the really. >> commissioner chan, aye. >> commissioner chen, aye. >> commissioner dorsey, aye. >> commissionerdio, aye. >> commissioner fielder, aye. >> commissioner mahmood, aye. >> chair mandelman, aye. >> vice chair melgar, aye. >> commissioner sauter, aye. >> commissioner sherrill, aye. >> commissioner walton. >> there are 11 eyes the motion is approved. >> all right. thank you madam clerk. please call our next item. >> 5. election of chair and vice chair for 2025 — action. >> all right. is i indicated earlier i'm not doing this job any more and though grateful to have the opportunity to do that i'll not be in the meantime, myself but like to offer this to nominates of chair and like to nominate our current vice chair melgar into the role of chair and fantastic partner. and over those last years. um, on and working on transportation issues and in those next couple of years will be pretty critical. year i guess this is an annual party over the next year need to do important work and the impacts of changes to the national legislation and all sort of things. i am as i said in the meantime, co

commissioner chen, aye. >> commissioner dorsey, aye. >> commissioner engardio, aye. >> commissioner, aye. >> commissioner mahmood, aye. >> chair mandelman, aye. >> commissioner dorsey, aye. >> commissioner sauter, aye. >> commissioner sherrill, aye. >> commissioner walton. >> there are 11 ayes the motion to vice chair melgar is approved. >> congratulations vice chair melgar. >> we're going to do some technical switching around. >> you let me know, which. >> okay. thank you colleagues very exciting. um, nominations are now in order for the office of vice chair. >> and i will take a moment to thank you for giving m the opportunity to do this and to nominate someone has expressed lots of interest in transportation and understand how crucial access to accessible and affordable transportation is to the climate to the equity our colleague commissioner fielder chair mandelman as segmented for commissioner sauter and i accept the nomination. >> okay. we now have to take public comment on that nomination. >> you have beautiful and now wasn't (unintelligible) recently honestly (unintelligible

the really. >> commissioner chan, aye. >> commissioner chen, aye. >> commissioner dorsey, aye. >> commissionerye. >> vice chair melgar, aye. >> commissioner sauter, aye. >> commissioner sherrill, aye. >> commissioner walton. >> there are 11 eyes the motion is approved. >> all right. thank you madam clerk. please call our next item. >> 5. election of chair and vice chair for 2025 — action. >> all right. is i indicated earlier i'm not doing this job any more and though grateful to have the opportunity to do that i'll not be in the meantime, myself but like to offer this to nominates of chair and like to nominate our current vice chair melgar into the role of chair and fantastic partner. and over those last years. um, on and working on transportation issues and in those next couple of years will be pretty critical. year i guess this is an annual party over the next year need to do important work and the impacts of changes to the national legislation and all sort of things. i am as i said in the meantime, commissioner dorsey is there a second? >> seconded by commissioner sherrill and vice chair me

good morning, commissioner one to young present commissioner martha knudsen present commissioner barbara sklar is excused and commissioner linda parker pennington present and us executive director kelly deering present. thank you president spears. we have a quorum. commissioners the next item is item three communications. we'd like to provide further instructions for the public comment process. public comment will be available on each item on this agenda and during general public comment. both channel 78 and s.f. gov tv dot org are streaming the number across the screen. each speaker will be allowed three minutes to speak comments or opportunity to speak during the public comment period are available via phone call. turn each public pub public comment period. viewers and callers will be instructed to call 14156550001 access code 26604 18597 3 pound and then pound again. when connected you'll hear the meeting discussions but you'll be muted and in listening mode only when your item of interest comes up. dial star three to be added to the speaker line. best practices are to call from a qui

