. >> her uncle, clarence elkins, was the victim's son-in-law. he lived about an hour's drive away and had no criminal record and no history of violence. his wife, melinda, couldn't believe that clarence would kill her mother. >> i remember my reaction distinctly when he told me that my mom had been murdered. i mean, i actually doubled over in pain, you know, like in a fetal position almost. >> clarence denied any involvement but was quickly taken into custody. >> and i said to them, yes, i am his wife. and yes, i know that some women do stand up for their man and lie for them. but you're missing the biggest point here. that was my mother. and i want the person who did this to pay. and i'm telling you right now, it was not clarence. >> but police discovered that clarence might have had a motive to hurt judy johnson. >> their theory is that clarence is -- has evolved a hatred for his mother-in-law because the mother-in-law was allegedly interfering in his marriage to melinda. >> there was a woman who said she was judy's best friend, saying she was