the commission staff will remain in place. the commission dis exists for 90 days beginning after today after the releases of defense. so with that, again, thank you for your attendance. let me turn to colonel chris dixon who has very ably handled all of our public affairs and media relations over the past many months. she'll be our facilitator. for a period of questions and answers. and i would ask you -- two rules. the first rule is, if you're a commissioned staff member, you are not allowed to ask any questions. [ laughter ] and the second rule is, all hard questions go to sergeant major of the army. >> thank you, sir. thank you, sir. >> secretary lamont just whispered in my ear. there is, for a small number of you in the room, there's a classified annex that offers the summary of much of the work that we did that underpins several of the recommendations. so those with the requisite security clearance that need to know they have access to that classified annex as well. colonel dixon? >> thank you, sir. before we begin, i wou

at this time we will open up item 3 to public comment. >> ♪ commission, commission, give me the news want a healthy authority waiting for you ♪ ♪ and it's going to fill our bill ♪ ♪ we have a healthy commission waiting ♪ ♪ and i want you healthy too >> thank you, next speaker please. >> thanks very much madam chair, supervisors, i am sumi suesa from the health authority, we are delighted to have dave woods as an authority. and he said it clear that for healthy san francisco, as a great challenge we pay medicare rates, and you can imagine the speciality drug important for our members, and that comes at a huge cost. and we are constantly struggling to transfer more dollars those really pharmaceutical therapies. having dave on the board would be incredibly helpful for us, with our strategy and we very much support his nomination. thank you very much. >> thank you very much, any other members of the public to speak on item 3. seeing none. public comment is closed. just to make sure we're all clear here on item 3 on the requirements. based on the city attorney notice here, we don't need t

each member of the public may address the commission up to three minutes. i have one speaker card. >> thank you georg georgia jewish. >> i've been going to the planning commission. much to believe it or not mr. the gentlemen about the issue of remodels that are really demolitions and there's been a lot of talk we had a meeting that commissioner richards and mr. sanchez and mr. duffy mr. star we looked at four or five case studies they thought 40 percent should have been calculated as demolitions but in this whole process of looking at it i live in noah valley that's where i'm focused and you're concerned about the facade ism what is faÇadism and i think we can agree this one here can i have the overhead i have a junior high school project i've been texted and the new part on the back and this one, two here is definitely faÇadism there is the building there it is and the back all gone i think that was illegally dug and others issues the one the major altercations is it a different kind of faÇadism really quick this one is the new building this is the old bui

so the commission therefore. recommends the army update regulations and policy to clarify and codify the allocation processes in use. and lastly, just one comment about the overall theme throughout this report. and it is, we are one army. one army acting under the integrated and operational total force policy. and we will strive to maintain that with whatever we do. in all these recommendations. thank you, mr. chairman. >> thanks. dr. hicks? >> thank you very much to general ham and to secretary lamont, my fellow commissioners and, of course, to the staff for all their hard work. as the chairman said in his opening remarks, the army has a supply and demand problem. the supply-ready army forces is struggling to keep up with the demand of the future and the future doesn't look much better than today. it's not a sustainable situation from the viewpoint of the commission. one of the commission's two primary tasks was to answer this basic question -- how should the army best organize and employ the total force in the

the commission and not to the occ personnel under police commission rules of order neither police or occ personnel or commissioners are required to responds but individual commissioners and police and occ personnel shall refrain from discusses during public comment please limit our comments to 3 minutes. >> good evening we'll start public comment. >> i see two folks up here. >> okay welcome and good evening. >> good evening my name is michael i represent government assess project i'm here about a few items first up on the screen it is a memorandum to the sunshine ordinance task force it is from the office the city attorney written earlier this month i've highlighted read is the basis of my complaint to the sunshine ordinance task force about your january 6th agenda when a person of average intelligence and education was interested the police killing of mario woods and the aftermath be aware aware of that item on the agenda that's enough with the image please come back to me turn off the image turn that off terrific so last night at the sunshine ordinance task force i complained again

congress said the commission shall.there have been lots of wild assertions about this proposal before anybody saw it. let's remember, this is the beginning of the information gathering process, which is why free he is disappointed that my two colleagues have made up their mind before all the facts are in an effort to meet for issues that have been identified. but let's stop for a second. there has been a lot of talk. let's look at how this had top box works again on the screen. let's be clear there is nothing different in the functionality between a hardware box and a software app. number one, the cable system sends a message to the box that says what is on. number two, the cable system tells the box what it was in title ii, what kind of rights the subscriber has. number three, the subscribers to the box what they want. number four, the box relays the choice that to the cable system. number five, the cable system delivers the programming.

