so we've had this conversation is aligns with the 5 on the data that mta data from 2012 that was banshe twitter status >> twitter. >> that's what we are looking to face are the preliminary collision factors are mostly the same. >> it came up at the hearing in january of 2014 there were more stop signs more types of enforcement but helpful to understand. >> those are the collision factors the citations. >> right. >> those are the crashes that happened we've termed what caused the crash. >> so going back to bayview stop signs telling me more about this factor why it is unique to bayview. >> that's the sheer numbers the analysis are broken down the the vehicle section and within the stop signs with respect the 4 primary i don't tell you was is a failure to at a four-way stop. >> it come up with reference to stop signs in the tenderloin not a lot of stop signs violations one stein in the same place but in bayview it is prominently controlled by stop signs stop signs but i had the data broken down i minimal this data is helpful to the captain at bayview to understand this is a at the scene

so part of my position is using the trauma registry data and using that with the police data to have a better recommendation of the collisions happening on the san francisco streets and combining think that with the emergency room and emergency medical services data to fill those data gaps and lastly i wanted to also mention transbay so with the development of the transportation surveillance system ultimately that okay of that data will be posted on transbay an open source web-based property owner hours over 2 hundred mapping of the important transportation and health data which is utilized by several city agencies and has been useful in- i don't know if this is the right presentation. >> as an example the transbay was used in the city's data driven process for public safety for walk first that allowed for the evaluation analysis and injury patterns in san francisco to identify capital safety improvements priorities in the city pretty much. >> great that sums everything up thank you very much. >> that's the last presentation i have a question first of all it is great to see the outco

we use the data to provide the teacher with the analytical dade data they use to help the students. so any data that is able to support learning becomes more powerful. and that is focused around the user interface, they don't have a huge bench strength where they can do the analysis themselves. so we really focus around the old user interface, analytics and presentation and it is easier and the teacher is able to look at something and use it affectively. to do that you need to invest in your infrastructure. >> any downside? anything you are getting too much data and it is counter productive? >> it is not it is counter productive because you need to understand what is noise and what is real data that enables you to use that from a prevent preventive perspective. identifying at-risk children is early and saves the system money. how do you identify the right data? the key is not to be -- is to be very conscious of privacy. the district owns the data and has the access. >> you talk about the expensive infrastructure in technology you need to get. chris are you using this and what are yo

inadequate data security express state data security laws. that can be used to enforce against what attorneys general team deem to be unreasonable data security practices. finally retailers voluntarily and by contract follow a variety of security standards including those maintained by pci, nis and iso. while retailers diligently ply this this a carefully crafted federal data breach law can clear up regulatory confusion and better protect and notify customers. rela supports legislation that is practical and proportional and sets a single national standard. rela supports data breach legislation that creates a single national notification quickly providing affected individuals with actionable information. that ensures the targeted notice is required only when there is an actual risk of identity theft, economic loss or harm. it ensures that the responsibility to notice is that of the entity breached but provides flexibility for entities to contractually determine the notifying party. that establishes a precise and targeted definition for persona

state data security laws. also, many states have so-called ftc acts, unreasonable data security practices. finally, retailers voluntarily and by contract follow a variety of security standards including those maintained by pci and iso. while retailers comply with the range of data breach notice and requirements, a carefully crafted federal data breach law clear of regulatory confusion can protect and notify customers better. they support legislation that's practice call and proportional and sets a single national standard. this supports data breach legislation that creates a single national notification center allowing businesses to focus on quickly providing affected individuals with actionable information that ensures that targeted notice is required only when there's an actual risk of identity theft, economic loss, or harm. that ensures that the responsibility to notice is that of the entity breached but provides flexibility for entities to notify the party, establishes personal information, recognizes that

this is a lot of data in the slides that stop signs is only in effect in one district and the fourth primarily collision thing not in the top 5 we'll get into that with the data and again i apologize there's a lot of data to give a shout out to our loan analyst karen that put this together with a mri idea of data resources to make something that make sense so here we have the 2014 san francisco government audit & oversight commission u citywide breakdown of citation issuance and we're 83 at 24 percent of the steernz they're in there and another large number the number one issue was cell phone and tint driving and april was distracking driving month the distransacted driving leads to outlet issues our biggest category as it is every year as others that includes the 4 hundred and 50 code violations that people while driving this is the mode 2014 is obviously the most complete data it was not complete we collected mid year around 2013 and going forward i predict it will get better bless you. >> as you can see 201494 percent of citations were issued to drivers of vehicles whether motor v

