chiu studied the harp in germany. here in taiwan, she teaches children to play the recorder. >> i have really not much time. so i want them to listen to me every time when they come in here. so they know exactly what they should do. >> what do you do if they misbehave? >> yelling, yelling at them. >> the kids are also taught english, japanese, german, and art. they do not get a chance to get bored. taiko drumming class use up whatever energy they have left in the afternoon. ms. fong also manages the taiwanese taiko association. if the neighbours complain, the kids practice on old tires. the formidable ms. fong's basic message is surprisingly warm-hearted. >> bringing up children is about showing them love and setting a good example. >> chiu is doing her best. at home, bo-han's day is as regimented as it is at daycare -- football, shower, homework, bed at 9:30. a 14-hour day. a taiwanese childhood. >> let's catch our breath quickly before heading off to the andes. the longest continental mountain range in the world, ex

lot legalization puts us on a path to requiring the legalization, of cours legalization supervisor chiu was passed a few years ago for the first time created a full path to volunteery legalization for the legal in-law units i was a supporter it passed unanimously that has taken the next step to you maurntd r mandating those units beleaguer listed there are exceptions for economics feasibility one of those - those exceptions don't include the ability to pay so i have a question and supervisor avalos or the planning department staff that you have one o someone that has an illegal in-law unit and not the ability to pay what is that person to do do i know that commissioner walker referred to the loan fund she and i worked on and dbi put more money into the fund and we created that fund an important thing in terms of helping the owners bring their property up to code right now $4 million in the code and more to be added but the the cost of bringing one in-law unit into the compliance or 75 thousands of dollars and 10 of thousands of units that quickly will be depleted i am to get a response

lot legalization puts us on a path to requiring the legalization, of cours legalization supervisor chiu was passed a few years ago for the first time created a full path to volunteery legalization for the legal in-law units i was a supporter it passed unanimously that has taken the next step to you maurntd r mandating those units beleaguer listed there are exceptions for economics feasibility one of those - those exceptions don't include the ability to pay so i have a question and supervisor avalos or the planning department staff that you have one o someone that has an illegal in-law unit and not the ability to pay what is that person to do do i know that commissioner walker referred to the loan fund she and i worked on and dbi put more money into the fund and we created that fund an important thing in terms of helping the owners bring their property up to code right now $4 million in the code and more to be added but the the cost of bringing one in-law unit into the compliance or 75 thousands of dollars and 10 of thousands of units that quickly will be depleted i am to get a response

lot legalization puts us on a path to requiring the legalization, of cours legalization supervisor chiu was passed a few years ago for the first time created a full path to volunteery legalization for the legal in-law units i was a supporter it passed unanimously that has taken the next step to you maurntd r mandating those units beleaguer listed there are exceptions for economics feasibility one of those - those exceptions don't include the ability to pay so i have a question and supervisor avalos or the planning department staff that you have one o someone that has an illegal in-law unit and not the ability to pay what is that person to do do i know that commissioner walker referred to the loan fund she and i worked on and dbi put more money into the fund and we created that fund an important thing in terms of helping the owners bring their property up to code right now $4 million in the code and more to be added but the the cost of bringing one in-law unit into the compliance or 75 thousands of dollars and 10 of thousands of units that quickly will be depleted i am to get a response

lot legalization puts us on a path to requiring the legalization, of cours legalization supervisor chiu was passed a few years ago for the first time created a full path to volunteery legalization for the legal in-law units i was a supporter it passed unanimously that has taken the next step to you maurntd r mandating those units beleaguer listed there are exceptions for economics feasibility one of those - those exceptions don't include the ability to pay so i have a question and supervisor avalos or the planning department staff that you have one o someone that has an illegal in-law unit and not the ability to pay what is that person to do do i know that commissioner walker referred to the loan fund she and i worked on and dbi put more money into the fund and we created that fund an important thing in terms of helping the owners bring their property up to code right now $4 million in the code and more to be added but the the cost of bringing one in-law unit into the compliance or 75 thousands of dollars and 10 of thousands of units that quickly will be depleted i am to get a response

