>>> good evening from new york, i'm chris hayes. we've got huge developments tonight in two of the trials of donald trump. just within the last half hour, judge tanya chutkan, who was overseeing the federal criminal case of january 6th and the attempt to overturn the 2020 election, issued a withering rejection of the ex presidents attempt to get his crimal case thrown out of court. trump and his lawyers had argued that he had total presidential immunity, and so the case should be dismissed outright. chutkan rejected that argument saying in part, quote,

i'm jason johnson in for chris hayes. as we approach the new year, when the many legal troubles facing donald trump will come to a head, tonight the ex president has just lost access to the presidential ballot in a second state. secretary of state from maine ruled that, quote, donald j trump is not qualifi to hold the office of president under section three of the 14th amendment. which bars people who have engaged in insurrection from holding office. quote, the events of january 6th, 2021, where unprecedented and tragic. and the evidce here demonstrates that they occurred at the behest of and with the knowledge and support of the outgoing president. she adds, quote, i am mindful that no secretary of state has ever deprived presidential candidate of ballot access based on section three of the 14th amendment. i am also mindful however that no presidential candidate has ever before engaged in insurrection. the main ruling comes just about a week before the colorado state supreme court reached the same conclusion. bayard trum

a very special "all in" with chris hayes starts right now. >>> good afternoon from new york.cial two-hour 4:00 p.m. edition of "all in." it's a little under an hour ago the supreme court rejected a proposal from

i'm chris hayes. are very polarized country where it's hard to achieve consensus on just about anything, a strong majority of americans believe that donald trump is a crook. this comes from new polling by the new york times which found that 58% of registered voters need the ex president has committed serious federal crimes. just a third of voters, 33% said no he hasn't. that's a 25 point gap. again, in our very divided times, that counts as a very strong consensus. to be clear, this is not some abnormally anti trump survey. in the very same poll, 46% of registered voters said they would vote for donald trump if the election were held today compared to 44% for joe biden. as within the margin of error so 11 months out it appears to be a neck and neck race between the incumbent democratic president and the guy who is facing 91 felony counts across four separate states and federal cases. this is, of course, the paradox, the things that his left many of us scratching our heads. same result from the same po

i'm chris hayes. nearly everyone watching tonight has either had the experience of being pregnant or being close to someone who has been pregnant. it's one of the most intense and overwhelming experiences in this life. i mean, i have felt, this three times when my wife's been pregnant, even as the person adjacent not having to do anything, i'll never know what it's like to have to physically go through it, and yet still, in the early stages, there's this real sense of precariousness. every one of those early checkups, your heart is in your throat. you wait to hear the baby's first heartbeat. and then you wait to tell your friends and family because you know that miscarriages happen. and then you get past that 12-week mark, which you have got in your head, on the calendar, the first trimester, where the vast majority of those losses occur. and you think, you hope that you're in the clear, and you probably show the good news in the start making plans for the shower and the nursery and the birth, and it

all in with chris hayes starts now. >>> w ith chris hayes starts >> tonig.

all in with chris hayes starts right now. now. >> >> tonight on all in the. >> i did everything right, and they indicted me. >> the paradox of the trump polling. >>

i'm chris hayes if you don't know.

all in with chris hayes starts right now. >>>right >> tonight on all in. >> why do you think most people still don't feel positive or feel good news about the academy? >> right-wing's hard sale in the face of a soft landing. >> everything the biden administration touches it burns to the ground. >> tonight, a brief history of solved problems in the era of joe biden. >> the grinch has nothing on these people. >> and donald trump launches the one hail mary pass that could push his insurrection trial past the election. >> i did everything right and they indicted me. >> that's a real story of a woman in texas who sued her state to obtain an emergency abortion. >> forcing me to continue the pregnancy, with the pain and suffering, i think it's cool. >> when all in starts right now. >> good evening from new york, i'm chris hayes. we're just a few weeks from the first votes, actual votes being cast in the early nominating contest for the presidential election. one of the main points of discussion, central focuses heading into this ele

