of anyone's tax returns anytime. then donald trump appeal that ruling to the circuit court of appeals which eventually ruled the same way, after reading that very same law, that donald trump appeal that ruling to the u.s. supreme court. all of the, even moving at a slow pace could have taken only nine months or less, but the trump judge trevor mcfadden made sure in-person, made sure that it took two years, and so, chairman of the house means committee richard neil will have donald trump's tax returns any day now. he should have had them three years ago. the chairman of the means committee has a legal right to make those tax or turns public because republicans will be taking control of the house way means committee in january, richard neil will no longer be chairman then and then we'll have no control over trump's tax returns. there's no need for chairman neal to make a rushed decision now about what to do with donald trump's tax returns because the chairman of the senate finance committee, which is the senate's tax rate committee has exactly the same authority as the chairman of the house means committee, the tax rev

in criminal cases, today we will tell you about the trio of judges of the northern commercial court of appeal, but first before the news , bohdan lviv, suspended from the post of judge due to the presence of russian citizenship, is trying to appeal this decision in the district administrative court of kyiv, and more in the lawsuit. he demands not only renewal in the position of a judge of the cassation commercial court, but to collect in his favor the amount of the average monthly salary during the period of forced absenteeism, the district administrative court kyiv, to which lviv appealed with a lawsuit, is known for questionable decisions in particular in favor of russia, so according to experts, the probability that the court will again play along with the aggressor country is very high, meanwhile, the petition to deprive bohdan lviv of ukrainian citizenship has gathered the required number of signatures and was considered by president volodymyr zelenskyi he instructed the citizenship commission to check the existence of grounds for depriving the judge of his citizenship, so in the near fu

he has been working as a judge since 2005, first of the lyubeshiv district court, and in 2010 yanukovych appointed him as a judge of the court of appealsktor gaponchuk is known for his ambiguous decisions , for example, in 2017 he released his colleague from punishment the judge of the lutsk district court, andriy sivchuk , convicted him of driving under the influence of alcohol ; the court deprived the judge of his driver's license for a year and imposed a fine of uah 10,000 and viktor gaponchuk annulled this decision due to an alleged procedural violation of an administrative offense against investigator andrii yevhenovich , holding him to account under the second part of article 123 of the code of administrative law, he used an administrative offense against the persons of the officer andrii yevgenovich , of bringing him to responsibility under the first part of article 130 of the code of administrative offenses administrative law violations with the participation of gaponchuk significantly reduced the sentence of volodymyr migas, who in 2016 drunkenly hit a 16-year-old lyceum student as a result of a road accident, the schoolboy re

only one with the constitutional authority to grant permission to detain a judge in the volyn court of appealthe new and old chairman was re-elected to this position, viktor gaponchuk . of the volyn region court of appeal, viktor gaponchuk is known for his ambiguous decisions , for example, in 2017, he freed from punishment his colleague, the judge of the lutsk district court, andriy sivchuk was convicted of driving under the influence of alcohol , the court deprived the judge of his driver's license for a year and imposed a fine of uah 10,000 , and victor gaponchuk canceled this decision due to an alleged procedural violation for three lifeguard administrative offenses against the investigator andriy yevhenovich, about bringing him to justice under the second part article 123 of the criminal code of ukraine, close the proceedings of the administrative offense case against andriy ivanovych sivchuk on prosecution under the first part article 130 of the code of administrative offenses of 2018, with the participation of gaponchuk, colleagues of the judges significantly reduced the sentence of vo

