place of frozen stillness, the hottest of passions, boiling jealousy came to call one day in tiny clymer, 1700 residents in the southwest part of the country, is still shaking off the shock of it all. joe gerace is the long-tim sheriff. >> my 35 years in law enforcement, can you ever remember a homicide in clymer? never. >> it began quite simply. the new school superintendent in town went missing one weekend, just a few weeks into the school year in september 2012. keith reed, 51 years old, was a long-time educator who had landed in the sweet spot of his professional career. >> parents and family members, do you believe in our graduates? >> reporter: the up until then school principal had applied for the top administrative job in the clymer district with his big brother, kevin, urging him on. >> says there's this little school up in chautauqua county called clymer. he said, i don't know whether i should apply there. i said apply. >> you were the nudger. >> i nudged him. and i knew what he wanted and once he was there, it was over. >> reporter: you might think a close-knit community like