. >> i'm christi paul. here's the question, was the fatal shooting on a movie set in new mexico preventable? we have new questions about safety on the set and the handling of the gun fired by actor alec baldwin. >> the moment so many parents have been waiting for, a meeting to decide on possible approval of a covid vaccine for young children. >> the critical week for president biden too. democrats are inching closer to that deal on trillions in spending. his agenda is on the line here before he leaves for a climate summit overseas. >>> from fires to floods, california, is bracing today for potentially catastrophic weather. evacuations are ordered in the face of a severe storm. >>> good morning. thank you so much for being with us. it is sunday, october 24th. hope you're having a great sunday morning. >> we are so glad to have everybody with us today and waking up, we appreciate you giving us that time of your morning. >> and christi, we're going to begin this morning with new information and new concerns ov

and i agree with christie. i don't think there's a real value here in terms of, of the marketplace for in a business meetings this way. but i don't think that's where zucker berg wants to go. i think where they really want to go is create augmented realities for children because we know through instagram and their projects there, that is his main focus. he wants to focus on kids and children, focus on creating augmented reality for them where they can exist and try to imagine, you know, worlds in which they can live. and i think the repercussions of that are much more serious. um, we're, we're giving them credit. and that's incredibly concerning, especially when you think of how it impacts kids today. when they go on instagram. they see these filter photos will think of if it is actually an entire character you're creating that doesn't match anything close to what you see in the near christy. what's your response to that? how do you think that is impacting the next generation or really this generation as they g

i'm christi paull. >> and i'm ryan nobles in this morning for boris sanchez. the fda say the benefits out way the risks for children. the fda to consider emergency use authorization for vaccine for children. >>> new details in that deadly pop gun shooting involving actor alec baldwin. what we're learning about how the entire thing played out. >>> and the warning signs from america's truckers to say the industry is in desperate need of drivers. how they're working to close the gap including getting more women and minorities behind the wheel. >>> and a pretty dire warning from the white house. why climate change could be a threat to national security. ♪ >>> saturday, october 23rd. thank you so much for spending time with us this morning. so, we begin with the renewed efforts to get the youngest people vaccinated against covid-19. a new report from the fda finding the benefits of pfizer's covid-19 vaccine outweigh the risks, particularly to children, ages 5 to 11. >> yeah, there's a lot of parents like me, christi, that have been waiting for this news. while case

christy, what's your response to that? how do you think that is impacting the next generation or really this generation as they get older? i think it'll be interesting to see the impact of the generation. but really, i think the biggest concern is that people are going to lose touch with reality and how to actually physically interact with their peers and friends. you already hear people complaining about the awkwardness after a quarantine of how difficult it is to get back to social interaction and how difficult it is get back to gathering and meeting places and striking up a conversation that is more than a text. because in a text you can ignore conversation simply by goes thing. and apparently these days in society is getting towards more and more of a trend where people are more so isolated. and you hear this phrase a lot, especially in big cities where you have kids being in big city. it's been like, i know i'm surrounded by a 1000000 people, but i feel like i'm the only person in the world. and that's kind of like th

elise christie. time european champion, but _ corridor. ten time european champion, but say - corridor. ten time european champion, but say the - corridor. ten time european| champion, but say the name corridor. ten time european - champion, but say the name and you think of the fall.— think of the fall. christie is once atain! think of the fall. christie is once again! twice. — think of the fall. christie is once again! twice, she _ think of the fall. christie is once again! twice, she left _ think of the fall. christie is once again! twice, she left the - think of the fall. christie is once | again! twice, she left the winter ol mics again! twice, she left the winter olympics full _ again! twice, she left the winter olympics full of _ again! twice, she left the winter olympics full of hope. _ again! twice, she left the winter olympics full of hope. twice, - again! twice, she left the winter| olympics full of hope. twice, she 0lympics full of hope. twice, she came back empty—handed. olympics full of

it's our discuss our boom bus co host, ben swan and christy i. now been, 1st of all, i want to say, i'm not suggesting anybody download that. i'm just saying that it is available. but 1st, let's start with just how a site like twitch, owned by amazon, visited by i assume, you know, millions to billions of people. how was it so vulnerable? yeah, i think that's the, that's the big question. this around says, look at that 120 a gig torrent file that sitting there. i'm not even sure how interesting it would be a much a why anyone would download it. it's not like it has credit card information on it that you could steal. it does have payouts of earnings, of, of twitch no gamers, if that interests you and you want to know how much they make, i guess. but here's was really interesting about this. so apparently it was some kind of internal server configuration change that was taking place, which is kind of interesting because it's similar to what happened to facebook when they went down on october 4th. they also had a configuration change for their serve