lot legalization puts us on a path to requiring the legalization, of cours legalization supervisor chiu was passed a few years ago for the first time created a full path to volunteery legalization for the legal in-law units i was a supporter it passed unanimously that has taken the next step to you maurntd r mandating those units beleaguer listed there are exceptions for economics feasibility one of those - those exceptions don't include the ability to pay so i have a question and supervisor avalos or the planning department staff that you have one o someone that has an illegal in-law unit and not the ability to pay what is that person to do do i know that commissioner walker referred to the loan fund she and i worked on and dbi put more money into the fund and we created that fund an important thing in terms of helping the owners bring their property up to code right now $4 million in the code and more to be added but the the cost of bringing one in-law unit into the compliance or 75 thousands of dollars and 10 of thousands of units that quickly will be depleted i am to get a response

of affordable housing money and rehabilitating affordable housing that was put forward by assembly chiu and king upwards of a billion dollars for the state i think that there's always more willingness at the state level to find matching programs for the local entities are committed and have skin in the game. >> on the logics so it was implemented say it went through a couple codify months we're probably getting off topic but forgive me but - >> get into the weeds. >> but how long - so let's see the program is implemented so you don't - you run out of funding it is obviously there is a lot of funding we need more how hard to turn around midstream and sxhaushgs is talking about the state level that gets complicate; right? so in the meanwhile people are under violation under the cu process been told you should legalize the unit and fund available but they're not there they've been used of or up or whatever how is that situation handled. >> are you referring to the fund that dbi puts into it normally with anything the budget one it is approved that's what is approved and you have to wait un

. >> chiu is doing her best. at home, bo-han's day is as regimented as it is at daycare -- football, shower, homework, bed at 9:30. a 14-hour day. a taiwanese childhood. >> let's catch our breath quickly before heading off to the andes. the longest continental mountain range in the world, extending across seven south american countries. our story comes from peru, where retreating glaciers are only one of the many signs of the impact of climate change. drought is hitting the region hard with many indigenous mountain communities forced to abandon their villages in search of water. there is no easy answer to their problem, but ancient inka knowledge could help them to adapt to their changing environment. ♪ >> there's only one glacier left here in the yauyos-cochas nation park ineru. there used to be more. to robejildo taipe, the landscape here is beautiful. so long as the glacial waters don't disappear, this region 4000 meters above sea level will remain a place he loves. >> there was no glacial ice left here when i

decimated bias or prejudice are throw the baby out with the bath water talking about this after supervisor chiu provide a volunteery legalization program in hearing some of the exemptions it seems to me one of the motivations behind the issue is to bring the markets to units or provide for these are existing in-law units on the rent-controlled unit if you mandate the legalization for those owners that actually have a illegal unit on their property if they're not listing to bear the cost those are ground floor units they have less natural light and smaller we call naturally quotes they don't rents for that those the newspapers today service workers and teachers can afford them we feel if this legislations it is passed the units will not be rented out i appreciate your consideration please line up here by the windows good afternoon. supervisors shawn i'm here today to share my comments on this about the demolition of the single families houses i'm concerned about the process of converting to a conditional use creates on reduce costly and complicated process a group who relies on this industry who

lot legalization puts us on a path to requiring the legalization, of cours legalization supervisor chiu was passed a few years ago for the first time created a full path to volunteery legalization for the legal in-law units i was a supporter it passed unanimously that has taken the next step to you maurntd r mandating those units beleaguer listed there are exceptions for economics feasibility one of those - those exceptions don't include the ability to pay so i have a question and supervisor avalos or the planning department staff that you have one o someone that has an illegal in-law unit and not the ability to pay what is that person to do do i know that commissioner walker referred to the loan fund she and i worked on and dbi put more money into the fund and we created that fund an important thing in terms of helping the owners bring their property up to code right now $4 million in the code and more to be added but the the cost of bringing one in-law unit into the compliance or 75 thousands of dollars and 10 of thousands of units that quickly will be depleted i am to get a response

with the famous three amigos from the board of supervisors, david campos who cannot be with us, david chiu who is with us now represent us up in sacramento, and mark farrell. where is mark? mark is over here. we like to thank all of them >>[applause] . >> phil are some women is with us but i understand he had to be. i want to into some of the other folks on the stage with. bob tomasello was the chairman of our board. michael terry of the present in the building trades. vernon chiang our chief medical executive. mike colville, former president of the west bay region of sutter health. jeff gerard, our current president of the center health bay area. tony wagner, the chairman of the board of center health bay area. and julie pacitti the ceo of the hospital for the sutter of bay area. now, of course, most of this event is about the team building the hospital there represented by the management and the workers from herero bold and we want to thank them. we want to figure architecture group the mother smith group, jj argument in the many trade partners, subcontractors and consultants who have he