how is the commission secretary position going? >> i will provide you with a written summary on that. >> okay. i'm just concerned about you, i just want to make sure that --. >> yes, yes, and i appreciate that. so shall i move on it item no. 10? >> yes, please. >> item no. 10, president's report. >> i attended a couple meetings this month which are relative to small business. the chamber has a small business committee and they are trying to reorganize it a little bit to be more effective in its outreach towards small business and how the chamber can be effective on behalf of small business. and i have made it very clear that i think the most important thing there is for them to promote business activity between big b and little b, meaning business to business interaction from big companies to little companies. and we have sfbiz connect, which is designed to get large companies to take a pledge for purchasing a percentage of their goods and services from san francisco bay's businesses, which i think is fantastic and the chamber of c

. >> commissioners tim frye one item to share item from last week planning commission the planning commissiond a hearing on the affordable housing bonus program this staff gave a short presentation on the key issued and supervisor president london breed and the mayor's office was in attendance and provided some or comments regarding the proposed ordinance to clarify the rent-controlled property will not be subject to the program and in addition the commission hated questions i answered in particular they had a question how we will elevate the unknown properties for the purposes of ceqa there was some concern over what that decide making process undercarriage a a non-eligible if they had a category b but all the work up to this the will be mute because the site is not eligible for the program the commission had a had a couple of concerns whether or not legacy businesses will be adapted as part of program and scalds to look at whether or not legacy sites should be exempted from the program the commission also asked us to look at creating a map like a layover of the map showing what sites will b

the commission and not to the occ personnel under police commission rules of order neither police or occ personnel or commissioners are required to responds but individual commissioners and police and occ personnel shall refrain from discusses during public comment please limit our comments to 3 minutes. >> good evening we'll start public comment. >> i see two folks up here. >> okay welcome and good evening. >> good evening my name is michael i represent government assess project i'm here about a few items first up on the screen it is a memorandum to the sunshine ordinance task force it is from the office the city attorney written earlier this month i've highlighted read is the basis of my complaint to the sunshine ordinance task force about your january 6th agenda when a person of average intelligence and education was interested the police killing of mario woods and the aftermath be aware aware of that item on the agenda that's enough with the image please come back to me turn off the image turn that off terrific so last night at the sunshine ordinance task force i complained again

simply put, the commission is -- commission's view is that our soldiers and marines and sailors and for the first time aviators who fought and died in world war one did so with the same courage and tenacity and sacrifice shown by the veterans of other wars that have a place on the national mall. they withstood the inferno of our garages, they went down to the bottom of the sea in their ships, they fell from the skies in burning recage of airplanes and charged out of trenches across open fields and into hills and woods that the enemy spent years fortifying to defend. and they did so in greater numbers than our other wars. 4.7 million men and women went off to war, 116,000 never returned. measured against today's population, that would be the equivalent of almost 15 million americans going to serve their country today with more than 360,000 fatalities. in vietnam, we lost 47,000 men years t in about eight of fighting. in world war one we lost 53,000 in six months. in one six-week period the major battle that years of fighting. ended the war lost almost as many men in that six weeks as we

each member of the public may address the commission up to three minutes. i do have one speaker card. >> georgia swedish. >> go ahead. >> thank you. good afternoon. i'm georgia swedish here last time i just want to bring up the issue i think there are two issues occurring now with regards to the faÇadism the main we know but i think it is concerning when a building is basically defendant's next in order and an ocher stark facade with a lot of glass takes it mrs. place in noah valley and in neighborhoods labor bernal heights and glen park many of the oldest neighbo neighborhoods the city is logging b rated building inspection building with texture for which the city is known whether you study this issue of faÇadism i was hoping you can examine the issue of this what i call pe verse faÇadism a building is denounced congratulated if a building b to c but yet in the meanwhile window replacement get scrutiny those facades changes don't so here quicken in the interest of time if i'm with the overhead those are if google earth this is 2008, 2011 i'm trying to look

