matthew green with dbi and chris buck be public works. the guidelines request you turn off all phones and electronics. no eating or drinking in the hearing room. the rowels of presentation for cases continued appellates permit hold and ares respondents given 3 minutes to present and people affiliated with them include comments within the 3 minutes. members of public not guilty affiliated have up to 3 minutes to address the board and no rebuttal during public comment. jurisdiction request 3 minutes each with no rebuttal you will get a warning 30 seconds before your time is up. 4 votes are required. if you have questions about requesting a rehearing the board rowels or schedules e mail the staff at board of appeals. public access are of importance to the board. sfgov.org is streaming live and the 8 to receive comment for each item on today's agenda will sfgovtv providing closed captioning for the meeting to watch on tv go to channel 78. tell be rebroadcast on friday on channel 26. a link is at sfgov.org/boa. public comment can be provide in

we'll hear from dbi. gi like to add if you do deny the appeal the building per mitt would be good for 360 days they would be eligible for automatic one time extension for another 360 days they have 2 years to decide before the permit expires whether they want to remove the deck or proceed with the variance to legalize it. >> is there action we can take that would extend that term beyond the one year extension and the year plus extension. >> i don't believe society length is based on the value of the work low value. >> thank you very much >> thank you. commissioners this matter is submitted. i think what is clear from the za in the best interest of the permit holder we deny the appeal to cancel their permit it would number their best interest to hold the permit. and then let nature take its course. any comments. i'm learning a lot fruand zoning add administrator and mr. green and members of the public and what i see upon once again is -- a look of communication and inability on members of the public's part

believe or not because that a company value g. quite bessie brownie doorbell no, once you start your dbi, not you. so i just dealing with i, you know, when you're from lucel, so talk to you my, me got a media audio. yes. a nice the middle with some of my stuff with people and some of my stuff to keep doors with them. but we keep missing that, this was all i do believe that when at the start a send them a, you know, in whitening, you know, you know, off a mike and then once you find out more the, you make more men don't believe me. that if really these credit in on your finance or not it or enough nationality. so 40 i go mean to they got a leaky gut feeling, 2 teeth chevron or but then i send them out a shovel here. mine can add for me to stand with b, a r o b boy appear limits shown into force and on voice. it's allergies he shouldn't, he was a civilian father. i just wanted to pull up when i mean to really events with his bottle such as order not been needed in the process of the desk of nissan amendment that check in the medical sick leave banked with equipment and to lead in on that s

once you start your dbi, not to soil object dealing with i, you know, when you're from lucel. so talk to my new guy for a nice a minute with some of my stuff with people with some of my stuff in the street with additional funding. i do believe where the stance is ascending normally a in whitening neuron. american in modest if a lot more to the main, but momento prelim your day if really these credit in on your finance or another officer, nationality, so 40 i will mean to la guardia. like a leaky gut feeling too deep or the sheer and all but then i send them on the order for shell here, my grand canal, middle stan with b. o. a boy appear limit soon to fours and boys appeared. so you shouldn't if was a civilian father, i saw you philip when i'm in. you've been serviced by the competitor in the middle of the possessive desk of this new minute. i'm check to say that it was if he needs to go back to the desk in touch with you the other because we said equipment him to lead in on the air. so non bad law, the believe medical. a joke coming to a company, gotch with with i louis, obvio

corey teague the za representatives planning and matthew green with dbi. the board

yeah. gee, quite bessie brownie doorbell no, once you start your dbi not to soil object dealing with i you know, when you're from diesel. so talk to my new guy for a nice and mental with some of my stuff with people and some of my stuff in the street with additional funding. i do believe where the stance is ascending. normally a in woke of whitening. no, i can in wonderful our more to the make but momento. believe me day if really these credit in on your finance or another office that finality. so 40 i will mean to the got a leaky gut feeling too deep or the chevron or not. and then i send them on the order for shovel here, my grand canal middle stan wasn't b. o, a boy appealing to force and on voice appeared. so if you shouldn't, if was a civilian father, i saw you philip. when i mean to leave you a bench with his bottle competitor in the middle of a possessive desk of nissan amendment, such as the said in the medical say he needs to go back to the desk in touch with me the other because we fit equipment and to lead in on the air. so non bad law, the believe medical a challenge in s

