posted on the dbi website. last page number 9 we need the discuss various times updates to the accessible entrance program and concrete program which you'll be hearing more about that in the near future that's our presentation and certainly ready to take questions if you have any. >> hi, thank you steve i don't have any questions but wanted to express my gratitude and our gratitude for our work and the groups work, i.e., personally and think our whole commissioner relies on the code citizens advisory committee we don't have the time often to take the deep dive into the issues you guys do i joined some of our meetings and appreciate the discussions we look to our recommendations we are then considering some of the issues so i think there is with great value in the group and i'm the one i suggested that item sorry to drag you up here but to understand the values they're giving to us i think that is are. >> participate steve is a structural engineer and so am i i value steve's opinion and contributions to the go u

we have lots of things for dbi to do. they got housing to get approved and other projects and i think that having them of course we want them to continue doing the education, but having being enforcement arm for federal law which we do not have to have them in that role i think not particularly helpful. so, that's a foreshadowing. for today what i hope the committee will do is pass the-forward the ordinance in front of you to full board with positive recommendation if so inclined. i'm also hoping and city attorney can figure which order these things need to get done, but i think we ought to also probably send back to building inspection commission another version of this that extends the deadline at least to the end of this year, so probably involves or i suggest the committee if open to it, that you duplicate the file and make the amendment to the duplicated file to change the date which is june 30, 2024 and duplicated file to december 31, 2024 in the duplicated file and that you all send that off to building inspection

and know i never wanted to pick up the phone didn't to call dbi so (clearing throat) my tenants haveually moved out couldn't handle the noise and i saw what was going on next door i'm sure the department knows of this they extent the ground floor to the retaining wall and runs down the back to pacific and broadway no backyard they're building is in line with my building. they said they're going to put in a unit down there and preceded to put in a deck above that and the next floor up is more work on that. the light well into the two buildings four feet wide and the both the light well, that blocks all the light next door and i was expecting my attorney to be here but couldn't make it he's out of town but i'll have my attorney for future hearings i want to be notified. and i just feel that um, he talks about being a victim he's not a victim owe knows exactly what is going on (bell ringing) and the scaled engineer he supposedly hired was after the fact and every time i went theretofore was was a sign on the wall stop work and that's all i have to say.. thank you very much. >> at the th

i would hope that dbi would us on that. i think we reach out to the permitting search through e mails mr. chan did. e mailed to see the process for changing the street numbers. for the properties. and we got some misleading some -- conflicting information. but we do certainly would go forward with doing upon changing the street numbers, >> thank you. >> yea. >> commissioner swig? >> i gallon in the same direction. get clearer. were you the architect, agent? architect. >> architect. >> there was a 311 notice it is site permit was there a meeting? there was a preapplication and meeting. tell me about it and did the neighbor attends, was the neighbor invited. all the neighbors were invited. there was a chart look of what most low occurrence are and those concerns were shown to the brief as well. how many people showed up? >> probably 11 or 12. >> yea. >> and the neighbor on -- both sides? >> on the -- on the if you look at the building on the right side. not the appellate? >> they did. >> they did. and the people on the other

it wasn't you know, dbi saying we're going to cut this budget. it was based on the budget instructions and understood. so it will be reduced in this upcoming proposed budget, correct? yeah thank you, and i think that, the next question is for mlcd. we appreciate it. thank you. and i think that the question is the emergency rental assistance, that was we were told that it's going to be reduced by 50% from $46.5 million. sure i'm brian chu, director of community development for mayor's office of housing and community development. so, we have three sources for our current erap program, one source was a one time, $10.5 million from what we call prop i. another source was a $32 million, one time mayoral enhancement, and then the third source is an ongoing work order from, h'sh, which is about a little over $12 million, so we are coming to the final spend down of the 32 million and the 10.5 million, we probably won't be spending all of that out at the end of this year. so we plan to roll that over into next year, and we also will have some unspent mone

, and here the most interesting thing began, both the dbi and the prosecutor, who accordingly supervisesoceeding, refused to close the case a. because roman has nothing to do with this case, he is nobody there, we went to court, appealed this decision, again the court obliged us to properly consider our petition, we were again refused, again with the same wording that chervinskyi the novel has nothing to do with it to this proceeding, this proceeding is factual based on the fact of the person's failure to appear before the military unit, that is, the proceeding is factually related to the novel, but it is not related to the novel. somehow, ms. lyudmyla, this whole story with this court hearing, with the other two court cases, it, well, at least looks like some kind of political or personal persecution of the colonel, what do you think about this, what roman chervinsky himself actually says? roman hryhorovych has repeatedly stated that he sees this as political persecution. for those things that were voiced by him at a certain time for the general public, for those operations that he cond