>> lot mergers would be prohibited until commission approved new guidelines. guidelines are only as good as --. >> typically -- go ahead. >> the ordinance is drafted with reference to the design guidelines and guidelines have to be approved by, they have the power of code but the specific guidelines do not live within the code, it is a separate document approved by the planning commission. >> added d today, we all thought it was important at the time we did it but it didn't work. >> commissioner antonini, as maker of the motion are you accepting those amendments that are making recommendations as opposed to no recommendation? >> yes. >> thank you. commissioners, there is a motion that has been seconded to recommend to the board of supervisors that they accept staff's recommendation regarding section d of the urban design and then that lot mergers would be prohibited until such time the planning commission approves new guidelines and then to refine the review as they relate to light and air. on that motion, commissioner antonini, aye. commissioner hillis, yes.

i was going to remind the commission we had plans doing other joint planning big commission hearing i think this would be a perfect on or about for that it has been you know outstanding for a lot of us but there are a couple of other issues that we tackled last time around that were left on the shelf and so it's been a year; right? >> at least. >> so great to very, veredond there is some of us have talked about talked about the in-law unit conversion to our point of you know the discussion and the understanding how it effects the building and the issues it bricks up so here on behalf of the appellant and commissioner lee and commissioner walker. >> okay. mr. shaw if you could do research what happens to the fees for the developers that they pay the city has been using to recreate replacing the sros or not i'd like to know historically. >> right. >> commissioner walker please. yeah. i really appreciate that detail that are a lot of situations right now around the conversion of housing the illegal listing of unit and follow-up programs it actually have been in effect since the last plan

i was going to remind the commission we had plans doing other joint planning big commission hearing i think this would be a perfect on or about for that it has been you know outstanding for a lot of us but there are a couple of other issues that we tackled last time around that were left on the shelf and so it's been a year; right? >> at least. >> so great to very, veredond there is some of us have talked about talked about the in-law unit conversion to our point of you know the discussion and the understanding how it effects the building and the issues it bricks up so here on behalf of the appellant and commissioner lee and commissioner walker. >> okay. mr. shaw if you could do research what happens to the fees for the developers that they pay the city has been using to recreate replacing the sros or not i'd like to know historically. >> right. >> commissioner walker please. yeah. i really appreciate that detail that are a lot of situations right now around the conversion of housing the illegal listing of unit and follow-up programs it actually have been in effect since the last plan

that is not been addressed by this commission. one of the things the mayor said in being shot dead three people were charged with corruption by the dist. atty. is he would not tolerate any type of page played type situations that most people believe are really prevalent throughout the town and have been for a wild. he simply was could do everything in his power to make sure that doesn't happen that san francisco should not turn into the soft corruption. if that is the case, mr. mayor, you should pass our budget. are fully funded budget. give us the tools to address the kinds of corruption, pay to play you say should not take place here. again, this does it for us. it's a full amount put the executive director has outlined as necessary to do the task could i think we should push it as hard as we can with the mayor to go ahead and fully fund this commission. to do all of the jobs that you identified that need to be done in the idea of a cut is just totally a disgrace to any aspect of san francisco hennie show of honest government wh

commending monica fish, congratulating upon her retirement of commission secretary on the commission of the environment. over the course of a decade as the commission on the environment monica fish has worked tirelessly for the san francisco didn't of environment and the entire city and county of san francisco family. whereas monica fish began with the long and distinguished track record having previously earned a bachelor of arts from the university of san francisco and having worked with various public agencies including the department of planning, the office of the controller and the clerk of the board of supervisors, and whereas monica fish began her service on january 24, 2005, where she worked diligently and faithfully until her retirement in june 2015. and whereas monica fish was responsible for providing administrative support on the commission of environment, the san francisco urban forest, the biodiesel task force. the peak oil task force. the community aggregation and ensuring the department of environment as a whole complied with reporting requirements and earned esteem o