knowing susana jer, dbi not too. so i checked with daniel from your school. so talk to you my me got a, a nice a middle with some of my stuff with people with some of my stuff to do with additional funding. i do believe that ready stance it assemble normally a in whitening in europe. american in modest, if a lot more to the do you make but momento believe me that if really these credit in on your finance or another or enough as their nationality. so 40 i will mean to la guardia like a leaky gut feeling too deep or the sheer on or nothing going to send them on the order for shell here might incremental stampede. oh boy, appeal soon to fours and boys appeared if he shouldn't. if was a civilian, a squadron, i saw you philip when a man you've been so he says by the competitor in the middle of a possessive desk of this nice minute. i'm check the said in the medical say he needs to go back to the desk. i can get in touch with you the other because we did find the tend to lead in on the mean that s or non bad law. the believe michael with, with, with with, with i lo

once you start your dbi not to soil object dealing with i you know, when you're from lucel, so talk to you my new got all that. yeah. yeah. the audio yes. the lesson isa mental with some of my stuff with people. and some of my stuff in the street. a funny, i do believe wet at the stand stead, assemble normally a in mancha, whitening in iraq american and wondered if a lot more to the demand. but momento believe me that if really these credit in on your finance or another office, that finality, so 40 i will mean to la guardia level league. we need to keep the chevron or not. and then i send them out at the warner for several here. my grand canal for a minute can with b o. b, boy appear limit soon to fours and on voice repeated. so if you shouldn't, if was a civilian father, i saw you philip, when i'm in your pants as bilateral competitor, in the middle of a possessive desk of nissan amendment. check in the mail for say he needs to go back to the desk. you in touch with me the other because we said equipment and to lead in on the air. so non bad law. the believe michael with the challenge

power in a qu no, no, it was one of thousands of young people who took to the streets to protest on a dbi now by george woodall my, she'll be able to get me on layaway when id find out. yeah, for a national surgeon and up with general lewis i, we are cod but the army crackdown was brutal and bloody nor was arrested a peaceful protest put in prison for over a month. when he got out, he knew he wanted to take up arms against the regime. it was it as much it goes to can be more to can no, she didn't much, you know, as you know, not to get a minute for you when i was, you know, again gone it. you check people ah key. the gun is only locked in. oh shit, no she no heater one. ah ah, ah yes. who is that? he was elijah orange and a lot. i d as in george, i hope with all that you've media. i was he, i miss will be mind to all i saw was all she has a gala gina is initiated. okay. much. oh no, no. made his way to a training cap set up by ethnic cochin insurgence. but he found out the young men and women who come to the jungle from all over me on mall to learn how to fight. no, no, no. do. so i do. s

power in a qu no, no, it was one of thousands of young people who took to the streets to protest on a dbi now by my george woodall. my, she'll need to know if i or anyone are g, a national surgeon to end up with general louis highway or c. okay. but the army down was brutal and bloody no one was arrested, a piece of protest put in prison for over a month. when he got down, he knew he wanted to take up arms against the regime. it was too much of those to be more than 15 feet isn't much and as you know, not to get a minute for you know, you know, again gone it. you check people ged gun is on de la m jo. shit though. she makeeta one. ah. ah ah yes. who is? i was the lights on to know what i d as in george, an oak with ubida was he? i miss will be mine too. all i saw was talking with somebody a gala a gina is initiated. okay. me myself? no, no, made his way to a training cap set up by ethnic cochin insurgence. but he found out the young men and women who come to the jungle from all over me on mall to learn how to fight. no, no, no, do. so i do. so are not long genders are not gonna run the ch

no, no, it was one of thousands of young people who took to the streets to protest on a dbi now by my georgia. no, i do without my she'll need to get me away when i send out a national surgeon and up with general lewis or c. okay. but the army crackdown was brutal and bloody no one was arrested, a piece of protest and put in prison for over a month. when he got out, he knew he wanted to take up arms against the regime. it was too much of those to can be more than 50 feet isn't much you know, not to get a minute for you know, you know, again gone it. you check people ged gun as on they lock it in. oh, shit. no she makeeta one. ah ah ah, yes. who is i wish you a challenge and a lot of hope with ubida was he i miss will be mind to all i saw was daughters. i somebody a gala and she gave it a new she made okay with my child. no, no, made his way to a training cap set up by ethnic cochin insurgence. but he found other young men and women who come to the jungle from all over me on mall to learn how to fight. no, no, no. do so why does, how are not long genders are not in some runny comb with

