commissioner beto? >> um, yes. >> commissioner clinch? >> yes. >> commissioner jacobo? >> i'm going to have to abstain only because of the process. >> commissioner tam? >> can i make a comment before i make my vote? >> sure. >> so i definitely understand, you know -- i definitely think that president mccarthy has served the commission and has the experience and kind of guided it thus far. and i also see that the process here is, in a way, kind of false and not what it should be. and i think, you know, elizabeth, commissioner tuk, pointed that out and kind of make that very clear. with that said, i would like to continue and put my vote in with a yes. >> okay. >> thank you. so this motion carries 5-2. so thank you. >> okay. so next item on the agenda, please? >> so we would need to do the motion for vice president. >> please call the question. >> is there a motion to nominate a vice president? >> i would like to nominate commissioner jason tam for the vice vice presidency seat, please. >> is there a second? >> i'll second. >> so kevin seconds. so there is a motion and a

commissioner covington? >> commissioner covington: yes. i move that we not disclose. >> president feinstein: oh, i'm not there yet. >> commissioner covington: oh, sorry. >> clerk: this is on report on any action. are we reporting on any action? >> president feinstein: that the settlement was approved. that's what we can disclose. >> clerk: okay. item 10, vote to elect whether to disclose any or all discussions held in closed session as specified in san francisco administrative code section 67.12-a. [roll call] >> clerk: it is unanimous. item 11, adjournment. >> president feinstein: commissioner nakajo's hand went up first. >> commissioner nakajo: i so move, madam president. >> president feinstein: commissioner cleaveland, i give this one to vice president rodriguez. all right. if there's no objection, we are adjourned at 6:36. preflt>> chairman: good morning. the meeting will come to order. welcome to the thursday, february 25th meeting of the public safety & neighborhood services. i'm supervisor gordon mar, the chair of this committee. i'

. >> commissioner diamond? >> here. >> commissioner none. >> here. >> commissioner imperial? >> here. >> we do expect commissioner tanner to arrive late today. first on your agenda is considering -- is agenda items proposed for continuance until april 1st, 2022. item two. prp at 2375 funston avenue. item 3, case number 16. 2214 cuyuga avenue and 3101 allegheny boulevard. proposed for continuance april 29th. item number 4, 468 turk street. a conditional use authorization, at the time of issue answer was proposed for an indefinite continuance. it's being month posed until march 25th, 2021. item 5, case number 2007 at 1145 mission street is proposed for indefinite continue u answer. and item 6, case number 2018-00 sr 63 has been withdrawn. we should open this up for public comment. if you wish to address the commission on any of these items, please press star then 3 to be added to the cue. seeing no requests to speak for members of the public -- i take it back, there is one. you have two minutes. go ahead, caller, you have two minutes. okay, i don't think this person wants to sp

. >> commissioner chan. >> yes. >> commissioner diamond. >> hear. >> commissioner fung. >> here. >> commissioner imperial. >> here. >> commissioner tanner. >> here. >> thank you. first is consideration items for proposed continuance. 1. 2020-003223 c.u.a. at 249 texas street. this is to continue to march 4th, 2021. 2. case 2019-021010 c.u.a. is withdrawn. further under regular calendar item 10 case 2013.1535 at 474 o'farrell street street and 532 jones street conditional use authorization is requesting continuians to march 11, 2021. item 11. 2018-014795 at 1516 folsom street requests continuance to february 18, 2021. i have no other items for continuance. we should open this up for public comment. members of the public this is your opportunity to speak for any items proposed for continuance. press star 3. one member of the public. you have two minutes. >> good afternoon. this is ella strong, president of the executive board of church of christ scientist. cosponsors of o'farrell street street and request continuance of our item. thank you. >> thank you. >> last call for public comment on items to

commissioner tanner. >> aye. >> commissioner chan. >> aye. >> commissioner diamond. >> aye. >> commissioner fung. >> aye. >> commissioner imperial. >> aye. >> commissioner moore. >> aye. >> commissioner president koppel. >> aye. >> that passes 7-0. that puts us on your consent calendar. only one item on consent. that is your consent calendar to be routine by the planning commission by a roll call vote of the commission. no separate discussion unless a member of the commission or public or staff requests. then it shall be removed and considered at a separate item. 3. 2020-007346 c.u.a. this is 2284-2286 union street. we will take public comment for anyone wishing to pull this off consent. members of the public press star three. no members requesting to speak at this time public comment is closed. your consent calendar is now before you. >> commissioner moore. >> i move to approve. >> second. >> thank you, commissioners. that motion to approve item 3 under consent calendar commissioner tanner. >> aye. >> commissioner chan. >> aye. >> commissioner diamond. >> aye. >> commissioner fung. >> aye.