he has been a judge since 2005, first of the lyubeshiv district court, and in 2010, yanukovych appointed him as a judge of the court of appealf the volyn region, viktor gaponchuk is known for his ambiguous decisions , for example, in 2017 he released his colleague, the judge of the lutsk district court andrii sipychuk, from punishment, he was convicted of driving under the influence of alcohol and in this decision, due to an alleged procedural violation for three rescue cases, an administrative offense against the investigator andrii yevhenovich, about bringing him to justice under the second part of article 123 of the criminal code of ukraine , to close the proceedings of an administrative offense against the sivchuk, andriy ivanovich, about bringing him to justice under the first part of the article 130 of the code of administrative offenses of 2018 , colleagues of the judges with the participation of gaponchuk significantly reduced the sentence of volodymyr migas, who in 2016 in 2016, a drunk driver hit a 16-year-old lyceum student as a result of a traffic accident. the schoolboy was seriously injured. the driver tried to

city of 19000000 people, schools are also being shot across bay. jing south africa's court of appeals says the release of former president jacob zoom from prison was unlawful. one has yet to rule on whether he'll go back to jail. soon received a 15 month sentence for refusing to testify before corruption inquiry. he was released on medical parole officer serving only 2 months july tends to with this spare a star studied opening ceremony on should in the 1st fi for world cup in the middle east. but house katara couldn't keep the magic alive on the pitch. i went down to nail to i could or in the 1st game sound been divided reports. the 10 a symbol of a culture. mm hm. it got artist, music, color and applause. okay. the weight is over for one of the sporting world's most anticipated championships. a football cups opening ceremony watched by thousands and millions of people across the globe. i heard something, not just music. oh, the 1st wall cup of the post code 19 era. the 1st in the middle east, the 1st posted by emerson country, oh, the traditionally popular sport. not just united nat

and basically we were the court of appeals. we did not make it to the state supreme court. the odds are incredibly against us. gift of four justices agreed to take your case. at least for have to go over every aspect of your case and make sure it's worth their time and effort to take this case to court. and we got that. >> what was it like when you found out you're going to the supreme court? what were you feeling? >> that was one of the craziest days of my life. there is that website called scotus a log. it stands for supreme court. and you could follow along any case you want to you and you are looking at. i followed my case for months coming up to was relisted which means they had in front of them, they talked about it let's put it off let's put it off. so i knew it was being practiced or talked about every week. it was drawing to the end of a court session where they break for the summer. it was the last week of the court. i was watching my computer and i had it turned on. hoping to get a decision whether we were denied or whether it had been granted. master piece of cak

court or any large thing. it was kind of a standalone case. basically we were coming from a court of appeals so we did make it to the state supreme court but the odds event are incredibly against us. you have to four justices agreed to takeag your case so that l four of the four have to go over every aspect of the case and make sure it is worth the time come worth the effort, the energy they would take to take this case to court. and we got the. >> what was it like when you found out that you're going to the supreme court? what were you feeling? >> that was one of the craziest base of my life. there's a website called scotusblog and scotus den for supreme court of the u.s. and is a website you can follow any case that you want to that they're looking at. i followed by case for months as it was relisted, which means that they had it in front of them, they talked about it, let's put often next week, let's put it off, let's put off. so i knew it was being conferenced or talked about every week. and it was a drawing to the end of the court session with a break for the summer, the last week of th

but _ court of appeal. i am very upset not to win again. but i _ court of appeal. ep on fighting, because we have already informed and changed the full�*s opinions about the law. i am very upset that babies with down syndrome can be aborted up until birth. this tells me that i am not valued as much as someone without down syndrome. this says my feelings don't matter. that makes me feel like i am not as valuable as a person. now many people know about the law thanks to others. and your amazing support. we want to thank everyone who has donated their time and money to our court case. we face discrimination in schools, the workplace, and thanks to this verdict, thejudges have upheld discrimination in the womb as well. it is downright discrimination, and when wilberforce wanted to abolish the slave trade, he did not give up, he had his eyes on the prize. they law was made in 1967 when we were not even allowed to go to school, because of our extra chromosome, so i think it is time that the judges move with the times. people should stop seeing us as a problem, and the lis

