i am david asbin. we'll go in focus with steve forbes and rick and elizabeth and john and rich and sabrina. steve, who's right? nobviously the senator is right. regulations in the epa are not based on real science at all and done damage to the energy production and hurt the production and economy. and if there is opportunity entrepreneurs will find. it big government smother opportunities and entrepreneurs find and create opportunities. gina mccarty said if we cut carbon pollution, we will grow jobs, is there any evidence of that? >> you guys are going to want to boo me. i will admit when i first saw the question, i thought it was a tough one. i did research. turns out a ten state organization from maryland to maine entered into the understanding where they would try to cut carbon emegzs and going on for ten years and you will never believe the results, it turns out not only cut carbon emissions 25 percent but their economies worked twois as well as every otheritate that was not a part of this. it is r