. >> commissioner black: here. >> commissioner foley: here. >> commissioner johns: here. >> commissioner pearlman: here. >> commissioner so: here. >> thank you, commissioners. first on the agenda, general public comment. at this time, members of the public may address the commission on items of interest to the public that are within the subject matter jurisdiction except agenda items. agenda items will be afforded when each item is reached in the meeting. members of the public, this is your opportunity to press star 3 to be entered into the queue. seeing no requests to speak, commissioners, from members of the public, public comment -- general public comment is closed. and we can move on to department matters. item 1. department announcements. >> just quickly, good afternoon, commissioners. i just wanted to let you know there was a recent court of appeals decision that upheld the city's decision to remove the statue, which i know many of you were involved in. the decision through certificate of appropriateness and skwal finding. -- ceqa finding. it was upheld in the decision. so happy to

commissioner lee or commissioner bush. commissioner lee. >> vice-chair lee: thank you, chair ambrose. i think that the year has been a very challenging one for both our country and the city. we were hit by a couple of viruses, covid pandemic, and also in the city the outbreak of the corruption virus. the commission has gone through a very challenging year in various ways. and i really appreciate chair ambrose's leadership in guiding us through some really unusual times. and i would nominate her to a second term, because we need steady leadership and continuity to bring us to a new chapter. to really rebuild the public's trust. and also to enforce the ethic commission's relevance in our work and tackling the -- the challenges that we're facing as a commission and in the city. so it is with honor for me to nominate chair ambrose to be our next chair for the commission. >> chair ambrose: thank you. commissioner bush. you are muted, unfortunately. >> commissioner bush: i second the nomination of chair ambrose. >> chair ambrose

commissioner tanner. >> aye. >> commissioner chan. >> aye. >> commissioner diamond. >> aye. >> commissioner fung. >> aye. >> commissioner imperial. >> aye. >> commissioner moore. >> aye. >> commissioner president koppel. >> aye. >> that passes 7-0. that puts us on your consent calendar. only one item on consent. that is your consent calendar to be routine by the planning commission by a roll call vote of the commission. no separate discussion unless a member of the commission or public or staff requests. then it shall be removed and considered at a separate item. 3. 2020-007346 c.u.a. this is 2284-2286 union street. we will take public comment for anyone wishing to pull this off consent. members of the public press star three. no members requesting to speak at this time public comment is closed. your consent calendar is now before you. >> commissioner moore. >> i move to approve. >> second. >> thank you, commissioners. that motion to approve item 3 under consent calendar commissioner tanner. >> aye. >> commissioner chan. >> aye. >> commissioner diamond. >> aye. >> commissioner fung. >> aye.

commissioner imperial? >> commissioner imperial: thank you. was concerns about the access to sunlight. perhaps the planner or at&t can clarify or describe the kinds of actions that they did when it comes to this complaint or kind of issue? >> sure. i'd like to defer to the sponsor as they were in direct communication with a different neighbor about relocating with the antennas and the screen. >> clerk: project sponsor, are you able to comment? >> yes, can you hear me? >> clerk: yes, we can. >> yes. during the community meeting, we actually took that into consideration along the way, and we moved the screen over approximately 2.5 feet, and we moved the screen down approximately 3 feet. we reduced the capacity of the antennas on those two sectors, and we tried to minimize the sector count and just the space in general as much as possible, and that's pretty much what we could do to keep the site still, the coverage, but we tried. >> commissioner imperial: and when you're doing that analysis, did you get to the point that it will take -- that that

commissioner peskin. >> aye. >> commissioner preston. >> aye. >> commissioner ronen. >> aye. >> commissioner safai. >> aye. >> commissioner stefani. >> aye. >> commissionerrual ton. >> aye. >> we have 11 ayes. the motion passes. >> thank you. please call the next item. >> item 4. allocate $7,524,841 with conditions and appropriate $6,000 in prop k sales tax funds to 13 requests. this is an action item. >> i believe we have a report from the deputy director of policy and programming here. >> good morning. thank you for the introduction and with that i will share my screen. chair, are you able to see my presentation? >> i am. >> okay. the first request is for $1.9 million for the design phase of improvements to two muni facilities that will be upgraded in order to accept vehicles that would be relocated from potrero maintenance yard during construction. a vacant lot that is used for accepting vehicles and doing testing. this would enable the design phase to be completed and see consequences for relocating the buses when the yard goes under construction and that funding is the next item on the

seconded by commissioner dooley. >> commissioner adams. >> yes. >> commissioner dooley. >> yes. >> commissioner hule. >> yes. >> commissioner laguana. >> yes. >> commissioner ortiz-cartagena. >> yes. >> commissioner laguana. >> yes. >> 6-0 with one recused. >> great. next item, please. >> item 10. general public comment. members of the public comment on matters within the jurisdiction but not on today's calendar and suggest new agenda items for future discussion. discussion item. >> any members of the public to comment on any matter not currently on our agenda? >> there is no one in the queue at this time. >> comment is closed. next item. >> item 11. director's report. update and report on the office of small business and the small business assistance center, department programs, policy and legislative matters, announcements from the mayor announcements regarding small business activities. >> thank you, commissioners. director of the office of small business. i want to start off with director's report by congratulating mayor breed for the new position as recorder. that was very exciting today.

