christine lumbergh said the media's focus on i was getting in the way of factual debate about germany's defense preparedness. the german chancellor olaf shawl says he will swiftly replace her, jessica berlin as a political analyst. she told me that german knees approach towards ukraine has been unclear since the start of the invasion from the beginning of the full scale invasion of russia and ukraine. the schultz government's response has really been highlighted by a lack of clear strategy that has also been not clearly communicated. the government has struggle to identify what really is it's school to achieve in its support of ukraine. for a long time this government struggled to even articulate that ukraine clearly should win, and russia should lose the war. on this has been going on for a good 1011 months. germany support to ukraine started with the offer of helmets, which was roundly criticized. almost an insulting offer in face of what kind of threat ukraine was facing. so there's not so much a shift in the german communication or strategy because the german response over this past