boris, christi?ling that report. >>> elsewhere in the nation's capital speaker nancy pelosi has reset the clock on a trillion dollar infrastructure bill as progressive and moderate democrats hammer out details on a separate, massive spending measure. >> the speaker has scheduled a vote on infrastructure bill for the end of the month now. remember, progressives refused to back the measure without a vote on a reconciliation bill that includes a number of president biden's top economic priorities. daniella diaz is with us now. we have a new deadline that gives democrats a little bit of give and take there. do we have insight into a strategy on how they will get there? >> it's only been a day, christi, since this deadline was set, but the problem here is, that negotiations continue, but lawmakers aren't here. i'm at the capitol right now it's totally empty and the house is in committee work for two weeks, they may not be back physically at the nation's capital to continue negotiating on this. nancy pelos

christy: it's literally long.t feel li we care aut each other more, like, in a deeper level because, like, of course, like, living together, like, who's gonna, like, cook? what if, like, you feel sick? who's going to take care of each other? and jt, like, all the small stuff and details, i feel like--it feels like wee, like, married in some ways. ck: oh, does it? christy: yes. jess: we've been dating since high school? amine: maybe, like, six years now? jess: yeah. it's 6 years. heh. everyone is always asking, "what's your next move," right? like, "what are yodoing after graduation?" like, "what are you doing with your life? what's the plan?" what are you doing? da da da. i think the pandemic has allowed us to say, "i don't know," and that be an acceptable answer. amine: that is very true. jess: and i think in the sense of our relationship too, like, before, it's like, what's going to happen? like, you know, what's your future? what are you doing? where are you moving? and now, it's like, "i just don't know," a th

boris, christi? >> let's talk about house lawmakers returning this week with other major items on their to-do list. democrats still divided over the president's economic plans. what have you learned about the strategy for trying to really salvage that agenda? >> that's exactly right. but the thing is there's still time. there's a new self-imposed deadline of october 31st to try to pass both this bipartisan infrastructure bill that has stalled in the house because progressives operately want to vote on a different legislation, the economic bill, set for $3.5 trillion, but two moderate democratic senators are holding it up, kyrsten sinema and joe manchin. that's what democrats are working on. democratic leaders are working on. they're going to try to figure out before october 31st what krysten sinema and joe manchin want. however there are a lot of sticking points they have to work out these next couple weeks, especially this week when they come back, it's crunch time before october 31st. they are tryi

i'm christi paul. >> good morning, i'm boris sanchez. you're live in the cnn newsroom. >> the fda's advisory committee recommended all adults who received the single dose johnson & johnson vaccine should get a second dose at least two months after their first shot. the fda has to decide whether to grant emergency use authorization followed by the cdc giving its recommendation on who is eligible for the doses. >> we should tell you about a new study by the department of veterans affairs on vaccine effectiveness that's giving cause for concern. researchers found that j&j's vaccine protection against covid-19 drastically fell from 88% in march to a mere 3% by august. the study, we should point out has yet to be peer reviewed. >> good note to make there, but about 15 million people have received the johnson & johnson vaccine, according to the cdc here in the u.s. and nearly 91% of them got their shots more than two months ago. cnn's nick watts has more on that and socdc's recommendation >> those fda advisers gave their thumbs up for a second

a lot, christy. i have about 30 seconds for this, but there's also the claims that facebook mid let misled investors about their reeds. what do we know about that? well, the whistleblower cleans that face was misled investors not the size of the audience and concealed basically years long decline and the younger audience, especially during the corona barriers pandemic. when overall social media usage search, every cohort use a facebook increase except when the $23.00 and under category, which then continued to decline. so facebook basically misrepresented its core metrics to investors and advertisers, including the amount of content produced on its platform. so by including these figures, facebook mon, centrally able to extort higher fees from advertises to run on their promotion when in actuality, and never got those eyeballs there in the 1st place, boom bus, spend swan and christie. i thank you so much for breaking this down. force and to energy prices are soaring with demand for oil, natural gas,

