commissioner fong are commissioner honda. okay. thank you very much that motion carries 4 to zero commissioners item 5 a and b that i'll call together this is a possible rehearing depending on the boards decision appeal 11 dash one 2 the rehearing request is in both cases is on monday night sodium street vs. the buckles which the board decided at this .4 to zero to one with one have a doubt to uphold the planning code section. the project is an existing large gate to be replaced and removed to comply with 90s notices of violation. the appeal that same denial of the permit on january 26, 2011, and having to do with building permit. and i believe the zoning administer is prepared to present first to set the stage for what is at issue here total >> just want to go over sorry members of the board the subject permit seeks to remove an off-street parking partially and we determined this parking space was satisfying a requirement for the adjacent property at the 6760 on montana sdoum street we denied the permit and the board upheld our pe

commissioner borden commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong >> commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 duo to zero. commissioners that places you on item 15 for 55 c at the 2048 carville street request for conditional use authorization members of the audience please leave the chambers quietly. we'd appreciate it. >> commissioners, i want to introduce you to a new staff member marseille as a current planner since november over 5 years of planning experience she's worked in the preservation planning in la as a city planner in glendale and holds a graduate degree from ucla. >> good afternoon commissioner president wu and commissioners marseille from the department staff the case is a request for conditional use authorization to advert a one thousand plus commercial space that was to a limited restaurant use. the project is located in the ground floor commercial space in the carville commercial district and within the carville sub district not needing any interior or exterior alternati

commissioner borden. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong. commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to endear and place you on commission matters the consideration of the draft manipulates for may first >> any public comment on that item? seeing none, public comment is closed. >> commissioner fong. >> move to approve draft minutes. >> on that motion to defeat definite the minutes. commissioner antonini. commissioner hillis. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong commissioner president wu so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero >> comments on a couple of things an unfortunate situation that occurred last week some you have saw it on the news a small restaurant in the mission dprakt was a van willed and painted with graffiti and said get out. sooeven son looked at this it is locals corner one of michael's boring it's a small placing place that's exactly what we want locally owned and sustainable feed food and locally grown and modifying frisz the memo so i really don't know w

commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. and commissioner antonini will be joining us shortly first, it the consideration for continuance item one case at 1010 bush stre 1010 bush street conditional use authorization is for case numbers d d and d and case 2010 at the 2820th century lake street conditional use are proposed for june 20th, 2014, i have no other items proposed for conditions i have one speaker card >> karen jones. >> other mike please. this is item one a-1010 bushy own the building next door i'm new to the process but this is the second continuance i'm trying to plan my summer vacation is there a limit to how much time something can be continued i want to be sure and there's no before and after but mr. magaziney. >> the project planner. >> okay. great. >> is there any public comment on items proposed for continuance seeing none, public comment is closed. commissioner moore >> move to continue as noted. >> second. >> commissioners, on that motion as proposed. commissioner antonini. commissioner borden. commission

commissioner borden. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero and places you under commission matters item four for the draft minutes for may 8 >> is there any public comment on the draft minutes seeing none, public comment is closed. commissioner sugaya >> i mows move to a adapt the minutes. >> commissioner antonini pr commissioner borden. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore pursue commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu. commissioners, on that motion that passes so moved, commissioners, that motion passes and places you on commissions questions or comments and commissioner antonini >> i'm not sure this issue falls under the jurisdiction of mta or the city through planning or is state of california but i had it pointed out to me from a visitor out of town that almost all signs are packaging prohibited and under every sign is a pan herald so if it's the cities job or the states job it says civic job

commissioner moore commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero and places you on item 12 a and braxton building inspection commission on bush street a request for kufks and we're consider requires for variances. >> good afternoon commissioner president wu and members of the board. i'm with the staff. the project is located at 1430 bush street and a conditional use authorization to construct a hundred and 15 at all mixed use construction and with the rent a car at the current location. you may recall it was heard by planning commission on september 9th of 2013 and just to bring to our memory the project that was shown at that time, in september. one hundred and 15 foot tall building with 32 unit facing a alley and at that time, there was a few members of public that spoke in opposition and if the commission continued to further work on the design. and there were concerns about a central courtyard in which the unit that faced the courtyard and at that time that was 33 to 38 feet betw

