we have seen more independent commissions than the last time around. when republicans made major gains in the process. and just to make things even more complicated, we have the possibility of significant new federal legislation with the hr one bill being considered that could further influence redistricting. we have an amazing panel today to help us figure out what of all -- what all of this means. i would like to invite them each to make some opening remarks on where we are coming from and where we are headed, and then i will have some questions and then we will have a chance to take questions from the audience. we have a congressman who represented illinois 10th district from 2015-20 17. he focused in particular on access to capital for small business and health care reform. and property issues. he's an original member of the no labels movement which he hoped would head -- help and gridlock in washington and he cochaired the tuesday group, which focused on pragmatic governing solutions. we also have a professor of law at harvard law school who teach

commission president's report and schedule of items for future commission meeting. action. >> president cohen: thank you. so at this point in the agenda i want to first welcome and recognize jim byrnes. but i also want to recognize commissioner petra de jesus and she has been a reremarkable resource not only to me when i was a board of supervisors, but also on this commission and i personally am going to miss petra and professionally i'm excited about the transition and how she's going to spend her newfound time wednesday evenings. but i want to give the floor to first any colleagues that would like to say good-bye to commissioner dejesus and we will close out with commissioner dejesus leaving some remarks. so i see commissioner elias first. please, the floor is yours. >> vice president elias: thank you. so, today is so sad because when i first got on the commission, petra was the very first person who welcomed me and she welcomed me with open arms. she was always there if you had any questions or didn't sundays something so she has been a huge resource and mentor t

reports to the commission. commission reports. xhis igs reports will be limited to a brief description of activities and announcements. commission discussion will be limited to determining if it will lead to any future meeting. commissioner announcements and scheduling of items identified for a consideration of a future commission meetings. action. >> president cohen: let's see, i would like to acknowledge commissioner elias at this time. >> vice president elias: thank you, president cohen. my issues are request to agendize items. i've asked in the past and i was hoping, chief, to get an e.t.a. on when that is. i think that there's so many times that myself and i believe other commissioners and we see it on the callers that call in regarding their understanding of how the discipline process works with internal affairs and d.p.a. and the conversations that occur between the chief and director henderson when cases are filed or charges are brought. so i was hoping that we could in addition to having the i.a. presentation before the c

jeff: well, nobody benefits from the failings of the european commission.resident is ultimately responsible for everything that happens, but she has a large team, and while it is true we have not procured this before, making joint procurement reality in the eu, this is a large commission with many experts, and we would have expected there would have been oversight during not just the contractual process , not just the hundreds of means of dollars invested in developing vaccines, but also in assuring the production so i would reiterate that we are where we are and we are facing a shortage, and if the european commission sued and it was resolved quickly in the courts, and if it meant more doses were provided to the eu, and for example, in a country like india, and were taken from a country like india, i don't think that would serve anyone, given the current state of affairs in the massive transmission going on in india right now, so i am not really sure what they are trying to achieve through the court case, and again, i would be investing the money in produc

have not picked a single democratic state to go after a commission yet. so they just jerry pick on - - cherry pick to pullout virginia when i got to the democratic side so we recognize there is politics played at this point in time looking at what's going on from a partisan perspective getting pulled to the polls. far more vitriolic. and with more 50/50 type of districts being drawn and have more in the whole state legislature in the halls of congress. >> but to be immersed in the effort to achieve recent reform in illinois and that is the actions of madigan and of the supreme court to be completely reprehensible. to be not as much if not more of any state of the independent commission. so with the national one - - natural political geography is states but the point is in all of the recent lawsuits wisconsin or north carolina or michigan it didn't rest pretty sure all of the lawsuits if you constructed the computer without constructing partisanship's. you almost never in the line drawing parties favor. the political geography of pennsylvania or ohio et ce

the european commission spokesman neither confirmed nor denied the reports before there are steps are taken or would be taken decisions taken by any commission together with the member states as again this is a strategy that we implement together with the member states and so for the county to come into question we are in it only options which help us to ensure newsroom of course a spokesman for astra zeneca says the company was not aware of any legal proceedings but it says it will continue regular discussions about supply with the european commission and e.u. member states we'll bring in our panel shortly but 1st let's take a closer look at inoculation campaigns across europe the e.u. is vaccine rollout has fared poorly compared to other developed economies only around 10 percent of the blocks 900000000 people have so far received a single dose of a vaccine but the situation changed this week with germany in the early doubling the pace of vaccinations following a boost in supplies it's also decided to let general practitioners administer the jabs france italy and spain are expected