yeah, certainly, especially as we're watching what may end up happening this winter now. christie, i know another topic that we've been talking a lot about, which also deals with the winter months has been the fact that europe is facing this ongoing search and gas prices. a supplies run low. now we've heard that russia has said it's ready to increase supply, but some in europe are saying moscow is just pushing for north stream to, to be officially certified. so how big of a role or politics playing here? when the soaring prices are affecting entire nations? you know, politics, obviously it plays a big part in this. and unfortunately, while these leaders are playing politics, it's the consumer and the people who are left suffering when they have no electricity for the winter. so the north stream to a pipeline was completed last month and still awaiting clearance from german authorities. so given the mountain energy crisis in europe with gas markets now up a staggering 500 percent. so far this year, the market breathed a kind of a sigh of relief when russian president put an offer to i

now christie is being reported that ever grand just misses 3rd round of bond payments and as many weeks intensifying market fears over contagion, as we noted. now, is this a case where every brand is too big to fail? i don't think anything is too big to fail because by saying that you're essentially saying that no risk is too great because at the end of the day, you'll just get a free bail out. so it's just like a perpetual get out of jail free card. so it's a very dangerous mentality to have to just continuously rely on the government for these bail us. and china doesn't want to create that dependency. so i don't think the market thinks it's too big to fail either, which is a good thing. it's trading more rationally now acknowledging the risks and the possible contagion effects slowing down the global economy. so far though, the sell off a queers to be appears to be very limited to more riskier bond names. but then there's also the problem of the potential follow up. the default heard the confidence of the consumers and the home buyers, which as calls just said it makes up a very signi

that's bringing boomers co health, christy. i and john, well to be in the land cobra business school to discuss this with us and to sniff out what is true and not true didn't grow to start with you. home cells in china, they are weighed down. that's not really surprising. in part because of restrictions on lending as well as these worries about developers financial health . it seems like china is trying to reset its entire housing industry here. i believe the statement was to be about living and not about speculation. is that working? well, the real estate sector in china represent, sorry, 5 trillion as in value. that's an extraordinarily high percentage of the chinese economy. and you're right to say that residential housing sales are off about 20 to 30 percent year on year. the fear is that the ever grand situation, which by the way, leaves about 1600000, every grand customers waiting for properties that haven't yet been completed. this is going to cause some contagion across the chinese real estate market, drive down values

so let's bring into moscow health christy. i to talk about this. christy. we talked about e t f earlier this week, the possibility of becoming a reality. what do you think of the chances here that this will actually happen, or is the fcc going away to the last minute and cut it off? well, this is literally something that we've been talking about for the last 2 years. i mean back then every single pitch seem to be so promising to get approval and there was a lot of optimism for. but then in the end something was always flag. it got delayed, no e t f. so someone always had something to say at the last minute against it. so this time around after 2 years of incubating and maturing with big institutional is now accepting it. i don't see how an a t of could get turned down. but hey, anything can happen, especially when you're talking about a topic as polarizing and disruptive as bitcoin. so i think there's probably a 65, maybe 70 percent chance of approval here. but at the end of the day, i don't think it really matters. sure. 2 years ago, having an 18 would hav

christy, i thank you so much for your insight. thank you. and finally, we've told you about the rental car company hurts and this plan to purchase 100000 and tesla. but did you know that half of that order will go towards a new partnership with over? it's all part of overs. pledge to operate only electric vehicles by 2030, the new plan and to get drivers a chance to read a tough le when they don't always have the means to buy one themselves. but it will come with a price only the drivers who have a rating higher than $4.00 stars will be eligible, and they will have to pay $334.00 a week in order to drive a tesla that's significantly higher than the current deal with hertz, which left super drivers, right? a typical 4 door sedan for a $180.00 per week, which becomes free if the driver has more than 75. right. the new program is set to kick off in los angeles, san francisco, san diego, and right here in washington, d. c. just this next week. let me interesting to see how that kicked off. and if your next right is that it seems like they're jus

and christy, i wanted to follow up on that because you make a great point. but then why make those arbitrary deadline? why was trying to making that move? if the case is that, hey, the technology is not ready and you're looking at a country that consume so much energy. all is really well. the entire point is to set the goal and that's what i said. it's great. is that a lot of the schools? the thing is politicians. they are in tune with the entire tech sector. the tech sector has their own roadmap and their own pipeline. they have their own objectives, their funding cost, those developmental costs, and you really can't push the development of technology until it truly becomes stable until you truly have a timeline and a plan for how to implement things. you just don't know so tech and their time like it's very arbitrary. sometimes it takes years to develop certain things and not mentioned have enough batteries. and that's a big thing with either with or when a lot of energy consumption actually get put back into the ground. it doesn't get use it gets dumped.

