it does nowa chevron. >> it has total control over chevron. it can reverse it tomorrow with respect to any titular statute and with respect to statue geray and it hasn't. for 40 years it has exceeded except for super rare cases. it has basically said this is the background rule. it gives us a default rule from which to write atute. we have except -- accepted. >> i am not sureeverybody in congress wants to overru chevron. >> everodin congress doesn't want to do everything. >> it is reallyanbe for some members of congress and not have to tackle onthe hard questions and allow for their friendtoget them everything they want. even if congress did it, the presidt uld be to. i think the third problem, even more problematic, if you ge back to that fundamental premise of chevron that when the silence or ambiguity we know the agency wanted to delegated -- delegate to the agency it is fictional and in a particular way. it assumes ambiguity is always delegation of. but it is not. more often when amguy yes, i don't have enoughot in congress to make it clea

chevron undermines that duty. eallocates interpretive agencies, and it forces courts to adopt inferior agency cotions that are issued for political or policy reasons. in doing so, chevron blocks judges from seas faithful agents of congress. it mandates judicial bias an enurages ancy overreach.■wemkeyn executive power, it threatens vidual liberty. chevron also violates the apa. the moaightforward reading of section 706 requires de novo review of legal questions. ss put constition equal footing, and it required both.endent legal judgment as to as justice scalia wrote, apa's text contemplates that courts, nocies, will authoritatively resolve ambiguities in statute and, third, this court's only justification for chevron is t implied delegation theory, but that theory is a fiction. there'no reason to think that congress intends every ambiguity in egency statute to give agencies an ongoing power to ret and reinterpret federal law in ways that override its best meaning. in this case, the agency misinterpreted the msa to

chevron undermines that du. it reallocate interpreti authorities from courts to agencies and forces courts to adopt inferior agency constructions that are issued for political or policy reasons. in doingso, chevron blocks judges from serving as faithful agents of congress. it mandates judicial biaan encourages agency overreach. by removing key checks on ecutive power it threatens individual liberty. chevron also violates the apa, the most straightforward reading of section 706 requires review of legal questions. congre put constitutional and statutory interpretati o equal footing anreired independent legal judgment to both. as justice scalia wrote, the text contemplatescourts, not agencies will authoritatively resolve ambiguities and statutes. and third, this court's only justification for chevron is the implied delegation theory but that theory is a fiction. there is no reason to think congress intends every ambiguity ve statute to give agencies ongoing power to interpret and reinterefederal law in ways that ov

it can reverse chevron tomorrow statute and with respect to chevron.st 40 years itasded t c super rare cas, it's the background rule, from which to write statutes and we've accepted that. >> we say three things. i'm not sure everybody in congress wants to overrule chevron. >> eryone in congress doesn't want to do everything. >> it's convenit for, and for t friends to do it and i th veto. it and second will i -- secondly, when you get to ■( n the's silence or am by amits fictional, an ambiguitys not at delegation. more amguity, i don't have votes in congress to me it clear, i'm going to leave it ambiguous and get over the bicameral, and we have major probms in society that aren't being solv, instead of doing the hd work of legislation wher you have to compromise with the other se at the risk of maybe drawing a primary challenger, you rely on an executive branch friend to do what you hypothetical. when-- >> and you end up in gridlock, which we have now. >> no, i'm saying that in contrg to gridlock. let me give you a concrete example. i would thinkhe uniq

do you see chevron that way? and you see it as differentin kind from the other inrpretation that we apply? >> i do thinit's different. i think it's fundamentally rooted in setting the ground rule for how the rancs of the government are operatin together. what i understand e urt to be doing in chevron is wrecked rising there are legitimate reasons why coress cannot answer every quesonself and why would want to go hand-in- hand with an agency by out charging that agency to administrating the statutes. i think it's not just interpretive cannon but it is grounded in the separation power. >> is it dendent on the judgment of whatcongress would wantwhen that would be empirically tested?>> it'snot getting into the subjective intent. the primary ratione at chevron game was that this is what coress would have intended. i don't mean to suggest that means that congress thinksout each and evy p, but set reasonle rates it knows it's not prescribing and leaving gaps in the agency. but even in the rcstance were congress doesn't

chevron is.i , you know, we recognize there are some places where congressional progression has run out and we think core would have one of the agency to do something rather than the cour we accept that. that is e st reading of congress and also because we know inouheart of hearts that agencieskn things that courts t. that is the basis of chevron. you take that doctrine of humility and u put on top of it starry decisis, another doctrine of tosuest we do not wy reversed things unless theris a special justification. here kaiser said it is ev more than that. there is enmore reason not to reverse something, because the have been 70 supreme court decisions relying on n. her decisions relying on chevron. you are saying blowupne and then expect anybody to think that the courts are acting like court. >> with respect, your honor, this court has on multle locations corrected its own errors when it comes to statutory interpretation, how to deal with qualified immunity, implied causes of action. in the encin