civil rights commission, which is a panel of seven gubernatorial appointees, they ruled against you, right, and then you chose to appeal to the colorado court of appeals. >> right. >> what was the crux of your appeal? >> the same thing, the state was forcing me through the arm of the civil rights commission to create cobs that went against my -- create cakes that went against my conscience, so we were asking the court of appeals to reverse that decision and allow me to obey my conscience and create cakes that are in line with that. >> in the book, you talk about, there was this kind of -- there's a double-standard because there was another denver bakery who did something almost identical to what you did. but they did not -- they were not persecuted in any way. can you tell us why that happened, what that was about? >> yeah. there was a gentleman here in denver who went to at least three different bakeries and asked them to create cakes that were shaped like a bible with a message on there, like a red circle with the x through it of two men getting married, and it was a message on a cake that said homosexual marriage is wrong. so he asked th

now, the supreme court of appeal has also said that it is an up to the court, specifically whether the time that he spent out of prison on this medical bro, if whether or not that would count towards the server, the prison sentences, or you should have served 15 months, but instead it would be up to the current commissioner and that he is empowered by law to do so. the commissioner might take that period into account in determining any application or grounds for release. he was supposed to serve 15 months. as you mentioned that he was released after just 2 months and so he served the remainder of that sentence, not under house arrest, but at his home under correctional services supervision. and that's one of the arguments that his lawyers have put forward, that he is ill. that he is 80 years old is too old to be in prison. and that should be taken into account. but now it's up to the commissioner to decide if in fact that is the case. but essentially, the supreme court of appeal has said that ruling, although that medical parole allowance was illegal and he should return to prison. and

that is what the court of appeals said those rulings now stand. so the next step is to appeal to the state supreme court. >> that sounds like a reeducation camp so you talk about this before but the government was ordering you to violate your conscience. was there ever a moment where you were wavering and wondering if you should just give in and do what they said? >> i would close the cake shop down but the question why is how far could be go? i learned the colorado state supreme court have discretion in the cases that they take and then my case was declined and thought it was over there is only one option left and that is to appeal to the united states supreme court. we were willing to do that but what they hear our case? that was the question. host: they were willing to hear your case and tell us the odds of the us supreme court to hear your case. >> the odds are extremely small you will be heard they are petitioned with between eight and 10000 cases every year the only grant between 70 or 80 and it has to be to circuit if they ruled differently

he nominated franklin roosevelt to the court of appeals. it was seen to this day and accurately so the second most important federal court in the united states. and then world war ii breaks out, franklin roosevelt says i need you. frankly vincent is here to get off the bench and participate more actively in the war effort. world war i america's involvement when the war ended just as vincent had finished basic training. he felt like he had missed out or world war i. so we wanted to contribute now in his later years in world war ii and a more direct manner. so he left his lifetime appointment with tenure in the pension and everything that comes with it agreed to become a cabinet member for franklin roosevelt hopscotch two different jobs. they stopped holding confirmation hearings for did stop holding votes for vincent. the white house but that nomination shoot down an office of emergency management. nominate for treasury secretary gets the most votes. they all knew him, they had voted on him so many times and said this is a matter of course fo

court of appeals function of the state level trial and appellate courts within the unique justice system here in the nation's capital. both courts are responsible for large volumes of cases each year, on the national center for state courts report that you see superior court files approximately 83,000 new cases across five divisions each year. one of the highest per capita rates in the entire country. despite this enormous caseload, both courts are suffering from expensive jet to vacancies which have delayed resources for parties before the court, and house increased the workload for judges. if confirmed, you're not only take on these case loads but determined matters that impact the freedom, livelihoods, and families of many people who will come for you. today's hearing is an import opportunity for this committee to learn more about qualifications and how you plan to serve. so one of each of you as well as your family members who are joining you here today, i thank you very willingness to serve. we look forward to hearing from all of you today. the acting ranking member james lankford,