go host christy i and octavio moran z. c o over miss l. l. c. kristi, let's start with you here. now of course, there have been a lot of questions about when and how the chinese government should be stepping in . why do you think we haven't seen more from beijing after another miss payment here? well i think they, she doesn't want to create the safety net mentality that. # we have here in the states that there's such a thing as too big to fail and that the government will always step in to cushion the fall. i mean, does the mentality of the market here in the us, we just keep on slow and up and up thinking that there's always going to be the money more stimulus policies, government bail out of failing industry. it's like she previously in banking, and then the airlines with coven, and that hotels and the leisure sector, but facing is trying to not create that dependence and expectation. thus, it's willing to have a hard landing here in order to teach a lesson to the market, not to be highly speculative, thinking that there will be absolutely no repercussions, because it's not lik

hope of music no corpus christi school. oh. what do i see in budget when you get the call when you finish with give me a glove when you spoke with said basil makes dreams come true. that every one who falls in love with people threatening like wide mm. headlining this hour. and i would say a british tabloids claim that russian spies stole vaccine secrets gets rivals digging deeper, calling out the story is inaccurate and opaque, but the son is yet to clarify or apologize. also a case of double standards, one of germany's most read newspapers build leaps to the defense of a cobra. discussion panel is content with removed by youtube, but it's the same newspaper that mercilessly lashed. i'll teach german news service during a similar struggle with the video sharing site. fuss a british m p. 's inquiry says the government botched its cobit pandemic.

now, christy, what all do we know about this hacker group called anarchy? well, not much in explicit detail, or i also wouldn't be so fascinating. it's essentially a captive ism group as in internet activism. they use these hacks in order to garner attention as a form of civil disobedience and or to promote a political agenda or social change. and i mean the roots of hacker culture and hacker as 6 are often related to free speech human rights or freedom of information movements. so this leak was literally intended to create a public statement and to create chaos. not out of greed are distortion like ransomware. so that's exactly what this is. the hacker blamed amazon's could bead and twitches sites toxic culture, and stated that the league was intended to foster more disruption and competition in the online video streaming space. essentially by posting the source code for the world to see the hacker, basically as mocking bay. so saying that base those paid $970000000.00 for this. and now he's giving it away for free. and here's why everything gets really in

i christie. good to have you hear? a lot of this comes amid these increasing hopes and expectations that a big going futures. e t f could soon be approved. if that happens, 1st of all, what kind of effect would it have? and will it happen? do you think it's going to happen? i am part of this appreciative certainly has to do with the e t f. although i think we give it way too much credit, there are expectations that a big when futures e t could be approved soon, but we've heard that line about a 100 times in the past 2 years. but look how far the industry has come without having an 80 as actually being approved. i think the main part of the coins appreciation actually has to do with the increasing concerns about inflation. in more than transitory, we have food prices at peak levels. oil topping $8.00, so that's really hitting consumers. so investors are starting to look back to the original peal of bitcoin, which is a store of value and something that is independent to the winds of any central bank . and interestingly t

and chris christie is joining us ahead on "sunday night in america."on't know anybody who's had it. your uncle had shingles. you mean that nasty red rash? and donna next door had it for weeks. yeah, but there's nothing you can do about it. camera man: actually, shingles can be prevented. shingles can be whaaaat? camera man: prevented. you can get vaccinated. baby, call the doctor. camera man: hey! you can also get it from your pharmacist! 50 years or older? get vaccinated for shingles now. hey i'm joe montana. when you get to be our age, you have little patience 50 years or older? for nonsense and inefficiency. after years of practice you become a pro at pretty much everything. so when i qualified for medicare, i got wellcare. they're pros at making things streamlined, efficient and convenient. wellcare offers great benefits like free grocery, meal, and prescription delivery. and if you need to see a doctor, you can get in-home visits and 24/7 virtual visits. wellcare is no nonsense. just great benefits and none of the hassles. [ doorbell rings ] i hav

ron christie, alwa s the united states. ron christie, always good _ the united states.nited states. ron christie, i always good to get your thoughts. good to see you, christian. here in the uk, the public health experts are calling for the covid booster programme to be rolled out faster. the number of new daily cases is just short of 50,000 — that's the highest level since mid—july — and downing street admits winter is looking "challenging". take a look at this chart. you can see how the uk cases from june this year onwards have surged past france and italy. at the end of last week, france was reporting 4,500 cases a day, while in italy, thery were just under 2,500. maybe the uk is a victim of its own success. having raced to vaccine so many, so early, maybe the defence the vaccine offers is beginning to wane, which is why the booster for older people is much needed. and while deaths may still be comparatively low, there are new worries about the serious damage the virus could be doing to some people's health. we have all heard about long covid, but there is now concern