commissioner lee or commissioner bush. commissioner lee. >> vice-chair lee: thank you, chair ambrose. i think that the year has been a very challenging one for both our country and the city. we were hit by a couple of viruses, covid pandemic, and also in the city the outbreak of the corruption virus. the commission has gone through a very challenging year in various ways. and i really appreciate chair ambrose's leadership in guiding us through some really unusual times. and i would nominate her to a second term, because we need steady leadership and continuity to bring us to a new chapter. to really rebuild the public's trust. and also to enforce the ethic commission's relevance in our work and tackling the -- the challenges that we're facing as a commission and in the city. so it is with honor for me to nominate chair ambrose to be our next chair for the commission. >> chair ambrose: thank you. commissioner bush. you are muted, unfortunately. >> commissioner bush: i second the nomination of chair ambrose. >> chair ambrose

>> aye. >> commissioner -- >> aye. >> commissioner perez? >> aye. >> commissioner wang? >> aye. >> commissioner binen? >> aye. did i just miss it? did we do public comment on the minutes? >> no, we didn't. so -- >> i think we should probably do public comment and then redo the vote just so everything's official. >> yeah. >> okay. is there any public comment on the minutes? >> i'm checking, and there are no hands raised in the audience, and there's no chat comments. >> okay. seeing none, public comment is now closed. [roll call]. >> the meeting minutes have been approved. the next item on the agenda is item no. 3, report from the executive director presented by the executive director. >> thank you so much, vice-president camino. it's nice to have you running the meeting. it's a breath of fresh air, although missing your [indiscernible]. this evening i want to share space for some updates relative to the shuddered venue operators program, so there will be a monthly update later in this evening's agenda, and the only other legislative item that i can update you on this even

. >> commissioner chan. >> yes. >> commissioner diamond. >> hear. >> commissioner fung. >> here. >> commissioner imperial. >> here. >> commissioner tanner. >> here. >> thank you. first is consideration items for proposed continuance. 1. 2020-003223 c.u.a. at 249 texas street. this is to continue to march 4th, 2021. 2. case 2019-021010 c.u.a. is withdrawn. further under regular calendar item 10 case 2013.1535 at 474 o'farrell street street and 532 jones street conditional use authorization is requesting continuians to march 11, 2021. item 11. 2018-014795 at 1516 folsom street requests continuance to february 18, 2021. i have no other items for continuance. we should open this up for public comment. members of the public this is your opportunity to speak for any items proposed for continuance. press star 3. one member of the public. you have two minutes. >> good afternoon. this is ella strong, president of the executive board of church of christ scientist. cosponsors of o'farrell street street and request continuance of our item. thank you. >> thank you. >> last call for public comment on items to

on that motion commissioner tanner. >> aye. >> commissioner chan. >> aye. >> commissioner diamond. >> aye. >> commissioner fung. >> aye. >> commissioner imperial. >> aye. >> commissioner moore. >> aye. >> commissioner koppel. >> aye. >> that passes unanimously 7-0. we are on item 9 for 2017-015181 c.u.a. at 412 broadway. this is a informational hearing. staff prepared to page your presentation? >> yes, i am. >> good afternoon. department staff. the item before you is an informational hearing regarding the conditional use authorization granned to the restaurant and nighttime entertainment at 412 broadway allow operating hours to 4:00 a.m. daily. it was approved by planning commission on october 25, 2018. extended hours operations first began for the penthouse club and restaurant on march 7, 2019. the commission required the sponsor for ongoing engagement and responsibilities from the liaison requirement for performance update based on the first year of extended hours of operation. that is the purpose of this hearing. the project complied with the conditions of approval. the interested

commissioners, i'll open it up for questions to the commissioners. john, there were parts of your presentation there that didn't come through. so i'm not sure. >> i'm sorry. >> it's not your fault. vice chair moss, do you have questions? >> vice president moss: no. >> president mccarthy: commissioner alexander-tut, do you have questions? >> commissioner alexander-tut: yes. thank you for your presentation. is the fee waiver only for new permits or is this for any fees related to existing permits for a.d.u.s? >> this would be for new construction. adus that are not legalized is separate. >> commissioner alexander-tut: any fees for existing permits for a.d.u.s or new permits for new a.d.u.s? >> i believe this is for new a.d.u.s, uh-huh. >> commissioner alexander-tut: thank you. >> president mccarthy: commissioner bito, welcome to the commission. do you have any questions, please? >> commissioner bito: not at this moment. >> president mccarthy: commissioner clinch? >> commissioner clinch: no. thanks. >> president mccarthy: commissioner jacobo. >> commiss

