are you chris gibbs? >> i am. >> thank you. we will now hear from planning department. nothing? department of building inspection? >> commissioners, joe duffy, d.b.i. i will try to give you guys so explanation. there is a lot -- there are two sides to that story and i just read the brief last night. i was involved with the case. the permit that is under appeal is a revision to permit application 2-018-102-3901. it is under approval. [indiscernible] there were drawings with that permit. now i refer back to the 2018 permit. the permit that that revised was four level one that had two bedrooms, a family room, a study , a laundry room, modify existing bathroom. level two, change existing room, remodel the kitchen in the dining area, replace the furnace , so that was the original permit. [please stand by] >> -- to document the work, including means and methods and sequencing of the foundation work. that permit that was required is the permit that's under appeal. that's the revision that d.b.i. wanted them to get to document how they actually done the foundation. so what happened was

are you chris gibbs? >> i am. >> thank you.