david winslow, staff architect. this is a public initiated request for discretionary review of building permit application numbers 2019-0730.7350 and 2019.0730.7351 to demolish an existing one-story commercial building and instruction a three-story over-garage building with two dwelling units within an rh-2 zoning district. this was supposed to be on consent last week to memorialize a change, a change specifically that was requested and adhered to by the project sponsor was to reconfigure the third floor to create a 5 foot by 12 foot set back adjacent to 250 hugo street, the requester's property, and number two, to reduce the roof and provide a privacy screen that extends 2.5 feet above the side of the deck and additionally to provide frosted glass windows at the light wells adjoining the d.r. requester's property. therefore, the staff's recommendation was to also take the d.r. and approve as modified to memorialize these changes, and to my knowledge, the d.r. requester was satisfied with these. however, on the eve

david winslow, staff architect. this is a public initiated request for discretionary review of building permit application numbers 2019-0730.7350 and 2019.0730.7351 to demolish an existing one-story commercial building and instruction a three-story over-garage building with two dwelling units within an rh-2 zoning district. this was supposed to be on consent last week to memorialize a change, a change specifically that was requested and adhered to by the project sponsor was to reconfigure the third floor to create a 5 foot by 12 foot set back adjacent to 250 hugo street, the requester's property, and number two, to reduce the roof and provide a privacy screen that extends 2.5 feet above the side of the deck and additionally to provide frosted glass windows at the light wells adjoining the d.r. requester's property. therefore, the staff's recommendation was to also take the d.r. and approve as modified to memorialize these changes, and to my knowledge, the d.r. requester was satisfied with these. however, on the eve

. >> good afternoon commissioners, david winslow, staff architect . the item before you is a public initiated request for review of building permit number 209, excuse me. 2019.001 96. it's a constructed ground-level horizontal addition that would add 890 square foot second residential unit and additional car parking space and 2 roof decks to the two-story family house. the existing building is approximately 3611 where the building would be approximately 549 square feet in size. the existing building is a category a historical resource in 1936 as part of the eligible marinecorporation residential historic district .there are 4 the art requests as residents of the adjacent property to the west has withdrawn its opposition based on revisions to the project for revised plan number 21. dr request charlie kathy harding of the report mallorca away east of the proposed project are considering that it would significantlyreduce light in their home and the railyard . lack access to a space and is out of scale with the neighborhood . also learned it is to reduce

the project planner is david winslow. i think that may offer a clue as to what happened. in any case i wasn't notified, my neighbors weren't notified. i had a statement from my neighbor, mandy. number two. that is my neighbor, mandy, she put her name on the list for notification. she heard nothing from them either. we have been in regular touch about it. we didn't know. that is really all there is to say about it, i think. the opposition in the neighborhood. i would very much ask the board to take jurisdiction to allow me to appeal this decision and present my arguments at the appeal. that is all i have to say. thank you. >> thank you. >> we will hear from the attorneys for the determination holder. >> yes, thank you. john kevlin on behalf of the determination. >> can i pause your time to make disclosure on this? >> no you did not. go ahead. >> i hired -- i am a partner in the law firm that hired this law firm. their appearance will not have any effect on my decision. sorry i missed that disclosure. >> go ahead. thank you. very briefly. i don't think the facts are in disp