complicated judicial issue as you may hear and listening in to the president of the criminal court of justice and what we're well we're going to go back to the court now and listen in once again said thank you very much for the moment here is the president of the international court of justice once again. before. finally all 10 has to defend 'd it on the 4th he received. in this called take the pill of his that you refer to procedure is the colors that follow in breaching its decision but he didn't say you know a fundamental way that if either men can stop it just will see. they contend that those procedures where the money 1st before all this constituted a fundamental principle of due process of the coincidence known. this call up on the court to exercise it to support vice 30 or 40 top all the decision of the a kill comes to be no voice of the nice. the call of the records in its judgment in the case can set up the billeting to do this fiction of they kill comes in via the suspects. you can find the. entire proceeding if. they kill bones in that department is just wish us to strew is fictio

sort of mohamad all honey for he is an agent of the state of qatar before the international court of justice here outlined the various next steps the court architecture. this is a very important flawless victory for the state of qatar before the international court of justice the chicago convention has clearly illustrated that if a decision was made by the council of the i.q. then the member states that are concerns with that decision must follow precisely that decision and if they did not then it is the authority or the right of the state that has been affected by that decision is to raise that matter again to the council and there are certain sanctions that the council me grant the state of qatar for example not allowing the member states to vote in the general council or even to certain extent spotters a pete in certain important meetings and that will have its own. harsh side effect on those states but definitely in all cases any decision that has been made or will be made by the i keel as a council then it's allowed and permitted to be appealed in front of the. let's assume for example

looking back now to our top story and the ruling by the international court of justice related to the gulf crisis dr mohamad al khalifa he is an agent of the state of qatar before the international court of justice and he's joining us live here in doha i thank you very much indeed for being with us sir how important was it to qatar to get this legal ruling in this case well thank you so much this is a very important flawless victory for the state of qatar before the international court of justice as you know in mid of the 2018 the 4 states the states decided to appeal the decision issued at the international a civil aviation authority organization which is going on as the i.q. in favor of the state of permitting the jurisdiction to all over the case so that was a 1st step towards settling this issue under the heel for the state decided to appeal that decision according to article $84.00 of the chicago convention and article 2 of the i.a.s. there. in front of before the international court of justice a court of justice to day by anonymous vote of all the judges decided to reject that a

dispute which has seen cuts are prevented from flying over there as space the international court of justice is about to deliver its decision at the hague live pictures officials taking a seat there will go live to step outside the court in the hague in just a moment but 1st. explains the background to the story his report. folk atari's this has been a long battle on many fronts the international court of justice is to issue its verdict on a dispute over airspace riots it began in june 2017 when sandy arabia u.a.e. bashar ain and egypt sever ties with qatar and imposed a land sea and air blockade. qatar took the case to the un calling on the international civil aviation authority to declare the blockade illegal as part of the dispute the blockade in countries have barred qatari aircraft from entering their airspace which qatar says violates the convention on international civil

who's outside the course in the hague this was an unprecedented situation for the international court of justice said step a very complicated case it was deciding on to appeal cases involving cotton its neighbors and is ruled in favor of the country's. yeah it's an important complicated but also binding fertig here in the hague the president of the court basically dealt with 2 cases at the same time filed by qatar at the council in 2017 basically dealing with very old international agreements on the freedom of every ation signed in 1044 by most countries here and also the countries involved in this dispute had all signed these agreements to make it more simple the president decided that the i.k.o. council which the 4 countries who were against qatar and having to locate that they basically their appeal was rejected did not do a great job but that what they did was correct so basically i k o has done the job correctly and can deal with the case from now on also the 4 countries had said that should have negotiated more before taking the case to well the president of the court also said that qatar