seconded by commissioner dooley. >> commissioner adams. >> yes. >> commissioner dooley. >> yes. >> commissioner hule. >> yes. >> commissioner laguana. >> yes. >> commissioner ortiz-cartagena. >> yes. >> commissioner laguana. >> yes. >> 6-0 with one recused. >> great. next item, please. >> item 10. general public comment. members of the public comment on matters within the jurisdiction but not on today's calendar and suggest new agenda items for future discussion. discussion item. >> any members of the public to comment on any matter not currently on our agenda? >> there is no one in the queue at this time. >> comment is closed. next item. >> item 11. director's report. update and report on the office of small business and the small business assistance center, department programs, policy and legislative matters, announcements from the mayor announcements regarding small business activities. >> thank you, commissioners. director of the office of small business. i want to start off with director's report by congratulating mayor breed for the new position as recorder. that was very exciting today.

commissioner lazarus and then commissioner swig and commissioner chang. >> commissioner lazarus: thank you. i'm not sure this is totally germane to what we're dealing with. but i don't quite understand i guess it's the timeline, because you -- the l.o.d. -- or the abandonment was from the early part of the 21st century. and then, there was an intervening active use. but then, somebody pointed out that it hadn't been used. so why is it that you were able to sort of -- or consider reverting back to that first period? does that question make sense? >> yeah, because the restaurant that was approved to go in the location in 2011 was approved in error. we never should have approved that to go in. it needed continue use authorization, because it had been abandoned. so while that we approved that use, we did so in error. and that's what we stated to the applicant at the time. you know, this information -- we said what evidence do you have? the same issue in the l.o.d. about basta pasta came up. we said what's your evidence? this was to the applicant. and they couldn't come back with anything.

commissioner tanner? >> aye. >> commissioner khan? >> aye. >> commissional fung? >> aye. >> commissioner imperial? >> aye. >> and commissioner koppel? >> aye. >> thank you, that motion passes unanimously, 7-0. and places us under commission matters, adoption of the minutes from january 28, 2021. members of the public if you would like to speak to the minutes, now is your opportunity to do so. seeing no members of the public wishing to speak at this time, public comments is closed and the minutes are now before you. >> commissioner diamond? >> move to approve both sets of minutes. >> second. >> thank you, commissioners on that motion to adopt the minutes. commissioner tanner? >> aye. >> commissioner khan? >> aye. >> commissioner diamond? >> aye. >> commissioner fung. >> aye? >> commissioner imperial? >> aye. >> and commissioner koppel? >> aye. >> that motion is approved 7-0. item three, comments and questions? commissioner tanner? >> good afternoon commissioners, and i'm just reminding everyone we're about a week and a half longer, most of the way through february

commissioner chan. >> aye. >> commissioner haney. >> no. >> commissioner mandelman. >> aye. >> commissioner mar. >> aye. >> commissioner melgar. >> aye. >> commissioner peskin. >> aye. >> commissioner preston. >> aye. >> commissioner ronen. >> aye. >> commissioner safai. >> aye. >> commissioner stefani. >> aye. >> commissioner walton. >> aye. >> we have 10 eye as. the he -- 10 ayes. time approval. >> item 9. adopt fiscal year 2021/22 transportation fund for clean air local expenditure criteria. this is an action item. >> let me bring up my slides. >> all right. the transportation fund for clean air funds projects to reduce motor vehicle emissions and improve air quality is funded by $4 surcharge on motor vehicle registrations in the bay area. 60% of the funds are managed by shuttles and ed chargers and 40% by the counties including the transportation authority administering the program in san francisco. this year we expect to have $730,000 available for projects. it is important to know the air district establishing the requirements and project types. it require county to guide the selectio

. >> commissioner mar. >> aye. >> commissioner melgar. >> aye. >> commissioner peskin. >> aye. >> commissioner preston. >> aye. >> commissioner ronen. >> aye. >> commissioner safai. >> aye. >> commissioner stefani. >> aye. >> commissioner walton. >> aye. >> we have 11 ayes. the motion passes on the first reading. >> thank you. please call the next item. >> item 5. allocate $5,773,403 and appropriate $150,000 in prop k sales tax funds with conditions for potrero yard modernization. action item. >> you are back. >> deputy director for policy and programming. i have a presentation to pull up. this was a presentation that was originally given be to the board on december 15th. this item was continued at that time at the request of commissioner walton to allow for some items to be clarified as far as the commitment to affordable housing in particular as far as with the new development and the housing portion of the development. by way every minder, this is an allocation request and appropriation request so there would be $5.8 million allocated to the s.f.m.t.a. for planning and environmental phases