there are a number of ways to get the data and staff said in previous hearings requiring the data from the legislation is one way but other ways of getting the platforms to collect the data we also become for acutely warrior aware there is a number of platforms that don't collect the data they not acting on a host between the rental. >> the staff testified before so maybe they can respond can they address the issue of do you building that this law can be enforced without the booking data. >> good afternoon emily rogers thank you for the opportunity i've been looking forward to clarifying any comments from the previous board about a month ago i said that will be helpful to have the information and that information could be gathered voluntarily or through web scraping or other technological means that's the full breath of any comments comments not really been always invigilant full. >> do i think this law can be enforced without the booking data? >> i think the data would help it is not the only way to enforce the law. >> i don't think my person opinion i concur with the director on his

we use the data to provide the teacher with the analytical dade data they use to help the students. so any data that is able to support learning becomes more powerful. and that is focused around the user interface, they don't have a huge bench strength where they can do the analysis themselves. so we really focus around the old user interface, analytics and presentation and it is easier and the teacher is able to look at something and use it affectively. to do that you need to invest in your infrastructure. >> any downside? anything you are getting too much data and it is counter productive? >> it is not it is counter productive because you need to understand what is noise and what is real data that enables you to use that from a prevent preventive perspective. identifying at-risk children is early and saves the system money. how do you identify the right data? the key is not to be -- is to be very conscious of privacy. the district owns the data and has the access. >> you talk about the expensive infrastructure in technology you need to get. chris are you using this and what are yo

are using that data. they are using that data to figure out how to make those services better for you to improve the services, create new products and services for new needs out there. our first speaker today, scott galloway, take that day and uses it to predict where the broader technology and media industry is headed. he is going to start with a presentation which he talked about who are the winners and losers of this landscape. then come back for a panel discussion. we are going to talk about data and innovation and how it relates to our industry. what we can expect to see, what lessons we can learn and what the future holds. it is my pleasure to introduce scott galloway, founder and chairman. scott founded it after developing an algorithm to talk about digital competence of this is a professor of nyu school of business where he teaches the strategy of digital marketing. in 2012 scott was named one of the 50 best business school professors. he is also the founder of red on the low and profit brand stra

data they'll brink in san francisco general data for gaps and citation reports so all of this really helps to kind of fill out out the picture of what our streets look like. >> thank you nicole and all our stiffer and holding us accountable we'll be back in the next quarter and commander maddox it will be interesting to see where we are and an update on the operation around schools and senior centers see you next quarter. >> inspector the occ director's report with right activities and the presentation and summary of cases received in march and mediation of containments in april and march of 2014 and the adjudication and the commander report. >> good evening director hicks and good evening commissioner president loftus and commissioner turman members of the commission. >> i'm just taking our time now. >> (laughter). >> chief suhr and members of the public. >> mayor brown asked me. >> are you going to remind the chief of last week. >> recent developments at the appendixes on monday we had a building where appendixes is housed on van ness experienced a two hour power outage and that po

with the city those are recommendation for the citywide not directed towards airbnb to focus on their data and third compacting the legislation for a year we don't recommend a number there's value and certainly that's in place for unhosted the board could consider the hosted and fourth amending the planning code for the platforms for this host so there's no mechanism now fire endorsing it or teeth in the current approach that is a summary again, i think this what we have clicked is on the conservative side a number of units that are thousand that we identified from the - had 90 no rectifies since we used rectifies we clarified those units in the casual group because we didn't want to overstate it and in addition the point i made was that the data from one company and the industry is larger than that so there's more out there than recorded in that report i'll be happy to answer any questions. >> thank you very much i have one quick question and i've got colleagues that have questions i was wording if you could summarize the methodology you used to prepare our report and the sources you've c

that we're going to be changing that and it is about data collection it not easy to get the data tonight we're working on that and going forward able to track data in a better manner working with the ceo to get the traffic and collision data 2014 the department issued over hundred and 2 did thesis citations you'll see that we're still at 24 percent focusing on the 5 remember that original 5 that was decided when we initiated the commitment to vision zero and. >> and could you remind us the 5. >> we based it on information provided via mta and they used twitter data two to three years behind and doing initiative things like education and all the e's involved we wanted more contemporary information and gone through a third party vendor that provides timely data and they were up to the end of april for the data it is timely and it is self-explanatory again, the top 5 24 percent another good percentage are cell phone citation and distracked driver's leads to other issues maybe 6 will be color to reaching our goal quicker all 2014 the same data breakdown by mold 94 sizings e citations were is

of consumer data, or a year of consumer data. you might only have 15 days or 30 days of consumer data. isn't that really one of the risks that we have so much data being collected and stored, not just from the government but from retailers. >> the information is designed to give them what they really want. corporations want receiptless returns. the element of consumers have voluntarily said we want to be able for you to have this information. >> i don't know that i've ever been asked. their service is offered to me and that information is kept on my card. and i do think there's a consumer protection issue here when we're not asked. it's just given to us. >> time of the gentleman has expired. chair now recognizes the gentleman from texas. >> thank you, chairman and ranking member waters for holding this important hearing today. and thank you to our panelists for your testimony. mr. chairman before asking my questions, i request consent that my statement be made a part of today's record? >> without objection. >> my first question i