it wasn't you know, dbi saying we're going to cut this budget. it was based on the budget instructions and understood. so it will be reduced in this upcoming proposed budget, correct? yeah thank you, and i think that, the next question is for mlcd. we appreciate it. thank you. and i think that the question is the emergency rental assistance, that was we were told that it's going to be reduced by 50% from $46.5 million. sure i'm brian chu, director of community development for mayor's office of housing and community development. so, we have three sources for our current erap program, one source was a one time, $10.5 million from what we call prop i. another source was a $32 million, one time mayoral enhancement, and then the third source is an ongoing work order from, h'sh, which is about a little over $12 million, so we are coming to the final spend down of the 32 million and the 10.5 million, we probably won't be spending all of that out at the end of this year. so we plan to roll that over into next year, and we also will have some unspent mone

oh that's dbi sorry. it's an annual fee. and you kind of voluntarily add yourself to the vacancy registry or it's complaint based. okay. so somebody complains, then you'll get added to the registry. and that's like a set amount of what, 780 something i believe. and then if the let's say the properties sit empty for a while, and they're on that registry when coming off of that registry, do the landlords have to kind of bring it up to code before releasing it? or now the new tenant would have to lease it, releases it, have to bring it up to code. it doesn't specify. yeah, yeah. so just to clarify, the commercial vacancy tax which the treasurer and tax collector's office, they were the ones who enforce on that one. so there's a, a form that is sent out every year to both the property owner and the tenant. information also has to be filled out. so if you keep a commercial space vacant for more than 182 days in a calendar year , then you'd have to be subject to the tax, and so and again, it was based on the linear linear feet. an

and this is the man dbi leesville achieve that. money is a good leader with a strong determination. he has done what he promised stood with a if you want to approach development to everyone. you got a slick publicity machine works over time to market because it is moody present to him as a decisive leader who has delivered his capital across the image analyst see as made him the beach, if he's most powerful weapon to all of our friends, to fulfill the dream is the developed india every minute. every single 2nd of my life is dedicated to this country. the economies one is will these media achievements, india has become the was 5th largest economy. and it's projected to become the 3rd biggest by 2027. but why g d p is going up? some economy, see it's only benefiting a very small segment of the population. unemployment is on the rise and the informal sector, which accounts for up to 90 percent of employment is struggling to this. so this behind, the multi machine is easy to do to political ideology, which promotes hinduism as the domain in political and cultural force in india. in janu

so i went this morning at dbi records and i looked at the demo calcs, and you can see those two there on the 317 be to be. and if the calcs had been adjusted at least twice, which they should have been since 2009, this thing would have been a demolition. i think it looks like a demolition. if you look at it closely, i don't see how anybody using common sense could say it isn't. and that one sold for, 5.7 and 21. they both sold during the pandemic and started at 1.3. and the other calcs are a little strange. they make no sense. they say they removed 83, but they say 24ft of horizontal. i don't know, it's the calcs needed to be fixed. they weren't fixed in. i know you're trying to fix them now, and i really hope you do. and i hope you codify the flat policy at short range in the housing element. 8.3.2 and also i have one more question is planning now in charge of intake, not dbi? i was just curious about that. and that's it. there's my words for the minutes. thank you. sorry for the chaotic presentation. any other members in the chambers wishing to submit general public comment? if not,

this building had a number of dbi issues. i asked in advance of this meeting if there were any current outstanding dbi issues and i was told there is not none. there was a situation last summer, it sounds like the elevator was out for more than a month, possibly two or three months. sxl that there is some measures that the provider has taken to ensure that they don't have a problem with elevator going out of service for a long time in the future. and specifically, i asked questions around, you know, is there issues with this building owner completing maintenance in a timely manner? and i was given the response the responsibility of maint pence for anything above 5,000 is on provider, sorry on the landlord and so i, i requested also to know what items are still expected to be completed by the end of fiscal year. i was given this list repair and replacement of security equipment to add cameras covering blind spots to the roof of the property and ventilation system to the ground floor. and so, i just wanted to acknowledge that t

going to zoom out before i talk more about thees grants, i'm going to zoom out and give an overview of dbi's budget. as an enterprise department we're budgeted by the fees. we fees are set by determining the reasonable cost of providing our services. the majority of our budget is non-discretionary with labor costs for the biggest chunk. when our revenues are down, we don't have a lot of opportunity to prim trim our costs. what it shows here is the gray line in the middle is our expenditures which have risen mostly as labor costs have risen. the orange line is our revenues which dropped significantly during and after the pandemic and the yellow line that spikes is our reserves which went up significantly during the boom years and have been mostly used up in the past few years to fill our gaps. the projection is our reserves will fall below 10 million in the next few years. i was asked to talk specifically about our fees and fee study. our fees are established by eye fee study to analyze our costs and sets a model for charging fees. we last cuttinged a fee study from 2015 which lowered most of