that's tonight's read out, all in with chris hayes starts now. all >>> tonight on all in. >> a jury still witnessed a what rudy giuliani did to me and my daughter, and held him accountable, and for that, i'm thankful. >> breaking news across all the networks. >> oh my goodness, all the networks. wow. tonight, the crushing verdict against donald trump's lead election denier. >> she, she. >> the attorney for them ruby freeman and shaye moss will join me. >> rudy was not the only one -- >> to week a apologies from two top codefendants could be a dark side of things to come. plus, new reporting on donald trump and the missing binder of classified intelligence on russia. and jodi kantor of the new york times on her explosive new reporting on how the supreme court maneuvered to end federal abortion rights all in starts right now. >> good evening from new york, i'm chris hayes. rudy giuliani has been ordered by a jury to pay to georgia election workers 100 and $48 million in damages after he was found civilly liable for defaming them with his repeated l

i'm chris hayes. the first notifications for jury duty have gone out. what is arguably the most important criminal trial in history of democracy. john allen goes hand to what looks like a form for prospective jurors in donald trump's federal election interference trial to begin march 4th of next year, just a few months from now. he has potential jurors of they will be able to attend, quote, five days a week for a period of approximately three months, starting on that date. and it tells them to prepare for more detailed series of questions, starting with february. the person to receive the summons told nbc news the document does not refer to trump by name, based on the days and the length of the trial, you can easily infer what is regarded. both sides in that trial are preparing with legal funds that give some indication the cases they will present, again, in this trial it's gonna happen in three months, according to one recent filing trump's lawyers are apparently going to try to confuse and hoodwink and misdirect the jury with all kinds of ludicrous an

all in with chris hayes, what did you say? it starts now. it does. it starts now. w. >> tonight on all in. >> i don't talk about anything. you know why? because i'm allowed to do whatever i want. >> the republican front runners nixon defense goes poof. >> when the president does it, that means that it is not illegal. >> tonight, why two major rulings against donald trump could be jack smith's biggest victory to date. >>> then, the tragic culmination of the george santos saga. >> you have no business in this building! >>> tonight, the long road to today's historic expulsion. >> that makes me jewish. it's always been a party favor, everyone's always laughed. now everybody is canceling me. >> just when you thought ron desantis couldn't get cringier. >> you are trolling folks and trying to find migrants to play political games and get some attention seeking out trump trump. by the way, how is that going for? you >> all in starts right now. >>> good evening from new york, i'm chris hayes. we've got huge developments tonight in two of the trials of donald trump. just wit

i'm chris hayes. we have a stunning bit of unprecedented news out of the state of colorado tonight. it comes at an unprecedented time, with an unprecedented presidential candidate, donald trump. tonight, the colorado supreme court ruled that the ex president cannot appear, even appear on the republican primar ballot in that state because he is constitutionally disqualified from holding office under section three of the 14th amendment to the united states nstution. that clause reads, in part, quote, no peon shall hold any office, civil or military, under the united states, who, having previously taken an oath, as a member of congress, or as an officer of the ipad states, to support the constitution of the united states, shall have engaged in insurrection or rebellion against the same. the purpose of that amendment added in the wake of the traitorous violent civil war, what is to make sure that people in positions of power, particularly officers of the, u.s. members of congress, wh betrayed the country could not come bd hold office again. many legal experts have argu that it's squarel

in the season of glad tidings, farmer chris hayes is our very own network santa. i'm happy to have him back for an hour, honestly. >> great television. dream we need more. >> thanks lawrence. >> thank you alex. we have breaking codefendant news tonight, don trump's criminal criminal codefendant in georgia, jeffrey clark, is under a bond order not to communicate with any of his codefendants in the case like donald trump. and so jeffrey clark, lonely jeffrey clark, has chosen today to communicate with me. because today is a day when he was exposed, as thinking out loud, that he might not be worthy to become the next attorney general of the united states, which he was secretly plotting to become with donald trump so that jeffrey clark could try to use the power and influence of the justice department to criminally overturn the results of the presidential election, a text exchange made public in court today revealed, washington post reporting the december 30th 2020 jeffrey clark, who was an obscure assistant attorney general overseeing some civil cases, discussed the

i'm chris hayes. we made it on the precipice of the end of the congressional career of one john george santos. tomorrow the new york republican will face his third expulsion vote in less than a year inoffice. it has to be some kind of record. there have been key developments since the last vote failed at the beginning of the month. remember, it's a two thirds vote. that was ethics deter me committee released a report saying found substantial evidence that santos violated federal law, divided he's own donors, and used campaign donations toenrich himself personally. he spending it on resort, stays luxury goods, tox, in the website onlyfans. that comesin addition to the 23 countedal indictment filed against the congressman in october the charges him with conspiracy, wire fraud, making false statements, falsifying records, credit card fraud, identity theft, and theft of public funds. and even beyond all that, george santos is just an enormous embarrassment to his party and to the institution of congress a