lot legalization puts us on a path to requiring the legalization, of cours legalization supervisor chiu was passed a few years ago for the first time created a full path to volunteery legalization for the legal in-law units i was a supporter it passed unanimously that has taken the next step to you maurntd r mandating those units beleaguer listed there are exceptions for economics feasibility one of those - those exceptions don't include the ability to pay so i have a question and supervisor avalos or the planning department staff that you have one o someone that has an illegal in-law unit and not the ability to pay what is that person to do do i know that commissioner walker referred to the loan fund she and i worked on and dbi put more money into the fund and we created that fund an important thing in terms of helping the owners bring their property up to code right now $4 million in the code and more to be added but the the cost of bringing one in-law unit into the compliance or 75 thousands of dollars and 10 of thousands of units that quickly will be depleted i am to get a response

this again at another hearing this is important we spent last year talking about supervisor david chiu in-law units and now this overlays what we spent last year doing with none having a chance to let that legislation work it is not only single-family homes a lot of my multi united business owne building eros owners can legalize the existing units this is going to be great housing la jolla affordable housing housing but not mess up that opportunity we're right on the verge of doing it if we don't spend the proper amount of timo looking at this and acknowledging the important process and the power jurisdiction you guys have over this so thank you. >> thank you. >> next speaker >> i see nun. >> public comment is closed. now. >> commissioner walker no. >> i want to commend the supervisors office for at least deali dealing with some of the issues i came to the land use commission meeting i think the issues chave been brought up by the corrode advisory teams and representatives are true we already have a complicated process going on that is not fully understood i too would like to see more

this again at another hearing this is important we spent last year talking about supervisor david chiu in-law units and now this overlays what we spent last year doing with none having a chance to let that legislation work it is not only single-family homes a lot of my multi united business owne building eros owners can legalize the existing units this is going to be great housing la jolla affordable housing housing but not mess up that opportunity we're right on the verge of doing it if we don't spend the proper amount of timo looking at this and acknowledging the important process and the power jurisdiction you guys have over this so thank you. >> thank you. >> next speaker >> i see nun. >> public comment is closed. now. >> commissioner walker no. >> i want to commend the supervisors office for at least deali dealing with some of the issues i came to the land use commission meeting i think the issues chave been brought up by the corrode advisory teams and representatives are true we already have a complicated process going on that is not fully understood i too would like to see more

that'sa ld chiu yous jtil kled. ie havo tve lih wit myab byo gne doi kn't wnow thatoo. d iti'm snll iho sck. it>> wesnessld to u tshe sctuspe ridescnptio a is hniispac male in 4 his w0's fithlaciar. hai ashe wri dving a wehitel pan van tthad ha nond wiows. >>k bace her liver neae tha are wh terehatpe hap aned,enyon s harminfon atioskis aca al c ecrimaqdepp sto 705-2-385.555 >> a: dan k we tnowf lepeop arenk driingur dinghe t pesuowr bnl oun sday. thasat wur ding thea gme at .5:30 we don't know if soomebdy was at paarty and got d arunkndov dre .home onwe d'tw. kno bu at werein hopgy thed finis th rspesack quiowra hibecos. bar y m k >>caim: thll riat cestato sspperba par nu imberu f yo aknowinnythtit thado hecan lp. bensiis h lbafoot atalk gbout ooing lff adest amch p velitu picoures st of cifran just a beautiful shot.a daana he boi pgntint thacou theam was about 45 mutin away from that ptuice.r >> a d: namcaew nnto throwing an inrctetiepon trehe. threeis ptoeynan minng. heas wll almi aesr teethqu bagall ymeteesayrd. cabato newt n nop onbrwicos itn 4- 210 despite the fa t

aaron no other questions from me i wanted to have someone from the mayor's office of housing bryan chius here with the issue of using source of funding and maybe the housing trust fund and as part of trust fund to cover the relocation for those who have hardships. >> bryan chew for the mayor's office of housing as supervisor avalos mentioned we do exercise authorities over funds created by the package of that housing trust fund act we have dollars available for single-family homes rehabilitation it is limited by in case to only use those few minutes for those owners blow one and 20 percent of the ami so we're accustomed to doing these small projects for single-family homes and my colleague from dbi mentioned it is unclear how many of the people applying for legalization fall into the categories of the single-family homes but if this is the day and qualify we will be happy to work with dbi with planning and with supervisors office to create a program that is appropriate for the low income homeowners for this system. >> great thank you. >> okay. no more questions that will ends the presen