chevron is.trine that says , you know, we regnize there are some places where congressional progression has run out and wethink congress woul have one of the agency do something rather than the court. we cept that. that is the best reading of congress and also because we know in our heart of hearts that agencies know things that courts do not. th the basis of chevron. you take that dori of humility and you put on top of itstarry decisis, another doctrine of humility, which is to suggest we do not willy-nilly reversed things unless there is a special justification. here kaiser saidt than that. there is even more reason not to reverse something, because suem court decisions relying on chevron. because the ve been 17,000 lower her decisions relying on chevron. you are saying blowup one doctri of humility, blowup another doctrine of humility, and then pe anybody to think that the courts are acting likeurt. wh respect, your honor, this court has on multiple locatis rrected its own errors when it comes

chevron undermines that duty.reallocates interpretive authority from courts to agencies, and it forces courts to adopt inferior agency constructions that are issued for political or policy reasons agents of congress. it mandates judicialias and encourages agency overreach. by removing key checks on executive power, it threaten individual liberty. the most straightforward reading of section 706 requi novo review of legal questions. congress put constitutional and statutory interpon on equal footing, and it required independent legal judgment ato both. as justice swrote, the apa's text contemplates that ts, not agencies, willieintatut. and, third, this court's only justification for n is the implied delegation theory, but that theory is a fiction. there's no reason to think that congress intends every ambiguity in every agency statute to give agencies an ongoing power interpret and reinterpret federal law in way override its best meaning.7 in this case, the agency misinterpreted the msa to force struggling fishermen

chevron is. chevron is a doctrine that says , you know, we recognizthere are some places where congssnal progression has run out and we think congress would have one of the agency to do something rather than the court. we acceptth. that is the best reading of ngss and also because we know in our heart of hearts that agencies know things that courts do not. that is thbas of chevron. you take that doctrine of humility and you put on top of it arry decisis, another doctrine of humility , which is to suggest we do not willy-nilly reversed things unless there is a ecial justification. here kaiser said it is even more anthat. there is even more reason t to reverse something, because there have been 70 supreme court decisions relying on chevron. because there have en17,000 lower her decisions relying on chevron. you are saying blowup one doctrine ofhumility, blowup anher doctrine of humility, and then expect anto think that the courts are acting like court. >> with re your honor, this court has on multi

and let's just take, for example, the judge's discussion of chevron. i think chevron is the most cited case by the u.s. supreme court ever. and so this is woven very much into the fabric of the law. congress, when it's been passing statutes since 1984, has passed them in the shadow of chevron. so they understand they don't have to so resolve every ambiguity because the agencies can do it for themselves. well, it now looks like the supreme court is poised to overrule chevron. and i guess i disagree a little bit with the judge. obviously, he does this for a living. i just dabble in it. but i don't think the major questions doctrine by itself has overrule chevron or in a practical way, because it is only applied in the big cases. you know something that is a major question. take the case that's pending before the supreme court. now it's about fishery management and who has to pay for, you know, if you're a fishery, do you have to pay for a monitor to be on the boat that that monitors how many fish or cow are caught on any given day? that is not a major qu

overturn chevron deference. it's about something called chevron deference. >> did you go looking for all of those? >> it's finally here. happy chevron deference day to all who celebrate. and if you don't, you need to start celebrating, but especially to our own poppy harloe, who is deeply passionate about her family, her profession, but mostly chevron deference. the high court will hear arguments today in a case about oversight fees on fishing boats, which sounds very niche, kind of weedsy, but could have massive implications for the federal government's regulatory power. why, poppy? >> it is true. let me tell you, the justices could decide -- i'm going to get you back for that one -- to kneecap the ability of federal agencies to regulate big things like health care, our environment, the workplace. they could do away with a landmark 1984 ruling that you guessed it, implemented chevron deference. in simpler terms, it requires courts to defer or side with an agency's reasonable interpretation of what the court thi