only a few representatives of each country were allowed inside the court building known as the peace palace but the ruling read by the president of the international court of justice did not leave any doubt because. one. froth. of. the out of the public of. the kingdom of saudi arabia and the united. the court also ruled that the international civil aviation organization the kerio has jurisdiction in the case filed a complaint at the council in 2017 saying saudi arabia bahrain egypt and the u.a.e. violated the 94 to 40 cargo convention dealing with free passage of passenger planes through foreign airspace parties now have to go back to the council now that the council decision has been affirmed the go back to the council and continue the case and that's when we get to the real heart of the matter the real issues about have the. services been interrupted. not only did the 4 countries impose an air blockade on cathay 3 years ago but they also stopped all traffic over sea and over land this left qatari aircraft having to make detours to fly in and out of the last year the i.c.j. also ruled in favor of kata saying the u.a.e. was guilty of racial discrimination by expe

only a few representatives of each country were allowed inside the court building known as the peace palace. the ruling by the president of the international court of justiceid not leave any doubt. , one unanimous, being brought by the kingdom up a rain, the republic of egypt, the kingdom of saudi arabia, and the united arab emirates. >> the court also ruled the international civil aviation organization has jurisdiction in the case. qatar filed a complaint at the sayingncil in 2017, saudi arabia, bahrain, egypt, the 1944ae violated chicago convention dealing with free passage of passenger planes to foreign airspace. >> the parties have to go back to the council now that the decision has been affirmed, and continue the case. that's where we get to the real issues about -- that the air service has been addressing. reporter: not only did the countries impose an air blockade on qatar three years ago, it also stopped all traffic overseas and overland. this left qatari aircraft having detours.h last year, it was ruled in favor of qatar, saying the uae was guilty of racial discrimination by expelling qatari citizens and a separating families. >> there are certain

only a few representatives of each country were allowed inside the court building known as the peace palace but the ruling read by the president of the international court of justice did not leave any doubt because of one. you know. rejected deal for all by the king of. egypt the kingdom of saudi arabia and the united. the court also ruled that the international civil aviation organization the kerio has jurisdiction in the case filed a complaint at the council in 2017 saying saudi arabia bahrain egypt and the u.a.e. violated in 1944 cheap cargo convention dealing with free passage of passenger planes to foreign airspace reporters now have to go back to the council now that the council decision has been affirmed the go back to the council and continue the case and that's when we get to the real heart of the matter the real issues about. the air services been interrupted. not only did the 4 countries impose an air blockade on katha 3 years ago but they also stopped all traffic over sea and over land this left qatari aircraft having to make detours to fly in and out of the last year the i.c.j. also ruled in favor of kata saying the us. racial discrimination by expell

the guys the protests were peaceful until a group of supporters is started throwing glass bottles beer towns and smoke bombs . u.s. supreme court justice ruth bader ginsburg has been admitted to hospital to receive receive treatment for a possible infection ensberg is 87 and one of the 4 liberals on the supreme court she's would place a new trump appointee as likely to shift the court in a solidly conservative direction. to bangladesh now where one 3rd of the country is underwater after some of the heaviest monsoon rains in a decade or than a 1000000 people have been forced from their homes by heavy flooding forecasters warn that major rivers i expected to rise even further in the coming days. officials say the flooding began in late june after heavy rains in the northern parts of bangladesh and neighboring india. the country share over 50 rivers while flooding takes place almost every year during the monsoon season this years have been particularly bad the situation in bangladesh has become dire for many especially farmers who depend on their livestock. that's why. the flood water is constantly rising neither we nor our cattle could g

of justice everything might take a lot of time and even if the european court of justice condemned france that doesn't necessarily mean that the country will act accordingly and quickly so in the past france has been condemned in various matters for example environmental matters for its air pollution by the european court of justice and that didn't mean that the country would take swift action really so it's not clear if this will work for the families and france lisa lewis in paris thank you. well now to the story of a teenage footballer and russia who has got to be one of the luckiest people alive look out for this fleeting moment that we're about to show you when the blinding flash strikes the pitch there you see it at the stadium in moscow even if skinny is unconscious his jersey burnt and smoking his coach helps save the goalkeeper 3 weeks later the only evidence of the strike is a burn zaborowski is chast another look at the flash shows the stunning power of lightning which somehow spared this 16 year old boy. who is lucky indeed and with that you're up t