power in a qu no, no, it was one of thousands of young people who took to the streets to protest on a dbi. now by my georgia, no, i do with all my she'll be able to get me on layaway when id send out a national search and end up with general lewis or c. okay. but the army crackdown was brutal and bloody no, no. was arrested a peaceful protest put in prison for over a month. when he got out. he knew he wanted to take up arms against the regime. it was it, as you know, much of those 2 can be more you can know much as you know, not to get a minute for you and you know, again, gone it. you check people ged gun is on de la m jo. shit. no, she makeeta one. ah, ah, ah yes. who is that? he was he later on to know what i d as in george, i hope with all that you've read yet. i was here will be mind to all i saw was doctors i somebody gala a g i b as in nancy. be it okay. be my to huh. no, no. made his way to a training cap set up by ethnic a chin insurgence. where he found out the young men and women who come to the jungle from all over me on mall to learn how to fight. no, no, no, do. so i do so a

this is appeal 22-052, peter poon versus dbi planning approval 331, 28th avenue. kenny and amy tseng. first floor bathroom and office and kitchenette and stair connection with first and second floor. permit 2022077177. the board voted 5-0 to continue to november 16. planning interesting department conduct an inspection of the property. the merit was after rescheduled for the hearing tonight on october 19th and buzz after dbi and planning did the inspection recommending revocation and permit holder agreed. we need a motion to grant the appeal and revoke the permit on the basis it was not properly issued. >> make that motion. >> okay. >> commissioner >> is there public comment on that motion? raise your hand? >> i don't see comment on that motion violent lopez. >> aye >> commissioner trasvina >> aye >> commissioner lemberg >> aye >> commissioner eppler yofrment that motion carries 5-0 and appeal is grant third degree concludes the hearing. thank you. >> you know, i remember when i was a teenager, they did i think it was on the grammys, boss scags narrated the san fr

we were shooting at the drone, st. dbi i to the little from the course. and if we hadn't shot the drone would have hit right on target. they would all hit their targets. yes, they were casualties. i saw them with my own eyes and we brought them all out. and it separates incidents. ukrainian authorities have released this voltage showing several police officers trying to shoot down a small drone in the skies of a key of using their rifles. ah, me apparently monies to hit the aircraft to make any change course was then seen crushing to earth and exploding on the road near by. several casualties were reported in the ukrainian capital after a series of russian air strikes of the past week. ukraine's even least a mobile app to help civilians take part in intercepting drones and missiles with people instructed to use the app to take pictures of incoming aerial threats and then send the data to the ukrainian military, which can then activates its air defenses against the targets instead of advising people to take shelter during an air strike, some ukraine offici

we were shooting at the drone, st. dbi i to the little from the course. and if we hadn't shot the drone would have hit right on target. they would all hit that targets. yes, there were casualties. i saw them with my own eyes and we brought them all out. let us separate incidents, ukrainian authorities have released this voltage is showing several police offices trying to shoot down a small drove in the skies of a key if ah, they apparently managed to hit the aircraft making it change cause it was then seen crushing and exploding on the road near by several casualties were reported in the ukrainian kept such a series of russian airstrikes over the past week. you cranes even really thin up to help people take part in intercepting drones and missiles with civilians in store to take pictures of incoming aerial threats and then send them to the ukrainian military which can then direct its air defenses at the targets. instead of advising people to take shelter during a narrate, some ukraine officials are calling on civilians to try to shoot down the projectiles

