with me now, cnn political analyst and former presidential adviser david gergen and former aide to generaleus, colonel peter mansour. colonel, do you believe that iraqi forceses have surrounded ramadi and are ready to retake it? >> no. i think we're in the very preliminary stages of gathering forces and it would be astonishing if iraqi forces were ready to retake the city. what they are doing is fighting further east in the twin villages of a hot bed of sunni radicalism and the place where saddam's intelligence services went to ground after 2003. in fact the brigade i commanded in 2003 and four fought a battle in the area. we called it bad karma. there is some progress in anbar province further east but i doubt that the battle for ramadi will begin any time soon. >> there's some sort of action. i'm looking at the glass half full here. let's talk about ash carter's comments. first, did he speak out of turn and might his comments have goated iraqi forces into action? >> thank goodness for ash carter speaking the truth the way he did. the united states public will support this will fully if t