. >> commissioner beltran >> present. >> commissioner benadides. >> present. >> commissioner carney. >> present. >> commissioner ferras. >> here >> commissioner hakimi. >> aye >> commissioner lu. >> present. >> commissioner rothschild. >> present. >> commissioner schnair. >> here >> commissioner shelby. >> heir >> commissioner walker. >> here. >> we have quorum. also for the record director of cultural affairs raffle remington, finance and administration sarah holenback are in attendance. president collins. do we have agenda changes in >> no changes. now for public meeting instructions. welcome all interested to attends in person at city all room 416. this meeting is arias live on sfgovtv 2 and at&t u verse 99. i want to reminds us of the policies and procedures for public meetings. at this meeting, we're bounds to follow the structure of our agenda and to adhere to the best practice set out in the good government guide. every public meeting there will be an opportunity for general public comment more members of the public comment on any item pertaining to this body. public comment w

commissioner campbell high commissioner mcgarry mr. williams i have commissioner braun i commissioner moore and commission president so i some of commissioners that motion passes unanimously 6 to 0 placing us on commission matters. item five the land acknowledgment the commission acknowledges that we are on the unceded ancestral homeland of the remington aloni who are the original inhabitants of the san francisco peninsula as the indigenous stewards of this land and in accordance with their traditions the roma to colony have never ceded lost nor forgotten their responsibilities as the caretakers of this place as well as for all peoples who reside in their traditional territory as guests we recognize that we benefit from living and working on their traditional homeland. we wish to pay our respects by acknowledging the ancestors, elders and relatives of the roma to colony community and by affirming their sovereign rights as first peoples. >> thank you. >> item six commission comments and questions if there are no comments or questions fr

call the roll. >> on item 2 commissioner chan. >> aye. >> commissioner sevier. >> aye. >> commissioner williamsch >> aye. >> there are three aye's >> thank you without objection they are arkansas appointment of khalid samerrae for local information. >> as this commission knows the end of left year our executive officer jirmy pollock resigned this commission watched his dedicated service the city has not since he was moved department of technology. but that upon means we must begin the process to find his replacement not guilty interim propose our policy analyst scammid samerrae be acting executive officer. we have the lafco legal council available to walk us through questions from commissioners. and -- seeing any can i open up for questions for, any questions. >> great. go ahead. >> thank you, chair williams. and i want to first thank i did not get a chance to thank our executive officer pollock for his work with lafco. it is good to see he remains in government and take this opportunity to thank mr. samerrae for his on going contribution as for all the work he has done and pleased see

. >> vice president i say here commissioner jammed are here commissioner level running here you have a quorum. >> thank you. before calling the first item i'd like to announce that the san francisco public utilities commission acknowledges that it owns and are stewards of the unceded lands located within the ethno historic territory of the mckenna aloni tribe and other familiar descendants of the historic federally recognize mission san jose verona band of alameda county. the puc also recognizes that every citizen residing within the greater bay area has and continues to benefit from the use and occupation of the work. maloney tribes aboriginal lands since before and after the san francisco public utilities founding in 1932. it is vitally important that we not only recognize the history of the tribal lands on which we reside but also that we acknowledge and honor the fact that the work maloney people have established a working relationship with the sfp ce and our productive and flourishing members within the many greater san francisco bay area communities today. please call the first

commissioner davis i. commissioner perez i. commissioner lander. all right. commissioner thomas i. all right. >> the consent calendar has been approved. if the applicant who is raising their hand has something important to say, just follow up with our staff and they will communicate with us in the future. >> now we can move on to the regular agenda. i believe. oh, i'm in the wrong place here . who's introducing this? whoever is introducing can vote. >> and president blake, i'm going to read the first item. thank you. i hear you already. >> okay. wait. i didn't get to see your new title projects and communication manager rice. >> i want to thank you. >> thank you, president blackmon. good evening, commissioners. the first item on the regular agenda is a one time outdoor event permit with extended duration for m.k. ji productions google pixel house activation located at the parking lot at 667 howard street. from february 13th through the 16th mhclg is organizing this on behalf of google during nba all-star week. the activation will include a basketball court featuring live music on s