he committed eblth cal violations dbi went after him. a number of problems with his service. >> could you repeat that one more time. >> there were a number of issues with commissioner murphy in his private practice this lead to investigations on his work. but as we know by the city attorney's memo we than there are 4 ways that commissioner can be removed, in fact one is for cause commissioners, with that -- could be remove -- and there are at real commissioner this is can be removed there is a process in our charter where americans this condition victed of felonies. again, all these put in place, why does the administration feel like the existing removal process is in the adequate? >> as i said earlier in response to supervisor preston who asks the same question. it happened in the last for you years on the airport commission. both those processes took 6 to 9 months. they shut can't speak to commissioner ma zooma i don't remember naone. but had it was the sheriff the ethiks shut down work. hired council issue spends money and take months

he committed eblth cal violations dbi went after him. a number of problems with his service. >> could you repeat that one more time. >> there were a number of issues with commissioner murphy in his private practice this lead to investigations on his work. but as we know by the city attorney's memo we than there are 4 ways that commissioner can be removed, in fact one is for cause commissioners, with that -- could be remove -- and there are at real commissioner this is can be removed there is a process in our charter where americans this condition victed of felonies. again, all these put in place, why does the administration feel like the existing removal process is in the adequate? >> as i said earlier in response to supervisor preston who asks the same question. it happened in the last for you years on the airport commission. both those processes took 6 to 9 months. they shut can't speak to commissioner ma zooma i don't remember naone. but had it was the sheriff the ethiks shut down work. hired council issue spends money and take months

i am maria optima up up on it. bootleg flu de la foot lyric dbi longo navigate really did or millennium took our prom commendable kind of reply to pet madrid. but after all, i knew as shy con, suv uncle, continental coastal. he would call on apple to show level to condemn down. so mod pd. sions. people can go and i've had ellen. gov and you'll news have i will go to shulty more on plenty of, of children football. you'll know by providing little shows on direct that he was classic, i would call a general normal and up political condo, vale, new york city court desk, the senate bible canal, she ogletree and while the school children of the empire were learning about volcanoes, he knew value one of the worst instances of colonial repression of the postwar iraq was seeking place off the east coast of africa. one that didn't appear in the history books. for decades, madagascar had been colonized by the french half a century before. but by 947 people had had enough of the colonial regime. the democratic movement for malagasy rejuvenation was founded by 2 m p. 's, joseph russet on the left, an

dbi issued a stop work order and voted 4 to zer tow to grant the appeal and revoke the permit on the the permit was improperly issued they contained inaccurate information and evidence of demolition confirmed by the inspections the project am require a new certificate of appropriateness and new roar yard variance and new permit to capture all work on the property. commissioners, the historic preservation commission did not meet yesterday but we did instead have a hearing on the 22 ndz and did mote on september 21st i will give you that briefing now. they adopted a resolution supporting the board of supervisor's resolution urging it is rk and park develop signage regarding the dark history at sharp park. and doomentd recommendations for approval for a number of legacy business applications blazing saddles bike and rental tours on hyde street. the mariposa yacht club on terry francois boulevard. the larkin brother's tire company on south vaness avenue. hotel bo hem on columbus avenue. cafe labo on 24th street. club

will actually be another kind of recovering from goal they'd be, are basically paying attention to dbi. and what's coming into focus is really unpleasant. the alarming view, the jewel w two's right and sounding along as many of the meshes associated with cove it and now being relaxed. does that mean this rise can be reversed? oh no, i would be be tv and corbin are such complete like the covered bios as far as that spread as quickly as the baby back is not like the lord leg listen, it spreads but it can remain dormant for a while. so what's happening would still taking would the many people say the time to make as well, which also really does not. but that's, that's not going to, these are not moving. in fact the would be, the one is not calls in the other. these are 2 different problem it's, it's so glen, the global help insecurities that we are going to be facing as a good, let's think sound to me to stop us. a lot of things that they're all solutions that we can fix all the corporate technologies and all the, the wenches. but the big quickly focus over can be turned to tv, which is n

i had the experience of working for 20 years at dbi and planning for tracking systems and they still don't have it right and it's part of what is going to help restore and instill trust, the transparency, the immediacy, the access. there's several things i really love about it. the fact that when someone inputs something new it gets immediately notified to the investigator. that's will be crucial so things don't sit around. i asked the question that you asked and do a version in the department and make it accessible to us because i think it would be really helpful to answer some of our questions and keep on track. to that point i really like the top line where you see within the system of where things are. at some point i know that some of my fellow commissioners when we're looking at updates on things it's like it's helpful to know a time range and you can be halfway through something but if the end goal is a million miles away it's helpful to sort of think about what the timeframe is if that's possible. i know it's hard to know what you don't know and who you have left to do, but h