let's bring in christy smith in san francisco. christy? >> there is certainly a lot of excitement out here today seeing olympians and performers. at the center of it all, community leaders who really stepped up during the pandemic. they were honored for commitment and effort during a very challenging time as we all look forward to the olympics. dancer set the tone at san francisco's holiday ice rink in union square. nbc bay area marking 100 days until the olympic winter games in beijing. >> it is so exciting. the clock is really ticking. i know the athletes are more than stoked to be going to beijing. >> figure skater was one of three bay area olympian onz hand to lend support in honoring elected and community leaders who made a real difference during the pan dem iblg. >> we shifted our work to support those seeking unploument insurance. and what we found is that was not language accessible. and so we had step up to provide hundreds of community members in making sure they had money to pay rent. >> i had helped neighborhoods like china tow

christy smith was there and joins us live from san francisco's union square with much more. christy, exciting day out there today. >> absolutely. there was a lot of excitement out here today. seeing owe lumpians and performers. at the center of it all, community leaders that stepped up during the pandemic. they were honored for their efforts and commitment to the challenging times as we look forward to the olympics in beijing. >> a line dance set the tone at san francisco holiday ice rink and union square. nbc bay area marking 100 days until the olympic winter games in beijing. >> it is so exciting. you know, the clock is really ticking for all the athletes. i know they are more than stoked to be going to beijing. >> figure skater was one of three bau area olympians on hand to lend support in honoring elected and community leaders who made a real difference during the pandemic. >> we had supported those who were impacted economically industries were completely shattered because of the economy. working in the service industry, hospitality stri in particular. >> they helped ne

christi. >> nadia romero, we appreciate it so much.ou. >>> you may have heard us mention during our conversation with congresswoman debbie wasserman schultz that there are major demonstrations happening today, more than 600 marches planned across the united states in support of women's reproductive rights. >> they're called rally for abortion justice marches. they're in response to texas enacting a restrictive antiabortion bill, and cnn's suzanne malveaux is live on the hardball mall, where i believe that is where the largest of these crowds is expected. what are you seeing there already, and good morning. >> reporter: good morning, i covered the women's march, the historic one five years ago. that was right after the inauguration of president trump and really, there were hundreds of thousands of women, many of them wearing those pink hand knitted caps, and there was a great deal of fear and uncertainty and rage, really, wondering what the state of reproductive rights would be at that time, and you had the likes of celebrities of alici

another hour, christi. another hour in the books. >> uh-huh. i know. just a couple more to go for this saturday. listen, we are following developments out of texas this morning, too, right, boris? >> yeah, authorities say that one deputy was killed and two others wounded this morning outside of a houston sports bar. >> police officials say the constable deputies w quote, ambushed and shot from behind, by a suspect with a rifle while working a police-related job this morning. cnn's jean casarez has the latest. jean, what do we know about the suspect here? >> reporter: well, we know that somebody is in custody. they're not sureful it's a witness or someone of interest that they believe is associated with this. here's what they know, this is a very critical moment right now because we are learning that one of the deputies shot in the back is currently in surgery right now. another one, shot in the foot, is headed to surgery any minute. and we also know that one of the deputies has passed away. now, this all happened. it was a police-related activity that

term and the impact is on tribal. joining us now to go further and up on this is boom, best co host christy i. now, christy, i mean we're still seeing growth in china just not quite as much as we did in the 2nd quarter. is their cause for alarm here, given that china was the only major global economy to see growth during last year, slow down. i mean, it's slightly a call for alarm here because the war has been just dependent on trying to be the growth engine to drive the rest, the g d p. so the growth engine falters. list everyone else out of the economic depression that we could be. and so can major bank have already trend there for the trying to g d p forecast. now a china is getting hit or multiple front. you have the power outage is going on in the factory because the government, i mean, the quality which is killing the sector and then they have the sluggish consumer spending. so trying it is more mental as there's just so much dried right now with things like the overhanging dragon koran merits right on the top. and also the chairs are still in effect. and now christy, the chinese gove

