women on the commission.nd i sat with her and know she is dedicated and knowledgeable. she has the understanding of the policy and works with the department. represents all of our commune especially the black and brown community. one purpose thing she has is institutional knowledge have you a young commission it is important to appoint somebody with institutional knowledge. if you remove somebody with historical institutional knowledge you leave a blind commission. when they wlarn is going on their term ended. i think she brings a lot to the table. you have to understand all the accomplishment we had. because of the commission's hard work. and i think it would be a disadvantage to take her off at this time. she is fair. a person for this job. we need to preserve her as the president of the commission she has done great work and the timing is not that important to me. what is more important we have qualified, dedicated people who know the policy and know the department. i also agree that we need look at the de

the controller appointed me to this commission to update him on our commission business. and seek advice on various issues and obligations we have. i had aim budget brief with dpw finance staff a sneak peek at when we will see on our commission in the next couple of weeks. and i will quite honest, it is overwhelming. not surprisingly begin the size of dpw the second largest department in the city and myriad of objigzs. secretary fuller had comments to add-on our commission's per spektdive and role. do you have anything you like to say? >> yes. >> so, specifically to the budget review process that we'll go through in the next -- month, the -- city charter and the admin code do layout for us a process where the department has to have a public meeting on their budget and since this commission exists, that public meeting will take place part of our normal regular january 20th meeting. and then that is -- of course followed up by a vote to approve it after that public hearing. and that will be taking place on february third. i think it is important to think about -- the budget

the controller appointed me to this commission to update him on our commission business. and seek advice on various issues and obligations we have. i had aim budget brief with dpw finance staff a sneak peek at when we will see on our commission in the next couple of weeks. and i will quite honest, it is overwhelming. not surprisingly begin the size of dpw the second largest department in the city and myriad of objigzs. secretary fuller had comments to add-on our commission's per spektdive and role. do you have anything you like to say? >> yes. >> so, specifically to the budget review process that we'll go through in the next -- month, the -- city charter and the admin code do layout for us a process where the department has to have a public meeting on their budget and since this commission exists, that public meeting will take place part of our normal regular january 20th meeting. and then that is -- of course followed up by a vote to approve it after that public hearing. and that will be taking place on february third. i think it is important to think about -- the budget

the competition is conducted by the competition commission . actually, it is completely independent, and no one, not even the president, can give it specific deadlines. moreover, i hope that this was done by the president unintentionally. i think that it is possible that someone who prepared some theses for him made a mistake, but well, we also saw that there were statements from prime minister shmygel, who also wanted the competition to end as soon as possible . indeed enough time, but if you remember how the process took place, back in february of last year , the composition of the competition commission was actually approved, and the problem was precisely that the government , while approving the composition of the commission, made an illegal demand against one of the members of the dragokos commission - this is an international expert. actually, the government did not allow him to participate in the meetings of the commission for the election of the director of the nabu until he gets rid of his membership in the commission for the election

all commissions and departments thank customer and he commission for the w on this. we adopted the resolution affirming the commission's commitment to racial equity. and also adopted the ramaytush ohlone land acknowledgment and commission rules of order and racial equity tool as we look at legislation and policies through the body that we are looking at through the lens of racial equity and he have criteria to help evaluate policies. and then we also did a fair amount of work with street vend and department of public works and making sure we were asking questions as they remember forming the program and the out reach to community what the program entails. people register and comply with this, this is on going effort. >> and last page here, thanks to all of you, am weigh nothing on graffiti, supervisor melgar and stefani created a graffiti pilot program this is under way now launched in november. so before the holidays. and again it was thanks to advocacy this program was created and funding allocated. 4 million for over 2 years. so that small buildingses don'ts have

by the commission it any commission requests the determination. the final until delete members of the commission agree to rekt foil it in closed session. this review must be conducted in closed session the case is confidential at this point. for the item before us today that has been the qualify review of execute ever director's recommendation of a finding of probable cause. it is important to understand what the term, probable cause means. under section 7d one of the commission enforcement regulation, probable cause exists when the evidence is sufficient to lead a person of ordinary caution and prudence to believe or entertain a strong position that is respondent committed or caused a violation. probable cause is not a finding the respondsent actually committed or caused a violation. if the commission finds that probable cause exists for any counts, the case will move forward to a hearing on the merit. which is a separate proceeding the commission will decide whether a fact violation did occur. a hearing on the merit is a public proceeding in ope