so this is one of the questions at hand at the moment is whether or not he will go to the constitutional court. and also what wasn't clear in the judgement by the supreme court of appeal was a timeline. so i had an al jazeera, the beautiful game begins, that could all takes the 1st when of the world comp over host cutoff. ah, anticipation is rising. and so with most of my cattle anyways. hello, we got some rather wet weather coming into central parts of for china at the moment you see how the brighter cloud that started to filters wireless with the cloud is at its thickest weather systems. trying to pull away from the or eastern side of the reach of just pulling out into the open waters of the north west pacific. as that where to where we're coming across central parts of china. some live the showers longest spells of rain there to clean to south korea. don't think to paddle fare too badly as we go on through where she is davis and where to weather coming back in. he was to go on 3 wetness day over the high ground. there will be some snow over the mountain strife guys, by this stage across the korean peninsula, central northern parts of china looking a little dry, but

if the department of justice wins this one and the circuit court of appeals decides to get rid of theasically judge dearie would just go about his business and give up everything and give everything back to the special counsel, which would be a loss for the trump legal team. arthel. >> arthel: watching it closely, david spunt, thank you. >> gillian: look at this, nasa scientists are looking at what caused 47 excrutiating minutes, decades of work and half a trillion were lost in space. what happened was nasa lost contact with its spacecraft on wednesday close to an hour. >> arthel: no astronauts were on board, but the reusable orion capsule is designed to one day take americans back to the moon. engineers are trying to figure out why they lost contact for such a long period. but the good news is they got it back online. >> gillian: and better news, unexpected surprise, it beamed back amazing images of the moon's surface, you are looking at one right there. a level of detail astronauts say they have rarely seen before. the pictures are coming out, dividing the internet. many on social m

the field of justice continued to be discussed at a meeting with the chairman of the supreme court of appeal of turkey on combating information crime and corruption environmental crimes. e domestic violence crimes against minor children, as well as the involvement of minor youth in the economic activities of realism. still, turkey, russia - these are two countries that are connected by test relationships in terms of economic policy, culture, we attach. the significance of your visit i would like to say that we have taken steps to develop relations in politics and economy. and now, in the judiciary, a separate important issue is the exchange of experience of russian experts ready to share consciousnesses. we have a common desire to jointly effectively counter today's challenges and threats. today. i was convinced how close our common approaches are. eh, the future turkish prosecutor and judge have already read the development of joint decisions on combating transnational crime during this visit to the academy of justice and are ready to expand it to a full-fledged course. a separate point of

the supreme court of appeal has made it clear that former prisoner jacob zoom was released on medical parole was unlawful. there remains a number of questions around exactly what happens next. the supreme court has also said that while it has said to that medical parole is unlawful, it is up to correctional services. the commissioner specifically to determine whether or not the time that the former president spent out of prison on that medical role count towards he sentence. so it's not clear whether not the former president will immediately return to prison. and also they all chances that he does have a number of a legal options on hand in terms of trying to challenge that latest judgment, that latest order by the supreme court of appeal one option is that he may be able to go to the constitutional court and if that's the case, he would have up to 2 months potentially, to try and challenge that. our latest judgment a, by the courts indic him back to prison. not one of the issues that is concerning is that when he was released from prison on medical parole, it was a by the former comm

of canyon troops is going to make a difference. a top south african court says medical parole granted to former president jacob zoom was unlawful, irrational, and unconstitutional. the supreme court of appeal is yet to rule and whether he'll return to prison. last year, zima was sentenced to 15 months for refusing to testify before corruption inquiry but was released on parole after just 2 months. for me, the miller has more from johannesburg. the supreme court of appeal has made it clear that former prisoner jacob zoom was released on medical parole was unlawful. there remains a number of questions around exactly what happens next. the supreme court has also said that while it has said to that to medical parole is unlawful, it is up to correctional services. the commission is specifically to determine whether or not the time that the former president spent out of prison on that medical role count towards he sentence. so it's not clear whether not the former president will immediately return to prison. and also they all chances that he does have a number of a legal options on hand in terms of trying to challenge that latest judgment, that latest order by the supreme court of appeal one opt