exclusive permission to market this data and so forth. we have failed in that respect. so yes, no one should be able to use your data without your permission and get rid of the patriot act just gave the government a blank check and hillary clinton says [inaudible] she did not trust them with her e-mails. why should i trust the state to promote my e-mails? [inaudible] >> legislatively, what would you like to see done? >> i would like to see that the patriot act not be renewed and that's coming up in june. you should call your congressman and that is the critical one. the guy that wrote the patriot act is on record as saying that they distorted it and the republican congressman, it should be dropped. rand paul has a petition he is a conservative, there are plenty of liberals that have repetition. people should be aware that the government was given a license to learn so much about you and if you had no privacy, you're going to end up being a fearful human being. they know everything about you. >> "they know everything about you: how data co

as to represent the industry and building our estimates are understated we're not- we didn't have data from all the platform companieses pratt from this one the impacts would be greater this first slide is a snapshot of housing and the short-term rentals in san francisco 3 hundred and 6 thousand affordable units and 12 rental hours units this is the u.s. anticipation and 8 thousand 4 hundred for rent in 2013, the vacancy rate airbnb listing we got this information from a website in 2014 there were 6 thousand plus listing in san francisco and this is unhosted and entire units and hosted private and shared rooms excuse me. 16.9 million visitors recorded in 2013 of which approximately 3 hundred and 21 thousand state in short-term rentals to a small number relative to the vitals and relative to the housing units and the how's duration is one .5 nights in visitors staying in short-term rentals we've averaged the airbnb prices for the different types of listing the private room hundred and 15 and shared 72 and $209 averages because we didn't have data compared to for example the analyze of h

was gathering bulk data on america's phone calls.ther the caller or the recipient was suspected of any connection to a wrongdoing. a federal court's the practice stretched the definition of the word relevance in the current law. the court ruling coming at a critical time as congress, the agencies and the white house are staking out their territories in a debate about the government's power to fry into your privacy. shark. >> reporter: it was shortly after the 9/11 attacks that the bush demonstration under the patriot act began to collect a massive drove of phone records, signed off by the intelligence court of the it continued under president obama. in 2013, the extent of the surveillance was revealed when edward snowden leaked n.s.a. documents indicating the government was sweeping up records of nearly every phone call made in the u.s. the aslu sued claiming this violated americans right to privacy. the court did not rule on that constitutional issue, but said the programme is illegal because it goes beyond what congress intended. >

that data.we are getting from the schools and school districts monday don't all collected the same way. certainly, the asian pacific data is one that we are working very hard to differentiate in the future. >> the school districts for differentiating in asians but not hispanic? why is that? dr. carr: they don't all report to us that way. they don't all report the origin. we don't correct the data in such a refined way. >> but you are planning to. yesterday we were talking about leveraging federal dollars, is there some way that some of the school districts -- you can request that they provide you broken down by subgroup. dr. carr: it is a matter of putting the procedures in place such that one state gives an indication or definition of origin of the student is the same as another state. i think it is a matter of getting a definition and procedures in place. i don't think it is a funding issue. >> whose response ability is that? dr. carr: it is a collective partnership between state and the surve

and think about the way that people place data centers where they store data, how they store data, theact that there's going to be wide variance between states doesn't sync with how we know cyber commerce gets done. >> as a governor, you know how valuable the solutionings are that are -- solutions are that are adopted in this area. it seems to evolve every day with new technologies, new ways to threaten consumers and really the security of our information. i'd like to ask stephen orfei given your organization's experience in establishing data security protocols and procedures, what would you say are the most important aspects of a company's data security plan? in other words, what is the most important thing that a company could do to protect their customers, to protect their company against data breaches? >> thank you congresswoman for that question. i think what's most important is the pci standard is in our view the best defense against cyber criminal attacks. it's really become a question of vigilance. and being methodical and disciplined in your approach and looking at and paying

been discussed how to enforce this without day more than anything the host is required to hold the data the number of nights so we have the penalties so i minimal we'll host what they're continuing to have on their own usage but also i think the notion i want to thank the planning department and the entire staff and director ram for that working with my office and mayor's office part of the office of short-term rentals to have the adequate staffing levels that the planning department they need in order to enforce the law we've had multiply reading with the treasurers and tax collectors observation to talk about the streamline process so we can facilitate and encourage individuals going to list their short-term rentals to register with the city with the times of the enforcement being under the as pies of our city i want to be clear i back and forth, if you will by putting in a hard cap and by creating the office of short-term rentals that will be the assumption adequate staffing in our budget at the board of supervisors do you feel therefore you can enforce the laws we're going to create