i'm chris hayes. i have some news about that recession that everyone said was coming. i think maybe it's not going to come. now whether you believe it or not or if you feel it or not, the united states economy, at the macro level, under president biden, is, according to nearly every metric we used to measure such things, in excellent shape. yesterday the chairman of the federal reserve, jerome powell, announced the fed will keep interest rates steady for now and forecast they will cut rates three times in 2024. that may seem obscure, the kind of thing the business press covers closely, but it's massively significant. it's a hugely positive indicator that we may be through the worst of our recent economic challenges, the most difficult turbulent ones that we have seen in a generation at least. and next year we could have something that looks like normalcy. better the normalcy. a growing economy, unfettered by the aftermath of covid. as jerome powell explained, it's not quite mission accomplished. the economy, our economy, has defied all expectations, our predictions of

all in with chris hayes starts now. ts now. >> tonight on all in. donald trump cannot make public comments about known or foreseeable witnesses in a case. the trump gag order is upheld in a major court decision, with big implications for the timing of the coup trial. >> it makes that march 4th trial date increasingly farm. >>> as trump's codefendant in georgia helps make cases in four other states. >> the please lower your hand instead your true and correct the legal name. >> kenneth john chesebro. >>> then the state of texas threatens to jail doctors for following court orders on a emergency abortion. >> this is the attorney general saying that she should be the one practicing medicine rather than the physicians in his state. >> and how in the world will be right wing spin machine handle another and unambiguously good jobs report? when >> i'm going to make the case that that decline in the unemployment rate is actually a negative, not a positive. >> when all in starts, right now. >>> that evening from new york, i'm chris hayes, today, a washington

i agree with chris hayes, saying the supreme court must act decisively and swiftly. >> brian: that wouldabout your guest list. >> dana: we have bill bill mcgurn and larry kudlow who will talk about the economy, tom dupree, will tell us his take on the colorado supreme court. >> dana: i will run upstairs and get coffee on the way. >> brian: coming up, thanks, dana perino. that is what they look like together. personnel from the federal bureau of prison deployed to the southern border as agents grapple with record encounters. our next guest joins us live from el paso next. of bringing textile manufacturing back to america. we're taking the best fibers our farm can produce, spinning it at one location, weaving it, then finally into a cut and sewn product. there's value in buying american made it has a real life impact up and down the supply chain. we want our customers to feel how special this product is, right when they open the box. go to redlandcotton.com and receive 20% off your order with code fox 20. luis fonsi: st. jude shares the breakthroughs and makes with doctors and researchers

i'm jason johnson in for chris hayes. as we approach the new year when the many legal troubles facing donald trump will come to a head, tonight the

i'm jason johnson in for chris hayes. as we apoa

i'm jason johnson in for chris hayes. we're waiting for the special council to respond to donald trump's wildly expansive claim of presidential immunity. trump says he can't be prosecute under january 6th because he wa acquitted in a senate impeachment trial, and he continues he has, quote, absolute immunity from prosecution with his acts as president. jack smith is expect today respond to those claims before the appeals court hears trump's case. that didn't stop the special counsel fromn' filing a new motn with judge tanya chutkan today asking the court to not allow, quote, the defendant to turn the courtroom into a forum in which he propagates disinformation and inject politics into the proceeding. smith also wants the court to, quote, prohibit the defendant from introducing evidence, making arguments, or framing questions to advance a theory of selective or vindictive prosecution. basically the special counsel wants to make sure trump can't say this is joe biden's doj targeting them. and in the response trump said bide

i'm chris hayes. it has been almost three years since the january 6th attack on the capitol, the combination of donald trump's attempted coup. an investigation of the assault on american democracy continues to this day. it is still an open case. it is the largest case in american history conducted by the department of justice. more than 1200 people have been charged, nearly all 50 states and the district of columbia. of course earlier this year the investigation worked its way up to the mom at the top, don trump now facing four felony charges related to his attempt to rein in power after he lost the 2020 election. but there are hundreds of people who participated in the violent attack that still remain at large. we're seeing an effort on the right from allies of the ex president republicans to help those people to evade justice. earlier this month speaker mike johnson openly said that republicans would be protecting the capital rioters by concealing their identities in footage from the attack they pla