our correspondent robin brant is at the court of appeal and has the latest. r. she's 27, she's married, she has down's syndrome and so does her husband and she challenged the government, the department of health, on the basis that the 1967 abortion law which legislates for abortion in england and scotland and wales, she says it is discriminatory. she says it stigmatises people like her and their place in society. now, she has brought this appeal. initially, it was overturned by the high court but she found herself here today at the court of appeal asking three appealjudges to make a further ruling on that, and at the heart of it is the european convention on human rights and the subsequent human rights act, and section 8 of that, which is the right to a private life — both that of heidi and that of women who become pregnant and heidi and her lawyers said that of unborn children, as well. well, it hasn't gone her way. the appeal courtjudges have dismissed her claim. when she came out of the court behind mejust after 10.30, we saw and heard her hug her mother in

superior court and court of appeals functioned as the state level trial and appellate courts within the guinea justice system here in the u.s. capitol. both courts are responsible for large volumes of cases easier, and the national center for state courts report the d.c. superior court has 83,000 courts across his cases this year, one of the highest per capita rates in the entire country. despite this enormous caseload both courts are suffering from extensive judicial vacancies, which have delayed resources for parties before the court and has increased the workload for judges. if confirmed, you will not only take on the schedule which determine matters that will impact the freedom, livelihood, and families of many people that will come before you. today's hearing is an important opportunity for this committee to learn more about your qualifications and how you plan to serve welcome to each of you as well as working members joining each of you. thank you for your willingness to serve. we look forward to hearing from all of you today. the acting ranking is not recognized for opening comm

. >> the supreme court of appeal has made it clear that former president jacob zuma's release on medical. if there remains a number of questions around exactly what happens next. the supreme court has also said that while it has said that medical parole is unlawful, it is up to correctional services, the commissioner specifically, to determine whether or not the time that the former president spent out of prison on that medical parole counts towards his sentence. so it's not clear whether or not the former president will immediately return to prison. and also, there are chances that he does have a number of legal options on hand in terms of trying to challenge that latest judgment, that latest order by the supreme court of appeal. one option is that he may be able to go to the constitutional court, and if that's the case, he would have up to two months potentially to try and challenge that latest judgment by the courts sending him back to prison. one of the issues that is concerning is that when he was released from prison on medical parole, it was by the former commissioner, who is know

of the supreme court. educated cassation and appeal courts of general jurisdiction of the cassation and appeal military courtsich began work on october 1, 2019 in the procedure of these courts. the principle of continuous cassation has also been implemented by the prince of exerritoriality, in accordance with which cassation complaints are considered collectively in a court session with the invitation of the parties. the results of the work of these courts over the past 3 years indicate that their creation has made it possible to increase the efficiency of the court of appeal, as well as legal proceedings in these instances, given the growing volume of work, one of the urgent areas for improving justice is the optimization of the judicial burden, the exclusion of redundant judicial procedures, the implemented legislative initiatives of the supreme court of the russian federation, and the expansion of the scope of both writ and simplified proceedings in civil administrative cases and economic disputes. traditional hmm guarantees of judicial protection of citizens and organizations are provided by compliance re

bush's nominee for the circuit court of appeals that we mentioned earlier but still is the second most powerful court in the united states. everyone who paid attention to these things knows if he got onto the d.c. court of appeals who end up on the supreme court unless something catastrophic happens. until the democrats decided we are not voting and chuck schumer at a press conference at what can you do to direct him to get a vote? and the senator said at the microphone, nothing. so to break down the process then, we would just end up in a very bad place. >> what do you think about the composition of the court with these three trumpet appointees? are you fearful of an extreme right shift of the court? or do you think it will be a more reserved and moved the right? >> first, i think president trump did, he actually did his job but if there is a vacancy you nominate someone. it's wrong of a president for not filling a vacancy on the court for any reason. whether it's 8:30 in the morning on january 20 here's my name here is the name and putting forward. my big problem right now if the cou