commissioner chan chan. i commissioner chin chin. i commissioner darcy darcy i. commissioner and gaudio and gaudio i. commissioner fielder. fielder i. commissioner mahmood mahmud i. commissioner randleman. randleman absent. chair melgar i. melgar i vice chair sadr sadr i . commissioner cheryl cheryl i. commissioner walton walton i there are ten eyes the motion is approved. >> thank you so much madam clerk let's go to item number three place item three community advisory committee report this is an information item. >> okay. we have chair kat siegel, cac chair to give the cac director's report. >> hi. good morning. chair melgar vice chair sauder and commissioners. at our january meeting the cac voted to support the proposal allocations for five requests. you'll also be considering today the 2025 2026 transportation fund for clean air local expenditure criteria and the state and federal advocacy program. on the latter item members reiterated concerns from several previous meetings about the difficulty in getting safety data reporting from autonomous vehicles. we al

commissioner mcgarry police commissioner williams i. commissioner braun i. commissioner imperial i.missioner moore. >> hi. and commissioner so i grant those items are continued items one, two, three and six. >> commissioners we'll move on to our next item on our agenda the consent calendar. all matters listed here consent constitute a consent calendar and are considered to be routine by the planning commission and may be acted upon by a single whirlpool. >> single roll call vote. there will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of the commission, the public or staff so requests in which case the matter shall be removed from the consent calendar and considered as a separate item at this or a future hearing. currently on your consent calendar we have the following items. item number four three grant avenue request for an office allocation. >> item 516 beer sheet conditional use authorized session and item 725 25 phelps avenue conditional use authorization. at this time we will take public comment on the consent calendar. if any member of the public would like to rem

commissioner hunter i. commissioner tompkins i. commissioner u.n. is excused. >> the motion passes the next item please. >> the next item is item four general public comment. members of the public may address the commission on matters that are within the commission's jurisdiction and are not already on today's agenda. >> are there any members of the public who wish to comment on this item? only? madam president, we have no speakers. >> all right. public comment is now closed. next item please. next item is item five nomination and election of the commission on the environment president and vice president. >> this item is for discussion and possible action. >> three hours. could you please provide a summary of the process for commission elections? >> yes we will begin with the presidency and we will accept nominations for this position only following nominations and discussion there will be public comment and a vote. we will then repeat the process for the position of vice president including nominations, discussion public comment and a vote commissi

commissioner baldauf, your commissioner vergara you're commissioner right here. >> commissioner foley vice president no sworn is expected to be absent and commission president matsuda here. great. we have five members of the commission here. >> we will move on to our general public comment at this time. members of the public may address the commission on items of interest to the public that are within the subject matter jurisdiction of the commission except for agenda items with respect to agenda items your opportunity to address the commission will be afforded when the item is reached. >> each member of the public may address the commission for up to three minutes. okay. any members of the public please come to the desk. you may 2nd. yeah i'm just trying to figure out how. >> there we go. gotcha. commissioners, can you hear me? >> here we go. good afternoon. i'm catherine petrone and i'm here to talk for just a couple of minutes about what the implications of historic district designation really are in this rather charged moment when we are dealing with so much misinformation. >> i w

commissioner hickey me here commissioner snare here and commissioner walker. you're a commissioner lou and you certainly are absent. for the record we have quorum today for today's meeting and also for the record the following staff ralph remington, evan glenn and mary chu are in attendance. >> thanks so much craig. i'd like to ask for any changes to the agenda. we do have item for the 2025 art on market street poster series has been tabled and with that i'd like to begin the meeting. i'd like to welcome all persons interested in this meeting to attend in person at one dr. carlton be good place room 416416 this meeting is being streamed on s.f. gov while this test technology grants us better accessibility for individuals listening to the meeting remotely, please be mindful that tech related difficulties may occur which could contribute to gaps and delays as staff transition the technology please know that we are doing our best and ask for your patience. >> i want to remind us of the policies and procedures for public meetings at this meeting we are bound to fo