people don't know what the chevron doctrine in. on the street and say hey, what's the chevron doctrine? and unless they're a very particular kind of lawyer, they won't know. but what it is, is the doctrine that lets america's regulatory agencies make the decisions where they have expertise. and it's really important when you're up against big industries, that have a lot of experts, to have experts against them, that can call bs on them, who can call their bluff, who can understand the complexities and don't get fooled. and what these industries want to do is shut down the regulatory piece of that and move so that they can make their arguments to courts, which are not expert, which are much more easily fooled, and which, if you pick the right judge, are on the side of the big industries now anyway after all of the federalist society's work packing various courts. >> and one of the things we've grown accustomed to hearing from the republican judges of the supreme court is that congress hasn't specifically authorized x or y. congress

it may be they further curtail chevron. in the last few years the court has been tacking back a little for chevron. many of the advocates want to see chevron simply taken off the table. the thing is that if you read some of the briefs of amicus, they make it sound like the world will come to an end if you don't have chevron. we lived in a world without chevron 40 years ago. rome did not burn. it means that judges have greater ability to review these agency decisions. so this is not a choice between the state of nature and civilization as many have portrayed. >> dana: it's a fascinating case. pay attention to it. i know you will and you will explain it to everyone. big deal on the docket. thank you so much. >> thank you. >> bill: the white house igniting a bit of a media firestorm this week when it accused the state of texas of blocking efforts to rescue migrants who drowned near eagle pass. that very claim is being discredited by the president's own justice department. matt is live in eagle pass, texas. good morning. >> goo

i wondered. >> i am teasing. >> chevron chairman ceo mike wirth joined maria in davos to ask is chevronquire for 53 billion the biden administration war on fossil fuel talked about and economy. >> 2023 was a major year for chevron company acquisition in october company announced 53-billion-dollar all stock deal to acquire hes, expected to close first half of the year middle of the year last august chevron completed 6.3 billion dollars acquisition, pdc, energy joining me to talk impact chairman chee of chevron mike wirth, great to see you now good to he you see. >> where are we on housing deal are you expecting that approval this year? >> we do, we are working through the approval process with federal trade commission, received a second question so more documents, process that we made to to go through going to take some time, but midyear would be right now the expectation we have there is no real fundamental competitive overlap issues from transax we and it technique approved. >> brings a country almost a hundred years tradition industry leader in many cases, company strong asset base, i

here we have another example of chevron acting just like >> martinez, refining company. she says flaring would be solved. at the chevron in martinez refineries comply with emissions standards by installing what's called a wet gas scrubber. instead, the refineries are suing the bay area. air quality management district over the standards. these 2 companies. >> are on the hot list for flaring and bad behavior. city county and state lawmakers on alert. i'm getting calls like every other week about an incident and one or another. they find california congressman john garamendi represents the district where all of northern california's refineries are located. he says flaring his cause, public health hazards in the past and that the refineries have a responsibility to operate safely. no matter the financial cost. what needs to be done is for them find to make necessary investments in equipment. whether that is a scrub or whatever other equipment might be necessary. >> to operate effectively safely and efficiently. taylor says that a group of contra costa county residents will

here we have another example of chevron acting just like >> martinez, refining company. she says flaring would be solved at the chevron and martinez refineries comply with emissions standards by installing what's called a wet gas scrubber. instead, the refineries are suing the bay area. air quality management district over the standards. >> taylor says that a group of contra costa county residents will be attending the county's board of supervisors meeting tuesday morning over the flaring. we are going to >> continue our fight to make sure that this is a priority and that somebody forces them to pay attention to what all this flaring needs. city county and state lawmakers on alert. i'm getting calls. >> like every other week about incident and one or another. find california congressman john garamendi represents the district where all of northern california's refineries are located. he says flaring his cause, public health hazards in the past that the refineries have a responsibility to operate safely. no matter the financial cost. what needs to be done is for them find

similarly, gary mentioned chevron.chevron is beyond the scope of precedent. i have argued that chevron does not get binding effect because what it asks of future judges is to make an interpretive inference about statutes that are not presented to the court in chevron, so i think it goes too far. i think it is a really difficult set of issues. to my mind, theave tried to do s focus on the parts that are at least pretty well established, and can we use them to start to build up a tradition-based or practice-based account? even though i think doctrines like strict scrutiny could create real questionof ithey are binding, the courts seem to accept that. the next generation of these discussions will be cases like e cases like chevron that push the boundaries a little far. i don't have my mind made up on all those, frankly, but i think the considerations we have been talking about are the ones that we have to keep focusing on is the notion that at the end of the day, the president is about requiring something of the judge at

