has been at the center of headlines, a federal investigation and a political tug-of-war between both parties. the "new york times" reports that the fbi could seek to question the former secretary of state and top aides in the coming weeks and that the investigation could be wrapped up by may. her campaign told the paper they've been cooperating and offered in august to meet with the justice department if needed. and earlier this week the state department released the last of the trove of more than 50,000 pages of

meanwhile in chappaqua, a downed tree and power lines have route 120 closed in both directions between douglas road and kip street. take it easy out there, everybody. alternate side parking is in effect citywide. back to you. >> thank you, kyla. >>> thousands of volunteers are trying to bring back a therapy dog who vanished on long island two weeks ago. >> tattoo helped michael recover from the latest multiple heart surgery since he retired from the nypd four police believe someone snatched the yorkshire terrier near the pooch's home. complete strangers stepped up to help find him. there's even a facebook page and go fund me page for tattoo. >> tattoo just isn't a pet. he's actually one of our children. he's our family. >> there is also a $2,000 reward to bring him home. no questions asked. >>> let's check in with cbs this morning. gail king and charlie rose have a preview. >> good morning. >> we're comparing footwear. don't you like this tennis shoot shoe look? >> i like it. >> i like yours, too. >> i think he should start a tennis shoe line. >> he'd have some competition. >> but ther

news exposed, revealed and expounded upon the existence of the secret e-mail server at her home in chappaqua turned out there were 66,000 e-mails but the state department, in fact, didn't have them. the state department has been so dragging its feet in getting the e-mails from mrs. clinton into the hands of those, judicial of watch, who have legitimately ordered them that two federal judges -- one appointed by president clinton, one appointed by president reagan -- both ruled the same thing. the second just a few minutes ago. the ruling is very interesting. there may have been a conspiracy in the state department to avoid transparency, and if so, that's a violation of federal law. so i, these two federal judges have ruled, am going to authorize you, judicial watch, to take depositions of mrs. clinton's senior aides from the state department. where are those senior aides today? they're in her campaign. and depending upon the answers they give you to these examinations under oath, come back to me, and i may authorize you to take mrs. clinton's deposition about what she knew, when she knew abou

to former white house staffer who helped set up the private server clinton housed at her home in chappaquaw york, when she was secretary of state. last september called in front of a congressional panel he invoked his fifth amendment right refusing to answer any questions. in a statement, a clinton spokesman says, the campaign is pleased pagliano is cooperating with doj, noting we urged him to cooperate back in the fall. >> i haven't even started on hillary yet. >> reporter: political opponent donald trump is already vowing to play the e-mail card if they faceoff in november. >> i guarantee you one thing, we're going to be talking about those e-mails every moment of every day. >> reporter: kristen welker, nbc 10 news. >>> after nearly a year on the international space station, astronaut scott kelly is back home in houston this morning. [ applause ] kelly arrived at ellington airport to applause near the johnson space center just after 2:00 this morning. the hugs from his girlfriend and his two daughters, his twin brother, retired astronaut mark kelly and his sister-in-law former arizona co

the next day is when brian pagliano began the migration of the two streams to her server in chappaqua course not. >> there were 2,093 emails exchanged containing classified. and over 20 that were so classified, they couldn't be listed in the mountain of evidence. >> so classified that the fbi agents investigating her lacked the security clearances to examine them. >> lastly, the timing. when are we going to find out what's going to go if anything? >> the timing is treacherous. i would think that democrats need to know whether or not they're about to nominate somebody for president who might be a criminal defendant in a felony prosecution before november. they should know that now. >> you would think they might feel pressure from somebody somehow to get this done before. >> prediction, something will happen by may. >> a story in "the washington times" and "washington post" all about this today. thanks for boiling it down for us. >> you're welcome. >>> 11 before the top of the hour. just heard from the judge about hillary clinton's e-mail probe as you know. donald trump reacts in about

do you go with chappaqua or manhattan?> you've got two basically new york moderates we'll call them who will be the nominees for their parties. trump very impressive last night. cruz more impressive than we thought winning three states. i thought it was interesting to watch all the speeches. donald trump looked like a president who had just -- was holding a news conference in the east room. he had all the staging. >> but can i say, though, it was a beautiful east room. >> more beautiful. >> a lot of gold. >> fancy one. >> it was a fancy east room. >> so you had trump there, you had hillary clinton talking purely about the general election saying we need love and kindness saying the rhetoric on the republican side is no good. she's pivoted. then you had ted cruz who felt like he had a good night winning three states saying to everyone else besides donald trump in the republican field, politely "guys, time to get out. it's me versus donald trump." obviously marco will stay in and try for florida and kasich for ohio. >> exact