as the commission desires. that's allir have. thank you for listening. >> that is our last final public comment on this item. >> thank you very much. we will turn to our next item. then. >> this the item then is general public comment continued from item 2. if necessary. and since we dp not exceed the 15 million time a lotted for comment at the beginning this item is in the needed and we can proceed with the agenda. >> thank you. is there remaining business? there is no further business on the agenda. >> hearing no objection i adjourn this meeting. i wish you a happy new year we will meet in the new year on friday january 6, 2023. thank you. >> still a lot of people wonder since the trees have a lot of issues, why did we plant them in the first place? >> trees are widely planted in san francisco. with good reason. they are workhorses when it comes to urban forestry. we have begun to see our ficustrees are too big and dangerous in san francisco. we have a lot of tree failures with this species in particular. thi

as the commission desires. that's allir have. thank you for listening. >> that is our last final public comment on this item. >> thank you very much. we will turn to our next item. then. >> this the item then is general public comment continued from item 2. if necessary. and since we dp not exceed the 15 million time a lotted for comment at the beginning this item is in the needed and we can proceed with the agenda. >> thank you. is there remaining business? there is no further business on the agenda. >> hearing no objection i adjourn this meeting. i wish you a happy new year we will meet in the new year on friday january 6, 2023. thank you. [music] san francisco emergency home program is a safety net for sustableable commuters if you bike, walk, take public transit or shares mobility you are eligible for a free and safe roadway home the city will reimburse you up to $150 dlrs in an event of an emergency. to learn more how to submit a reimbursement visit sferh. >> good afternoon everyone. i'm san francisco mayo

on commissions like this. which made it all the more an honor and privilege for me to have the opportunity to work with you all the work on behalf of all of you. that brings me and i of course, i would be remiss without talking about regina helped with the original direct. all of us i joined the commission and knew nothing about this stuff. we have to learn on the job. if you are on the job and feel like i don't know what ask happening. i don't know what is happening. tell be more of the same. but she was a really very and is a really careful and patient teach and she is like everybodiacy stayed engaged. and i saw her wuk in the room. we had to stop being response and i have proactive i hope that is a gear this commission never lose i hope we continue to write letters i hope we continue to nudge our elected officials and leaders and law enforcement. and to doing more and better for the sector that offers the most hope i'm a high school grut who was homeless when i moved to the city. i got fire friday every job

during his long tenure on the healing commission served as commission you vice president, chair of the laguna honda hospital joint conference and chair of finance and planning. he was devoted member of the zukerberg general hospital joint conference and arrangemented the health commission on the hospital foundation. and where as doctor sanchez joined d. family and community medicine at the san francisco campus in 1969, and retire in the 2005. during his 36 years he held many positions ucsf voice chancellor of academic affairs. trumental in connecting the campus to the community through the development of programs such as the child support advocacy and resource center. urban health and latino assess am center. and a dedicated leader within san francisco throughout his life served president of the police commission and president of the board of education. he was an emotional many boards of directors including community college board. san francisco foundation, california commission on age and catholic charities columbia park boy and girls club. san francisco education fund. san francisco

a future commission meeting.) >> - commission president's report - commissioners' reports - commissionncements and scheduling of items identified for consideration at future commission meetings (action) >> thank you. commissioner benedicto? >> commissioner kevin benedicto: thank you, i want to offer my congratulations on your reappointment to another term of board of supervisors and it's been an honor to serve with you. congratulations. >> thank you, i appreciate it.. >> vice-president carter oberstone? >> commissioner max carter-oberstone: thank you, president elias. for me, last month i did a ride along with two officers, roger moore and michael caas. i saw a lot of really excellent police work that day. i was just incredibly impressed to see up close, the information sharing, the coordination, the decision making that has to happen under intense time pressure and all types of pressure. so i just want to thank them both for allowing me to intrude on their workday and thank you for your service of this city. at the last meeting i raised the issue of dto h 10 and first time activities