commissioner hillis? >> aye. >> commissioner moore? >> aye. >> commissioner sugaya? >> aye. >> commission president wu? >> aye. >> so moved, commissioners that motion passes unanimously 6-0. >> do we need to keep this material? >> i would imagine you are going to be receiving revised plans. >> >> okay. commissioners, that will place you on your last agendized item, no. 17, for

commissioner borden >> commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong. commissioner president wu so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero >> the commission will take a 20 minute break. >> thursday, may 22, 2014. i'd like to remind please silence all electronic devices. that may sound off and and when speaking before the commission, if you care to, do state your name for the record. commissioners we left off under your regular calendar on item 11. the mission alcohol beverage special use ordinance amending the alcohol beverage special use district. diego sanchez i'll be talking about the special use district alcohol beverages, however, i'm i'm to provide supervisor campos office with time to present on the motivator >> good afternoon, commissioners the amendment to 9 special district is pretty small a narrow exception allowing the miniature golf course to serve alcohol beverages and bowling alleys enjoy this similar section and approached by a company and the business was conceived the people have been in the ne

thank you commissioner hillis. commissioner antonini. commissioner borden >> commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero. commissioner fong >> i was absences at the leasing last hearing and had the ability to look at it on line and prepared to take action. >> i believe there's a request to make a statement. >> good te

commissioner moore arrest commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong >> commissioner president wu. >> so moved, commissioners, that motion passes amazing 7 to zero. commissioners you have another item mr. your department matters the 2013 housing inventory report >> commissioners i'd like to introduce you to audrey she's been with the department for about a year and calm down of cal poly i didn't with engineering degrees and worked that the san lose obtaining focusing on the transportation planning she's had a criteria in her life and a taste for analysis and doing work on transportation issues as well welcome audry. >> welcome. >> welcome. >> thank you director ram for introducing me. good afternoon commissioner president wu and commissioners i'm audry of the planning department information and analysis group in the citywide planning division i'm pleased to introduce the housing information this is an informational hearing no action will be required. the housing inventory was produced in 1967 and has been product with the same consist

commissioner antonini. commissioner borden. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero. >> the commission want to >> good afternoon. welcome to san francisco planning commission regular hearing nor thursday, may 15, 2014. i'd like to remind members of the audience that the commission does not permit outbursts of any kind please silence all electronic devices. that may sound speaking before the commission, if you care to, do state your name for the record. . commissioners we left off under our regular calendar for items 13 a and b for the case e and c at the 1634 on pine street commissioners you'll consider the environmental impact report and hamburger from the staff on the on the conditional use authorization please know the revised porlgsz portion of draft eir end and public comment will be received but not responded inform in writing >> that good afternoon. i'm jenny from the planning department the certification of an eir draft motio

mrrtd read the roll >> commissioner courtney. kwaen. commissioner torres. commissioner moran is expected in a moment and commissioner torres is excused >> thank you please call the roll. >> the next it the minutes for may 13, 2014. >> commissioners. >> i'd like to move the approval. >> it's been mofld and seconded my public comment relate to item 3 the approval of the minutes of may seeing none, public comment is closed. it's been moved and seconded i'll call for a vote please certify by you and opposed the motion carries madam secretary next >> i have 3 speaker cards please submit a speaker cards the first is from francisco. good afternoon >> good afternoon, commissioners. i'd like to first take action (inaudible) >> advocates come over here to speak so there are some new assistant general manager's who have come on board that are other assistant general managers who have already about this on board and, of course, our general manager who knows elsewhere that i'm going to be speaking about in the two minutes and 21 seconds that i have. so let me start with