there is a requirement for notification for lead based paint to dbi and sunsetted more than two years ago so the ordinance requires this to sunset within two years and since we past this date we can remove the language from the code and then shifting of chapter numbering. this concludes my presentation. you also -- theres is also an attachment of -- i have that. okay. i call this the cliff notes of all the changes you're seeing and this has every single code that is presented to you in the ordinance. all of the sections associated to the change and a summary of what you will see in that section that changed. as you can see in the cliff notes many of them is correct numbering, correct references you know add a hyphen to one and family dwelling and all non technical and all ministerial. if you have any questions i am here to answer any questions that you may have. >> okay. i do have a couple of questions for you. the first one is what is the department's usual way to get this out to the contracting community in terms of the changes just because folks refer to certain things by the numbe

i am the compliance office for dbi as in my role as integrity office and monitoring the compliance program and we have a compliance committee which includes members of key functions within dph that support the compliance officer. next slide. we we procedures that promote the commitment to compliance and address risk. next slide. employees must feel comfortable reporting internally and organization should have multiple reporting avenues such as reporting directly to the compliance officer or a anonymous hot line so we have open lines of communication and have a confidential hot line and anyone can report a concern or issue and they can remain anonymous if they desire. we have a dph email and we get compliance issues and concerns directly. i receive them and so does our deputy director. next slide please. education and training. all employees must receive on fraud and laws and the compliance program and we provide annual training through online training modules. we do targeted training as needed if we have an area that has anne issue and we can do target training for groups and distribute ne

dbi code and the different sorts of keds. so it seems like it is a catch all terms how different the departments interact with this body. but exists for a reason and there for a reason. i think that this requires more discussion. if we go in the direction or not. i'm a bit disheartened that a decision was made a machining before this kim you to. this is something this i foal like dillows our policy making authority in ways. and does not the preferred way for us to make policy decisions that is another thing that i think needs addressed in the future. at this point i would be in favor of supporting the fare increases and the first 2 pieces of the policy and severing the board of appeals piece of it. >> okay. thank you that is very clear. other questions director cajina. >> no that's it. thank you. >> okay. my questions have been requested boy clothes i love to ask for a motion. from one of my colleagues if someonements to make it. >> madam chair i would be happy it make a motion we approve the item with the exception of the bo

dbi issued a stop work order and voted 4 to zer tow to grant the appeal and revoke the permit on the basis the permit was improperly issued they contained inaccurate information and evidence of demolition confirmed by the inspections the project am require a new certificate of appropriateness and new roar yard variance and new permit to capture all work on the property. commissioners, the historic preservation commission did not meet yesterday but we did instead have a hearing on the 22 ndz and did mote on september 21st i will give you that briefing now. they adopted a resolution supporting the board of supervisor's resolution urging it is rk and park develop signage regarding the dark history at sharp park. and doomentd recommendations for approval for a number of legacy business applications blazing saddles bike and rental tours on hyde street. the mariposa yacht club on terry francois boulevard. the larkin brother's tire company on south vaness avenue. hotel bo hem on columbus avenue. cafe labo on 24th street. club deluxe on haight street. and that concludes those updates and rep

that's a priority in working with the planning department and dbi and constituents on how we could accelerate adu applications permitting and construction. as mentioned, we created adu pilot program in district four back in 2020 and it was just -- the planning department created it with asian inc. as a partner and that provided technical assistance to 30 homeowners in the sunset that wanted to take the first step in taking an adu but we're facing barriers so that was successful. lamar from asian inc. is here today and i sponsored the legislation earlier this year to create the housing development for homeowners so that would expand the adu resource and technical assistance program citywide and also expand it from adus to duplexes and fourplexes as allowed by sb9, so i know the planning department is, has been working on launching that new program. we found that homeowners are very interested, particularly asian homeowners in my district but i think citywide next panned tlg homes to meet the needs of their extended family to increase the value of their home but it's very expensive and the perm