have those amendments that require a referral back to committee around planning commission supervisor chiu first then supervisor kim and i want to suggest i am wondering if we can before duplicating making the substituted amendment would be with we can agree on and duplicate the file and at this point are supervisor breed's and supervisor kim i believe those are the two colleagues that have amendments that trail and need to go back to committee. >> any outlooks. >> that was my intention to duplicate the file after the non sufficiently susan substantive files. >> we'll be making the non-substantive amendments first with that, the first one is the amendment promoted by supervisor breed that was regarding the response required for no violations so again, this is a technical amendment that was made do we need a roll call no we'll take that without objection. the amendment is adapted the second one is an amendment proposed by supervisor farrell regarding a private right of action for business owners and the second portion has on adapted do we need a roll call workman's compensation this is adap

on short-term rentals do we need a roll call vote. >> madam clerk. >> supervisor campos supervisor chiu no supervisor cohen no supervisor farrell no supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor tang no supervisor wiener no supervisor yee supervisor avalos supervisor breed no there are 5 i's and 6 months this amendment fails okay did next amendment i believe if i'm correct those are all the amendments we could adapt that did not require a referral back to committee with that, islam i'd like to move into the dipped files and take those that go to planning commission and deputy city attorney. >> one suggestion say you could take those all in one file duplicate file e.r. did you want again, because they're two categories that requires one referral to committee and one to committee and the boards, of course, i'm throwing that out there. >> supervisor wiener. >> just to avoid confusion supervisor kim disappointed it so early on the disappointed files were adapted in both version i want to make sure we don't have a version floating around with no amendments so i suggest we may be eliminate the dup

. >> through the chair thank you, president chiu for raising this i guess in my conversations with the planning staff it's unclear whether or not prop c as like 1950 mission is built is that under the inclusion. >> i'm not familiar with the 1950 mission project but fits its part of the mayor's office of housing they would not be allowed to sub lease. >> he the other small site acquisition program i i know that the city and the mayor's office of housing is utilized to make sure we have enough affordable unit throughout the city is that type of program covered as a residential unit. >> i'll recommend if those are the types of specific uses instead of concluding the language we call out those specific types as you've described them as opposed to this general language. >> that's any intent and hopefully with the support of the board and if that's accepted by the author of the main ordinance i'll withdrew my amendment but i would ask the president in my conversations with the planning staff we can insure we're going to include those types of unit we've discussed. >> so colleagues just to cl

. >> president chiu i was speckling to the city attorney there's one additional technical amendment to clarify in the civil actions in the subsections and ask the city attorney to clarify that on the record address move that amendment and take a moment to thank mri run burn through working with the department through this point close to one hundred amendment thank you for your tireless work. >> deputy city attorney merlin burns through the chair the additional change to section 41 a .5 subsection d and a number of small tweaks were made to the section to clarify that the hosting approach is liable for violations of the noticing requirement under this chapter any violations of the tank code is enforced in the tax regulation code not under this chapter that is an additional clarification in the entitled civil action to the second sensitivities that begins with in addition that language changed to emission to a business owner or entity in violation or a hosting approach in violation that may be subject to penalties subsection g-4 a the noticing provision that the platform to provide notic

. >> 90 so, now we're taking substantive amendment in another duplicate file supervisor chiu a question. >> i want to clarify so to our point we're taking one of the duplicate files and making potential changes to trail or trail back to committee or back to planning and back to committee. >> that's correct. >> so, now we're going to take further amendments so let's see here i believe the first one that was requiring a committee hearing only was supervisor mar's amendment regarding in-law units do we need a roll call. >> madam clerk. >> is this i'm sorry this is supervisor mar on in-law unit. >> supervisor campos supervisor chiu no supervisor cowen no supervisor farrell no supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor tang no supervisor wiener no supervisor yee supervisor avalos not to exceed no there are 5 i's and 60 notice that amendment fails the next one is supervisor kim's the proliferate right of action do we need a roll call for this supervisor campos supervisor chiu supervisor cohen supervisor farrell no supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor tang no supervisor wiener no supervisor