the second measure staff is recommended support for is by assembly member chiu on page 18 and this deals with bus safety inspections. established criteria and requires dmv to notify public utilities commission can when a bus companies first register as vehicle that isn't happening yet so this steps in and takes or addresses that gap in notification. then if there is a inspection and not a satisfactory rating the bus is prohibited to be used from that company. the next mexer measure is special session bill, abx 1 is our framing for special session. number 18 is found on page 25 of the matrix. this bill that mr. linder would return state truck weight fees that are collected and used to offset transportation general obligation bond debt service squu mounts to about a billion dollars a year and this is a proposal to return the truck weight fees back to transportation services where they have been used for years and years. it has a potential impact on the general funds because the general fund has the obligation to make debt service payments so that is the fiscal and policy tension bringing t

the second measure staff is recommended support for is by assembly member chiu on page 18 and this deals with bus safety inspections. established criteria and requires dmv to notify public utilities commission can when a bus companies first register as vehicle that isn't happening yet so this steps in and takes or addresses that gap in notification. then if there is a inspection and not a satisfactory rating the bus is prohibited to be used from that company. the next mexer measure is special session bill, abx 1 is our framing for special session. number 18 is found on page 25 of the matrix. this bill that mr. linder would return state truck weight fees that are collected and used to offset transportation general obligation bond debt service squu mounts to about a billion dollars a year and this is a proposal to return the truck weight fees back to transportation services where they have been used for years and years. it has a potential impact on the general funds because the general fund has the obligation to make debt service payments so that is the fiscal and policy tension bringing t

before her appointment she served as legislative aide to supervisor chiu.ll get to know her and the issues facing the city. welcome, supervisor. thank you for join using us. >> thank you for having me. >> let's start with a little about your background. where you grew up, went to school and what kind of jobs you had in the past. >> sure, i grew up in the sunset district. still live there. spent about 20 years living in the sunset district and just am so proud to be able to represent the district that i grew up in and where my parents still live. i had gone through the public education system and went to neighborhood schools throughout the sunset district. so, had gone to francis scott key elementary school, hoover middle school, lowell high school and am just so proud to be able to come back full circle to support a lot of those schools that i went to and be part of that community in a very integral way. >> so, you spent most of your life in san francisco. why did you choose to live in the city? >> well, first of all, my parents decided to move us to the su

aaron no other questions from me i wanted to have someone from the mayor's office of housing bryan chius here with the issue of using source of funding and maybe the housing trust fund and as part of trust fund to cover the relocation for those who have hardships. >> bryan chew for the mayor's office of housing as supervisor avalos mentioned we do exercise authorities over funds created by the package of that housing trust fund act we have dollars available for single-family homes rehabilitation it is limited by in case to only use those few minutes for those owners blow one and 20 percent of the ami so we're accustomed to doing these small projects for single-family homes and my colleague from dbi mentioned it is unclear how many of the people applying for legalization fall into the categories of the single-family homes but if this is the day and qualify we will be happy to work with dbi with planning and with supervisors office to create a program that is appropriate for the low income homeowners for this system. >> great thank you. >> okay. no more questions that will ends the presen

aaron no other questions from me i wanted to have someone from the mayor's office of housing bryan chius here with the issue of using source of funding and maybe the housing trust fund and as part of trust fund to cover the relocation for those who have hardships. >> bryan chew for the mayor's office of housing as supervisor avalos mentioned we do exercise authorities over funds created by the package of that housing trust fund act we have dollars available for single-family homes rehabilitation it is limited by in case to only use those few minutes for those owners blow one and 20 percent of the ami so we're accustomed to doing these small projects for single-family homes and my colleague from dbi mentioned it is unclear how many of the people applying for legalization fall into the categories of the single-family homes but if this is the day and qualify we will be happy to work with dbi with planning and with supervisors office to create a program that is appropriate for the low income homeowners for this system. >> great thank you. >> okay. no more questions that will ends the presen