i will say if there is a commission that deserves salaries is a police commission as much as any other. police commission meetings for those who haven't been through them are often long and contentious. you are only seeing the public portion of it because there is a lot that goes on behind-the-scenes in closed sessions and there is not a single person that hasn't said that president elias is a hard worker. this precedes me in the city attorney's office and wayne who was a mentor to me, an lgbtqia plus member with harvey milk whose desk i sit on. who created a great lgbtq plus community. i believe that commissioner elias is worthy of being a commissioner, but there are times that i will have to cast a vote not because i question anyone's commitment or competence or being a great person, but just because there are political differences and i think that's what we are elected to do. for me, this is a decision that is not based on personal, but rather on principle and a principal that i'm not going to observe just for this vote on the police commission appointment. it's going to be one that

a future commission meeting.) - commission president's report - commissioners' reports - commission announcements and scheduling of items identified for consideration at future commission meetings (action) >> thank you. commissioner benedicto. >> thank you president elias. a few things from my report. i want to provide a update on-last week commissioner yee and i mentioned i would be attendeding the chinese (inaudible) on january 20 based on the conversation with commissioner yee before the meeting started with (inaudible) meeting later date as they have other things to attend to but i (inaudible) in order to provide information to those important organizations about our pre-text stop policy. a few updates on the department general orders that i'm responsible for, after a few months of productive meetings between the chief and stakeholders on dgo5.16 regarding search warrant we have reached as far as we will get (inaudible) i will check with the chief after the meeting and stakeholder tuesday see if there is a chance they can agree on language, otherwise i'll ask that to be agendize

thus, the majority of this commission will be ukrainians.t important thing is that this commission will only select candidates, the final decision on the appointment of judges of the constitutional court belongs to the president of the parliament and the congress of judges, no one can force these bodies to appoint someone they do not want appoint a judge of the constitutional court that is, the sovereign right to form a constitutional court will belong to the ukrainian authorities, however, as proposed by the venice commission, the verification of candidates for compliance in accordance with the requirements of the constitution and the law, it should be carried out by independent bodies for a temporary period. by the way, a group of experts with the involvement of foreign experts . well, i understand that you also have no doubts that already during the ukraine eu summit, which will be held in early february, these issues should be removed and resolved at the very least, there should be a clear signal from the ukrainian authorities that it is

i will say if there is a commission that deserves salaries is a police commission as much as any other. police commission meetings for those who haven't been through them are often long and contentious. you are only seeing the public portion of it because there is a lot that goes on behind-the-scenes in closed sessions and there is not a single person that hasn't said that president elias is a hard worker. this precedes me in the city attorney's office and wayne who was a mentor to me, an lgbtqia plus member with harvey milk whose desk i sit on. who created a great lgbtq plus community. i believe that commissioner elias is worthy of being a commissioner, but there are times that i will have to cast a vote not because i question anyone's commitment or competence or being a great person, but just because there are political differences and i think that's what we are elected to do. for me, this is a decision that is not based on personal, but rather on principle and a principal that i'm not going to observe just for this vote on the police commission appointment. it's going to be one that

decision of the commission.no claims, or there are claims, but the measure has been changed, if, for example, the ratio was a preventive measure of detention, we can change this preventive measure, when we see that he really repents, or an event not related to the restriction is chosen freedom. he brings this document to the border and calmly crosses it with this document. now we are working to ensure that the draft law is appropriate. uh. in this case, the decrees of the head of state are a norm that, e, would oblige the border service authorities to ensure the passage of such persons, with the relevant documents for entry into the territory of the republic of belarus, the document can also be received by mail. yes , some kind of electronic version, and inside belarus there are still people who are worried that maybe the security forces will come to them, or they quit their job for some reason of their own , we lend a helping hand to them. you know, this is a very strong misconception that one size fits all is