commission president's report and schedule of items for future commission meeting. action. >> president cohen: thank you. so at this point in the agenda i want to first welcome and recognize jim byrnes. but i also want to recognize commissioner petra de jesus and she has been a reremarkable resource not only to me when i was a board of supervisors, but also on this commission and i personally am going to miss petra and professionally i'm excited about the transition and how she's going to spend her newfound time wednesday evenings. but i want to give the floor to first any colleagues that would like to say good-bye to commissioner dejesus and we will close out with commissioner dejesus leaving some remarks. so i see commissioner elias first. please, the floor is yours. >> vice president elias: thank you. so, today is so sad because when i first got on the commission, petra was the very first person who welcomed me and she welcomed me with open arms. she was always there if you had any questions or didn't sundays something so she has been a huge resource and mentor t

signed up to or was it that the head of procurement for the european commission who has his critics a lot of them didn't actually spot that the contracts weren't as good as they could have been. well given that you know the contacts have really been redacted and we haven't you know been able to read them in death i think the issue at hand is at astra zeneca probably over promised i mean we've the world has never been in a situation where we've had to produce so many vaccines so quickly so other companies have also probably over promised but they're vaccines aren't necessarily or haven't been approved yet so we don't know if they'll be able to deliver but astra zeneca promised a lot of vaccines more than that and more they could produce to to different countries so i think there's you know probably some errors made on the part of the e.u. part definitely some errors on the part of of astra zeneca but again you know the issue at hand is how do we increase the production and since the e.u. was making such a large purchase you know what kind of oversight was there during the entire produc

byrne to the police commission. because of his commitment to the police commission and i do have a voice that has the experience that mr. byrne has with the immigrant community will serve the commission well. thank you for your time. >> chairman: thank you. next speaker please >> hi. i met the jim byrne through my paper work for immigration to this country. i found him to be a very understandable person. my community knows him very well. so he's a very rounded person and i definitely support him for the commission position. thank you. >> chairman: thank you. >> good morning supervisors. can you hear me? >> yes. >> good morning. good morning supervisors. this is arcella. i am a professor where the majority of my students are immigrants. i'm an immigrant myself. of course, of other religions and i'm calling in support of mr. jim byrne to be appointed to the police commission. i met mr. byrne and i asked questions and i'm very satisfied. he understand the trials and tribulations of the immigrant community and, myself,

enforced _ commission for gender equality... enforced state _ commission for gender equality...sterilisation - commission for gender equality... enforced state sterilisation of - enforced state sterilisation of hiv—positive women stop mac she's one of a0 women featured in a report about gender equality published in 2020. the standard procedure in any care, and we are talking specifically about people who are pregnant, is that in those months leading up to the birthing process itself there should have been some discussion around contraception. what happens with many women is that they've alleged that when they were in the hospital because they were hiv positive all of them are black, most of them are from a rural area. they were forced or coerced into signing a consent form to agree to a sterilisation but also in terms of intervention a sterilisation is only an emergency intervention, and that's a problem in this case is that's a problem in this case is that many of the women, the first time they heard about sterilisation was that birthing process in the emergency when they thems

a future commission meeting. >> okay. can you see me? >> commissioner hamasaki: we can see you. >> in the statistics, we are at 222 cases that have been opened so far. this time last year, we are at 233. this year so far, we had closed 286. this time last year, we closed 273. we currently have 301 cases that were pending. last year this time, we had 391. we had sustained 17 cases so far this year. this time last year, we were at 11. for cases that are past the 270-day investigation mark, we are at 35. this time last year, we were at 41. again, our numbers are going down. again, i'm not going to do this every week, but again, i went through every single one of the daises to see what the delays are just to make sure i'm keeping a more thorough watch on everything. several of the cases were pending criminal and/or civil investigations, tools that are involved, on going officer involved shooting cases, they're still being worked up. two of them were delayed, several are body-worn camera footage, and others are where

under the trade commission act if the commission formally condemns a particularly illegal practice, inne case other companies who knowingly engage in the same practice can face big fines. here's an example. when a company recently posted fake positive reviews that tricked consumers into buying its products the federal trade commission issued an order condemning that practice. using its penalty offense authority the ftc could potentially now issue serious fines against any company that knowingly defies the federal trade commission by posting fake reviews for their own products. and hit companies where it hurts if they scam consumers. mr. coffman, what are your thoughts on this approach, and is the federal trade commission currently inventorying existing orders to see if it can collect civil penalties from scam artists who are operating today. >> the penalty offense authority is one of the additional tools we're very closely looking at to make sure we can do everything we can in our power to protect consumers despite the loss of 13b. one issue i have with that authority is that it gives