that was the one in hers now chappaqua. early on there were concerns about clinton using a blackberry in the so-called mahogany row era of the state department because of previous espionage attempts. according to the "post," when a stop state department official told clinton "any unclassified blackberry is highly vulnerable in any setting to remotely and covertly monitoring conversations, retrieving e-mails and exploiting calendars." nine days later, clinton told the official that she had read his memo and gets it. according to an e-mail sent by a senior diplomatic security official. but according to the paper, clinton kept using her private blackberry and the basement server. vice news notes that more than 1800 e-mails were withheld or heavily redacted under exemptions to the freedom of information act, including 22 that were not released because they were deemed top secret and would cause "exceptionally grave damage to national security if disclosed." >> ron foreignier, th ifourniere here. hillary clinton and her team hav

process of diverting state secrets from the state department email server to the clinton server in chappaquae about. who was behind it and who knew about it. martha: clearly we're beyond the point where he is saying, i have no idea, you know? i'm just the guy who was, can you please do this today so i did it today? i went over and set it up. i have no idea why. >> before immunity is granted he and his lawyers sit in room with justice department prosecutors use crazy system of silly colloquialism, queen for atoday. he says whatever he wants. the government agrees information will room unless and until he gets immunity. if the government likes what he said they will give him immunity. they apparently like what he said because it will help indict someone. martha: timetable? >> very soon. like may i think. in terms of somebody getting indicted. martha: judge, thank you very much. with your help, appreciate it. bill: 20 minutes past the hour. conservatives gathering for one of the biggest conferences of the year, cpac is underway. nebraska senator ben sasse is up now. joni ernst from iowa up next

front-runner saying that it is good that bryan pagliano, the staffer who set up her private server in the chappaquaived immunity from the feds. she says she is happy. it signals that the investigation must be close to wrapping up without any indictment. >> it is security review. i'm delighted he agreed to cooperate as everyone else has. i think we'll be moving toward a resolution of this. martha: judge andrew napolitano, fox news senior judicial analyst. she is happy. she says this is signal things are almost done. >> she wants us to think she is happy but really too smart to be happy over this development. this person was present at the creation of what a lot of people believe evidence was shown as agreement of office of secretary of state to avoid the freedom of information act laws and espionage laws by manner which she cared for the national secrets proposed to her via email. this young man who originally invoked the fifth amendment when congress sought to interview him has now been given immunity by a federal judge to testify to a grand jury. one does not get immunity to deal with the fbi. one

. >> from chappaqua. hillary clinton kicks off apollo. teresa priolo outside of the apollo until hillary clinton gets there? >> reporter: that's right. she will appear at 11:30. people lining up outside of the apollo. blocked by trucks but secretary clinton will talk about wage inequality. it is the native new yorker against new york's former senator. and the push is on for your support, ahead of new york's april 19th democratic primary. both bernie sanders and hillary clinton are pulling out all of the stops with a race closer than ever, clinton hopes to hold on to a lead she enjoys in new york. today she will kick off the new york blitz with an event at the apollo. some polls show she is up commanding 34%. nationally that gap is closing. nbc surveymonkey poll, 6 points separates clinton and sanders. hand in the delegate count. sanders is riding high after three primary wins last weekend. he will arrive in town on thursday and campaign in the monthhaven in the bronx. he will bring his brooklyn affectations that shows he has new york cred

campaign had hoped to be focusing on trump and republicans alone, but at a rally today not far from her chappaquae, clinton found herself tangling with support s supporters -- >> the bernie people came to say that. >> reporter: she had the last word. >> what i regret is they don't want to hear the contrast between my experience, my plans, my vision, what i know i can get done and what my opponent is promising. >> reporter: it's a stark reminder the democratic primary is also boiling hot. in wisconsin, which votes tuesday, sanders leads clinton by four percentage points. here in new york, clinton holds a 12-point lead but she's not resting easy, even dispatching former president bill clinton to union halls across new york city. before a nighttime rally in the bronx, sanders stopped in pittsburgh. >> what an extraordinary turnout. >> reporter: he lashed out at clinton's support for trade agreements and ties to wall street. >> i just don't know why wall street has not invited me to speak before them. i've got my cell phone on, i'm waiting for the call. >> reporter: the acrimony between clinton, sand