. >> supervisor campos supervisor chiu no supervisor cowen no supervisor farrell no supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor tang no supervisor wiener no supervisor yee supervisor avalos not to exceed no there are 5 i's and 60 notice that amendment fails the next one is supervisor kim's the proliferate right of action do we need a roll call for this supervisor campos supervisor chiu supervisor cohen supervisor farrell no supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor tang no supervisor wiener no supervisor yee supervisor avalos supervisor breed there are 8 i's and 430 notice this amendment is adapted the mexico one has to do with supervisor campos with the transit occupies this need to be received back to planning roll call. >> supervisor campos supervisor chiu no supervisor cohen no supervisor farrell no supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor tang no supervisor wiener no supervisor yee supervisor avalos supervisor breed no there are 5 i's and of nos this amendment has failed correction. >> just making sure you're all paying attention (laughter) the next one is supervisor campos prsht are short-t

chiu for taking on 24 legislation it's been a difficult process and thank also process i appreciate you working with any office to think about ways to address insurance and notification to property owners and who list of concerns that are still to this day coming up so thank you pursue a couple of remarks i want to make and some amendments to the legislation as well we all know this legislation needed to be done i hope that today, we can move it forward governments infect regulatory safety and community needs it's why we feel confident our milk would have toxin or our car won't explode but private industry often moves faster than government i know we hate to admit that it's a challenge we see everyday with the transportation network like uber and lift and experiencing with short-term rentals like airbnb companies and individuals who use and enjoy their products have created a new market we have a rocketed to insure that market like p.i. any other are not community needs i don't want a free-for-all that turns houses in san francisco into hotels and leaves the permanent resident out i

two incredible supervisors who have done a lot for san francisco supervisor campos and supervisor chiu the candidates will answer questions and also questions by the legacy of women's voters they have agreed to ask their supporters to be respect fell and maintain quiet if you have your phones just turn the ringer off please not to interfere with the miff and tonight's forum will view a chance to hear from your candidates this really nice the candidates get 30 seconds to a minute 0 they're to get 22 half a minutes especially on tv our stories are 25 seconds to they're going get to stand ladies and gentlemen, welcome give a warm welcome to david chiu and david campos (clapping). >> stack hands and come out fighting verbally, of course. >> all right. okay so we have a total time i was wrong total time of 2 and a half minutes between the both of i i mislead you sorry if you haven't been a legacy of voter women we have a timekeepers ladies raise our cards so what was when necessary hold the yellow card you have 15 seconds to finish when the red that means stop so show the audience okay, her

thank you president chiu. >> i did have one question i know that a number of colleagues raised around the collection of taxes. i think everyone in the room agrees at the moment there's significant economic activity that's occurring on home sharing platforms platforms and yet the city is not seeing a progression at amount of taxes i'm sure you're aware of this is important to me, in fact, i refuted to introduce legislation until air b and b made a public commitment you public library committed you'll facilitate the collection and remittance of taxes percent a requirement for the online platforms and your platform still has not yet move forward with the technology to facilitate that if i could ask you for an update on what air b and b will help the city to collect taxes. >> we announced by this summer we'll have a procedure in collecting taxes. and where the preliminary obligation exists to collect hotel taxes whether on our platform we've been working diligently along with the city attorney and thank you to the city attorney's office this is a complicated go issue and it raise novel is

. >> president chiu u president chiu has joined us as the lead author of item 4 and president chiu called for the hearing president chiu. >> thank you, colleagues. i appreciate you hearing those two items and it's good to be here in land use without talking about short-term rentals i offered this to help build out our fiberoptic to limit the impacts on the residents and neighborhoods and traffic what is a fiberoptic in effect the backbone of the network fiber is to the network go what tire is the integrate. >> we've installed $40 million of fiber we've moved city hall and hundreds of the facilities away from the key lines from the private seeshthsd to a charger network how we eye hetch hetchy hydroelectrical powders to keep the lights on at city hall and the trollies returning before you i talk about the details i want to talk about connectivity once a policy will help is close your cities diagnoseal divide and too much members are not online quality services is not an openal lurk but it is 4e67 helpful in our city in the 21st century cities need access to high speed broadway just as acce

. >> supervisor chiu? chiu no. supervisor cohen? cohen no. supervisor farrell? farrell no. supervisor kim? kim aye. supervisor mar? mar aye. supervisor tang? tang no. supervisor wiener? wiener no. supervisor yee? yee aye. supervisor avalos? avalos aye. supervisor breed? breed no. supervisor campos? campos aye. there are five ayes and 6 no's. >> amendment fails. [gavel] >> colleagues, with that, any further discussion? okay, at this time, madam clerk, could you please call the roll for whether this ordinance shall be finally passed. >> on item 9, supervisor chiu? chiu aye. supervisor cohen? cohen aye. supervisor farrell? farrell aye. supervisor kim? kim aye. supervisor mar? mar no. supervisor tang? tang aye. supervisor wiener? wiener aye. supervisor yee? yee no. supervisor avalos? >> n-o. >> avalos no. supervisor breed? breed aye. supervisor campos? campos no. there are 7 ayes and 4 no'ses. >> this ordinance is finally passed. [gavel] [cheering and applauding] >> thank you, colleagues. with that, why don't we proceed to item 10. >> item 10 is an ordinance to amend the busine