benedicto is yes commissioners yes commissioners is yes. >> commissioner. vice president carter i was done. yes i was. carter was on is yes you have four yeses line item ten discussion and possible action to approve department general order 5.13 diplomatic immunity for the department to use a meeting and conferring with the affected bargaining units as required by law discussion and possible action. good evening. >> um vice president carter oberstar and commissioners chief scott. director hanson. good evening i'm lieutenant bass you but i currently serve as the officer in charge of the special investigations division . in that position in that capacity i'm the liaison between the state department and the various consulates and not really embassies but consulates that we have here in san francisco of which there are 38. i took over as the subject matter expert for this diego from my predecessor lieutenant david o'connor who along with the policy development unit and manager steve's did the lion's share of the work. i'm just here to get it over the finish lin

commissioners, questions or comments? commissioner leveroni? >> look the the i believe wd2897, looks like that contract award was 234782? and the original estimate was thought it would come in 183? >> yes. >> so then, and that was a resolution i'm not sure how to intercept 24 -- 0111. >> the resolution number. that for the award. for the award. >> yes. >> okay. that was awarded may 14 of 24. >> correct. >> okay. >> now i'm understanding that. and now look at pro0120, the current aim for what i'm looking at there was 15 million? >> correct. >> and looks like we -- added two items. and increased the -- ozonation from one. 8 to 7.7? and what did we what happened there? was it just -- the original price was not taken in what was needed to bring ozone down? correct. the remember the time advertisement for the contract, the estimate was low are than that the construction contract was award for. joof that's time we had information at the time of taegz we had the information we had and based our estimateos that number. >> okay. commissioner leveroni th

. >> commissioner carney. >> present. >> commissioner ferris. >> here. >> commissioner hikimi. >> commissioner rothschild. >> present. >> commissioner schnair. we have quorum. raffle remington and programs even glen. finance and administration sarah hol korenbeck and chief of staff are in attendance. thank you very much. there are agenda changes. >> no. >> for public meeting instructions. welcome all persons interested in this meeting to attend in person at city hall room 416. this meeting is airing live on sfgovtv. and at&t u verse 99. i want to reminds us of the policies and procedures for public meetings. at this meeting, we are bound to facility structure of our agenda and adhere to the best practices in the good government guide. >> every public meeting there will be an opportunity for general comment members comment on an item pertaining to the body. opinion comment taken in person. with remote access provide for those require an ad a accommodation. we ask you keep your comment in on topic. each public comment is limited to 3 minutes. understand that the commission does not contribute di

commissioner kim. >> commissioner lindo. yes. and president joyce i so moved our action items listed under item ten a first is item ten a which is a resolution approving housing choice voucher administrative plan policy amendments and sections four dash two c opening and closing the wait list for dash 3c2c rad slash pbb site based waiting list for dash three c2d for project base vouchers site based waiting list and exhibit 4-1 for definitions and exhibit 4-3 for site based wait list and this will be presented by linda mason, our general counsel. >> thank you. okay. thank you commissioners. good afternoon. this particular item came to us as a as an initial conversation with our partners at the mayor's office of housing community development oci and mercy because two buildings that for the interest of time i'll leave their descriptions within the staff reports but in particular 607th street and the hunters point shipyard block 56 building will be coming online shortly. these two buildings already had waitlists openings and they are

can you call roll. >> on item 3 commissioner chan. >> aye. >> commissioner sevier. >> aye. >> commissioner williams. >> aye. >> there are three aye's >> thank you. so without objection khalid samerrae is appointing as acting executive officer. >> can you call item 4? item 4 is a chair person's report including update on the final study for the mid town park apartments. >> colleagues, our agenda states we are due for an update on the mid town park apartments final study. however we only just received a response letter from the mayor's office of housing and community development. in order to give us an opportunity to review the letter i like to propose we continue this to the call of the chair and we will likely hear this at our mechanic meeting on march 21st. khalid do you have anything to add >> i'm working with consultants to do a full presentation on the final study. and then seth up a meeting with residents to debrief them. and the consultants wish to draft a response to the letter alcohol be on our agenda for march 21. >> colleagues, comments or questions? okay. i -- might have one. wh