u chiu and supervisor wiener and tom ammiano that offered the legislation i saw the loose to a realize to build up to two to three percent affordable housing we are that not successful the inclusion of the treasure island but again, if you issue to reestablish the tools the san francisco throughout the cities of california that is choeshl and possible we called been the tida to explore the development to leverage legislation and other ways to establish the 40 on treasure island and being clear about going from thirty to 35 percent from the 20 percent income range and phil the rest we've done in other deals that is one and 50 percent of afternoon area income we're drastically underbuilding affordable housing and households that make between 80 and one and $30,000 that's another educator we believe that is important to figure ways to use the general fund our supporters support they want the tax dollars to be used for more affordable poor i know you've gone through the presentation i've looked through and you looked at creating a performa at both 25 i'm sorry letting elite me put this up.

the table and we also know that even the assembly level again, i want to echo that assembly member chiu just a matter of us reaching out to all the other stakeholders and binge them on board and see how to pursue that trld treasure island milestone might be strurnl in guiding the stakeholders on that matter we definitely want to make sure that tihdi it is homeless you know housing is built and we can come up with all kinds of various ideas i want to echo that sentiment and be part of that committee. >> okay that i am on this item hearing none, next matter. >> item 6 consent agenda are considered to be routine may be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the commission. there will be no separate discussion of these items a member of the commission, the public, or staff so requests in which event the matter shall be removed from the consent calendar and considered as a separate item at this or a future hearing. item 6 a approving the minutes of january 3rd, 2016, and item 6 b authorizing the execution of this with with marin county flea market, llc doing business as treasure island and

with the famous three amigos from the board of supervisors, david campos who cannot be with us, david chiu who is with us now represent us up in sacramento, and mark farrell. where is mark? mark is over here. we like to thank all of them >>[applause] . >> phil are some women is with us but i understand he had to be. i want to into some of the other folks on the stage with. bob tomasello was the chairman of our board. michael terry of the present in the building trades. vernon chiang our chief medical executive. mike colville, former president of the west bay region of sutter health. jeff gerard, our current president of the center health bay area. tony wagner, the chairman of the board of center health bay area. and julie pacitti the ceo of the hospital for the sutter of bay area. now, of course, most of this event is about the team building the hospital there represented by the management and the workers from herero bold and we want to thank them. we want to figure architecture group the mother smith group, jj argument in the many trade partners, subcontractors and consultants who have he

on the motion to accept the verbal resolution superviso david chiu's. >> no commissioner vice president turman marry no commissioner marshacommissioner marshall what are we voting for so accept the verbal resolution that commissioner president loftus read into the record. >> sxhaush how do you vote. >> i'm still. >> this is pretty straightforward a verbal resolution the public has not seen on a piece of paper commissioner mazzucco didn't want wants to vote on what is read into the record and to approve the concept when everyone can look at it. >> he didn't want to make the amendment an up and down vote go. >> commissioner marshall how do you vote own the motion to accept the verbal will motion from commissioner mazzucco. >> i've heard a no vote means what your you're not accepting the verbal motion as read into the record by commissioner president loftus. >> it's not about the issue. >> does that make. >> make another motion dr. marshall. >> we're the middle of a motion we have to follow procedure dr. marshalls vote how do you vote. >> i'm sorry was that a no. >> the original thing we d

named i believe this body should consider a one paragraph resolution calling on mark len and david chiu to call on their colleagues in sacramento to change the cop protection law we have to name the cops when the complaints with filed the next matter is i filed a sunshine ordinance task force complaint against this body you are not adhering to the sunshine laws that call on commissions to put on specific your agenda say a report from the chief financial officer and the president when we show up you've got a long list of specific things you'll address that we need to know in advance you are going to address it is not okay to keep on saying chiefs report and that's it chief tells you what you're going to talk about i'm not buying in department of justice cops investigation of the department the d o jewelry box cops investigation for this police department for wrongs doing is not looking at the mario woods it is window dressing it is not a federal investigation that is going to carry legal weight chief financial officer you'll be able to dismiss with the doj cops come back you know when i

named i believe this body should consider a one paragraph resolution calling on mark len and david chiu to call on their colleagues in sacramento to change the cop protection law we have to name the cops when the complaints with filed the next matter is i filed a sunshine ordinance task force complaint against this body you are not adhering to the sunshine laws that call on commissions to put on specific your agenda say a report from the chief financial officer and the president when we show up you've got a long list of specific things you'll address that we need to know in advance you are going to address it is not okay to keep on saying chiefs report and that's it chief tells you what you're going to talk about i'm not buying in department of justice cops investigation of the department the d o jewelry box cops investigation for this police department for wrongs doing is not looking at the mario woods it is window dressing it is not a federal investigation that is going to carry legal weight chief financial officer you'll be able to dismiss with the doj cops come back you know when i