commissioner green. commissioner green? okay. i don't see -- let's go to commissioner chung then. can folks hear me? >> i think commissioner green was trying to say something. i think she may have been muted. >> clerk: i will try to unmute -- >> president bernal: commissioner green, you should be unmuted now. >> vice president green: everyone has said this so eloquently, i wanted to lend my voice of thanks. i know dr. baba was at the site and it wasn't lost to many that you were present interacting with the community as have other members of your team and we appreciate that you're doing that. i also was struck in this presentation, besides the incredible quality and care, it represents such notable collaboration because your community groups and you represent our key populations that are underserved and left out so often. before the meeting i kind of looked at some of the demographics and notably, it's quite a mixture of individuals. black african americans, 28%, asian, latinx at 15%. it struck me in the way you are collaborating, you're sending a great example. the community heal

seconded by commissioner dooley. >> commissioner adams. >> yes. >> commissioner dooley. >> yes. >> commissioner hule. >> yes. >> commissioner laguana. >> yes. >> commissioner ortiz-cartagena. >> yes. >> commissioner laguana. >> yes. >> 6-0 with one recused. >> great. next item, please. >> item 10. general public comment. members of the public comment on matters within the jurisdiction but not on today's calendar and suggest new agenda items for future discussion. discussion item. >> any members of the public to comment on any matter not currently on our agenda? >> there is no one in the queue at this time. >> comment is closed. next item. >> item 11. director's report. update and report on the office of small business and the small business assistance center, department programs, policy and legislative matters, announcements from the mayor announcements regarding small business activities. >> thank you, commissioners. director of the office of small business. i want to start off with director's report by congratulating mayor breed for the new position as recorder. that was very exciting today.

commissioners, i'll open it up for questions to the commissioners. john, there were parts of your presentation there that didn't come through. so i'm not sure. >> i'm sorry. >> it's not your fault. vice chair moss, do you have questions? >> vice president moss: no. >> president mccarthy: commissioner alexander-tut, do you have questions? >> commissioner alexander-tut: yes. thank you for your presentation. is the fee waiver only for new permits or is this for any fees related to existing permits for a.d.u.s? >> this would be for new construction. adus that are not legalized is separate. >> commissioner alexander-tut: any fees for existing permits for a.d.u.s or new permits for new a.d.u.s? >> i believe this is for new a.d.u.s, uh-huh. >> commissioner alexander-tut: thank you. >> president mccarthy: commissioner bito, welcome to the commission. do you have any questions, please? >> commissioner bito: not at this moment. >> president mccarthy: commissioner clinch? >> commissioner clinch: no. thanks. >> president mccarthy: commissioner jacobo. >> commiss

commissioner peskin. >> aye. >> commissioner preston. >> aye. >> commissioner ronen. >> aye. >> commissioner safai. >> aye. >> commissioner stefani. >> aye. >> commissionerrual ton. >> aye. >> we have 11 ayes. the motion passes. >> thank you. please call the next item. >> item 4. allocate $7,524,841 with conditions and appropriate $6,000 in prop k sales tax funds to 13 requests. this is an action item. >> i believe we have a report from the deputy director of policy and programming here. >> good morning. thank you for the introduction and with that i will share my screen. chair, are you able to see my presentation? >> i am. >> okay. the first request is for $1.9 million for the design phase of improvements to two muni facilities that will be upgraded in order to accept vehicles that would be relocated from potrero maintenance yard during construction. a vacant lot that is used for accepting vehicles and doing testing. this would enable the design phase to be completed and see consequences for relocating the buses when the yard goes under construction and that funding is the next item on the

commissioner adams. >> here. >> commissioner dickerson. >> here. >> commissioner dooley. >> here. >>r hule. >> here. >> commissioner laguana. >> here. >> commissioner zouzounis. >> here. >> commissioner ortiz-cartagena. >> item 2. introduction of new commissioner lawanda dickerson. >> commissioners i would like to take this moment to warmly welcome lawanda dickerson to the small business commission for her first meeting. she is the owner of u3 fit in bayview. i am thrilled to have her join us. i am ex streetly pleased to report that she is also an experienced and accomplished drummer. that is very important. commissioner dickerson, would you like to say a few words? >> i would love to. thank you so much. i want to say greetings to everyone on the commission. it is an honor to be here. i am excited to be part of this small business commission just because of the experience that i have had being a small business here in the bayview san francisco. i have had the amazing privilege and so much has been invested in me with all of the help i have received through oewd and spdc and the diffe