whether it happens here at this commission or more importantly at the planning commission.i think it is also a call to action for clarification of the sites actually impacted. so let's figure out the real impact is. so we can quantify the problem. i also think this is a call to action for some recommendations from the public as to how you recommend we move forward. that is to say, that no, is not the right answer. the answer is, yes, but. if were going to make affordable housing in this city, how do we balance the needs of the residents and the needs of small businesses. there is going to be impact. there's no question about it but i think it's very clear to me that we need more discussion about how we moderate or mitigate the impact on small businesses that are already at risk in the city. i completely agree as a small business owner and minibus up are either small business, have been small business owners, or our clients are small business owners and we all know the difficulty if not basically the death sentence of having to suspend or relocate our businesses. especially

the ethics commission investigation is long overdue. everyone knows in the court of public opinion ed lee was in bed with-and the fbi agent and he knew it was about paying down his campaign. you have to investigate this. >> good evening. david-. i do want to recognize the soon to end the term of commissioner hur and i was going to mention under item 8 rats in the future meaning of an appropriate recognition for commissioner hur and his good work over many years. thank you. >> i should tell you that the assessor has asked commissioner hur to remain beyond the february 1 date to our next meeting, while she has an opportunity to that a replacement. so all of the compliments that are very deserved for commissioner hur, we can save until february 22. his term may officially end. >> members of the ethics commission, you have not seen me in a while. i guess that's something you're not too unhappy about. i would like to refer this commission to the decision of the united states courts of appeal for the ninth circuit which is of course the circu

to responder to the commission any board or commission can respond to the public they choose not to if they want to respond they can next i'd like to say i commend the facilitators i was a facilitator myself for 20 years when i lived in hawaii taught they university of hawaii it is a difficult job and difficult position you have a small window of opportunities hebecause they're your off affordable housing to the community the community gives trust and show up and speak up but if they don't feel something will come they'll stop coming you have a small window of opportunities the thing over the years i've watched out the general orders drag on literally for years green before something finally comes of it you don't have that you have a small window of opportunities for them if they go back and ask people to come to the malia cohen's and speak up those people gets the impression you'll not do anything that will shut off really quick i want doesn't end they not only talked about what was important to the citizens the community but to the officers themselves the 5 officers involved the i

the commission shall. we've heard from some folks who always keep talking about how their strict constructionalist about what the congress told us to do or not to do. suddenly reaching out to all kinds of wild expansive suppositions. but it's pretty clear. congress said the commission shall. now, there have been lots of wild assertions about this proposal before anybody saw it. or let's stop mber for a second. there's been a lot of talk. let's stop and let's look at how a set top box works. again, on the screen. let's be clear that there is nothing that is different in the functionality between a hardware box and a software app. number one, the cable system sends a message to the box that says what's on. number two, the cable system tells the box what it is entitled to. what the subscriber -- what kind of rights the subscriber has. number three, the subcriber tells the box what they want. number four, the box relays that choice back to the cable system. and number five, the cable system delivers the progra

to responder to the commission any board or commission can respond to the public they choose not to if they want to respond they can next i'd like to say i commend the facilitators i was a facilitator myself for 20 years when i lived in hawaii taught they university of hawaii it is a difficult job and difficult position you have a small window of opportunities hebecause they're your off affordable housing to the community the community gives trust and show up and speak up but if they don't feel something will come they'll stop coming you have a small window of opportunities the thing over the years i've watched out the general orders drag on literally for years green before something finally comes of it you don't have that you have a small window of opportunities for them if they go back and ask people to come to the malia cohen's and speak up those people gets the impression you'll not do anything that will shut off really quick i want doesn't end they not only talked about what was important to the citizens the community but to the officers themselves the 5 officers involved the i