bush's nominee for the court of appeals. we mentioned earlier that it is still the second most powerful court in the united states. everyone who pays attention to these things knew that if this person got onto the central court of appeals, they would end up on the supreme court unless something catastrophic happened. the darker wickets just decided that they were not going to vote. they said, well, what can they do to get a vote? the senator said at the microphone, nothing. we began to break down the process then. you just end up in a very bad place. >> what do you think about the composition of the court with these three trump appointees? are you fearful of an extreme right shift on the court? do you think it will be more reserved moved to the right? maybe not at all. >> i don't blame them. i think that president trump did his job. if there is a vacancy, you nominate someone. i would highly fault president for not fulfilling a vacancy on the court for any reason. here is my name, here is the name that i am putting forward. m

a woman with down's syndrome has lost a legal battle in the court of appeal . legal battle in the court of appeal. heidi legal battle in the court of appeal . heidi croucher legal battle in the court of appeal. heidi croucher had challenged legislation which allows the abortion of babies with the condition up until . allows the abortion of babies with the condition up until. in england wales scotland there is a 24 week limit for termination but that can be extended there is substantial risk the could be born with physical or mental abnormalities . the foreign abnormalities. the foreign secretary has announced a package of hands on support to help ukraine through the winter . the country is still experiencing power blackouts after russian air strikes hit key infrastructure . during his key infrastructure. during his first official trip to kyiv james cleverly pledged to send 35 more emergency vehicles as well as a further 35 more emergency vehicles as well as a furthe r £3 million to well as a further £3 million to help rebuild the country. he says it's important the uk , its says it's im

court. ges 208-220 of the appendix, the district court binding on this and 93-97 the court of appeals, and the smith committee analysis on this. basically what the district court found wasas said, simulation d would require siifantacrifices, on almost every dimension that harvard values. including a substantial decline, we are not talking about a decline in sat scores,oi from the 99tpeentile to the 98 percentile. we are talking about the foowing things the court found. the percentage of the matriculating class thou t academic 1s or 2s would go down by 17%. every other factor would go down by 10% to 22%. the number of matriculate's interested in majorininhe humanities. mar tip that harvard gives because of harvard's recent inability to matriculate excellent students that nto major in the humanities would go but -- down by 14%. the number of african-americans woulgoown from 14% to 10%. it was the confluence of all those consequences lead the diri court to confirm that it was not a workable eective race neutral alternative. >> it seems to the justices that know those other things are compelling i

of them. it was a real thrill to argue cases in the supreme court. i have argued quite a few in the court of appeals, but the supreme court is different, and even though i had been in court a lot, i felt a little bit nervous during my first argument. in those days the office was gentler than it is now, so they always gave an attorney a sure win case for the attorney's first argument. then i started to talk, and unfortunately justice o'connor asked me the first question, and it was a really big softball question, so that was good. it was a thrill and a privilege to handle those cases. my first boss was directly -- re x lee. rex was a gentleman and a very impressive scholar and fireman. i will give you one example. i had worked in the brief indicates call fcc versus the league of women voters. it had to do with the constitutionality of a federal statute that prohibited editorializing by public broadcasting stations. it was a somewhat important case. the statute was one that an refused to defend, because he thought it was pretty clearly unconstitutional, but when smith took over as attorney general he