commissioner fung. commissioner hwang. commissioner honda >> okay. that motion carries 4 to zero and the permit it denied we're on item 15. again at&t california versus the department of public works and the map is on hate street appealing the denial of an excavation of a surface mounted facility. mr. johnson >> thank you. so just a couple of quick points on the specifics of this permit. the permit application was originally filed for had a street on august ethnicity at&t didn't receive a final decision until march that was more than 2 hundred days after at&t submitted it's application throughout the period at&t both in fasting meetings and in written corresponds repeatedly ritsd it expelled the city to comply you with the law especially, after the box walk it took the cities 90 days and that's not if compliance with the law i have nothing further to add for this particular location >> ms. short. >> the only thing i'll note again, the application was submitted august 9th and the box walking was on november 22nd that's month months later. >> public co

commissioner fung. commissioner hwang. commissioner hurtado. commissioner president lazarus. thank you. the vote is 5 to zero that motivator is rescheduled to june 4th and please go over the meeting board guidelines and enact the swearing in process please. please be advised the ringing of and use of cell phones, pagers and similar sound-producing electronic devices please carry open conversation in the hallway appellants and permit holder and department representatives each have 7 minutes to present and 3 minutes for rebuttals people must include their comments within the 7 minutes and parties that are not ffltd may not have rebuttal interest are are. members of the public who wish to speak on an item are not required to submit a sprrd the speaker cards are available on the left side of the podium there's a customer satisfaction form if you have questions please speak to the staff or call the board office on 1650 mission street. it is broadcast live over sfgovtv capable 78 and dvds are available for purchase. thank you for your attention if you tipped to testify and wish to

commissioner antonini. commissioner borden >> commissioner hillis.

commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong. commissioner president wu that places you under your calendar and may be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the commission. there will be no separate discussion of these items a member of the commission, the public, or staff so requests in which event the matter shall be removed from the consent calendar and considered as a separate item at this or a future hearing. we have one item under consent item 5 at 840 irving street i have no speaker cards but i believe commissioner sugaya has an announcement >> i have a member of a medical group i impounded with a city attorney and he said there were no conflicting positions but i'll be voting on the item. >> commissioner fung. >> i'm a member of that group as well. >> commissioner antonini. >> seeing. >> we need to take public comment. >> then i move to. >> having is there any public comment on the consent calendar seeing none, public comment is closed. >> move to approve item 5. >> second. >> on that motion to approve item 5. commissi

commissioner antonini. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore and commissioner sugaya. commissioner borden is expected to run late this is items for continuance the first at the tennessee bush street for for the next case and 2014 d at the 3305 broadway restrict street are for may 14 and the next case golden gate avenue conditional use authorization and the next at 23 turk boulevard is for indefinite continuance and further on your regular calendar for the next case bona fide eating place we've received a request from the supervisors office asking for a continuance >> i have no speaker cards. >> are there that any comments on the items proposed for continuance? >> good afternoon, commissioners i'm mrs. mcauthor i live on bush street across from tennessee bush street this was brought brought to my attention i said have opposed it i want you to know we have a lot of elderly people on bush street and their concerned about the - ma'am, on this time we're only taking comments on the matters of continued. >> this is continued. >> this is to support the conditions to that cont

commissioner borden. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero and places you under our discretionary review calendar. item 14 for the case d at the 1110 ashburg after may first, they continued the matter by a vote of 6 to zero commissioner fong upper absent at this item and for you to participate you'll have to say you've reviewed the materials and that's correct i watched it on sfgovtv and am ready. >> if we can say add consulted the secretary on how to consultation the hearing this is the third hearing we just decided to allow for the staff for 3 minutes from the dr requester and open this up for public comment. >> okay. >> good afternoon. commissioner president wu and members this case is a discretionary review for 1110 ashbury street to allow the property owner project sponsor to work on the design and incorporate feedback. as a reminder the dr was filed by the resident directly from the adjacent property to the north. the dr re

commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner president wu. sxhun so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero . >> good afternoon. welcome back to san francisco planning commission regular hearing for thursday, may 8, 2014, i'd like to remind members of the public the commission that the commission does not permit outbursts of any kind and please silence all electronic devices. that mating may signing seen off and when speaking before the commission, if you care to, do state your name for the record. commissioners we've left off in your your regular calendar the sponsor planning codes to eliminating fees. good afternoon. welcome commissioner i'm kevin i'm the fence and i t manager for the planning department i'm here to ask for eliminates of fees i've presented this to the commission on february 5th and 4th i presented the planning proposal on february 5th and you approved the departments budget the property code amendments eliminates the fund foreclosure fees for the reactuation for closed cases none have a high volume a

commissioner borden. no. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore >> commissioner sugaya. no. commissioner fong. commissioners that motion fails three to 2. 3 i's >> i'm sorry the motion does pass because otherwise, we'd, or be stuck that motion moved and gets continued to july 17th because a majority of the commissioners voted in favor of the continuance >> we have two other matters. >> do we keep that that i commissions on 16 a and b on broadway restrict street mandatory discretionary review on a demolition and construction. >> g good evening. i'm christen planning staff. the item is a mandatory discretionary review for broderick. the project is to demolish a one story single-family dwelling and construction another one the property is located on the west side of broadway restrict street. the subject lot measures 25 feet by 94 feet deep and continuing lot area. the lot continues a single-family residence. the property is located within the rh 3 district. the surrounding neighborhood has 2, 3, 4 residential dwellings and the block facing the property while buildings in the mi

commissioner hillis? >> aye. >> commissioner moore? >> aye. >> commissioner sugaya? >> aye. >> commission president wu? >> aye. >> so moved, commissioners that motion passes unanimously 6-0. >> do we need to keep this material? >> i would imagine you are going to be receiving revised plans. >> >> okay. commissioners, that will place you on your last agendized item, no. 17, for case no. 2013.340d, at 1423 [ao-fb/] avenue a request for a mandatory discretionary review. >> commissioner antonini. >> i am going to have to recuse myself from this. i am waiting for interpretation. i have project sponsor is a dental patient of mine. we're not entirely sure whether his services at this point and renumeration and once i have a clear understanding for project probings it may have a similar circumstance, but in this case we'll just have to ask for recusal today. >> move to recuse. >> second. >> good evening. >> sorry, one second. on the recusal of commissioner antonini commissioner antonini? >> aye. >> commissioner borden? >> aye. >> commissioner hillis? >> aye. >> commissioner

commissioner moore no. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu. that motion fails three to four with commissioner moore's and commissioner fong and another commissioners voting against this project will be approved ass as in its curiosity state >> commissioner moore. >> i want to suggest that the architect try to create the courtyard in principle that was discussed in the previous time and there was a number of people that expressed the need for an adjacent building keeping with the adjacent courtyard and the light well dimensions. i think that applicant has started with a very, very good idea i like it and the more rigorous way to come to the ground floor and i think it's possible to do that so my motion s this is being tried >> i'm sorry. >> my motion that the project be returned and the applicant try to modify the design as suggested. is that >> that's a motion to continue working on that. >> second. >> i think some of the challenges i noted there wasn't a full agreement by commission so there what i remember there was who directs to move back

commissioner borden >> commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero and places you on item 10 for case and intention to initiate the development related to formula retail uses and to consider an adaptation of an ordinance at a later hearing >> good afternoon. commissioner president wu and commissioners in the an exciting day for the staff after implementing the formula retail controls we're ready to unveil our policy recommendations. the action is simple we having ask you bring those to life but to describe the full action of controls and to hear from you. the broad consensus the noticeable process is working it has expand and seems to be an effective method to provide public input your proposal recognitions this and seeks to build upon the framework. we will expand the process in some geometric areas while reducing some in some circumstances the retail depiction will expand in some and reduce in others. we believe this is a murder and ba