. >>> good evening from new york, i'm chris hayes. as we begin the official start of the 2024 election season, there is hardly, a growing awareness across the political spectrum that donald trump is running on an explicit pledge to be a dictator, some form of presidential dictator. if he wins back the white house, then he plans to smash american contribution will -- that he will finish the job that he began on january six. there is a problem with campaigning on the platform. preserving constitutional government is not top priority impulse, people do seem to be turned off by candidates run around sayg that they'll be a fascist dictator. anyone in public politics to bring themselves together understands that this is probably the last message you want to try to win an election, let alone stay one. -- showing that the most strenuously pro coup, pro big lie candidates loose in competitive races, time and time again. in fact, it was all of those losses in the 2022 midterms, momentarily startled some republicans into thinking that, it would

. >> the economy that michael just mentioned and you also mentioned the 401 k, chris hayes has been amazing on this, talking, exhausting himself about the biden economy and how good it is. it is as if people forget that donald trump helped dive the country into a global pandemic pandemic. he was president in 2020. i think there is a feeling, democrats are feeling hopeless, a little bit, about looms in the foreground. there is a sense that issues like abortion, if the economy isn't resonating, the performance of democrats on social issues, like important issues like abortion, could help the biden candidacy and democrats down-ticket. >> you have to do all of the things. so we have a year out. we have the most fragmented media environment any president candidate has faced in a century, certainly. so take advantage of that because you could tell a lot of different stories to different audiences by using digital tools. so i think you have to, somebody tied to ask to get advice on what do you think everyone should do? suggested that the biden campaign go back and re-tell the story of march 2020,

msnbc.com slash 2023 and you will find a special video where you can hear from yasmin, jen psaki, chris hayest, president biden is using the prime minister netanyahu to protect civilians and gaza. that's international pressure for a cease-fire grows and what we know about discussions between the two leaders. plus, operation angel tree, the program giving incarcerated parents a chance for them to buy gifts for their kids and what it means this holiday season. nd what it means this holiday season season yup, that's how you business differently. hi! need new glasses? season get more from your benefits at visionworks. how can you see me squinting? i can't! i'm just telling everyone! ...hey! use your vision benefits before they expire. visionworks. see the difference. nexium 24hr prevents heartburn acid for twice as long as pepcid. get all-day and all-night heartburn acid prevention with just one pill a day. choose acid prevention. choose nexium. whenever you're hungry, there's a deal on the subway app. buy one footlong, get one 50% off in the subway app today. now that's a deal worth celebrating.

all in with chris hayes starts and three, two, one, now.two, one, now >> tonight on all in. >> santos was buying

all in with chris hayes, what did you say? it starts now. it does. it starts now.ht on all in. >> i don't talk about anything. you know why? because i'm allowed to do whatever i want.

all in with chris hayes starts right now.ght >> tonight on all in. >> why do you think most people still t

ronan bergman, one of the foremost military reporters and analysts in israel, told my colleague, chris hayesthe hamas document. >> it's about 40 pages, and anyone who starts reading that, it was translated it hebrew, the original was of course in arabic, cannot help but be stunned to the extent of intelligence, the details, the details that hamas was able to connect with the fortification of the wall and other security arrangements in the border. it's not coming from open source. i assume someone is investigating how can this kind of intelligence can reach hamas. but besides that, it translates the intelligence into positioning of forces into a location of gear. it's a massive plan that calls for the deployment of 2000 commanders, hitting the fence at 60 different places, all simultaneously and at the same time, massive bombing of israel with rockets and motors and missiles for diversion, using paragliders and drones to take out all the towers, the cell phone towers, the communication centers, the cameras, and the automatic remote control machine guns. do that at the same time, to create int

. >> danielle, let me play for you what the admission secretary of state told my colleague chris hayes last night about how concerned she was over how wayne county could've been the first domino to fall in trump's election subversion plot. >> we knew we were the first domino to fall if we failed to stop the domino from falling. that was a win for these election subversion attempts. who knows what could happen next? thankfully, it didn't fall. the people stood firm and as a result the elections were certified. >> for me, daniel, we came to a razor-thin moment, if you will, of losing our democracy because whether it is mike pence on january 6th, brad raffensperger and not finding him a vote, or these individuals and wayne county, i guess that it is not the law it is just people interpreting what they think they should be doing. that is how close we came to losing our democracy. >> that is what i want people to pay attention to as we turn the calendar year into 2024. the reality is the only reason why we still have a democracy is because of a handful of people who decided that the constit

i'm jason johnson in for chris hayes. waiting for the special council to respond to donald trump's wildly expansive claim of presidential