. >> commissioner chan. >> yes. >> commissioner diamond. >> hear. >> commissioner fung. >> here. >> commissioner imperial. >> here. >> commissioner tanner. >> here. >> thank you. first is consideration items for proposed continuance. 1. 2020-003223 c.u.a. at 249 texas street. this is to continue to march 4th, 2021. 2. case 2019-021010 c.u.a. is withdrawn. further under regular calendar item 10 case 2013.1535 at 474 o'farrell street street and 532 jones street conditional use authorization is requesting continuians to march 11, 2021. item 11. 2018-014795 at 1516 folsom street requests continuance to february 18, 2021. i have no other items for continuance. we should open this up for public comment. members of the public this is your opportunity to speak for any items proposed for continuance. press star 3. one member of the public. you have two minutes. >> good afternoon. this is ella strong, president of the executive board of church of christ scientist. cosponsors of o'farrell street street and request continuance of our item. thank you. >> thank you. >> last call for public comment on items to

commissioner green. commissioner green? okay. i don't see -- let's go to commissioner chung then. can folks hear me? >> i think commissioner green was trying to say something. i think she may have been muted. >> clerk: i will try to unmute -- >> president bernal: commissioner green, you should be unmuted now. >> vice president green: everyone has said this so eloquently, i wanted to lend my voice of thanks. i know dr. baba was at the site and it wasn't lost to many that you were present interacting with the community as have other members of your team and we appreciate that you're doing that. i also was struck in this presentation, besides the incredible quality and care, it represents such notable collaboration because your community groups and you represent our key populations that are underserved and left out so often. before the meeting i kind of looked at some of the demographics and notably, it's quite a mixture of individuals. black african americans, 28%, asian, latinx at 15%. it struck me in the way you are collaborating, you're sending a great example. the community heal

commissioner green. commissioner green? okay. i don't see -- let's go to commissioner chung then. can folks hear me? >> i think commissioner green was trying to say something. i think she may have been muted. >> clerk: i will try to unmute -- >> president bernal: commissioner green, you should be unmuted now. >> vice president green: everyone has said this so eloquently, i wanted to lend my voice of thanks. i know dr. baba was at the site and it wasn't lost to many that you were present interacting with the community as have other members of your team and we appreciate that you're doing that. i also was struck in this presentation, besides the incredible quality and care, it represents such notable collaboration because your community groups and you represent our key populations that are underserved and left out so often. before the meeting i kind of looked at some of the demographics and notably, it's quite a mixture of individuals. black african americans, 28%, asian, latinx at 15%. it struck me in the way you are collaborating, you're sending a great example. the community heal

i have a motion by commissioner elias, seconded by commissioner -- >> commissioner brookter: brookter. >> president cohen: brookter. can we take that without objection? motion passes without objection. next item. >> clerk: item 8, discussion and possible action to adopt revised department general order 1.08, community policing, meet-and-confer draft was approved by the commission on october 7, 2020, discussion and possible action. >> vice president elias: president cohen? >> president cohen: yes. >> vice president elias: i'm going to make a motion to accept this, but before let's d go to public comment. >> clerk: members of the public, at this time, this is your opportunity to make public comment on item 8. members of the public who are listening, press star, three now. good evening, caller. you have two minutes. caller, you have two minutes. >> oh, excuse me. i was trying to unmute. this is starchild again, libertarian party of san francisco. i don't see the proposed order here. i'm calling in by phone, no summary of the changes that this would make have been given, so i would just l

commissioner carr? >> approve. >> commissioner starks? >> approve. >> commissioner signington? >> approve. >> the commissioner votes aye. would any colleagues like to nation comments at this time? >> i do. >> go ahead commissioner starks. >> thank you, madame chairwoman. a new year, a new semester, which means new interns in my office. so proud to announce artay barns, our first diversity initiative intern. i'm deeply proud to announce that. it is a program that was announced last fall with a goal of creating a more diverse commission. so welcome. i also have lexi cafasso who was a intern with the public safety bureau. she joins us from catholic law school, and katie melinger, a intern from wake forest, and also jeff boxer from ucla. in addition to the telecome work he has been doing traction on how to figure out what time he is supposed to coordinate with folks across the country so thank you all for your hard work and continued efforts in my office, thank you. >> anyone else with an announcement? >> well, if not i have one of my own, before we ajourns let me get going. i want

i have a motion by commissioner elias, seconded by commissioner -- >> commissioner brookter: brookter. >> president cohen: brookter. can we take that without objection? motion passes without objection. next item. >> clerk: item 8, discussion and possible action to adopt revised department general order 1.08, community policing, meet-and-confer draft was approved by the commission on october 7, 2020, discussion and possible action. >> vice president elias: president cohen? >> president cohen: yes. >> vice president elias: i'm going to make a motion to accept this, but before let's d go to public comment. >> clerk: members of the public, at this time, this is your opportunity to make public comment on item 8. members of the public who are listening, press star, three now. good evening, caller. you have two minutes. caller, you have two minutes. >> oh, excuse me. i was trying to unmute. this is starchild again, libertarian party of san francisco. i don't see the proposed order here. i'm calling in by phone, no summary of the changes that this would make have been given, so i would just l

commissioner dejesus? >> commissioner dejesus: [indisc ernible] >> president cohen: it was hard for me to hear what you were saying. >> commissioner dejesus: what i said earlier, when we talked about -- there was a caller, second time it's been brought up, about forfeitures and seizures of property. people are asking how it works. it wouldn't hurt to have a small presentation how it works. >> president cohen: commissioner hamasaki anything from you? please continue. >> at this time the public is welcome to make public comment on line item 3. members of the public like to make public comment please call 415-655-0001. enter access code. 146 033 9858 please press star 3 now if you like to make public comment. we have a number of callers. >> president cohen: let's begin. >> good evening, caller, you have two minutes. >> hi. can you hear me? >> yes. >> i was calling concerning my son who was murdered august 14, 2006, to this day no capture of the person who murdered my son. i'm a mother who is calling every wed