new commission business. >> any new commission business? seeing none, next item, please. >> next item is 9. consent calendar. all matters listed here are considered routine by the san francisco public utilities commission and will be acted upon by a single vote. no separate discussion unless a member of the commission or public so requests. it will be considered as a separate item. >> anything to be taken off? madam secretary, public comment please. >> members of the public lieu wish to comment on the consent calendar dial 415-655-0001. (146)682-8986-pound pound. to speak press star three. you must limit comments to the topic of the item discussed and remind you you do not stay on the topic the chair can interrupt and ask you to limit your comment. we ask public comment is made in a respectful manner and refrain from profanity. address your remarks to the commission and not the individual commissioners or staff. >> do we have any callers? >> there is one caller wishing to be recognized. >> you have two minutes. >> coalition for san francisc

well everything is in the media everything is in front of the commission a police inspector can leave for another country without taking up less than 12 hours it doesn't have to be stressing this particular case they are saying. we want you for our number one who says he was threatened you must not be part of a conspiracy all these things well and they will probably give me lots of money to do these all these i don't know how you don't know that mr secretary that's that's a sign of saying that inquiries are coming out all these things that is why i said it will come out with the talk in china in january last year your presidential commission investigating so-called political victimization of public officials began intervening to halt prosecutions including those of 2 former navy officers charged in relation to the disappearance of 11 people in 20082009 this intervening in judicial proceedings doesn't inspire public confidence does it so also this commission has intervened in favor of military intelligence officers interfered in other trials including by withholding documentary evidenc

the electoral commission is not going to. i'm with ou. commission is not going to.not going to. i'm with yom george. what— commission is not going to. i'm with you. george, what do _ commission is not going to. i'm with you. george, what do you _ commission is not going to. i'm with you. george, what do you make - commission is not going to. i'm with you. george, what do you make of. commission is not going to. i'm with i you. george, what do you make of the story? the mail is right to make this its front page lead, isn't it? other stories are important like india, but that's been going for several days now. this has to, but a genuinely new development. absolutely, and it's particularly unsurprising that the mail is leading _ unsurprising that the mail is leading on this. it's been pursuing the story— leading on this. it's been pursuing the story with vintage fleet street tenacity. — the story with vintage fleet street tenacity, and as borisjohnson will know_ tenacity, and as borisjohnson will know of— tenacity, and as borisjohnson will know of formal journalist ten

a future commission meeting. >> okay. can you see me? >> commissioner hamasaki: we can see you. >> in the statistics, we are at 222 cases that have been opened so far. this time last year, we are at 233. this year so far, we had closed 286. this time last year, we closed 273. we currently have 301 cases that were pending. last year this time, we had 391. we had sustained 17 cases so far this year. this time last year, we were at 11. for cases that are past the 270-day investigation mark, we are at 35. this time last year, we were at 41. again, our numbers are going down. again, i'm not going to do this every week, but again, i went through every single one of the daises to see what the delays are just to make sure i'm keeping a more thorough watch on everything. several of the cases were pending criminal and/or civil investigations, tools that are involved, on going officer involved shooting cases, they're still being worked up. two of them were delayed, several are body-worn camera footage, and others are where

well we have seen this document prepared by the human rights commission and that's ok but you know there had been 5 i mean from 201220132 those and 14 and now 2 of those 2021 so every time this government comes to power they said resolution from the united nations human rights council right is that fair i think we have to ask that the human breakup council and then that is fair if i only child should be held to a country or actions isn't it mr secretary i don't know what your father is one of your foreign minister called the accusations force and complained of our resolution was politically motivated but more than 40 countries co-sponsored this resolution 22 voted for it 14 abstained only 11 against your rapidly losing international support and credibility and the vote to prove it to him who are these 40 countries and if i countries are in your wrong right then outside the europeans canada and america england malawi and solomon marshall islands so $35.00 countries got together and make this unsubstantiated accusations allegations so this is nothing to do with the human race in sri lanka