if the supreme court overturned chevron, as it appears poised to do, it would drastically shrink thefederal agencies to regulate much of anything at all. which means private businesses and corporations may have more ability to challenge and violate regulations, like environmental regulations, food safety regulations, trading and financial regulations, just to name a few. the knock on effect of overturning chevron is difficult to calculate, because it has the potential to have an impact on nearly every facet of our government and of our daily lives. after a quick break, the great melissa murray joins me to further explain what's at stake here. t stak here as the world keeps moving, help prevent covid-19 from breaking your momentum. you may have already been vaccinated against the flu, but don't forget this season's updated covid-19 shot too. honey... honey... nyquil severe honey. powerful cold and flu relief with a dreamy honey taste. nyquil honey, the nighttime, sniffing, sneezing, couging, aching, fever, honey-licious, best sleep with a cold, medicine. struggling with the highs and

first of all, if you want me to make a prediction, they'll overrule chevron. second of all, and they should. >> but -- >> one of the ironies of this is that chevron which was in some ways the brain child of antonin scalia and justice thomas, conservative justices have realized they made a mistake in setting up the regime the way they did. the question isn't what the justices were just saying about whether court should be the decider or bureau kcrats shoulde the decider. congress writes it so vaguely, our constitutional system, the branch of government that's the most democratic has the most power. if congress wants to require monitors on these fishing boats, it can just write a law saying so. this was an invented thing by a bureaucrat that should not have deference, so to speak, just simply because we think experts should be in charge. >> but congress can't pass anything. they can't even keep the government funded. the idea that they'll write a law for, in this particular case, you know, one federal agency, and say by the way, when it gets to herring, here's w

do you want me to make a prediction, they are going to overrule chevron.of all, one of the ironies, one of the ironies of this is that chevron, which was in some ways the brain child of scalia and this related thing was the brain child of justice thomas. conservative justices have realized they made a mistake in setting the regime. the question isn't as the justices was saying about whether courts should be the decider. congress outsourced its responsibility and rules so vaguely that empowers unelected bureaucrats. our constitutional system, the branch of government that is the most democratic a has the most power. if congress wants to require monitors on these boats t could write a law saying so. this was an invented thing that should not have deference just simply because we think experts should be in charge of everything. >> but congress can't pass anything. they can't even keep the government funded. theed in they are going to write a law for one federal agency and say by the way, when it gets to herring, here's what you have to do. somebody is going t

over 17,000 cases have been decided under the chevron deference doctrine.ne of the good points that justice alito kagan brought up during his arguments is, we could literally see, re-litigation of those 17,000 cases and what makes matters worse, we could see inconsistent ruling coming from different judges in different jurisdictions on concepts that are applicable for all americans, correct? >> yes, kagan said that, ketanji brown jackson brat of the fact that it would just simply be her words in practical and chaotic to move chevron deference. you know what the conservatives it? they laughed. i am not making -- conservative super lawyer paul clements. so, of course, we weren't going to overturn 17,000 precedents, we're just going to return this one and the conservatives on the court had a big chuckle about it. they left and i counted three times over the course of the hearing as they joked about ending the administrative state. it's funny to nominate funny to them because again, katie, they have unassailable, unaccountable power. as i wrote, the supreme cou

first, as a justice, he has called for reconsideration of chevron. he dissented in a 2022 case when fellow justices postponed looking at this chevron dock trip. he wrote, quote, rather than say what the law is, we tell those who come before us to go ask a bureaucrat. we place it on the scales of justice in favor of the most powerful of litigants, the federal government, and against everyone else. unquote. the federal government counters, of course, that those bureaucrats of which gorsuch speaks are experts in their field. now another interesting element of justice gorsuch is that the chevron case dates to the tenure of his mother ann gorsuch over agency. she was the first female chief of the epa, appointed by ronald reagan in 1981. the case began as a dispute over the loosening of an epa permit requirement and ann gorsuch embraced the reagan anti-regulatory agenda and constantly was battling with the democratic run congress. in one fight she was held in contempt of congress and she was essentially forced out of office by her own administration. ann g

the chevron refinery in richmond is once again under scrutiny. the bay area water quality management district investigating six complaints of flaring on new year's eve. this is the latest in a string of similar incidents and other violations at the richmond refinery. chevron says the flaring was part of a so-called process upset. chevron says flares are a safety measure used to relieve pressure and help keep that plant operating safely. >>> now to a follow-up, the driver involved in the uc, santa cruz, bus crash last month has died. you might remember earlier in december a bus crashed on the campus. five students were injured, and the driver was taken to the hospital. that's where he's been ever since. that driver, dan stevenson, died on sunday. he was a metro and campus bus driver for 25 years. the cause of that crash is still under investigation. >>> now to a live look this midday at southern israel toward the gaza border. israel's military launched new air strikes while announcing it will begin withdrawing troops in the beginning days. as nbc