are and that is really a way in which the court of justice is ascertaining the the importance of reform that we have achieved in the european union and the fact that we need to maintain this standard of protection also in dealing with 3rd countries thank you very much for talking to us about this we appreciate your insights and that was go on to professor of law and joining us a from mass strict in the netherlands. fighting has broken out once again on the azerbaijan armenia border despite both sides saying they're trying to find a peaceful solution both countries say their villages are being shelled by opposition forces at least 16 people have been killed since border clashes erupted on sunday tension between the famous soviet republics has been escalating for several years as a fight over the disputed region of nagano caught about. and still ahead on al-jazeera a major hoch of twitter fake messages that appear on some of the most followed accounts including bill gates iraq obama's and even mosque. and a warm welcome but an uncertain future how mexico's tourism industry is adapting to

the international court of justice in the hague has ruled in favor of qatar in a dispute with 4 arab countries that imposed a blockade on the gulf state and prevented catherine aircraft from flying over their airspace the court ruled the u.n. civil aviation agency had jurisdiction in this case. decor one. you know. rejected today of the broth by the kingdom of bahrain the art of the public of egypt you kingdom of saudi arabia and the united. 2 by 51. called the consul of the international civil aviation organization has jurisdiction. they. submitted to it by the government of the state of other of october 27th the seat of the occasion you saw admissible. the former girlfriend of jeffrey abstaining has been charged as being denied bail on charges of facilitating the abuse of minors british socialite delaine maxwell appeared by video for her hearing accused of helping epstein recruit girls for abuse the judge agreed with prosecutors that maxwell was a flight risk she's pleaded not guilty and is due to stand trial within a year those are the headlines the stream is coming up next lookin

has been ruled illegal by the european court of justice privacy activists at all geared that the accord was unlawful because it gives the u.s. government access to european citizens private data without their consent. as india approaches 1000000 cases the northern state of bihar has been placed and the and new 15 day lockdown ever since march when the country went into its 1st lockdown millions of migrant workers have fled their cities to return to their home villages many on foot they feared being left without food and water if they stayed so how have those workers been faring since they headed home to india correspondent . traveled to. and i've just done to find out thank you. for nearly 2 weeks of husband working on this water reservoir it is 7 hours of hard labor every day just can't punishing fun especially for someone who was doing it for the 1st time. was one of more than 30000 migrants who fled home. district when india along down in late march. her husband had been making good money working 2 jobs in jeopardy she focused on reason their 5 children they didn't need a 2nd income

government says it can't ensure the security of weiwei equipment the international court of justice in the netherlands has ruled in favor of cattle in a dispute with 4 arab countries that imposed a blockade on the gulf state and prevented qatari aircraft from flying over its airspace the court ruled the u.n. civil aviation agency does have jurisdiction in the case. maxwell the alleged accomplice of convicted sex offender jeffrey epstein has been denied bail by a judge in new york the british so slight pleaded not guilty to charges that she helped epstein recruit girls for abuse. and the trumpet ministration has reversed its policy to revoke visas from international students if their schools health classes exclusively online because of the coronavirus. rewind is next to stay with us here on out to sara. a global pandemic mass protests demanding change economic recession and geopolitical tensions not to mention the small matter of

international law dr mohamed al khalifa is an agent of the state of qatar before the international court of justice and here in the various next steps the council could take this is a very important flawless victory for the state of qatar before the international court of justice the chicago convention has clearly illustrated that if a decision was made by the council of the i.q. then the member states that our concerns with that decision must follow precisely that decision and if they did not then it is the authority or the rights of the state that has been affected by that decision is to raise that matter again to the council and there are certain sanctions that the council me grant the state of qatar for example not allowing the those member states to vote in the general council or even to certain extent spotters a pete in certain important meetings and that will have its own. harsh side effect on those on those estates but definitely in all cases any decision that has been made or will be made by the i keel as a council then it's allowed and permitted to be appealed in front of the. let's assum