. >> there's a motion on the floor second president chiu and since today, we have quite a few amendments proposed colleagues, i want to suggest we go through the elevators amendments to the legislation and precede tend to take a vote on all the amendments. >> okay. all right. we have a quorum i have one more proposal this particular proposal is not necessarily for the current legislation that is on the floor but for its considered trailing legislation to this legislation and will need to go through an additional process more specifically one of the suggestions that i had from individuals about had something to do with the ellis act evictions happening and those ellis act eviction were taking place as a way to use property for airbnb prurpz purposes i want to propose legislation that will completely weigh the mosaic active process in the current legislation and allow a potential nonprofit housing rights group to basically sue if the if it's found in the a building h that has had an ellis act eviction in the past 5 years rather than wait until there's a determination whether or not a viola

. >> thank you president chiu supervisor cohen thank you, very much. i'm delighted to hear that supervisor wiener is going to be calling a hearing 0 on trees i'd like to add my name to that request it's a significant problem an ill conceived idea to transfer those sick trees to resident i'd like to close today's meeting in memory of a great man under johnson he was the only african-american elected to the sacramento board of supervisors and later appoint to the u.s. health and human services and also served as a cabinet secretary he was widely praised with a keen political insticks out a a passion to help people he was a strong voice in the 71 and a champion of the social justice work to protect the interests of the working class and uses emphasis position to better those lives and the lives that are around him that were around him tested survived by his wife ms. lee turning and daughter patricia and katherine and others he'll be solely missed i want to recognize it's legacy lives on not only inspires me but there are organizers here in san francisco t

francisco because of the policies that have been lead in city hall including policies that president chiu has supported the reason why the other campaign has nor more is because if i go to sacramento i'll stand up for your middle-class (clapping.) do both david and i agree that affordable housing is the top priority for us moderating but the fact of the matter i've been working on this for 6 years he's been talking about it he voted against 21 thousand units of new housing in the city including public housing and low income affordable housing when i go to sacramento i support the reforming of the ellis act but we need to bring back to san francisco the hundreds of million dollars of year making the decision to cutting that funding it will take a lot of work but the consensus i've been building year after year as we've been rebuilding public housing and for the diversity which san francisco housing xhoups has been voting against this is my priority i'll continue to fight and continue to deliver on any record (clapping). >> all right. we come to the candidates closing statements if you're n

supervisor chiu? chiu aye. there are 11 ayes. >> those resolution are adopted and motions approved. [gavel] >> and item 34. >> item 34 is a resolution urging the city and county of san francisco to support the rights of worker to unionize and boycott the le meridien san francisco and hyatt fisherman's wharf. >> thank you, colleague. just briefly, i want to thank the workers from member of local 2 and the workers at these two hotels who have been working very hard to protect the very basic right that every worker should have to decide for themselves whether or not to form a union. i think it's important for us to support their efforts. these are sometime lowest pay workers and they're working under the toughest conditions and i think it's really important for us to send a very clear message that we're not going to tolerate this kind of mistreatment by this company of these workers. thank you. >> thank you, supervisor campos. can we take this item same house same call? this item is adopted. thank you. [gavel] >> next item, madam clerk. >> item 35 is a resolution urging the city and co

. >> at the tights my understanding this is also being co-sponsored by president chiu. >> supervisor david chiu as well as its my privilege and my honor to be recognizing the couple that's standing here today first lieutenant dennis and his partnering jeff jonathan on their marriage in city hall that takes place after they he get the accomodation outside of chambers they've met almost 8 years through the catholic church and jonathan sank in the choir their faith is a bond and their friendship is something we're going to accommodate at city hall those men have served our country in valuable ways jonathan as a teacher of religion to aspire his students how the church can be an instrument to bring love and acceptance and support to all members is a try mission listened church and christianity aid an ordained minister he served in the army thank you for your years of service fighting for our community and provided mental health and to the men and women in the gnat zone dealing with post traumatic stress serving in our gnat area he supports homeless veterans in the veterans administration