named i believe this body should consider a one paragraph resolution calling on mark len and david chiu to call on their colleagues in sacramento to change the cop protection law we have to name the cops when the complaints with filed the next matter is i filed a sunshine ordinance task force complaint against this body you are not adhering to the sunshine laws that call on commissions to put on specific your agenda say a report from the chief financial officer and the president when we show up you've got a long list of specific things you'll address that we need to know in advance you are going to address it is not okay to keep on saying chiefs report and that's it chief tells you what you're going to talk about i'm not buying in department of justice cops investigation of the department the d o jewelry box cops investigation for this police department for wrongs doing is not looking at the mario woods it is window dressing it is not a federal investigation that is going to carry legal weight chief financial officer you'll be able to dismiss with the doj cops come back you know when i

named i believe this body should consider a one paragraph resolution calling on mark len and david chiu to call on their colleagues in sacramento to change the cop protection law we have to name the cops when the complaints with filed the next matter is i filed a sunshine ordinance task force complaint against this body you are not adhering to the sunshine laws that call on commissions to put on specific your agenda say a report from the chief financial officer and the president when we show up you've got a long list of specific things you'll address that we need to know in advance you are going to address it is not okay to keep on saying chiefs report and that's it chief tells you what you're going to talk about i'm not buying in department of justice cops investigation of the department the d o jewelry box cops investigation for this police department for wrongs doing is not looking at the mario woods it is window dressing it is not a federal investigation that is going to carry legal weight chief financial officer you'll be able to dismiss with the doj cops come back you know when i

the second measure staff is recommended support for is by assembly member chiu on page 18 and this deals with bus safety inspections. established criteria and requires dmv to notify public utilities commission can when a bus companies first register as vehicle that isn't happening yet so this steps in and takes or addresses that gap in notification. then if there is a inspection and not a satisfactory rating the bus is prohibited to be used from that company. the next mexer measure is special session bill, abx 1 is our framing for special session. number 18 is found on page 25 of the matrix. this bill that mr. linder would return state truck weight fees that are collected and used to offset transportation general obligation bond debt service squu mounts to about a billion dollars a year and this is a proposal to return the truck weight fees back to transportation services where they have been used for years and years. it has a potential impact on the general funds because the general fund has the obligation to make debt service payments so that is the fiscal and policy tension bringing t

named i believe this body should consider a one paragraph resolution calling on mark len and david chiu to call on their colleagues in sacramento to change the cop protection law we have to name the cops when the complaints with filed the next matter is i filed a sunshine ordinance task force complaint against this body you are not adhering to the sunshine laws that call on commissions to put on specific your agenda say a report from the chief financial officer and the president when we show up you've got a long list of specific things you'll address that we need to know in advance you are going to address it is not okay to keep on saying chiefs report and that's it chief tells you what you're going to talk about i'm not buying in department of justice cops investigation of the department the d o jewelry box cops investigation for this police department for wrongs doing is not looking at the mario woods it is window dressing it is not a federal investigation that is going to carry legal weight chief financial officer you'll be able to dismiss with the doj cops come back you know when i

on the motion to accept the verbal resolution superviso david chiu's. >> no commissioner vice president turman marry no commissioner marshacommissioner marshall what are we voting for so accept the verbal resolution that commissioner president loftus read into the record. >> sxhaush how do you vote. >> i'm still. >> this is pretty straightforward a verbal resolution the public has not seen on a piece of paper commissioner mazzucco didn't want wants to vote on what is read into the record and to approve the concept when everyone can look at it. >> he didn't want to make the amendment an up and down vote go. >> commissioner marshall how do you vote own the motion to accept the verbal will motion from commissioner mazzucco. >> i've heard a no vote means what your you're not accepting the verbal motion as read into the record by commissioner president loftus. >> it's not about the issue. >> does that make. >> make another motion dr. marshall. >> we're the middle of a motion we have to follow procedure dr. marshalls vote how do you vote. >> i'm sorry was that a no. >> the original thing we d