each member of the public may address the commission up to three minutes. i do have one speaker card. >> georgia swedish. >> go ahead. >> thank you. good afternoon. i'm georgia swedish here last time i just want to bring up the issue i think there are two issues occurring now with regards to the faÇadism the main we know but i think it is concerning when a building is basically defendant's next in order and an ocher stark facade with a lot of glass takes it mrs. place in noah valley and in neighborhoods labor bernal heights and glen park many of the oldest neighbo neighborhoods the city is logging b rated building inspection building with texture for which the city is known whether you study this issue of faÇadism i was hoping you can examine the issue of this what i call pe verse faÇadism a building is denounced congratulated if a building b to c but yet in the meanwhile window replacement get scrutiny those facades changes don't so here quicken in the interest of time if i'm with the overhead those are if google earth this is 2008, 2011 i'm trying to look

army from the national commission on the future of the army.t was released as defense secretary ashton carter announced proposals of his own to modernize the military as a whole. one of those proposals calls for more parental leave. >> the commission, as you know, was formed by the congress and the national defense authorization act of 2015, and it was charged with a number of tasks, two of them at the forefront were how should the army be organized in a period of challenging resources and seemingly expanding threats. and secondly, a specific charge to address the army's proposal as advanced through the aviation restructure initiative endorsed by the department of defense to transfer all apache aircraft from the army national guard to the regular army. there are several other tasks that you're all familiar with. but those were the guiding, the two foundational tasks charged to the commission. over the time that the commission has been in existence, we have engaged more than 320 individual units, regular army, army national guard and army reserv

to responder to the commission any board or commission can respond to the public they choose not to if they want to respond they can next i'd like to say i commend the facilitators i was a facilitator myself for 20 years when i lived in hawaii taught they university of hawaii it is a difficult job and difficult position you have a small window of opportunities hebecause they're your off affordable housing to the community the community gives trust and show up and speak up but if they don't feel something will come they'll stop coming you have a small window of opportunities the thing over the years i've watched out the general orders drag on literally for years green before something finally comes of it you don't have that you have a small window of opportunities for them if they go back and ask people to come to the malia cohen's and speak up those people gets the impression you'll not do anything that will shut off really quick i want doesn't end they not only talked about what was important to the citizens the community but to the officers themselves the 5 officers involved the i

and when speaking before the commission, if you care to, do state your name for the record.

to responder to the commission any board or commission can respond to the public they choose not to if they want to respond they can next i'd like to say i commend the facilitators i was a facilitator myself for 20 years when i lived in hawaii taught they university of hawaii it is a difficult job and difficult position you have a small window of opportunities hebecause they're your off affordable housing to the community the community gives trust and show up and speak up but if they don't feel something will come they'll stop coming you have a small window of opportunities the thing over the years i've watched out the general orders drag on literally for years green before something finally comes of it you don't have that you have a small window of opportunities for them if they go back and ask people to come to the malia cohen's and speak up those people gets the impression you'll not do anything that will shut off really quick i want doesn't end they not only talked about what was important to the citizens the community but to the officers themselves the 5 officers involved the i

to responder to the commission any board or commission can respond to the public they choose not to if they want to respond they can next i'd like to say i commend the facilitators i was a facilitator myself for 20 years when i lived in hawaii taught they university of hawaii it is a difficult job and difficult position you have a small window of opportunities hebecause they're your off affordable housing to the community the community gives trust and show up and speak up but if they don't feel something will come they'll stop coming you have a small window of opportunities the thing over the years i've watched out the general orders drag on literally for years green before something finally comes of it you don't have that you have a small window of opportunities for them if they go back and ask people to come to the malia cohen's and speak up those people gets the impression you'll not do anything that will shut off really quick i want doesn't end they not only talked about what was important to the citizens the community but to the officers themselves the 5 officers involved the i