and human rights groups the international commission of jurists has consistently called for the repeal of this that which is being used it says to arbitrarily detained suspects for months and often years without charge or trial why do you keep such repressive laws in place. team from 2015 to 2019 there was a discussion of a counter-terrorism bill the unity government which was formed by some of the main 2 political parties with the support of e.u. with the support of us and other countries drafted the counter-terrorism proposal that is the new act but they could not just do it right so there are issues in our p.t.a. we do accept that we need to revisit our p.d. if we do our sense that this long term and i mean the way you are sending your time on on revisiting it you said that sri lanka has a very democratic regime no repression whatsoever these are your words but your anti terrorist laws make a nonsense of that what place does arbitrary detention without charge or trial have in a democratic country if that's what you are that's what you claim to be this is why i said we need to revisi

we have seen this document prepared by the human great commission now that's ok but you know there had been 5 i mean from 201220132 those and 14 and now 2 of those 2021 so every time this government comes to power they said resolution from the united nations human rights council right is that fair i think we have to ask that the human breakup council then that is fair if i only child should be held to a country or actions isn't it mr secretary i don't know who your father is one of your foreign minister called the accusations forced and complained about the resolution was politically motivated but more than 40 countries co-sponsored this resolution 22 voted for it 14 abstained only 11 against your rapidly losing international support and credibility and the vote prove it to him who are these 40 countries that if a country's are in your wrong right then outside the europeans canada and america england malawi and solomon marshall islands so $35.00 right countries got together and make this unsubstantiated accusations allegations so this is nothing to do with the human race in sri lanka a

behavior is ensuring the penalty offense authority under the federal trade commission act, if the commission formally condemns a particular illegal practice in one case, other companies to knowingly engage in the practice can face fines. when a company recently posted fake positive reviews that tricked consumers into buying its products, the federal trade commission issued an order condemning bad practices, using its authority. the ftc can now potentially issue serious fines against any company that knowingly defies the federal trade commission by posting fake reviews of their own products. in other words, using penalty offense authority, the ftc could put whole industries on notice and if companies where it hurts. mr. coffin, what are your thoughts on this approach, and as the federal trade commission currently inventorying existing borders to see if they can use them to correct civil penalties of scam artists who are operating today? >> ies from s the penalty offense y is one of the additional tools we are very closely looking at. one issue i have with that authority is it gives you penalt

and planning commission. to remove that redundancy. it doesn't mean conditions are going away. we are no longer going to require planning to impose them. >> thanks, sheila. >> there are a number of long standing nighttime entertainment. [indiscernable] land use authority from planning. in this moment of time we know the businesses are facing changes looking for new ownership and there is fear from the people coming in to continue the businesses of the land use process. what this is proposing is that when long standing nighttime entertainment use is operating with all of the required permits from departments like the entertainment commission for at least 10 years, zoning administrator will add mince straighttively place the land use authorization and not go through conditional use. this is someone operating, known to the city more than 10 years with per mets. that we have access to this. the next final changes are to the police code. first is that we would like to remove requirement for limited live performanc

a future commission meeting. >> okay. can you see me? >> commissioner hamasaki: we can see you. >> in the statistics, we are at 222 cases that have been opened so far. this time last year, we are at 233. this year so far, we had closed 286. this time last year, we closed 273. we currently have 301 cases that were pending. last year this time, we had 391. we had sustained 17 cases so far this year. this time last year, we were at 11. for cases that are past the 270-day investigation mark, we are at 35. this time last year, we were at 41. again, our numbers are going down. again, i'm not going to do this every week, but again, i went through every single one of the daises to see what the delays are just to make sure i'm keeping a more thorough watch on everything. several of the cases were pending criminal and/or civil investigations, tools that are involved, on going officer involved shooting cases, they're still being worked up. two of them were delayed, several are body-worn camera footage, and others are where

the planning commission and entertainment commissions would still have the ability to impose any requirement they see fit. in addition, there's a few police code amendments that are also built into this that i'll just highlight quickly. [inaudible] without an entertainment permit. the second is to remove a restriction on one-time permits where they're currently limited to 12 days in a 12-month period, we're going to remove that restriction and move a limited live performance from 10:00 p.m. to 11:00 p.m. to give asummary to the equity impact, it's to reduce the need for capital and open impacts. we recognize that simply removing these barriers does not lead to -- does not directly lead to equitable out comes, so we see all of this supported by all of the other support programs to support those who need it, whether it be individual businesses or neighborhoods and communities. for a.d.u.s, we hope this might be able to produce more affordable housing time that is embedded within neighborhood amenities, and i just want to note there's no prohibition against modifying anything against future des