i'm christi paul. >> i'm boris sanchez. a developing story out of haiti where 17 american missionaries, some of them kids, have been kidnapped. what we're learning about how this happened. >> the house set to make moves to hold steve bannon in criminal contempt for defying that subpoena from the committee investigating the insurrection. how this is expected to play out in the coming days. >>> plus, a race to the finish. the virginia governor's race narrowing to within the margin of error. why latino voters could make the difference and how both parties are trying to attract them. >>> also, the show will go on, the 11th hour deal that will keep thousands of film workers on set avoiding a costly and show-stopping strike. >>> welcome to your sunday, october 17th. we are always so grateful to have your company. >> good morning, christi. great to see you. >> you too. >>> we want to begin this morning to let you know about the kidnapping of 17 american missionaries in haiti north of the capital city port-au-prince. >> a source te

guitar collectors tell us christie's estimate of 150,000 for les paul's number one is conservative.d for a guitar sold at auction. that record is currently held by kurt cobain's 1959 martin acoustic which sold for $6.2 million. the "cbs overnight news" will be right back. do you have a life insurance policy you no longer need? now you can sell your policy, even a term policy, for an immediate cash payment. call coventry direct to learn more. we thought we had planned carefully for our retirement. but we quickly realized that we needed a way to supplement our income. our friends sold their policy to help pay for their medical bills and that got me thinking. maybe selling our policy could help with our retirement. i'm skeptical, so i did some research and called coventry direct. they explained life insurance is a valuable asset that can be sold. we learned that we can sell all of our policy or keep part of it with no future payments, who knew? we sold our policy. now we can relax and enjoy our retirement as we had planned. if you have one hundred thousand dollars or more of life insur

christy, let's start with you here. i mean, the reaction to dorsey's comment has been sort of surprised that he would use the term hyper inflation. do you think that's an accurate warning? given everything we've seen over the last year? i mean, it might have been a little surprising for people to hear dorothy colon hyperinflation, when most other investors and economists has just kind of called it inflation. but dorsey isn't just any investor, he's also the see of twitter and square. so he has a different perspective and a different timeline. you don't become the ceo of a revolutionary social media company and this rapid fin tech company by following the heard. so he has a different mindset for thinking mindset of how the landscape will look and change 5 years from now, 10 years from now. and he builds towards that. so he has a much longer time horizon, envision than the average investor, or even those like cuban, because cuban doesn't actually build products. and now peter, when we talk about inflation, we've heard the

christy with price is heading their highest level in years. why wouldn't opec make a move after plans, or i'll move to alter the plan that is to say and actually increase their production. well, they decided to not increase production and go off track as the o. thank joint technical committee reviewed the market outlook and cited a high potential for another outbreak of the delta variance as we headed to the winter months. so a surgeon delta would certainly slow down economic productivity and reduce the demand for oil. so, opec movies the market is now balance and will continue to monitor the situation rather than loosen up the production to flood the market and drive prices down. so opec loss is continuing to feel the pressure to wind up production. however, they are scared of a potential force weight, so they're avoiding making any big moves and they'll regret later because they overreacted and also with well price. now above 80 nice producers, they're happy with the price. this is a level that makes consumers uncomfortable, not angry, but j

well, joining us now, gosh, i assume that's co host an crypto analyst, christy i, and michael guy at portfolio manager at truro. so investments and publisher of the lead lab report, it's great to have you both on the show today. michael, let's start with you here. i know robin hood is now warning that the seasonal headwinds as they call it and decrease retail trading are expected to continue for the rest of the year. so what does that say to investors and where does that put robin hood after the company lost more than $1000000000.00 just in the last quarter? i mean, 1st of all, we gotta define what seasonal patterns mean. that's kind of a strange, amorphous statement. churchill, let's be very clear when you look at what happened with robin. it wasn't really about crypto revenue only entreating there. it was about those coin revenue and creating phone, which was really the bulk of a pretty much everything. i just put a tweet on leave lag report, you know, you live by the do you, you die by the right thing. thing, right? because if, if robin hood growth is predicated on these momentary

now, christy facebook and all of its properties, both some 3500000000 users. so what did this outage show us about how many people actually rely on facebook and all of its other apps? i mean, it shows us that people are more reliant on facebook than we think. i mean, we think of facebook and instagram as to social media platforms. to share pictures and get likes, but they're actually critical platforms for businesses. so many businesses, a lot of facebook for communicating with customers, selling goods. basically you lost a day of selling goods. if you're an online merchant and then customer support was disrupted because that's how people communicate with businesses. so even for businesses who run through their own website, had their own email list, he stover line instagram and facebook to run ads and posts. and then even on top of that, what's happened messenger there is central tools for communicating hostile orders, and especially in parts of the developing world, the cost of the facebook outage was felt hard in latin american africa. these services are ess