of justice everything might take a lot of time and even if the european court of justice condemned france that doesn't necessarily mean that the country will act accordingly and quickly so in the past france has been condemned in various matters for example environmental matters ever pollution by the european court of justice and that didn't mean that the country would take swift action really so it's not clear if this will work for the families in france lisa lewis in paris thank you. afghanistan now where years of conflict have left a health care system that is under resourced and struggling even before the coronavirus pandemic hit well now with cases surging there are barely any ventilators and not enough skilled workers to build them but help could be on the way thanks to a team of young afghan women with a keen interest in robotics. this is what the new ventilator prototype looks like and these young women designed it especially for afghanistan hospitals when they're not going to school in herat in the far west of afghanistan they spend their time optimizi

of justice everything might take a lot of time and even if the european court of justice condemned france that doesn't necessarily mean that the country will act accordingly and quickly so in the path france has been condemned in various matters for example environmental matters if we ever pollution by the european court of justice and that didn't mean that the country would take swift action really so it's not clear if this will work out for the families here in france lisa lewis in paris thank you. for latin american girls turning 15 is a very special birthday it's known as a kenson yetta the rite of passage into womanhood but coronavirus pandemic is adding some hurdles to this year's celebrations but as our next report shows lots of girls in cuba are finding fashionable ways to attack it. schick and safe it's the way to go for young cubans the likes of fia who are celebrating their king thing i knew it up or 15th birthday during the penn demick. i designed my 15th birthday dress and the mask was very important to me it's a symbol of an important stage in my

to the european court of justice. the ruling hands a big legal victory to apple the e.u. general court said the e.u. commission did not succeed in showing that the tech giant had received an illegal economic advantage in ireland over its low taxes the decision is a major blow to competition commission moderator vested his efforts to crack down on low tax regimes in the block. the commission fully behind the objectivity that all companies should pay their fair share of tax if member states give certain multinational companies tax advantages not available to their rivals this harms the fair competition in the e.u. the e.u. commission has 2 months time to decide if it wants to challenge the ruling in need use highest court the core of the problem is that the e.u. does not have one common tax code at the moment firms officially pay 12.5 percent corporate tax in ireland that's compared with the e.u. average of 21.3 percent officially companies in germany have to cough up at least 30 percent. that alone has attracted many companies to ireland and in fact apple paid far less tax

it's a community business thank you as i look now at some of the other stories making headlines around the world today u.s. supreme court justice ruth bader ginsburg has been admitted to hospital to receive treatment for possible infection ensberg is 87 and one of 4 liberals on the supreme court if she's replaced new trump appointee is likely to shift the court in a solidly conservative direction. thousands of bug arians gathered for the 6 evening in a row all their government orders sophia demonstrators are piling pressure on veteran from yeah boris off to resign over his perceived links with all the goss the protests were peaceful until a group of protesters started throwing glass bottles beer cans and smoke bombs. german police and customs officers have discovered 31 migrants hidden inside a refrigerated truck vehicle stopped near the checked border turkish license plate on the turkish driver who is now in custody reports say by a groundswell mail and came from turkey syria iran and iraq. the irish government and apple have won their appeal against 2016 e.u. decision that said apple had to pay the irish government $130000000

of the affair that no certainly not the european commission although doesn't confirm this yet but it will be a shock if they weren't going to appeal this to the highest court european court of justice and that if that happens we'll be waiting for another 2 years we could be back here in 2 years time talking about this guard and the overall fight against tax avoidance in europe and in the world as a whole one that they always today is involved in that's not going anywhere the waters are rising on this issue it's a blow to the commission there fight a significant blow but this is not over hello and thank you very much for well to bangladesh now where one 3rd of the country is under water after some of the heaviest monsoon rains in a decade more than a 1000000 people have been forced from their homes by heavy flooding forecasters warn that major rivers are expected to rise even further in coming days. officials say the flooding began in late june after heavy rains in the northern parts of bangladesh and neighboring india. the country's share of a 50 rivers while flooding takes place almost every year during the monsoon season this years have been particularly bad the situation in bang