so right now under chevron deference, when an agency faces a big decision.can talk about the environment, pollution, labor law, consumer law, whatever, you name it, there are a lot of ambiguities in the law and congress can't predict the future and so under this principle, if an agency interprets the law reasonably then the courts cerf to that interpretation. they say you know what? you're the expert. the epa is filled with scientists who know exactly how much mercury can be released into the atmosphere or exactly how a nuclear reactor needs to be constructed and under chevron the court said we'll defer to you. you guys understand it, we don't. this case seeks to abolish that deference and instead put unelected federal judges in the driver's seat of every major policy decision under the sun and that would effectively mean that presidents are stricken of their ability to enact a whole lot of major policies through agencies and other parts of the executive branch because there are always going to be unelected judges sitting there who say we know better than yo

. >> we'll tell you what's in store for the former chevron headquarters in san ramon. and it could for 89 years... believes in continuous improvement... like rounded corners that resist peeling, with an array of active ingredients... and sizes to relieve your pain. salonpas. it's good medicine. canyon road right across the street from two already busy shopping centers, city center and the shoppes at bishop ranch. the developer gave abc seven news reporter leslie brinkley a look at some of their plans for the 92 acre parcel. >> since the 1980s, massive oak trees have lined the road into chevron's headquarters in san ramon. the trees will stay, but the global headquarters have moved down the street and everything else will change, according to sunset development, which bought the parcel from chevron and is drafting up plans . on the property. >> it's 92 acres. it's going to be about 2600 homes and a new retail center. great neighborhoods, a new park and the homes will range from two stories all the way up to seven story apartment condo buildings. >> sunset development sa

and chevron is exploited, in the favor the federal government, i can feel the momentum on the part of conservatives, including neal gore such to try to really rollback this policy, and a host of areas. including environmental protection and work-based safety and consumer rights. >> a figure federal regulator. >> you're very cognizant of what's happening when you're 15, he wasn't five, he was 15. >> writing in the memoir, and when she was forced out, and raise me not to be a quitter and you quit. >> and she is on his mind. >> actually i know we have to wrap up, one of the lawyers representing the fisheries actually raised her just briefly. >> a fascinating story.>> to members of the british royal family are dealing with health scares requiring time in the hospital, live to london, latest on king charles and catherine, the princess of wales. >>> major medical news out of great britain concerning prince charles. kensington palace confirmed that the princess is in the hospital after undergoing what has been described as a successful abdominal surgery. >> king charles is preparing for his

instead, during oral arguments this week he helped lead the attack against chevron, clipping that thehe individual and in favor of the government. now, we are going to have to wait until june for the courts final decision, but this much is clear. not only will this case have major implications for the future of the adnistrative state in the u.s., but it also could furthermage the already batted tation of the supreme court. as the new republics kate are enough puts it, if gorsuch overturns the chevron doctrine, quote, it will cement the supreme court's reputation as a pay for play venue, where billionaires can fetch a big return on their investments in future supreme court justices. elie mystal and jill wine-banks, on the sticks of whatever the court decides. that's next. that's next. an office. hi! hello! a cinema. so automated. yes, the definition of a car changes... but one thing stays the same. it's a mercedes-benz. [deep exhale] [trumpet music plays] 579 breaths to show 'em your stuff. every breath matters. don't let rsv take your breath away. protect yourself from rsv... ...with

chevron says the flaring was a result of a so-called process upset.fety measure used to relieve pressure and help keep the plant operating safely. >>> and before we go, we're going to check in with kari one last time. >> i just wanted to show you the sunrise. >> oh, how nice. >> we're taking a look live in san jose. clouds coming in. looks good. we are getting ready for rain and that is most likely going to arrive after lunchtime for the north bay and then in time for the evening commute for much of the rest of the bay area. >>> at least if you have to go back to work, you've had a pretty decent commute so far. we've had a smooth commute from the north bay, through the peninsula. i will say 880 is starting to see building traffic, 101 in san jose. 880, this is where i'm starting to notice the most slowing. but it isn't because of any accidents. i think a lot of folks are finally heading back to work. >> and one of my sons goes back to school tomorrow. >> oh, my goodness. >> back to reality. >> yours today? >> yeah. >> we're until the 8th. it seems lik