of evictions and are also high in the short-term rental commercial hosts we using our model and the data we have obtained to determine the impacts of the various caps that have been decided in the various legislation this is different had an the relatives of the analyze that was i was describe to the members are close so as you can see here with the 6 how's hundred and 13 units we've identified on the short-term rental market in december how many would be removed if current conditions or the conditions as of december remained in place from the 6 thousand plus hundred and 29 night maximum 4 hundred and 7 units will story and i don't mean disappear but can't remain as the level of renting for 2011 and in terms of enforcement of short-term rental laws and this issue has been discussed by the planning department but certainly we've observed that the department has so hurdles in trying to enforce the law and again back to the about the of the locations they're not known there's no road map of who is in the business and not and booking information is available in an aggregate basis on an indiv

they are collecting a lot of data about what is happening with this data? is the car relying autonomous but also drive -- there's a separation from outside because everything that is generating can forget immediately after the privacy issue. so they are not quite clear. what is the right path for the future? the fraction thinking we need a lot of data from around the car, from city centers and so on they then have immediately the problem of what the privacy and security of this data. data from the car can corrupt the car and corrupt the driving situation. again safety issues. secondly is sending data outside of itself, whose the owner of the vehicle, who can use that vehicle. is it the driver, is it the car owner, is it society? these are all the questions we have to discuss and this is a cultural issue around the globe not in every country the same. one thing is for sure. as soon as data is available, it will be used and it will be used for business. it was always the same story in the world. it will happen here again. so as soon as data is outside of the

data is mostly based on census data that it's aged. we are in a very awkward place in this city that we know for sure because of what's going on that the demographics of the city, it's probably a good question to say are they at a much different trajectory today. or for example the last time we did the survey about the aging in san francisco and what happens to the population because we are setting policies now that we are going to live with for many years to come in setting services. so it's kind of our responsibility to get when we know that this change has happened to get as precise a handle as we can although it will be unprecise. i know the department has done some work on it and i think it would be worthwhile having the department present to us. here is what the census in 2010 said or here is what the data we are going off of says about different populations in the city and where they live, etc. here is what we are smelling given more recent data that we ought to keep in mind as we are making policy in the next few years until th

chris's the analysis but refuse to provide the data for more accuracy so one question i have is that based on our review you have heard the comments from the planning department staff in terms of enforceability of the law without the booking data and in your opinion is this law be enforceable without the booking data. >> i guess the question if there's going to be a hard cap there's a hard cap on now this seems like critical information to have how many bookings took place to know what with host exceeds it's 90 day coop i'll that is important. >> someone else that's been proposed the creation of a new government bureaucracy the office of short-term rental rented in your opinion based on what our seen do you think that office could enforce the law that included a hard cap out the booking data. >> i don't know the dials supervisor campos i know one of the legislation dui but don't know what it entails i'll go back to the point booking data is important for some measure to know when the 0 hosts are stooefd the cap and chastises in our opinion about the comments this law has only been in

rental o and on and on if we're talking about a major policy recommendations to require the data reporting back my challenge is that that is scapegoating would be company but if we are looking at the regulating this industry as a whole how does it impact the neighborhoods and how can he regulate that we need that holistic approach that didn't take the expedite to target one company but all the listing and airbnb is a moisture in san francisco what i've heard the trends continue to make that more that way so as the city to only targeting one company is half the problem if he consider the short-term rentals so from my prospective i'd like so say we can't collect data and from the majority of listing in san francisco from my prospective is a much better approach to streamline the process to people that point better short-term rentals we, the jury at city of san francisco i ago that the statistics are poor we need more and more people to register but from my prospective may i see it, sir? that's how we regulate it most effectively if we look at the entire industry and encourage those strildz i

that comes to the hint of data rñ?ñ -- point of data. to we have data aroundoqñ?ñ?ff andanñ?ñ the rate of rehospital station. i think that'sgzñ?ñ? something that i'm more interested in.zññ?ñ?ñro% Ñlj!pm8 v#'e&@3t%s07:dvíe?rf-á it's about improving outcomes of any of these patients. also, when we talk about placing them in communities, this actually happened to close friends of mine. she was placed in a community skilled nursing facility outside of san francisco. is that usual also?(uñ?ñ? in >> i can speak to the first question. i don't have data on rehospitalization. for free standing sniff of patients that were discharged. a quarter of them was discharged back to the hospital. >> the second question is when you talk about free standing community sniffs and where we placing them, all of them within san francisco or some of them are outside of san francisco? >> we all do on education -- occasion have to place people outside of san francisco. we all know one of the things we all lack in healthcare is predictability and volume. there are times where all systems are ful