let's get to chazin. i pulled the wrong tab. chazin is equally horrifying. and you say in chazin, this is something senator graham asked you. the guidelines lay out different enhancements and you said repeatedly, and this is true in all your cases you say you disagree with the guidelines, you think they're wrong. and the two guidelines you disagree with is one there's an enhancement for use of a computer. and you say the world has changed and now all of these are on a computer. i understand that. i don't agree with you but i understand that. that is an understandable thing to say. but the second thing you say over and over again is there's an enhancement for the number of images and you say repeatedly, for example, in chazzin you say whatever the state state of the law at the time the guidelines were first adapted neither the use of the computer nor the number of images are especially aggravating factors today. now, i find that bizarre. and you say it in every case. you say the number of images, it's not an aggravating factor, it doesn't matter and you won't

in every other case, united states versus chazin, the prosecutor asked for 78 to 97 months. you imposed 28 months. 28 months is a 64% reduction. in united states versus cooper, the prosecutor asked for 72 months. you imposed 60 months. that was a 17% reduction. in united states versus downs, the prosecutor asked for 70 months. you imposed 60. that was a 14% reduction. the united states versus hawkins, the prosecutor asked for 24 months. you imposed three months. that was an 88% reduction. in united states versus savage, the prosecutor asked for 49 months. you imposed 37. that was a 24% reduction. the united states versus stewart, the prosecutor asked for 97 months. you imposed 57. that was a 41% reduction. every single case, 100% of them when prosecutors came before you with child pornography cases, you sentenced the defenders to substantially below, not just the guidelines which are way higher, but what the prosecutor asked for on average of these cases 47.2% less. now you said you made sure the voice of the children was heard. do you believe in a case like united states ve