why do they say chevron should stay?sically argue there is a hidden agenda in this case beyond the herring fishermen, who are the plaintiffs. that is they want to paralyze or cripple the bureaucracy so that federal agencies cannot make rules on major problems in american life, things from air pollution and may be eventually even artificial intelligence as justice elena kagan raised today , to health care. they say if you return these decisions to unelected federal judges, something like 800 of them around the country, it risks people's medicare and medicaid programs, very complex programs that mean a lot to people's lives. being decided one way in one state and one way and another state. that could really sow chaos for people's lives, just in their personal pocketbooks, as well as for environmental regulations and workplace protections. you just cannot have a system where the regs mean something in one state and something else halfway around the country. william: in his confirmation hearings, now justice cortege expresse

that's what i understood chevron to mean. >> we haven't relied on chevron over that time.ean, have we overruled it in practice? >> now, you know how lawyers make things difficult. sometimes judges make things even more difficult. what they're saying when they say chevron is just talking about the old case that i mentioned that they might overrule. so, that's the name of the case, just like roe v. wade. what they're really saying is, maybe chevron's already died. maybe we can just pretend every time we overrule something that we're not violating the oaths they took, the speeches they gave, the testimony they gave about roe and other super precedent. i can also tell you that some of the obama and biden appointees were more precedent friendly today, and congress hands these powers as i mentioned, defers. it's basically even maybe very confident politician whose don't defer on other things in their life. they know they're not doctors, so the justices were also asking about how the fact is that we know congress has historically deferred to the people who k things. >> is consist

chevron, ox e, an x on. they are making acquisitions. taking advantage of these really cheap evaluations. both sectors think there are sectors are cheap, companies are cheap. so july! i think you could see real returns and a catch-up trade this morning. i'm not giving up on text and. i do think that there is better value elsewhere. which is encouraging. >> let's talk about a couple. things i want to ask you about this adding to energy and the fact that you used to be, in chevron, talked about it all the time, it kind of got fed up and sold it. now have bought x on. give me that first. i want to go a little bit deeper on this mega count conversation. >> look, exxon have been executing a lot better over the last couple of years versus chevron. that is a reversal. it is a little frustrating with chevron and the charge rights and the right down to have to take. they are not immune, i know. but they do seem to be more frequent. i just didn't think that it paid to wait. it is cheap, for sure. i like the better operator. exxon has about $30 mil

the more interesting development about, from conservative thinkers is that chevron itself at the timees and republicans because it meant that president reagan whose deregulatory efforts were being this warranted by the courts, all of a sudden -- this warranted by the courts, all of a sudden -- thwarts warted, what we've seen in the time since is rather than empowering judges, what this does is diminish congress. and representatives and senators can now just kick the can, punt decision making on controversial issues to the executive branch which then gets sued. and so we're deciding so many major issues of you are to politics, of our government power in the courts rather than letting congress, making congress work out those compromises. paul: so are you saying that chevron and the ability to let i judiciary, to hand power to the executive has essentially contributed to the dysfunction we see in congress or the unwillingness for congress to step up and solve critical national problems like, say, immigration or the lawyer said cryptocurrency. they just say let the sec do it. [laughter] >

, well, he’s not distracted by chevron, we call him the regime, the artillerymen built this long-termpoint for themselves, the underground passage leads straight to.. this is an mt12 gun in common parlance rapier, considered an artillery sniper rifle. particularly hot hours for them it was literally the day before our arrival. shoot! supported the infantry. now , in moments of relative calm, there is time to read the letters that come from children from all over the country on new year's eve. i would like to wish you endurance, patience, self-control. fortitude, so that in the new year you will defeat the enemy, thank you very much for defending your homeland, the future of our country, our children is in your hands, happy new year, for truth and justice, you are our heroes , together with you our hearts, and let without a fight chimes and a festive concert, but still a new year in which everyone believes it will only get better, happiness, health to you and your loved ones, in general, so that good luck always accompanies you in everything , victory is always with you, just thank you

in general , his name is chevron, well, he doesn’t get distracted by chevron, we call him red.ilt this long-term firing point for themselves; the underground passage leads straight to the gun. this is the mt12 gun of the common people rapier, considered an artillery sniper rifle. the hours turned out to be especially hot for them literally the day before our arrival. we supported the infantry, now in moments of relative calm there is time to read the letters that come from children from all over the country on new year's eve. i would like to wish you endurance, patience, self-control , fortitude, so that in the new year you will defeat the enemy, thank you very much for defending your homeland, the future of our country, our children is in your hands, happy new year yaroslav, and of course. dear friends, we are saying goodbye to 2023. some words from the head of state, including about them. today i would like to address our to military personnel, to everyone who is at a combat post, at the forefront of the fight for truth and justice. you are our heroes, our hearts are with you