>> this is the public utilities commission. madam secretary, take the roll, please. [ roll call ]. >> clerk: we have a quorum. before we get started, madam president, i would like to make an announcement. due to the covid-19 emergency and the public health recommendations issued by the san francisco department of health and the governor and the mayor have looked into restrictions on teleconference. this meeting is being held by teleconference and televised. for those of you watching the live stream, be aware there is a lag. on behalf of the commission, i would like to extend our thanks to staff for their assistance during this meeting. if you wish to make public comment on an item dial 415-655-0001, meeting id 146 7158 0343 pound, pound. you must limit your comments to the topic of the agenda item being discussed unless you are speaking under general public comment. the chair can interrupt and ask you to limit your comment on the agenda item comments. we ask that public comment be made in a civil and respectful manner and refra

got it wrong with vote leave _ commission got it wrong with vote leave and — commission got it wrongicised about — leave and got heavily criticised about that. they don't want to make that mistake again. it will take this very— that mistake again. it will take this very slowly which is very bad news _ this very slowly which is very bad news indeed for borisjohnson, who 'ust news indeed for borisjohnson, who just wants _ news indeed for borisjohnson, who just wants the story to go away. which _ just wants the story to go away. which witi— just wants the story to go away. which will not happen. how this plays— which will not happen. how this plays out— which will not happen. how this plays out in the local elections will be — plays out in the local elections will be very telling. there is a school — will be very telling. there is a school of _ will be very telling. there is a school of thought that turnout is normally — school of thought that turnout is normally low in local elections, it is elderly— normally low in local elections, it is elderly people who turn out. most of them _ is

the commission does not take a position on this. we have said repeatedly, high skills immigration in our nation is very important. >> let me just change directions, because i was just so struck by those comments. i thought he had to be addressed. let me ask the final question, which is on ai, a two-part question. one, it seems to me it is in our country's they vanish to move towards forms of ai, and when you look at some of the work jeff hawkins has done how the human mind works in terms of maps of reference angela got mit and what they're being able to do, saying a child doesn't need thousands of pictures to understand what a cat is. but understanding high categories of human perception works. it would be valuable for the united states to invest in that kind of general learning ai so that we're not dependent on data because china love huge advantage over data. if you could address that, then second address what it means for us to human judgment, she would control so the defense decisions are not being just made by algorithms by ai

i am bringing it to the commission because the commission was enthusiastic when we checked in on worker co-op. then i began developing this proposal. >> great. >> so it is exciting work and i think it takes a big chunk of staff time to work on the co-op project when it doesn't have a legislative home. so i would just, i think every piece of work on our work plan should have a pathway to policy implementation and so i just want to maybe step back and say if there are other commissioners, chair chan or commissioner mar, that are interested in taking this back to the board of supervisors, that maybe we hold off on projects that don't have a home or a sponsor. so that's one that i just want to flag. also, the e-bike program, which i think you said was not moving forward because of the department of the environment did not get their grant. >> that's right commissioner. i'm not asking that i have any role on that at all. i just wanted to flag it for you as i'm hoping we will move forward at a different home. >> okay. great. >> i am interested in the post proposition 22 survey project. it soun

we have seen this document prepared by the human rights commission no that's ok but you know there had been 5 i mean from 201220132 those and 14 and now to those who went to 21 so every time this government comes to power they said resolution from the united nations human rights council right is that fair i did we had to ask that the human race council then that is fair. to be held to a country or actions isn't it mr secretary i don't know your father as minister your foreign minister called the accusations force and complained about the resolution was politically motivated but more than 40 countries co-sponsored this resolution 22 voted for it 14 abstained only 11 against your rapidly losing international support and credibility and the votes prove it you who are these party countries that if i countries are in your wrong right then outside the europe is canada and america england malawi and solomon marshall islands so $35.00 countries got together and made this an unsubstantiated accusations allegation so this is nothing to do with the human race in sri lanka so they automatically so

it has been about six months since he promised the commission. the composition of it does not inspire confidence in times of how progressive it will be. there are about 36 members on it, including a lot of people that contributed to the politicization of the federal judiciary, members of the federal society, the right wing group that brett kavanaugh and amy coney barrett belong to. it is hard for me to imagine that these members of the commission would be open to reforms. the other feature that does not inspire tremendous confidence is that the president literally said in his instructions to the commission that he does not want them to make formal recommendations to him. he just wants them to study the issue. a lot of observers are saying this looks more like a classic washington blue-ribbon commission where ideas go to die. i think the attention the commission will bring to the issue is to the good. we will try to leverage that. and i doubt that the commission itself and anything it issues will significantly move anything. host: john in elmo, ca