>> aye. >> commissioner moore? >> . >> aye commissioner sugaya? >> commissioner fong? >> aye. >> commissioner president wu. >> aye. >> that motion passes unanimously -06789 commissioners that will pace you on item 14 or case no. 2012.04 the 3x1201 request for authorization. >> good afternoon agencies, rich sucre department staff and the project is a large project authorization for proposed project at 1201-1225 tennessee street and seeking modification for rearar, dwelling unit exposure, off-street loading, horizontal reduction and accessory for dwelling units. the proposed project including demolition of existing two-story commercial ware hughes building and automotive service station, and new construction after i 6-story residential building with 259 dwelling units of which 34 will be affordable dwelling units. and grund-floor corner retail, approximately 2260 square feet. 2-car share parking spaces, 147 off-street parking spaces and 259 class i bicycle parking spaces. the project includes a dwelling units consisting of six 3-bedroom units, 105,2-bedroom, 49 one-bedro

commissioner borden. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero. zoning administer >> take the closed public hearing and take the matter under advisement. >> commissioners that will place on item 13 as 18 street. >> good afternoon commissioner president wu and members planning staff this is the request for an conditional use authorization at the 18 union street a 3 story mixed use at the aaron that was developed in 1933 features resident and ground floor and at the rear of the first floor it features a t mobile as well as an at&t facility. the t mobile is a single-family antenna mounted to the base and it consists of the antennas mounted along the intersection of octavia and union streets it is up to 6 panel machines on the rooftop and larger equipment cabinets inside the building and the screen will be used it on the rooftop in order to screen the antennas as well the equipment the northeast part of the building is component of two a

and with commissioners hillis and moore, voting against. >> and commissioners, the next two items were listed on your agenda as items 19 aand b because they have the same address, or very similar addresses but they are two different projects and we will be taking them up separately, 19 a 2014.0043, >> the item before you is a request for a conditional use authorization for 22055 a union street, a use that is also a limited restaurant doing business as earth bar where a vacant ground floor located at the fourth story commercial building to be occupied by the gym. it will occupy 1600 square feet and 750 square feet will be dedicated to the restaurant use as a juice bar and 500 square feet will be dedicated to the fitness apparel and retail sales and the remaining 325 square feet will be shared circulation and storage and rest room space and no changes to the building envelope are proposed. and the operation will consist of four to five full time employees and would operate 7 days a week, from 6:00 a.m. to 11 p.m. currently, there are five stand alone earth bar location and ten locations

and commissioner antonini? >> maybe i could ask teddy, from at&t project sponsor to answer some questions and a lot of speakers have been talking about the pool across the street. and to my knowledge, you have to go down that john, young drive quite a ways before you get to that, am i thinking of a different location? because the police station and the pool are down at the end and so that in itself is a few 100 yards i would say to get to that but what about the pool? is it high enough, even if you were able to talk park and rec into it for a site for to give you the coverage? >> so, thank you commissioner for your question. our rf team sent, went out there several different times to try to find locations in that area. and they determined that they could serve one of the sector and it would be the four panel sector that would lead six antennas left on the roofs of the building. and they could serve one sector out of balboa park just because it is pretty far away. and in terms of rf distance not necessarily in w

thank you commissioner hillis. commissioner antonini. commissioner borden >> commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero. commissioner fong >> i was absences at the leasing last hearing and had the ability to look at it on line and prepared to take action. >> i believe there's a request to make a statement. >> good afternoon, commissioners we were just informed today that the public health department has made a question on the developer and granted a permit through the change of ownership we request that item 15 the discretionary review on ocean avenue be continued to the commission can include and consider supervisor yee's legislation on the developer clustering the supervisor is not against the applicant but we're incentive to the clustering of the cannabis dispensaries on motioning mission avenue. >> commissioner sugaya i wish the city attorney were here i have a procedural question maybe staff know the answer. since this is pending as has been pending for awhile e

any public comment on the designation of creditor and commissioner fung and commissioner hwang and commissionerresident lazarus and commissioner honda we'll use the civil rights transcript for the preceding and items 10 and 11 will not be heard they've withdrawn and the rest of the items we're going to hear them in a manner similar to how we heard the previous wounding wounding once we're agreed about the parties to give the parties time at the beginning of those hearing to present global argument and rebuttal and take each item via with a shorthand amount of time and decide it separately we'll start with the appellant to start with the global argument. >> is there a reason why we can't hear this aggregated the brief is based on an aggregate argument. >> if you want you can ask that felt appellant and my understanding is their interest to be able to present more factual information about each address but if you want we can ask chairperson johnson to talk about that. >> the last time there were no specific arguments. >> that's why we want to change that. >> if they want it i understand okay. >>

