daved pilpel in support of the initiating the landmark for the park side branch library. thank you. >> thank you so much and this completes the queue. >> thank you. madam clerk, public comment is closed. >> i would like to make a motion we sends this out with positive recommendation as a committee report. >> and on that motion supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye >> you have 3 aye's >> that motion pass. this is our last committee meeting of the year and my last day as chair i want to say thank you it has been a pleasure. and i will miss you supervisor mar and thank you deputy city attorney and madam clerk for the wonderful work. >> wait! wait! why is it your left day as chair y. we have a new board next year, newark signments. >> but you could get the same assignment. >> do we have other matters before us today? >> that completes the queue. >> that completes the agenda. >> thank you. lovely holiday break to all my colleagues and staff. thank you. >> adjourned. shop and dine in the 49 promotes local businesses and challenge

daved pilpel. first time this year i have a number of commentsos 4a, b and c. i don't feel a need to have them pull exclude heard separately i will do it within 3 minutes if i go over ask me to conclude so i can get everything on items item 4a under item 4, on page 4 of the draft minutes, my public comment i did suggest moving it prior to the votes in the minutes. i also commented and appreciated the expanded text read about items 4c and d at that meeting related to ceqa. and i think something should be inserted there related to my comments about ceqa on -- page -- on item 8 in the upon minutes on page 5. commissioner newhouse segal requested lower case r on item 11 and public comment. suggesting lower case s and i don't be if and wait, and adding the meeting schedule attachment to the resolution or, too, is missing finotice anything else i'm happy to communicate that to commission secretary. manager full and suggest that throughout where it references members present and voting it should indicate voting in favor. so it is clear. and the record. it is also just

daved pilpel. first time this year i have a number of commentsos 4a, b and c. i don't feel a need to have them pull exclude heard separately i will do it within 3 minutes if i go over ask me to conclude so i can get everything on items item 4a under item 4, on page 4 of the draft minutes, my public comment i did suggest moving it prior to the votes in the minutes. i also commented and appreciated the expanded text read about items 4c and d at that meeting related to ceqa. and i think something should be inserted there related to my comments about ceqa on -- page -- on item 8 in the upon minutes on page 5. commissioner newhouse segal requested lower case r on item 11 and public comment. suggesting lower case s and i don't be if and wait, and adding the meeting schedule attachment to the resolution or, too, is missing finotice anything else i'm happy to communicate that to commission secretary. manager full and suggest that throughout where it references members present and voting it should indicate voting in favor. so it is clear. and the record. it is also just

daved pilpel. the special meeting contemplayed for january 30 the monday upon i don't know the time give me a time i will block that out. on the city budget over all, we are going to hear thursday afternoon about the mayor's budget instructions i participate the general fund deficit to be huge somewhere north of 100 million. i heard terror between 103 million. i suggest may be soft thenning of general fund source this is fiscal year i don't know that will require mid year changes but i believe there will be pressure from general fund departments publish prudent. realistic and right sized. prudent in maintenance and to the, realistic in how quick low people can be hire exclude projects deliver exclude right size in the terms of of staff, resource and programs. and this is slightly off topic i was not around i want to rescue noise magsz of mike hardman former member of the commission and suggest you adjourn today in his memory of thank you. thank you. peter, tuolumne river trust. i point made this yo

daved pilpel. i support debbie receiveiel and her work.stand that there is no public probable cause report at this time. i believe what allegations the staff has should be public. whether you find probable cause or not. i believe any arrangements made were legal at the time and any subscent change in law cannot be alied retroactively. if items were not disclosed on form 700 i asoul they have been correctd and were unintentional. i believe she has no prior enforcement history and should not be subject to penalty if any. we should bear in minds the proper obligation of department heads while in office and reasonable post and employee burdens in this case i think the burdens here. people should not have to retain private council at personal expense in this case it deterse good people for serve nothing city government. thank you for listening >> thank you. can you call the next speaker. >> yes. stand by. after this caller jumped in. after this caller we have one more. >> okay. welcome caller your 3 minuteings begins now. >> thank you, can you

daved pilpel again. commissioner segal. ka over the air to make a comment since her concern that she expressed the addresses include perhaps on the agenda to enabling clear for the members of commission and the public. i don't disagree in general but there may be specifics where revealing the location is not warranted or it does not apply and i am a bit correspond about the length of the short title and long title or staff recommendation for items i wanted to be careful about bulking up the agenda with long description this is have to be read and understand. and how that comports with the brown act and sunshine ordinance. as to brief meaningful descriptions of items i think it is appropriate in the staff report and also.ed to reenforce my previous point about including maps and photos of projects not just in the presentation but staff report to where the projects are and to develop more specific templets how items are packaged and prosecute voided to the decision. this is an evolving matter and we will continue to --ity rit