>> the health commission. >> the full health commission. so i report providing info and feedback on that as it moves and the participation from the merchant community. >> great. >> and addition to the formula retail subsidiary conversation that is also on the radar for a lot of small corner merchants that also are scared of the target and walgreen's mini mart phenomenon that may play into that conversation but hasn't really been voiced yet. >> great. commissioners, any other reports? all right, well, time for. >> item no. 13 is general public comment. >> do we have any members of the public that would like to comment on anything else today or to recommend anything for the future? seeing none, public comment is closed. next item, new business. >> item no. 14 is new business, allows the commissioners to introduce new agenda items for future consideration. >> miriam, did you have something you want to recommend or did i just not cancel you? okay, when it pops up on the screen -- i'd like to just memorialize my request for a new business item w

walker from the planning commission and abatement appeals commission a directors hearing will happenhe notice of violation will be upheld and the directions to the 14 to fix it it can be appealed to the abatement appeals commission we uphold or deny the appeal and at this point it leans against the property the fee currently there is no mechanism for fixing it if the owner doesn't fix it other than liening the property the concern in the meanwhile a tenant in that location it is the issue we deal with unpermitted units we have a problem that needs to be fixed in some cases it is had been ability issue if we don't get a resolution from the property owner it is in limbo we have situations i'm sure that tommy from the hufrts committee will unfortunately, we have to evict the people have to be evicted with a health and safety issue mold and crumbling ceilings and stairs that can't be used no assess - many number of things that could be the problem it is one of the i think primary reasons to create a resolving funds in those situations we have it as an emergency demolition funds the prope

commission you both. commissioner o'reilly fub cities book at the new america foundation on the allocation of the 5.9-hertz band dickey said auto manufacturers should only expect to the nix it determines is necessary. this seems to imply the remainder, the majority of the spectrum allocation should, in fact, be freed up, taken away from specific allocation freed up for sharing. can you confirm or clarify that? commissioner pai, i would be curious your comments on that thought. >> i don't think i said nhtsa would verify or certify. i didn't type to nhtsa. my point is i want to take spectrum from them. it is spectrum that you should be for safety purposes. i don't want spectrum used for parking spots and host of other things that haven't been contemplated by many different folks including new america in the report on purposes that could be used for. i'm not trying to take spectrum from the. i want spectrum to be allocated for safety purposes. >> i generally agree with that. i'm guessing with respect to what

each member of the public may address the commission up to three minutes.e one speaker card. >> thank you georg georgia jewish. >> i've been going to the planning commission. much to believe it or not mr. the gentlemen about the issue of remodels that are really demolitions and there's been a lot of talk we had a meeting that commissioner richards and mr. sanchez and mr. duffy mr. star we looked at four or five case studies they thought 40 percent should have been calculated as demolitions but in this whole process of looking at it i live in noah valley that's where i'm focused and you're concerned about the facade ism what is faÇadism and i think we can agree this one here can i have the overhead i have a junior high school project i've been texted and the new part on the back and this one, two here is definitely faÇadism there is the building there it is and the back all gone i think that was illegally dug and others issues the one the major altercations is it a different kind of faÇadism really quick this one is the new building this is the old building

. >> item 1 is a a motion confirming the mayoral appointment of eleni kounalakis to the port commission term ending may 1, 2016. >> and i believe she is here today. >> thank you very much. members of the rules committee, supervisors tang and cohen, i'm very honored to be here today and to have been nominated by mayor lee to serve as the san francisco port commission, i grew up in northern california and left my heart in san francisco bh i was a young girl on a special visit to the city to visit family. my husband marcos who like me is a child of greek immigrant parents was born and raised in san francisco. we have made our life here for most of the last 16 years, raising our two children and being part of the civic life of this great city. like many first generation san franciscans, i feel grateful this beautiful, vibrant and ever evolving city is my home. san francisco's waterfront is one of its greatest and most important features, it is a multi-faceted gateway to the city, seeped in history, it includes some of the important sites tourism not just in san francisco but for the whole s

and leader of the commission president the fire commission until january 19th the talents 1 and passedway in january of 2016 commissioner hardeman talked about how much contributions he gave to the city i said to give me a couple comments and again, i invite in any fellow commissioners if you want to comment as well for many of you the audience and some of you at home those of you who are san franciscans you're very, very aware of has to do with will i rocketing who he was he was a bureauly guy cleaver and funny and witty and passiona one of the life experiences was in attendance i'm making comments about the high school part of that learning from that high school staked heart a lot of and dedication to san francisco as a city and be part of fighting irish or whoever you want to cheer for but the love was amazing to me i can take that a transfer it to sacrificed heart the person i wanted to work with was has to do with will i roth he loved it and working hard and paycheck to paycheck and at one point he was chief of staff for mayor gordon he gave me 5 and a half minutes but with the bl