in the extensive discussion of race neutral alternatives about the distri crt opinion and the court of appeals opinion a that for example with rescto academic excellence the academic factor, the number of matriculate's who score one or twoheld five-point scale would go down 17%. >> i am familiar with all of that. we go from 99 to 98% talbert i've got it. if i might shift gears here. i'm familiar with all of this. and i appreat that and i understand your point it is a hypothetical. what do we do about history here? one thing we kno or we think we know we are told i the briefs at least as harvard moved to the holistic application approach happened in the 1920s. because it wanted t iose a quota on jewish applicants but it did not want to do it through the front door. so use diversity as subterfuges for raci. quotas. what the ror in this case shows interest discussed in some detail i'm going to blank on the names of the reports about the various reports that harvard has done over the years on diverty and diverse admissions in the case, is that harvard actually, even before the civil war h at its a

over in one of the federal investigations, into trump, today, a federal appeals court in atlanta heard arguments in the justice department's appeal of the special master appointment. you know, the special master that wasste reviewing the government records found at mar-a-lago. now, the justice department today, calling the appointment an intrusion, arguing that the trump-nominated judge in florida shouldmi never have appointed a special master in the first place.rs the three-judge panel of the 11th circuit court of appeal seemed poise to toss out that order. here's "the washington post" report about today's arguments in part, reading, chief judge william pryor seemed to criticize trump's team for asking for a special master without proving that the initial search was illegal. if you can't establish that it was anunlawful, he said, then wt are we doing here? ouch. well, we don't know when a ruling will be handed down. it could come at anytime. but the fact in the last 42 daya of being in the majority, democrats have finally cleared the way to obtain six years of trump and their business

significantly reduced the amount of compensation er later the supreme court canceled such a decision indicating not very er significant violations that were admitted by the judges of the appealsand actually on the basis of this, the highest qualification of the commission of judges recommended the release of this circle, but the supreme council of justice refused to do so. this story took place in 2012, at that time the entire judicial system was controlled by the administration. in order for president yanukovych, the so-called gray cardinal was deputy head andriy portnov, he actually managed the supreme council of justice, so by not giving consent to the release of the circle, he could take it under his control by providing the necessary decisions in the right moment is pointed out by the experts, then i, who should be fired, but who is not fired , owes something to this. for example, a tailor or his assistants , he finds himself on the hook and then he has to follow instructions because he understands that if not, he can be fired at any moment, it is very this is a very common story precisely in order to make such stories impossible in the future. ukraine is reforming and i

case is currently active in the court of appeal circuit which the courts of appeal can take months torley. >> carley: you know mike miner speaking out from president biden's comments with nationwide shutdowns for coal plants, listen to this. >> no one is building new coal plants because they can't rely on it even if all the coal guaranteed for the existence of the plan. we will shut these plans down all across america. and i have wind and solar. >> carley: shutting the plants down across america. coal miner is here to discuss, you confronted hillary clinton when she said something very similar. here we go again. what went through your mind when you heard the president say that? >> personally, i thought, carley, the only reason not reliable because the government will shut them down. it is the most reliable form of energy we have. if it weren't for coal, the energy grid now would come to a standstill. >> carley: yeah, coal alone accounts for 22% of electricity in the country. if the president is successful and shuts down the coal plants, what will that look like for people when there i

the court of appeal have subjected the claimed that abortion rolls around down syndrome are discriminatory vows to take the case to the supreme court. a former soldier has been found guilty of unlawfully killing a man in northern ireland. a third formal complaint has been lodged against deputy prime minister dominic raab as he faces mounting bullying accusations. welcome to dowe hart. the hosts qatar are up against senegal. senegal currently 1—0 up at half—time. the big story of the day so far as the dramatic match we saw between wales and iran, huge disappointment for wales. they've lost 2—0 to iran, after goals from ramin rezaeian and then rouzbeh cheshmi deep into stoppage time. the goals followed a red card for wales goalkeeper wayne hennessy, he was sent off for a rash challenge outside the area. our correspondent hwyel griffith reports from qatar. if it was simply down to the singing, wales would be in the semifinals already. four—part harmonies hang in the air when there's the chance of a first world cup win in 64 years. i get nervous every time and he makes me more nervous. i've co