privacy but now germany's highest court says no not if it's weighed by public interest reporting on europe correspondent peter all of a next. the german federal court of justice the supreme court here has sided with google in a landmark case when it comes to a person's right to be forgotten versus the public's right to know what it means is essentially this ruling is that a person can request internet companies remove articles about them from internet searches but the company is under no obligation to do so there is no presumption of a priority for the protection of the interests of the person concerned but the conflicting fundamental rights not to be weighed up equally good person responsible for search engine does not have to take action until he becomes aware of an obvious and at 1st glance clearly recognizable violation of the law or the person concerned back in 24 t. the european court of justice the e c j rule to say citizen has the right to have inaccurate inadequate irrelevant or excessive search results linked to their name removed from search engines what that doesn't mean is that things would be removed from the internet they just wouldn't show up

against these sweetheart deals and so they will certainly go to the next level the european high court of justice and try again and sort of put the legal arguments and whether that will be successful we will see at some point next year but they won't give up that easily it will while apple celebrates could this all boost investment or not and of obviously that's what the government the irish government is hoping that over the last few years u.s. investment has continued to copenhagen but the wider context of this is that the waters are gradually rising for low tax regimes like ireland they always seem to be currently trying to get a global agreement on holocaust as barbara just pointed out european commission is continuing to try and bring this fight so i would say it's unlikely that in the longer term arden's tax regime can exist in the way that it has done for years and perhaps is not going to be the bounty that maybe song on the other side in the government would hope for perhaps not obvious other than thank you very much for reporting on this and bob are available for your reporting from brus

this ruling earlier this week related to is going to see their case referred to the european court of justice they're going to make another ruling on this as europe tries to essentially find privacy laws that are fit for purpose in today's information age. this is sad among the many troubling consequences of the pandemic is that millions more children are going hungry a study by the british medical journal the lancet estimates that by the end of the year an extra 6700000 children under the age of 5 risk malnourishment thousands are predicted to die from hunger the un's flagging up an urgent call the right now for action more children are becoming malnourished due to socio economic shocks created by the pandemic in low income and middle income countries as leaders of 4 u.n. agencies we are issuing a call for action to protect children's right to nutrition. the report also highlights the vicious circle that the military puts families in their children a greater risk of contracting and dying from covert help is struggling to get through to lock downs of seriously hampered humanitarian organizati

also in the hague the international court of justice is usual on counsel's legal bed to remove the air blockade imposed by 4 arab states it's now been more than 3 years since saudi arabia the u.a.e. bahrain and egypt imposed a land sea and air embargo on cata. explains. folk atari's this has been a long battle for many friends in the international court of justice is the issue its verdict on a dispute over a space riots it's begun in june 2017 when saudi arabia u.a.e. and egypt serve their ties with qatar and imposed a sea blockade. qatar took the case to the un calling on the international civil aviation authority to declare the blockade illegal as part of the dispute the blockade in countries have barred qatari aircraft from entering their airspace which qatar says violates the convention on international civil aviation referred to as the chicago convention the blockade in countries challenge the qatari move saying the u.n. agency doesn't have jurisdiction to handle the case but into a 1018 the international civil aviation authority rejected that claim insisting that it does have jur

have the rise of things like not just the united nations and security council and international court of justicewhich i just mentioned but things like the chemical weapons convention again has a secretary or the wto has new forms of courts and new forms of regulatory bodies that sit outside the control of any one country but independence, a kind of power that international institutions didn't have before. it used to be fair to say international institutions were more directly under the control of a few nations or some nations, now they are seen as independent of any nations so just to give an example the united states and other countries in the world were ever to reach an agreement about global warming it would have both these characteristics, a global warming treaty to be effective would have to be able to reach into energy production and use in a country in ways the federal government today doesn't regulate here at home even to the extent of regulating domestic or home energy usage. at the same time, would create international institutions that would have to decide how much each country was al

only a few representatives of each country were allowed inside the court building known as the peace palace but the ruling read by the president of the international court of justice did not leave any doubt because. one. you know any more project is the other deal brought by the kingdom of bahrain. of egypt the kingdom of saudi arabia and the united. the court also ruled that the international civil aviation organization the kerio has jurisdiction in the case filed a complaint at the council in 2017 say in saudi arabia bahrain egypt and the u.a.e. violated in 1944 cheap cargo convention dealing with free passage of passenger planes through foreign airspace parties now have to go back to the council now that the council's decision has been affirmed the go back to the council and continue the case and that's when we get to the real heart of the matter the real issues about. their services been interrupted. not only did the 4 countries impose an air blockade on 3 years ago but they also stopped all traffic over sea and over land this left qatari aircraft having to make detours to fly in and out of the last year the i.c.j. also ruled in favor of qatar saying the u.s.