in 1968 the commission was formed _ me. in 1968 the commission was formed to— me.ssion was formed to investigate the causes of uprisings _ formed to investigate the causes of uprisings across major american cities _ uprisings across major american cities and — uprisings across major american cities. and a man named doctor kehheth— cities. and a man named doctor kenneth clark, a famous african american — kenneth clark, a famous african american psychologist who along with his equally accomplished psychologist wife contributed to compelling research in the brown versus— compelling research in the brown versus board of education case. and doctor— versus board of education case. and doctor clark — versus board of education case. and doctor clark testified that the current — doctor clark testified that the current commission. i want to quote you what— current commission. i want to quote you what you — current commission. i want to quote you what you he said. i read the report— you what you he said. i read the report that _ you what you he said. i read the report that on

commission of the commission says that it is launching this legal action because astra zeneca in its opinion has breached its contract has failed to deliver the number of doses it was supposed to deliver as agreed now astra zeneca delivered 30000000 doses in the 1st quarter of the year to the e.u. that is far from the 120000000 doses that the e.u. commission says that it had actually promised to deliver the new commission also said that astra zeneca could have for example diverted some doses that were produced in the u.k. to the e.u. to try and make up the shortfall now we have heard from astra zeneca they have given a response to this legal action being launched against and they say that is that they say that it has no merit and that they look forward to the opportunity to be able to clear their name now the trasher all the e.u. states have backed this prior to some concerns about legal action tell us more. well the commission met with diplomats from the member states last week to try and garner support for this plan and we know as you say the e.u. member states have all backed the

this may have not come before the commission. there has been a significant turnover on the commission. i urge the commission to agendize this issue once again. thank you. >> this is carol, chair of sierra club water committee. thank you for your service to the committee that is needed for decision making during this time. our committee has three counties south of san francisco. we are seeing one obstruction in managing demand as utilities desire to preserve billable units of water as stated by the board of directors. this explains the emphasize on expensive pipe solutions as alternatives, not the end of the pipe, not potable reuse and stormwater and so forth. please note san mateo uses 96 gals per day 85 residential. hayward 50 the,. [indiscernable] irrigation is the first target. water committee is asking you to create a forum or body of task force to share information and more importantly create implementation channels, topics could be alternative supply, local flows like stormwater and big gray water, local storage, alternativ

at the end of the first world war. commission at the end of the first world war-— commission at theat but how long has the commission knowing that| long has the commission knowing that this has been an issue?— this has been an issue? we've known since the david _ this has been an issue? we've known since the david lammy _ this has been an issue? we've known since the david lammy programme i since the david lammy programme which was a real catalyst in helping us understand perhaps the scale. we have had an archive with millions of documents in and historians and archivists who we have brought into play who have been able to start to chart this level of non—commemoration and i think we've donein non—commemoration and i think we've done in the last 30 years in various parts of the world to commemorate non—commemorated people is extensive. this research report is welcome. it's sobering and very disappointing reading. it gives us the ability, now we know the numbers, and the areas to look, we can start the search is properly and we can pick up on the failings of the past to make sure tha

it has agreed to not only support the work of the commission but to assist the commission in every way possible. well founded in miller's outside the zone of commission building in johannesburg there's been a lot of speculation of course about what little rommel pose and the a.n.c. knew and did and when they did or did not do it given that the realm of force has been speaking at the commission are we any closer to knowing that. well he's used the start of his appearance to go through this prepared statement that we've just heard a bit from where he talks about not wanting to defend the indefensible and so very much wanting to make a point of i'm here at this commission to cooperate and that's especially after former president jacob zuma of here you refused to to reappear after being at the commission once or twice and then saying this is intially was a witch hunt and he wasn't going to stand for it and that's what many african national congress party that's the governing party in south africa what many members echoing that this is a witch hunt that this isn't about corruption a broader

i feel like our commission has actually pushed this. rick even before this office and this kind of mandate on legislative analysis existed our goal has been asked the board of supervisors to look at the economic impacts of certain demographic communities and so i'm really excited to actually develop tools for, you know, that can be applied objective to help us with that and so we our director endrizzi is going to follow up with the board of supervisors to see if there's budget legislative analysis to see if there's a certain type of rubric applied to it or there's something that we can kind of work off of that is already being used with other departments or other parts of our city. but we have a good basis looking at this plan as is. >> president laguana: great. awesome. well, that will be fantastic. looking forward to that. seeing no other commissioner comments. why don't we check and see if there's any public comment. >> we currently have no one in queue for public comment. >> president laguana: seeing none. public comment is closed.