commissioner adams? >> here. >> commissioner yee riley? >> here. >> commissioner tour-sarkissian? >> here. >> commissioner white? >> here. >> the commission has a quorum with four members present. public comment, is limited to 3 minutes per speaker unless otherwise established by proceeding officer of the meeting. completion of the speaker card while optional will ensure proper spelling of speakers' names. greg, do we have any members of the public who would like to make any comments that are on items that are not on today's agenda? seeing none, public comment is closed. next item, please. >> item 3 approval of the airport 14, 2014 regular meeting minutes, action item. >> do we have a motion to approve the minutes? >> move. >> so we have a second? >> >> all in favor? >> aye. >> next item >> motion passes four votes in favor, none opposed. item 4 discussion and possible action to make recommendations to the board of supervisors on bos file no. 140097 medical cannabis dispensary ocean avenue neighborhood commercial transit district and we have with us the legislative aide for superv

on that motion made that i commissioner fung. commissioner hwang absent. commissioner hurtado. commissioner president lazarus and commissioner honda >> that motion carries 4 to zero we'll move ton to item 21 on scott street. mr. johnson. >> i don't believe there's anything particularly unusual about this appeal i'll try to be very, very brief there's an 11 most gap and ms. fong again found that at&t complieltd with the requirements of the s m f. during the sidewalk as the hearing director reported two members of the community attend the box walk and at&t walked the neighborhood and found another site - my apologizes i'm reading from 100 furton street. what happened was about at&t offered to walk the site to review alternative site locations, however, the obtain terrors found no suitable area and that's one of the difficulties that at&t faces because the way this process is supposed to work at&t works with the community to find the least impacted loeshgs but if the community won't identify any location then at&t appeal the specific denial was that the hearing officer saw the pro

commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner president wu. sxhun so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero . >> good afternoon. welcome back to san francisco planning commission regular hearing for thursday, may 8, 2014, i'd like to remind members of the public the commission that the commission does not permit outbursts of any kind and please silence all electronic devices. that mating may signing seen off and when speaking before the commission, if you care to, do state your name for the record. commissioners we've left off in your

commissioner antonini. commissioner borden. no. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. if you could for the record if europe following the procedures >> commissioner moore. >> no. >> commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu >> that motion passes 5 to 2 with the commissioners commissioner borden and commissioner moore voting against. xhirgz commissioners that places on item is 13 for a conditional use authorization >> good afternoon president chiu and planning staff this is for a at&t making could facility the project site is a 41 foot tall church the site was developed as the george washington ma sonic area and the site is surrounded by single-family residences with the expectation of the park as well as the mixed use building to the south the dell tin and the residents above will feature panel on the roof or sectors that will be set back and rise 6 feet above the roof and it will mimic penthouse elements the facility features a cage roof access ladder in the northeast corner of the building as well as a rear yard equipment area in the area c

commissioner adam >> i'd like to follow-up on my fellow commissioners. i tank i came to the meeting lateone of the issues that was an issue was trust. one thing that i believe about trust goes 2 ways. you just can't, and i said this [inaudible] you can't sit on the sideline throw stones and not come to the dance. you have to come to the dance you've got to come to the [inaudible] you get the mike. i'm a union guy. i run an organization is a bottom-up organization rank-and-file. you know what, this port commission like a lot of people that are commissioners [inaudible] give a right to criticize. you can sit outside and who knows because i was believed in a fair [inaudible]. i believe that. i know that the african-american chamber, hispanic feel i'm sure that people to show favoritism. that happens. but i will also say this: in life nobody's going to give you everything. you've got to go for. you better take it. and you get to have your a game. unfortunately, about people in my life i'm sure we all have, some people interview well some people don't. sometimes only get one chance to make a