a major is development, chevron.il major chevron is blaming a new big $4 billion hit to their earnings on california's chaotic, hostile regulatory environment. california is hurting -- how california is hurting all businesses there big and small. also this story, this breaking news, the trump team just asked the supreme court to intervene on colorado's attempt to ban trump from state ballot. the fallout of this. plus, a new report on congress' alleged insider trading. top democrats are beating the s&p 500, and wall street analysts again asked about the dubious timing of more treaty move -- trading moves by former speaker nancy pelosi is. her net worth has soared while on the job. it's all coming uh-uh up on -- up on "the evening edit." ♪ ♪ limu emu & doug ♪ [bell ringing] and doug says, “you can customize and save hundreds on car insurance with liberty mutual.” he hits his mark —center stage— and is crushed by a baby grand piano. are you replacing me? with this guy? customize and save with liberty bibberty. he doesn'

it looks like from the argument that the court is actually poised to attack chevron deference.does, it not only will add to the dangers, to americans' health and safety, which regulations help protect against, but it will also move the unaccountable supreme court further into the policies making function -- policy making function to the elected political branches. in short, it's a power grab by the unelected judicial bench at the behest of and benefit of polluter billionaires. and they have done this on the speshus -- on the false grounds that these administrative agencies are unaccountable. well, even if that claim were true, it's hardly solved by moving the locus of decision to the least accountable part of the government, to the united states supreme court. if your problem is the decisions are being made in unaccountable fashion by bureaucrats, then moving it to even less accountable judges is not a solution to the problem, but the fact of the matter is they're wrong about the bureaucrats because of the cra, because of the appropriations process, because of congressional ove

maria: my thanks to chevron ceo mike with.eed t [ applause ] the day you get your clearchoice dental implants changes your struggle with missing teeth forever. it changes how you eat, how you feel, and how you enjoy life. it changes your smile and how others smile at you. clearchoice network doctors have changed over 100,000 lives with dental implants, and they can change yours, too. because a clearchoice day changes every day. schedule a free consultation. you always got your mind on the green. not you. you! your business bank account with quickbooks money now earns 5% apy. (♪) that's how you business differently. intuit quickbooks. maria: welcome back. one thing you need to know about ahead of next week, the barbenheimer duo receiving buzz with nominations a announced this upcoming tuesday. other best picture favorites include killers of the flower moon, poor things and the holdovers. just under $9 billion spent on movie tickets in 2023. that is the highest grossing year for the box office since before the pandemic. we'll be

maria: my thanks to chevron ceo mike with.important thing you need t this thing, it's making me get an ice bath again. what do you mean? these straps are mind-blowing! they collect hundreds of data points like hrv and rem sleep, so you know all you need for recovery. and you are? i'm an investor...in invesco qqq, a fund that gives me access to... nasdaq 100 innovations like... wearable training optimization tech. uh, how long are you... i'm done. i'm okay. you know, when i take the bike out like this, all my stresses just melt away. i hear that. this bad boy can fix anything. yep, tough day at work, nice cruise will sort you right out. when i'm riding, i'm not even thinking about my painful cavity. well, you shouldn't ignore that. and every time i get stressed about having to pay my bills, i just hop on the bike, man. oh, come on, man, you got to pay your bills. you don't have to worry about anything when you're protected by america's number-one motorcycle insurer. well, you definitely do. those things aren't related, so... ah

chevron told us the flaring was the result of a process upset chevron also said that a community warning system level one was issued to keep residents informed. >> in oakland, a driver performing stunts on international boulevard hit and struck or killed a pedestrian overnight at oakland. police say the car was doing donuts on international and 42nd avenue around 1245 this morning. police say the driver fled the scene right aft the incident. the victim later died at the hospital. no word if any arrests have been made. and this morning, chp responded to a person possibly suffering from hypothermia. umea on black sands beach down below the marin headlands southern marin fire, first to arrive on scene and then requested that chp chopper, the helicopter flew the patient to a nearby roadway where medics were waiting. the patient was transported to the hospital, where they are now receiving treatment. >> right now, bart is working to restore service to a line running along highway 24. this morning, a train derailment near the orinda station disrupted operations along the yellow line. the crash

all right, lawrence, we are following yet another flaring incident at the chevron refinery in richmond started just before. >> 2 o'clock this afternoon or rather the afternoon on saturday. this is video from past incidents. chevron is investigating the cause and says that there's no public health risk over the last few months. chevron has gotten several air quality violations at that richmond refinery >> developing news tonight, defense secretary lloyd austin has been released from the hospital after complications from a procedure that he kept secret from the biden administration. austin was admitted and underwent surgery to treat prostate cancer. but later developed an infection was hospitalized on new year's day. the lack of transparency regarding his medical condition triggered reviews and criticism from member of con men burr's of congress on both sides of the aisle. more than 5 months after the deadly wildfires in la hina. the time has come for debris to be removed off properties. >> so that residents can start the rebuilding process. nikki schenfeld has that story. it's a day man