>> commissioner black: yes. >> commissioner foley: yes. >> commissioner johns: yes. >> commissioner pearlman: yes. >> commissioner so: yes. >> vice president matsuda: yes. >> president hyland: yes. >> jonas: so moved, commissioners. that motion passes unanimously 7-0. item 4, commission comments and questions. okay, seeing a request -- >> president hyland: i put in a request there, did you not get it? >> i see it now. i saw it under the minutes. >> yeah. >> am i up, thank you? i wanted to make a comment and i'm going to read something about the school renaming that has been a hot topic. i'm sure many of you saw the articles in the paper about that. i wrote something out and i'll just read it into the record. i want to extend my sadness, frustration, and alittle bit of disgust to the board of education for its school renaming exercise. thinks one that takes political correctness to new highs. while there are names that shouldn't be associated with the schools of our city due to past endeavors, the shoddy way the schools were collected and the lack of intellectually measured historical researc

commissioner chung. >> commissioner chung: yeah, i just want to join, you know, all of the commissioners and echo all that have said. and i also want to personally, you know, to let you know that you have been a great teacher. at least for me personally. i have learned so much, you know, like commissioner green says, you know, like the great examples. and the other great example is really about collective impact. and i want you to know that your presentations have made such a great impression on me that i thought that it was all the work that we could do now. thinking about how we can all work and create an impact that we envision. so thank you so much for being such a great teacher and such a great -- we just have public health fun. i don't know how you do it, and listening to you, you make it fun. we'll miss you greatly and knowing that you have going to be leaving the health department for california -- you'll be still be working for the health department for california, i feel safer. thank you. >> president bernal: thank you, commissioner chung. commissioner christian. >> commissione

bittner. >> yes. >> commissioner carrington. >> yes. >> commissioner jung. >> commissioner jung. >> yes. >> commissioner lum. >> yes. >> commissioner sklar. >> yes. >> thank you. we have the vote unanimous. >> thank you so much. commissioners, item 5 is executive director's report. please begin your report. welcome. >> thank you. i just want to start off by saying to everyone happy black history month. this is an exciting month. it certainly is a time to celebrate the contributions of black african-americans in the united states, but certainly in san francisco so i hope that everybody is doing something special to honor this month. i am going to start as usual with my report by talking about the federal level with respect to the populations that we serve. i was remiss last time when i talked about the most recent stimulus package that did come out. i said it didn't have a lot for older adults. it was true. it did have money for food banks and for some programs that do help serve older adults. it didn't have anything specifically for people with disabilities. however, i forgot to say

commissioners? commissioner low? >> i actually thank commissioner mazzola had his hand up first, but i'll be happy to cut the line in front of him. >> why stop now? >> i know. kelley, can you highlight maybe the difference between turf and grass with respect to the dog park. i realize we went over this at the capital committee, but i thought it would be helpful to have other commissioners briefed on this matter, about the difference. >> absolutely, yeah. so what we -- and as i said, i have eric anderson to speak to more of the technical issues. one of the overarching stores is when you have natural turf, especially the kind of things that you see in some dog parks, heavy use, natural turf is a natural material that needs time to rest and recover, to be reseeded. it also, in the rainy months, the soil can get compacted. so for those two reasons, for the restoration and the protection of the soil and the medium in which the grass grows, we will need to close the natural turf dog play area for a certain portion of time

>>president cohen: commissioner hamaski commissioner hamasaki?>commissioner hamasaki: i want topiggyback on my fellow commissioners gratitude for the presentation . you and officers for justice have been an important organization for myself and a number of commissioners, i don't commissioner lis got to know this department and to understand the depth of the challenges that the officers for justice and its members have gone through historically. i think it's an important part of the history of this department and i'm glad the department is taking more notice and recognizing everything that's been overcome and i really appreciate osj putting together the masks. i know it's in a receiving line and i just wanted to thank people in your organization. >>yulanda williams: thank you sir. >>president cohen: thank you. commissioner. >> everyone's echoed what i want to say but i think it's so important to remind everybody where you started and where you've come from and what's still left to do. i do appreciate you coming. it's timely. i just want to thank y