. >> item 1 is a a motion confirming the mayoral appointment of eleni kounalakis to the port commission term ending may 1, 2016. >> and i believe she is here today. >> thank you very much. members of the rules committee, supervisors tang and cohen, i'm very honored to be here today and to have been nominated by mayor lee to serve as the san francisco port commission, i grew up in northern california and left my heart in san francisco bh i was a young girl on a special visit to the city to visit family. my husband marcos who like me is a child of greek immigrant parents was born and raised in san francisco. we have made our life here for most of the last 16 years, raising our two children and being part of the civic life of this great city. like many first generation san franciscans, i feel grateful this beautiful, vibrant and ever evolving city is my home. san francisco's waterfront is one of its greatest and most important features, it is a multi-faceted gateway to the city, seeped in history, it includes some of the important sites tourism not just in san francisco but for the whole s

each member of the public may address the commission up to three minutes. i do have one speaker card. >> georgia swedish. >> go ahead. >> thank you. good afternoon. i'm georgia swedish here last time i just want to bring up the issue i think there are two issues occurring now with regards to the faÇadism the main we know but i think it is concerning when a building is basically defendant's next in order and an ocher stark facade with a lot of glass takes it mrs. place in noah valley and in neighborhoods labor bernal heights and glen park many of the oldest neighbo neighborhoods the city is logging b rated building inspection building with texture for which the city is known whether you study this issue of faÇadism i was hoping you can examine the issue of this what i call pe verse faÇadism a building is denounced congratulated if a building b to c but yet in the meanwhile window replacement get scrutiny those facades changes don't so here quicken in the interest of time if i'm with the overhead those are if google earth this is 2008, 2011 i'm trying to look

to responder to the commission any board or commission can respond to the public they choose not to if they want to respond they can next i'd like to say i commend the facilitators i was a facilitator myself for 20 years when i lived in hawaii taught they university of hawaii it is a difficult job and difficult position you have a small window of opportunities hebecause they're your off affordable housing to the community the community gives trust and show up and speak up but if they don't feel something will come they'll stop coming you have a small window of opportunities the thing over the years i've watched out the general orders drag on literally for years green before something finally comes of it you don't have that you have a small window of opportunities for them if they go back and ask people to come to the malia cohen's and speak up those people gets the impression you'll not do anything that will shut off really quick i want doesn't end they not only talked about what was important to the citizens the community but to the officers themselves the 5 officers involved the i

the commission up to three minutes. address the commission up to three minutes. i do have couple of speaker cards. >> yes. georgia and thoosie. >> ask the starch the recalculation for all pending dr cases and the 311 for the rh1, rh3 two excuse me. i think the reason it is important because maybe they need drs southern the executions with mr. sanchez and commissioner vice president richards it was discovered that was a 40 percent issue that 40 percent of time some of these should have been calculated as demolitions and those remodels so i would hope that if you're going to go forward and have the staff consider how they calculate in the future that perhaps at least consider it for pending dr case and thing that these that involved involve major altercations and relocation of a unit as i said it was discovered at least 40 percent likelihood they're not calculated correctly the samples i submitted for the case study there they're the ones he had photos of whole process of demolition and the new project that is a lot i did

they look at the planning commission -- planning code. and i am distressed with my experience that the planning department staff, the guys and the girls who have come in, gone through planning school, been here a year, two years, six months, are analyzing the project and are not asking the questions that should be asked. so the history is the planning commission has to be the entity that makes the decision, not the planning staff. the planning staff is the kids that graduate from planning school long after the plan is done so keep your role, send this out, there needs to be a lot more thought but the planning commission should send it to the board of supervisors and make (inaudible). thank you. >> hi, john schwerk, i wasn't going to speak today but my young girl planning intern decided since she came this far she wanted to get on television. i'd like to make a couple quick points about something people said tonight that struck me. one, we don't want any more rich white people coming into san francisco which i thought was kind of interesti