please tell me about the two requirements of the venice commission . the commission does not set anyequirements that all four of these representatives from international partners and the origin of the russian commission were foreigners, so it is a bit wrong to say that they will all be international experts very often that if such a composition were to be formed. by the way, the group of experts says that ukraine is against sovereignty because foreigners will select the judges of the constitutional court. this is not the case . for example, we believe that the fourth employee is the fourth employee nominated by international experts. it can be a ukrainian, a representative of civil society, an expert who meets the requirements . of the law. thus , the majority of ukrainians will be in this commission, and the second requirement of the venice commission is that the decision of the advisory group of experts be now i will remind you that the law allows such a situation when, by the way, a group of experts agrees to say that it does not meet the requirements of the professional level nec

and i really i know this commission feels it those this knew him in the commission or outside felt it. you know he smiled the laugh the work and everything about him. is a huge losdz for san francisco and for those of us lives touched by him. i would move that we adjourn in his memory. >> very good. >> this meeting is adjourned at 10:20 a.m. >> i went through a lot of struggles in my life, and i am blessed to be part of this. i am familiar with what people are going through to relate and empathy and compassion to their struggle so they can see i came out of the struggle, it gives them hope to come up and do something positive. ♪ ♪ i am a community ambassador. we work a lot with homeless, visitors, a lot of people in the area. >> what i like doing is posting up at hotspots to let people see visibility. they ask you questions, ask you directions, they might have a question about what services are available. checking in, you guys. >> wellness check. we walk by to see any individual, you know may be sitting on the sidewalk, we make sure they are okay, alive. you never know. somebody might

this work also speaks directly to the resolutions adopted by commission and historic preservation commission which calls for general plan policy to address racial and social equity. however we want to emphasize even though we are mandated to do this work we also think the effort is long overdue. the project launched march 2020 and as we saw the ensuing health and economic crisis following by racial inequality we saw this project a key opportunities to reorients our general plan and work more broadly towards equity. so, our approach is is multi-pronged. first we are proposing to create an environmental justice framework which will be incorporated by reference into a updated general plan introduction. so, the ej framework is meant to provide a roadmap identifying over arching priorities for city agencies and partners to address environmental justice. the framework will also include environmental justice community map which highlight the communities most impacted. these will be accompanied by policies embedded throughout the general plan. you have already adopted a set of ej and equity policies

members of the public may address the commission you will to 3 minutes on the matter in the commission's jurisdiction that it is not appear on the agenda. speakers shall address remarks to the commission as a whole. commissioners are not to enter in debate or discussion the lack of a pregnancy by the commissioners or personnel does not constitute agreement with or support of statements made during public comment. >> and i believe we have one member of the public present to make public comment. hi. i'm stacy. i'm a 20 plus year resident of san francisco a mother of 2 teens and my mine mode of transportation is a bikeful i hopeum indulge me extra timei'm the only person here not affiliated with sfd and reaction to an emt and the lives told by your public information officer jonathan backs tor. i have been threatened online overnight phone by people across the country for calling out a san francisco fire department driver on december 29th a cold and rainy day like today i was bike to a meet when i came across a san francisco ambulance number 50. parked in the bike lane on 7th street. this w

commission matters 2. land acknowledgement. >> commissioner will lead us in the acknowledgement today. >> the planning commission acknowledges that we on the homeland security for the original hazard of san francisco peninsula in addition to the stewards and in accordance never been seated and the caregivers of this place and people reside as guests we recognize working under the traditional and wish for the respect of all people . thank you. >> item. >> b.3. consideration of adoption: draft minutes for january 5, 2023. members of the public your opportunity to address the commission on their minutes and again, in the chambers come forward or calling in remotely press star three seeing none, commissioners seeing none, commissioners public comment is closed and they. >> the item is now before you commissioners. >> snarm. >> move to adopt the minutes. >> thank you, commissioners. on that motion commissioner braun, aye. >> commissioner ruiz, aye. >> and commissioner diamond, aye. >> commissioner imperial and