commissioner benitez. commissioner cornett. present. commissioner dickerson. present.missioner herbert is absent. president. he here? commissioner he's cartagena is absent. vice presidencies in us present. president you have a quorum. >> thank you. >> the san francisco small business commission and office of small business staff acknowledges that we are on the unceded ancestral homeland of the promoters aloni who are the original inhabitants of the san francisco peninsula as indigenous stewards of this land and in accordance with their traditions. the dramaturge aloni i have never ceded lost nor forgotten their responsibilities as the caretakers of this place as well as for all peoples who reside in their traditional territory. as guests we recognize that we benefit from living and working on their traditional homeland. we wish to pay our respects by acknowledging the ancestors elders and relatives of the armitage's aloni community and by affirming their sovereign rights as first peoples. >> please call item two item two approval of legacy business registry application

commissioner lim no. commissioner lim votes no. commissioner brackett no. commissioner brackett says no. vice chair aquino yes and chair scott i. >> madam chair. the vote is two yeses two no. this motion does not pass. thank you. >> please call the next item. we're still in the comments for commissioners and for this item we're still an item for a. and we're we closed public comment so it's commission questions and comments. fellow commissioners. >> yes. i have some questions. >> deputy slutsky yesterday i attended a board meeting with the board of supervisors and at that meeting we had planning officials as well as our office of economic and workforce development officials who basically made a blanket statement stating that oci had gotten rid of all of our property that was more than 20 years old as a result of dissolution 2012. so i would like for you to briefly explain to the public how we were able to keep cfd one still under our care and control and monitoring that and maintaining that property to this day since it has been in our port portfolio since

commissioner clay resident commissioner benedicto commissioner yanez president commissioner ye hear vice president carter i was told you have a quorum present alliance is in route. also with us tonight we have chief scott from the san francisco police department and executive director paul henderson from the department of police accountability. one item for tonight are two items for tonight line item number 12 is going to be moved up after line item one and under consent calendar the donation of funds from the community foundation for the community police academy has been removed from the agenda for tonight. line item one weekly officer recognition certificate presentation of an officer who has gone above and beyond in the performance of their duties officer christina star roster number 2154 terryville station good evening commissioner chief distinguished visitors distinguished guests also the family of christina cicero her two sons and sister and friends and colleague from the concord police department. my name is captain bryan who i'm the commanding officer terryville station today we

commissioner jonas is yes commissioner ye yes commissioner yes. yes. and vice president carter stone yes i was present carter always jonas yes. and president elias? yes. present licenses? yes. you have six yeses lean on him for chief support discussion weekly crime trends and public safety concerns provide an overview of offenses, incidents or events occurring in san francisco having an impact on the public safety commission discussion of unplanned events and activities the chief describes will be limited to determining whether the calendar for a future meeting. >> chief scott thank you sergeant youngblood. >> good evening president elias vice president carter over stone commission executive director henderson and the public starting off of crime trends and the chiefs report this week overall there is a 36% reduction in part one crime year to date so it's a good start after a really good year last year. but just to break it down briefly. total violent crimes are down 14%. total property crimes are down 39% in terms of violent crimes homicides we had on

commissioner campbell. commissioner gary i. commissioner braun. i. commissioner imperiale. i.missioner moore. i am commission president so i. so move commissioners that motion passes unanimously 6 to 0 and will place us under your consent calendar all matters listed here under constitute a consent calendar are considered to be routine by the planning commission and may be acted upon by a single roll call vote. there will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of the commission, the public or staff so requests in which event the matter shall be removed from the consent calendar and considered as a separate item at this or any future hearing. item four case number 2024 hyphen 0072928 2900 alimony boulevard conditional use authorization in item five for case number 2024 hyphen 009436 way at 1210 ninth avenue conditional use authorization. again members of the public this is your opportunity to address the commission and request that either of these two consent calendar items be pulled off and heard today or a later date. last call for public comment. seeing none