. >> we are following another flaring incident at the chevron refinery in richmond. it started just before 2 in the afternoon on saturday. we do have video here of past incidents. chevron is investigating the cause and they say there's no public health risk over the last few months. chevron's gotten several air quality violations at that richmond refinery taking a live look outside where we're not complaining in the bay area. when you look at the weather across the rest of the country, it's dry. it's chilly, but it's not subzero yeah. my brothers in school in nashville, he's been sending me video of snowy. they got 8 inches in nashville warrants. crazy stuff going and just that cold, this going to go on. >> for a long time, california, one of the warmest places in the country. if you can believe that. but yeah, this cold outbreak going to stick around california. not going to be affected so much by that. but we do have a rain event headed our way. that one coming in as early as tomorrow outside. right now you've got a couple of clouds floating up above a nice evening

maria: my thanks to chevron ceo mike with.t thing you need t (vo) sail through the heart of historic cities and unforgettable scenery with viking. unpack once, and get closer to iconic landmarks, local life, and cultural treasures. because when you experience europe on a viking longship, you'll spend less time getting there and more time being there. viking. exploring the world in comfort. i got into debt in college and, no matter how much i paid, it followed me everywhere. so i consolidated it into a low-rate personal loan from sofi. get a personal loan with low fixed rates. borrow up to $100k. and no fees required. sofi. get your money right. businesses go further with 5g solutions. that's why they choose t-mobile for business. pga of america and t-mobile are partnering on 5g-powered analytics to help improve player performance. t-mobile's network helps aaa stay connected nationwide... to get their members back on the road. and las vegas grand prix chose t-mobile to help fuel operations for one of the world's largest racing

maria: my thanks to chevron ceo mike with.got one important thing you need t fresh, warm hot dogs! when i'm not selling hot dogs, i invest in a fund that advances innovations like robotics. fresh, warm hot dogs, straight out of my torso! one for you, one for you. oh, you're a messy one. cool, right? so cool. anyone can become an agent of innovation with invesco qqq, a fund that gives you access to nasdaq-100 innovations. hot dogs! fresh, warm hot dogs! before investing carefully read and consider fund investment objectives, risks, charges, expenses and more in prospectus at invesco.com. jorge has always put the ones he loves first. but when it comes to caring for his teeth he's let own maintenance take a back seat. well maybe it's time to shift gears on that. because aspen dental has the latest technology and equipment. with a staff that goes out of their way to provide exceptional care. plus free exams and x-rays for new patients without insurance and 20% off treatment plans. making it easier to get started with quality care.

the space. >> we don't own exxon, we own chevron. i will end up having exxon because i own pioneer. >> there you go. >> this is the time you want to buy these stocks. you don't want to buy when they're 90. the average cost for these guys to make money is in the 40s. >> exxon and chevron, their breakeven is $35. >> you see any type of soft or no hard landing. these stocks are trading at such a cheap value that nobody cares about them. we're back to the story about they have really good balance sheets. i want to be in the sector. >> we have other moves throughout our program. i do want to move to big stories. boeing, the fallout there, today the ceo is holding an employee safety meeting. inquiring minds want to know what you're doing with the stock. yesterday jim lebenthal, which was kind of a surprise, felt a little emotional in saying, i'm out completely. i don't want to wake up and have to worry about headlines that are negative or if not catastrophic. what are you doing with it? >> staying patient. i will hang on to it. it's not do

maria: my thanks to chevron ceo mike with. about ahead of next week. that's next. my se are yep, tough day at work, nice cruise will sort you right out. when i'm riding, i'm not even thinking about my painful cavity. well, you shouldn't ignore that. and every time i get stressed about having to pay my bills, i just hop on the bike, man. oh, come on, man, you got to pay your bills. you don't have to worry about anything when you're protected by america's number-one motorcycle insurer. well, you definitely do. those things aren't related, so... ah, yee! oh, that is a vibrating pain. oooohhh, it is cold outside time to protect your vehichle from winters wrath of course the hot sun can be tough on vehicles too you need weathertech all year round! come on, protect your investment laser measured floorliners and cargoliner will shield the carpeting from sand and snow for your interior, there's seat protector and sunshade plus, mudflaps and bumpstep for the exterior order american made products at weathertech.com surfs up yeah, right