legal action we have the international court of justice they are going to be. trained. in the international court of justice the international civil aviation organization has been notified by the union government and they are supposed to take an action but the u.s. has and is obviously illegal and these international bodies. should and i think will condemn these type of activities so that's on the legal side i think even in the moment realizing that the u.s. is doing this out of a policy decision that they did not do this before this is. an airline that has been going to lebanon for many many years this is the 1st time they have done that so this may be a policy decision to escalate this type of pressures against iran given the fact that trumper administration may be out of office in january and the people who designed the maximum pressure campaign. in state on are feeling that they're running out of time so since this is a political decision and a military decision i think they don't you know may actually take political decisions and military decisions in response part

and also some of the other stories making headlines around the world today u.s. supreme court justice ruth bader ginsburg has been admitted to hospital to receive treatment for a possible infection is 87 and one of the 4 liberals on the supreme court if she is replaced a new trump appointee is likely to shift the court in a solidly conservative direction. thousands of bolivians half protested against their government in the capital of past because of economic hardship caused by covert 19 some burnt effigies of political leaders they want to thirty's to do more to reactivate the economy after massive layoffs bolivia has about 50000 covert 90 cases. thousands have called on israeli prime minister benjamin netanyahu to resign in a protest outside his official residence in jerusalem that has seen his popularity drop in recent weeks as he faces a trial on corruption charges and grapples with a deepening coronavirus crisis. for one 3rd of bangladesh is under water after some of the heaviest monsoon rains in a decade more than a 1000000 people have been forced from their homes by heavy flood

he served as a law clerk to justice arthur goldberg of the supreme court of the united states during the october 1964 term. after justice brier pursued a career of teaching and public service president jimmy carter appointed him to the u.s. court of appeals for the first circuit in 1980. in 1994 president clinton nominated justice brier as an associate justice of the supreme court to succeed harry blackman. he took his seat august 3rd, 1994. since joining the court justice brier has completed no less than a number of books including "active liberty, interpreting our democratic constitution," making our democracy work, a judge's view, and then most recently "the court and the world, american law and the new global realities." with thanks and appreciation i would ask you to welcome justice steven brier. >> thank you. i'm glad you're all here. i was just talking too my wife has written a book. she's a clinical psychologist and she just wrote a book on what you do if your child is very sick, and very helpful to a small group of people. she was talking about it as st. judes in memphis so i

court editor of the harvard law review. he clerked on the d.c. circuit court before he clerked for chief justice burger. he went to nyu in 1981, and by 1988 he was dean of his tenure there was extremely successful. the law school is firmly ensconced in the rankings as one of the top five in the country. by 2002, he had been elevated to president of nyu. he served there until the end of 2015. during that tenure, freshman applications doubled. the endowment grew by over 200%. minority in rome and went from 11% to 19%. and throughout all of this he continued to teach. -- we are going to have to get ready for our lecturer -- he set up a variety of other important positions including president of the federal reserve bank of new york, president of the american association of law schools, president of the new york academy of science -- thank you -- it was 43 years ago that chief justice burger founded this society. to talk about warren burger, president john sexton of nyu. >> thank you very much. it is a great honor for me to be here today my first introduction to warren burger and the society came at the same