commissioner chan chan. i commissioner chin chin. i commissioner darcy darcy i. commissioner and gaudio and gaudio i. commissioner fielder. fielder i. commissioner mahmood mahmud i. commissioner randleman. randleman absent. chair melgar i. melgar i vice chair sadr sadr i . commissioner cheryl cheryl i. commissioner walton walton i there are ten eyes the motion is approved. >> thank you so much madam clerk let's go to item number three place item three community advisory committee report this is an information item. >> okay. we have chair kat siegel, cac chair to give the cac director's report. >> hi. good morning. chair melgar vice chair sauder and commissioners. at our january meeting the cac voted to support the proposal allocations for five requests. you'll also be considering today the 2025 2026 transportation fund for clean air local expenditure criteria and the state and federal advocacy program. on the latter item members reiterated concerns from several previous meetings about the difficulty in getting safety data reporting from autonomous vehicles. we al

commissioner jam da. hi. >> commissioner ferrone. the item passes. thank you. >> please read the next item. item four general public comment. members of the public may address the commission on matters that are within the commission's jurisdiction and are not on today's agenda. and i'd like to note as i do every meeting that the commission values civic engagement and encourages respectful communication at the public meeting. we ask that all public comment be made in a civil and courteous manner and that you refrain from the use of profanity. thank you. remote callers please raise your hand if you wish to provide general public comment. are there any members of the public present who wish to provide comment? if so, please approach the podium seeing none. >> moderator are there any callers with their hand raised ? >> ms. linear there are no callers that wish to be recognized. thank you. >> please call the next item. item five is report of the general manager. >> thank you ms.. lynn. madam president, nothing to report in the general manager report other

benedicto is yes commissioners yes commissioners is yes. >> commissioner. vice president carter i was done. yes i was. carter was on is yes you have four yeses line item ten discussion and possible action to approve department general order 5.13 diplomatic immunity for the department to use a meeting

commissioner florus feng here. commissioner salahi here. commissioner. so are your staff in love with the former? yeah. with former members present and accounted for you have a quorum. >> thank you. that i call agenda item number two. general public comment. does anyone in the room wish to make general public comment? >> seeing none. mr. clarke, will you check if there are any remote callers please? >> chair felt that we were checking to see if there are callers in the queue. chair live there are no callers in the queue. >> thank you. hearing no further members of the public wishing to speak. general public comment on item two is now closed. i now call the consent calendar . >> colleagues as noted in the agenda unless one of us wants to discuss an item on the consent calendar or a member of the public wants to. we will not discuss them separately anyway. >> i'm sorry. go ahead. commissioner, i can say there's nothing that i want to add substantively but i did just want to offer a welcome to everybody who we recently hired and also thank everybody whose p

commissioner guggenheim. >> hee >> commissioner guillermo. >> here >> commissioner christian. >> present. >> commissioner giraudo. >> present >> [ramaytush ohlone land acknowledgment] >> thank you. next is the approval of the minutes of the health commission meeting of january 13. commissioners you have buffer the minutes are there additions or corrections? >> commissioner guillermo, notified me i made an error and included her as present when she was not in town. i will correct that. >> and given this correction, is there a motion to approve the minutes? >> a motion. >> is well a second >> is there public comment? >> any public comment on the minutes? >> a.m. all in favor say, aye. >> aye. >> excellent. thank you. the next item is general public comment. and morewitz will read a statement before we entertain the comment. >> for each agenda item members will have an opportunity to make comment for up to throw minutes the press is designed to have input from individuals in the community. process does in the allowed questions to be answered or back and forth conversation with commissioners

commissioner in chicago. commissioner morgan. commissioner lowe. secretary marquis allen. members of the command staff and other guests. welcome. first of all, we'd like to welcome our new commissioner. commissioner lowe, welcome. we really look forward to collaborating with you and working with you on this commission. sincere welcome and also congratulations to president frazier and the vice president collins. your appointment as officers of this commission again we look forward to working with you going forward. this is my report for february 12th, 2025. chief of department dean matthew chrisman. i think this would be a good opportunity for me to express our shared vision of our command staff that we've assembled over the last several weeks. so first and foremost the most paramount issue for us is safety of our members. so you will see that every decision that we make in our department has that as our first priority. so whether it is equipment purchasing training, any actions that we take and any decisions we make we'll have our firefighters, paramedics and emts. safety