, commission for the presentation. and also, commissioner green has questions about some of the hourly rate of the health services advisory group which they have two new contracts that we reviewed. train new staff to replace them, you know, like when the--and that they only pay only for the services that they rendered. it seems luke a lot of hours but it may not take that much hours for them to complete the job. can until the consent calendar for the report, we'll have to extract the chinese hospitals contract report separately because commissioner chow had mentioned conflict of interest and will have to recuse himself on that particular item. >> okay, let's see, i know going to run us through this especially through the item that needs extraction. >> before we get there, we need to take public comment. >> yes, yes. >> is do see a hand. so folks online, if would you like to make a update, press star-3, again i see a hand. you have three minutes. you are unmuted. >> speaker: i'm speaking on item 8 and later on item 9. >

commission policy. you know, vice president oberstone looked at the arrest data and the percentage of resulting in gun, and i think that's really interesting data. if you lock at the all the offenses that spur looked at, the spras majority was 1% or lower for finding a gun, many were 0 or under one percent as the highest may have been 2 or 3 percent. and this is locking at 10,000 stops worth of data. so the data really speaks for itself, you would luke to challenge, interested members of the public to look at this this data is posted on the commission website. tt not as fun as a single tweet or point. i challenge people to look at the data present a that's we've had and look at the recommendations that wove had from subject matter experts and from organization that's have done analysis of this, of this type of work done across the country. i think that's where, you'll see data pointing in the same conclusion. i would like to thank spir for adding to this commission as it considers this general order and

commission.(clerk of the board) >> thank you. madam city clerk. >> i don't see anyone on the roster please call the roll. for item 42. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> no. >> supervisor mandelman, no. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor stefani, no. and commissioner chan, aye. >> there are 8 i's owe three notices with supervisor dorsey and supervisor mandelman and a vote of 8 to three this motion is approved madam city clerk, call the call the roll. for introduction. >> first member up to introduce new business is supervisor chan thank you, supervisor, supervisor dorsey submit. >> supervisor mandelman. >> thank you. madam city clerk i have an ordinance a um, motion to calendar a hearing a closed session and a moratorium in memoriam the ordinance will make important choices for the construction and increase the accountability for city contrac

commission manager and one commission management assistant. this slide is budget snapshot by divisions and this represents the divisions all the funds in the division. the public works budget is reported to manage 7 bureaus. the budge td for the general administration bureau is largely allocates today the other 6 bureaus through the departments and direct cost plan. at the very top building design and construction, the year over year increase of about $2.7 million is comprised mainly from increased labor cost as well as software licensing cost for the capital project management system. next is infrastructure design construction. year over year decrease reflected is due to the cacapital programs and not reflected in the fiscal 24-25 budget. this amount to $30 million for the street resurfacing and $11.7 million for the critical repair projects. those are not included in the fiscal 24 budget at this time. next is street use and mapping. year over year decrease of about $.6 million a result of the special funds transferred to the general fund. ne

will ukraine fulfill the recommendations of the european and venice commission ?c news with a pass and was left without a job as the head of the department of the patrol police in the lviv region , roman pylypenko was removed from his post for presenting his girlfriend with a permit to travel through the market square, she herself posted a video with a gift on her instagram page and tagged in the post and pylypenko after the video began to spread on the network on the facebook page of the patrol police of ukraine there was a notice about the dismissal of the head of the patrol police department of the lviv region and the appointment of an official investigation public we contacted roman pylypenko for a comment, we have not yet received an answer about lease of the pochaiv lavra with the ukrainian orthodox church of the moscow patriarchate, the author anna voytovych claims that the ukrainian orthodox church conducts anti-ukrainian propaganda in every possible way supports the enemy, the term of the lease expires in 2052, is it possible to terminate it early, who sh

good afternoon welcome to the ethic's commission. minutes reflect this meeting is held pursuant to the 45th is up element to the mayor proclamation the existence of a local emergency and subject to conscience of that proclamation. today's meeting is live on soft sfgovtv. for public comment members mail attends in person or by phone. can you explain how the remote public comment will be handled today? public comment available on each item on this agenda. each member allowed 3 minutes. for those in person opportunity to speak during the public comment will be made available in 416, city hall. for those remote, public comment can be provide by calling 415-554-0001, access code: 2486 188 0913 ## press star 3 to enter the speaker's queue. when the mess anning says have been unmute third degree is you should turn on peek you will hear staff say, welcome. we encourage to you state your name. when you peek have you 3 machines to provide comment. 6 millions if online. you will hear a bell had you have 30 seconds remaining. if you change your