ofclearly relates to the use -- when you have that private server in your home in chappaqua and it is off the grid -- not encrypted or secured -- and you know everything going through that will theoretically be compomise double -- romisable, and when you and your staff use iphones or androids or ipads through that computer, all of that information is comp romisable. haveecretary, she may never sent a received anything classified. but that is not the standard under the statutes. the espionage and gross negligence statute say nothing about the labels on a piece of paper. what matters is the substance of the information in the communication. of anyone who is signed a nondisclosure agreement one given their top security clearance -- that i know my duty to know what is classified whether classified or not -- classification markings mean nothing when it comes to whether or not something is classified. host: if you are defending or hired to be on the other side of this issue -- you are not on either side, this is just -- guest: i am not. host: what would you tell her? do not be interviewed b

on the hillary side, the person who installed the server in the bathroom in chappaqua has a deal to spillnapolitano talks about that one when bill and i see you at the top of the hour. make a dep-- vo: it happens so often... (box smashing) you almost get used to it. (voice on phone) main menu. representative. please hold-- representative! hello, retirement account number 61414-- here's a retirement plan built just for you. vo: which is why being put first-- you built this just for me? that's how it works. takes some getting used to. not always. join the nation. ♪ nationwide is on your side [bassist] two late nights in blew an amp.but good nights. sure,music's why we do this,but it's still our business. we spend days booking gigs, then we've gotta put in the miles to get there. but it's not without its perks. like seeing our album sales go through the roof enough to finally start paying meg's little brother- i mean,our new tour manager-with real,actual money. we run on quickbooks.that's how we own it. >>> you know her from the popular -- her popular roles in these hit shows. >> what did yo

"new york times" discovered and "washington post" discovered the secret server and her home, and chappaquaced to download from the investor and give to the foia judge what had been secured there, that judge and appointee of her husband ordered that all her senior aides be he deposed examination infer oath before trial looking for whether or not there was conspiracy in the office of the secretary of state to violate fiea laws to violate the -- >> if judicial watch lawyers find a conspiracy he then said come back to me, the judge in foia case i will let you did he' mrs. clinton if she is forced to testify under oath before the fitch bi decides whether or not to charge her, she cannot answer those questions, and that will be about catastrophic to her political career if she takes the fifth amendment. >> we will see about that, you think this is all going to take place this is going to play out in the next two months. >> i do. >> judge thank you. >> you are welcome. >> see you soon judge napolitano before we break check out bizarre moment on video, cyclists pushed to limits warming up to tour

pagliano bill and hillary clinton paida 5,000 not a lot of money but 5,000 to install server in chappaquainvolved migrating two e-mail accounts a public state department accounting which anybody could e-mail in the state department publicly e-mail to it and secret state department e-mail migrate two of them away from state department, without the state department's knowledge, to her server in chab kwa mr. pagliano how did you gain access to mrs. clinton's secrets state department e-mail stream. >> gave me password. >> gave you her password. >> signed an agreement saying wouldn't give password away to anybody once two-hour fbi tutorial explain obligations to safeguard national security secrets who you she could we prosecuted whether intentionally exposed hymn or negligently -- the k duty to recognize a seethe ally she saw one. >> pagliano a private guy or worked for state department? >> he worked for her campaign, he worked for her presidential campaign. he worked for her senatorial campaign he worked for the clinton foundation, and then he worked for the state department. >> do you rememb

she might as well sit around her house in chappaqua and drink mimosa iss.poll that came out yesterday from gallup. they asked about famous people and what you think about them. donald trump's unfavorability rating was worse than serial date rapist bill cosby and just barely better than genocidal maniac bashar al assad. he cannot win a general election. >> i saw those polls. however, it looks like he is going to be the nominee and in light of that because he is going to have the delegates by the end of the process. how can become the nominee that doesn't work in a democracy as you know. you are doing a lot of work to further discredit trump even more than he has discredited himself. how does that not help hillary clinton? >> well, look, the thing that would most help hillary clinton is nominating donald trump. because she would crush him. and when you talked about letting the voters speak, 71% of republican voters have not even had a chance to vote in this primary yet. 71%. >> so what's the path? make us all feel better those of us with misimifings about don