recovered and i know they're not conduit underneath there so i definitely want to thank you, president chiu for bringing this forward i'm happy to co-sponsor it i have you know tied into this is my frustration i know that president chiu shares the amount the city's dark fiber is being leased out dwp should be doing more to get the dark fiber those researchers exist and it explicit seem like a lot is happening when you look at the connectivity of the city compared to other cities it's embarrassing our infrastructure doesn't compare well, to other cities amendment so i say all this in the context i know that d t will be issuing the registration and d t will have the discretion and i'll have question about the 9 linear feet and d t will there that and also to issue a lot of regulations that could potentially limit the unanimous of conduit authenticity laid and give the past track record i have concerns that d t may minimize the where its budget concerns or logical or onsite others departments are this and that problem and the automatic response well, if any departments obtains we'll not move f

them i want to take a moment to thank etch that has orchid that the legislation thank you, president chiu for bringing it that's is an interesting pope piece it's gal knitted aloof people it's critically complex issue but beginning to address a very critical step in combating san francisco affordability issue i've spent many hours in committee hearings and gotten thousands thank you thousands of e-mails plus phone numbers on phone calls on this topic it's been interesting to have conversations around the city of san francisco people are will definitely paying attention and are concerned or dialed in on the issue i believe we need to step forward and regulate this activity to protect our city rent control housing stock awhile afforded hosts that need the money that many others are in need of and continue the short-term rentals under a limited circumstance i believe that the legislation is really come a very long way after many amendments and i'm grateful that the committee accepted the amendments addressing the safety issues the san francisco affordability is complicated and my two priorit

so president chiu would you like to make any introductory remarks >> thank you, colleagues foyer your consideration again of our proposal i want to take another moment and thank everyone every everyone a it's in been involved in the last couple of years and particularly the last couple of months from tenant and landlords the hotel community and neighborhood advocates, the human resources community and the department of building inspection and the city attorney all of the commissioners of various department as well my aid amy chang let me start with a couple of preliminary comments everyone in this room in this chamber agrees that the status quo is not working when it comes to short-term rentals in san francisco we need a regulatory and framework how to move forward with considering the activity around short-term rentals in san francisco that doesn't exist today as i've said before the flying value to address the activity in the context of our city's affordability crisis how do we afford to live in the city this legislation addresses that it would for bid the activity for those individ

. >> hi, i'm skate thanks for having me back i'm encouraged that supervisor david chiu is looking at regulating home sharing in the city and airbnb is paying the tax legal missing home sharing in san francisco we're close to approving the legislation it's important to look at the restrictions i'm discouraged its been decides two difficult to tell if someone lives in their home that's across the board time limit on hurrying i'm discouraged the time limit is still be considered i'm determined the city continues to shut down hosts like me awhile greedy landlord continue to ellis act in what should be affordable apartment building and homeowners are not the reason for that high hotel rates in unindirectly areas we not responsible for buildings that are ellis act and not converting affordable housing shock into short-term rentals please don't paint us with the same brush as bad folks help us to stay in the city without a cap on the 90 days it's good for homeland security and good for our neighborhoods and good for our city thank you very much for listening. >> thank you very much. next sp

supervisor breed. >> yea. >> excuse me, actually, supervisor chiu or president chiu, i actually was going to introduce the whole thing then we can go to that order that you mentioned. >> i'm sorry, i didn't realize that you were going to do that. i'm happy to -- >> i apologize that had not been communicated to you. and that's my fault. >> supervisor avalos. >> thank you. >> sorry, supervisor breed. so, colleagues, thank you for joining supervisor jane kim and myself in commemorating october filipino-american history month by bringing together such a great slate of individuals and organizations who have done so much to represent well our diverse filipino community in san francisco. we have also been coordinating with the mayor's office who will also hold their filipino-american history month celebration this afternoon at 5:00 p.m. at the rotunda. it will probably be a quick ceremony unfortunately because the giants are up. [speaker not understood]. so, for all the honorees and their family and friends, i hope you can also stay to join the program later in the reception. as you know, the th

the way, because i have a comment oh, at the end with that, first of all, i want to thank president chiu for his hard work on this issue everyone recognizes that as a no win situation there are groups involved here across the board that rarely agree and it's been an will fascinating experience thank you, everyone for being so involved i certainly want to thank our da merlin and john gibner, deputy city attorney for their hard work i'll say general buildingly so to speak our airbnb has revolutionized things across the city i don't think that generally in the early stages government should not get in the way of consumer demand whether uber or airbnb but there reaches a point the government rethsdz those industries and those behaviors we have reached that point with airbnb in san francisco i know other cases throughout the country i very much agree it was part of the legislation i see stationss t is core and central that's a no brainer and insurance for anyone that could be affected by behavior in my units this legislation does not peers the vail of the existing leases or the agreements alr