chair: thank you, commissioner. commissioner stark. commissioner stark: thank you. i'm going in reverse order, and again, thank you for the presentation on mapping and that detailed update on the commission effort on broadband data and maps. and the mapping funding you mentioned congress appropriated is going to propel this mission toward significantly better data practices. for too long, the commission was aware that our broadband data was deeply flawed and was pushing forward with data practices, and we shouldn't be surprised that parties are already raising instances of mapping related problems in the face-one results. so i am focused on going forward, the commission does need to ensure quality data foundations on our-cost program. as commissioner carr mentioned, this is going to drive results in 5g mobility. now is that time for thoughtful execution. i look forward to working with you and the collaboration of the commission's talented staff with many stakeholders we have two make better broadband maps a reality. when it comes to telemedicine, i have long thought

commissioner green. commissioner green? okay. i don't see -- let's go to commissioner chung then. can folks hear me? >> i think commissioner green was trying to say something. i think she may have been muted. >> clerk: i will try to unmute -- >> president bernal: commissioner green, you should be unmuted now. >> vice president green: everyone has said this so eloquently, i wanted to lend my voice of thanks. i know dr. baba was at the site and it wasn't lost to many that you were present interacting with the community as have other members of your team and we appreciate that you're doing that. i also was struck in this presentation, besides the incredible quality and care, it represents such notable collaboration because your community groups and you represent our key populations that are underserved and left out so often. before the meeting i kind of looked at some of the demographics and notably, it's quite a mixture of individuals. black african americans, 28%, asian, latinx at 15%. it struck me in the way you are collaborating, you're sending a great example. the community heal

. >> aye. >> commissioner diamond. >> aye. >> commissioner fung. >> aye. >> commissioner imperial. >> aye. >> commissioner moore. >> aye. >> commission president koppel. >> aye. >> so moved. that passes unanimously. that places us on commission matters. 4. consideration of adoption draft minutes january 21, 2021. we should take public comment. members of the public this is your opportunity to address the minutes. no members of the public to speak public comment is closed. minutes are now before you. >> commissioner diamond. >> move to approve the minutes. >> second. >> on that motion to adopt minutes from january 21, 2021 commissioner tanner. >> aye. >> commissioner chan. >> aye. >> commissioner diamond. >> aye. >> commissioner fung. >> aye. >> commissioner imperial. >> aye. >> commissioner moore. >> aye. >> commissioner president koppel. >> aye. >> so moved that motion passes unanimously 7-0. >> item 5. commission comments and questions. okay. moving right alongying no requests to speak from commissioners. department matters. item 6. directors announcements. >> no announcements today

commissioner green. commissioner green? okay. i don't see -- let's go to commissioner chung then.? >> i think commissioner green was trying to say something. i think she may have been muted. >> clerk: i will try to unmute -- >> president bernal: commissioner green, you should be unmuted now. >> vice president green: everyone has said this so eloquently, i wanted to lend my voice of thanks. i know dr. baba was at the site and it wasn't lost to many that you were present interacting with the community as have other members of your team and we appreciate that you're doing that. i also was struck in this presentation, besides the incredible quality and care, it represents such notable collaboration because your community groups and you represent our key populations that are underserved and left out so often. before the meeting i kind of looked at some of the demographics and notably, it's quite a mixture of individuals. black african americans, 28%, asian, latinx at 15%. it struck me in the way you are collaborating, you're sending a great example. the community health centers and par

. >> commissioner harrington. >> here. >> commissioner. >> here. >> commissioner paulson will be arriving in 15 minutes. we are a quorum. >> i would like to welcome our new commissioner to our official meeting. welcome and thank you so much for your commitment. thank you. >> looking forward to working with you. >> thank you. next item, please. >> before i read the next item i would like to make a brief announcement. due to the covid-19 health machining and given the public health recommendation issued by the san francisco department of public health and governor newsom and mayor breed lifted restrictions on teleconference. this is being televised by sfgovtv. if you are watching live stream there is a brief time lag. on behalf of the commission i would like to extend our thanks to sfgovtv for assistance during this meeting. if you wish to comment on an item dial 415-655-0001. meeting id1463590630. followed by pound pound. to speak press star 3. before i call the first item i would announce that item 15 is removed from today's agenda. for those watching if you want to speak on item 15 you m

. >> commissioner chung. >> present. >> clerk: commissioner christian? >> penalty. >> clerk: commissioner chow. >> present. >> clerk: i think that's all. i don't see commissioner green. miss commissioner green. >> present. >> a quorum being present. we'll call the commission health meeting of tuesday, february 16th, 2021, to order. the next item is approval of the minutes and i understand, mark, you have a few notes about that. >> yes, first of all, commissioners. i'd like to apologize. i cut and pasted the director's report and usually a complex cut and paste. i didn't go back on a second review to correct a lot of format errors. i apologize. and i will correct that in the final. it's just simply spaces. so that doesn't really change the content. commissioner christian pointed out -- let me get -- on page 11, her comments -- and i hope i captured them, commissioner christian, if not we can do that after the meeting. but that on page 11, third paragraph down, she added a statement regarding importance to maintain precautions such as wearing masks and soc