. >> good evening from new york, i'm chris hayes. we're just a few weeks from the first votes, actual votes being cast in the early nominating contest for the presidential election. one of the main points of discussion, central focuses heading into this election, centers around the economic well-being of our country. that's because generally speaking how people feel about the economy writ large is largely predictive of how an incoming president will perform if they run for reelection. a lot of people notice there's a strange paradox at the center of our economy, which is that if you look at many if not most of the empirical metrics, the economy is doing surprisingly well. if you do it economic sentiment, how people feel about the economy, the numbers are near historically pessimistic. there is a real gap between how the economy is actually doing, at least based on most of the measurements we normally use, and how people think the economy is doing. or, i should say, at the very least, how they tell pollsters they feel about it. you ca

our colleague here at msnbc chris hayes was reporting on the same issue here.tween what we can understand with economic data, even with the caveats that it's complex and how everyone is feeling. >> you can see on the chart, the blue line, how you would expect people to feel about economic numbers and the redline, how they actually feel, have usually been insync. when things get worse people feel worse. right now there's a huge between them. that golf does not exist in similar wealthy countries like france or germany and the uk. it's only here. even though we are doing better than those places. >> chris is making a very fair point with the data and the gap and as our friend marvin gaye said, what's going on? well, i'm sorry the story ends this way but we are just charting this out. if it's not happening in other places that don't have well this kind of right wing echo chamber, that could be a big factor, which is, facing what i showed you that trump's predictions didn't come true and inflation to drop and the wall streetlly is happening this week exceeds me, so

i'm jason johnson, in for chris hayes. we're waiting for the special counsel to respond to donald trump's wildly expansive claim of presidential immunity. trump says he can't be prosecuted for january six because he was acquitted in a senate impeachment trial. he contends that he is, quote, absolute immunity from prosecution to the prosecution for his official acts as president. jack smith is expected to respond to those claims before the appeals court heals hears arguments on trump's immunity claims on january six. all rulings on the jaime six case are currently on hold, a lot appeals process plays out, but that didn't stop the special counsel from filing a nemotion from char judge john near chuck in. today asking the court to not allow, quote, the defendant to turn the courtroom into a forum in which he propagates relevant disinformation and should reject his intent to inject politics into this proceeding. smith also wants the quo courts to, quote, prohibit the defendant from introducing evidence, making arguments, or fr

i'm chris hayes. >>> colorado republicans are publicly threatening to change how they ve r presidentialees in light of yesterday 's decision by the state supreme court in colorado to barr trump from the primary ballot under the 14th amendment of the u.s. constitution. and the state gop is now saying it may be getting the legally fraught process of switching from a primary caucus in order to allow its members to still cast their vote for trump next march. as of now, that seems like posturing, to be honest. but for all of the controversy, when you go back to the relevant text used to raise the challenge, section three of the 14th amendment, it really does stand out as pretty darn fitting. quote, no person shall hold any office under the united states, who, having previously taken an oath as an officer of the united states to support the constitution shall have engaged in insurrection or rebellion against the same, or given aid or comfort to the enemies thereof. you cannot hold government office if you are an insurrectionist or you supported insurrectionists. it's quite clear, quite simple

eastern, michigan secretary of state will be joining chris hayes live on msnbc. >>> but up next, from israel and hamas to ukraine and russia, a world at war. richard engel has a look at what's next for those regions. g. (mom) please forgive him. (carolers) ♪ it's all good - just a little awkward. ♪ (soloist) think we'll wrap this up. (vo) it's your last chance to turn any iphone in any condition into a new iphone 15 pro with titanium and ipad and apple watch se - all on us. that's up to $1700 in value. only on verizon. (man) mm, hey, honey. looks like my to-do list grew. "paint the bathroom, give baxter a bath, get life insurance," hm. i have a few minutes. i can do that now. oh, that fast? remember that colonial penn ad? i called and i got information. they sent the simple form i need to apply. all i do is fill it out and send it back. well, that sounds too easy! (man) give a little information, check a few boxes, sign my name, done. they don't ask about your health? (man) no health questions. -physical exam? -don't need one. it's colonial penn guaranteed acceptance whole life insura