court justice stephen breyer. justice breyer is on the united states supreme court and one of only 113 people to have ascended in our nation. i believe only 18 jews have done so before. for our purposes, he was a professor at harvard law school and at the harvard kennedy school of government. he served as chief judge of the united states court of appeals for the first circuit. justice breyer, it has been a delight to speak with you over the past few weeks. you have been very kind, generous, so i thank you. when i was a kid i was asked to memorize, as an assignment, the nine justices and yours was the easiest to remember because my home was filled with breyer's ice cream. in my mind, you were justice ice cream. a friend came to visit me last year and his two-year-old started calling me rabbi ice cream. maybe after this we can get some ice cream. justice breyer: no relation unfortunately. moderator: talia is my very good friend and is currently in jerusalem. she earned a degree from oxford and completed her doctorate at harvard law school and is finishing up a phd in business economics of the department of economics a

to illegal state aid the european commission is expected to appeal the ruling to the european court of justice. earlier this year then irish prime minister lavrov current apple chief executive tim cook had an anniversary to celebrate 40 years since apple started manufacturing in ireland over the decades the e.u. country in the us i phone maker have both profited from the arrangement apple gets a massive tax break but it provides employment for multinational companies the favorable situation in our land is practically unrivaled in europe at the moment firms officially pay 12.5 percent corporate tax in arland that's compared with the e.u. average of 21.3 percent officially companies in germany have to cough up at least 30 percent. that alone has attracted many companies to ireland and in fact apple paid far less tax at times for example is little is 0.005 percent in 2014 when the tech giant paid just 50 euros tax on every 1000000 euros in profit. that was the last straw for e.u. competition commissioner my creative us here in 2060 in the european commission ordered apple to pay arlen 13000000000

the next 3 months german carmaker volkswagen could face a new wave of lawsuits the european court of justice has ruled that owners of cars in the e.u. with the emissions cheap devices consume volkswagen in their own countries not just in germany admitted in 20 fifteenth's using illegal software to cheat on emissions tests. well piles of potatoes vats of unpurchased milk produce around the world has piled up in recent months as pandemic lockdowns take away traditional buyers such as restaurants and export markets now it's french cheese that's affected a cultural commodity as well as a big industry. more breather he knows what to do with lockdown measures in france has made it hard for morgan call home to sell his high quality soft cheese now it's past its peak. as of today we have a 1000 more patches of pleated more than we need they're drying out at the moment and really they're no longer actually fit for sale. morgan's usual buyers include restaurants and markets in paris and surrounding areas he produces a 1000 tons of debris every year and pirated milk from a nearby farm he couldn't bring

court declared that holding you jel in custody was illegal breaching his personal freedom so we will appeal today's verdict and continue to pursue justice dennis's cases also before the european court of justice right now today's ruling shows that turkish law is not about justice. this should all you jail was forced to leave turkey after 12 months spell in prison from germany he reacted to the ruling. this verdict again shows how little the rule of law counts in turkey and in what a terrible state it is the constitutional court didn't just declare my imprisonment illegal it went through all of the articles mentioned in the indictment the commentaries reports and interviews i wrote for event and it declared all of them lawful under the constitution. this isn't the only case against you joe in turkey 2 new counts have been brought against him insulting the turkish president and the state. we asked our on in istanbul yulia han just how independent the turkish courts are and what message the turkish authorities might be trying to send with this but it's. well according to dennis your job himself and his lawyer this whole case has been politically motivated from the very beginning presiden

on cata it's legal bit to remove the air blockade now hinges on a ruling by the international court of justice due to be issued later on tuesday has some expense. for qatar is this has been a long battle or many fronts the international court of justice is to issue its verdict on a dispute over space riots it's begun in june 2017 when saudi arabia u.a.e. and egypt serve their ties with qatar and imposed a sea blockade. qatar took the case to the un calling on the international civil aviation authority to declare the blockade illegal as part of the dispute the blockade in countries have barred qatari aircraft from entering their space which qatar says violates the convention on international civil aviation referred to as the chicago convention of locating countries challenge the qatari move saying the u.n. agency doesn't have jurisdiction to handle the case but into a 1018 the international civil aviation authority reject of that claim insisting that it does have jurisdiction the mast own but we are not there yet in terms of qatar's progress because while qatar will move a step closer into rega