later time is how what happens after a fire in many way system the people, this advises people to daul dbi. my i'm wonder figure they are available 24/7 for people who are adviseed call them after a fire that destroys their lives in a second. i don't know if you than but. >> i 24 hour response, no. >> so. the answer is, no. this was on the weekend. of course and that would not have worked. okay. really appreciate your report and the work of the fires. commissioner nakajo do have you questions? >> thank you very much. president morgan. i know the department adjusted. i'm just curious as to the issue of what that is. why did this help? or is this common? you want to comment, chief? >> could be 3 versions and i'm not sure which is. so, the report being issued for 3 different locations for fire have not got to the bottom of that yet i will check. for the addition of the third street was a misstatement that carried over there was a fire the previous night at that intersection and i believe it was top of mind and got reported that was quickly corrected. third piece would be the am change in radi

collaborations with to in order to get things done for example, is the mayor's office of disability, dbipw and sometimes it's puc. and then if we got fortunate enough that we will have to also talk to pg and e. so i will do all of that, and i will be able to pick up the phone and also ask with the support and help with all the amazing talent we have in the planning department and also, each of your supervisors districts, your amazing legislative a is also be able to really be helpful to, chime in to, to get a collective processes of understanding where are there a lot of issues. but then we need to distill down to what are the most critical culprit. and then we need to focus on, bringing them down. bring the barrier down. thank you, thank you. well, i am very excited to be supporting your nomination, and i just want to express my gratitude to you for being willing to serve again in this new role. and with all your experience on so many different city commissions, is it? i think it'll it'll be such an asset to the planning department that you'll be able to understand the inner workings of

we obviously have regular conversations with other agencies, particularly dbi, but also most cdd and we've reached out in separate meetings to environmental groups, contractors, business representatives to basically share our ordinance as the task force was developing it. and get feedback, particularly in the definitional phase, to figure out what what language to use to make sure we capture the intent that the task force was sharing with us. but grounding, grounding that intent in in existing legislation or in existing regulations and then finally, we've got a couple more outreach opportunities ahead. a chinese media roundtable coming up, later, i think that's in april. or is it later this month? later this month? that's right, and then meeting with the chinese chamber of commerce in middle of may. so we've done a lot of work, also with the batf to identify additional stakeholders that need to be involved in this process. and then the themes we've heard back are ones that you will now recognize preserving affordable housing, protecting tenants, educating residents about these upcomi

we're currently parallel processing the permits at dbi and hope to have it under construction before the end of 2024. so this is a live project before we get to that, though, the c we are seeking today is to allow for the demolition of an unpermitted dwelling unit in the existing building at the site. the existing 9000 square foot, two story commercial building was constructed in 1972 and has been occupied by various sales office and business uses over the years. it is typically been broken into multiple tenant spaces. a previous commercial tenant of the building, eco imprints, occupied a suite on the second floor over the years. the business has. owner john borg would sleep over at the site so he wouldn't have to drive home. his principal residence is in bolinas, where he lives with his family, and he vacated the property in 2022 when his commercial lease expired. oh, yeah. thanks, due to the technical, standards, it was determined that this 738 square foot space was a you.do, although it never served as any tenant or household's principal residence and was always associated with th

dbi reviewed the plans and approved. construction is performed with pg&e involvement. the permit area is approximately 11 by 40 feet or 414 square feet. the term of the license is approximately 10 years or the remainder of honeybee lease for the private premises or until december 8, 2034 should the licensee continue under one of its options at the restaurant, we would then bring this license back to be approved for additional term. the license fee is actually yearly not monthly at $1200 per year and 3 percent annual adjustment. i thought we sent revisions for that in the resolution, but apparently those were not received and or taken, so i do have to ask for revisions to the resolution at page 1, line 1. page 1, line 7. and page 2, line 8 that the monthly be changed to yearly. and we ask for your positive recommendation. >> so, we are looking at--i think that is a significant value discrepancy or difference from $1200 monthly base fee to-same amount, $1200 of a annual fee. >> license fee,s yes. >> license fee. can you walk us through a little more, just- >> how we got

i'm denise a student of ecology dbi logic environment i wanted to um, thank phil for his report and i appreciate the location of the in ram was passed and approved by the commission in ri68, and safety is paramount i urge you rec and park to plant local native plants from other parts of california or the world because a you may have heard there are episcopal narrates that provide us with food and that's why california encourages us to plant local plants any other comments on the general manager's report for those own the web e comment on the general manager's report unmute the first speaker. >> hi this is carol from san francisco district. thank you for san francisco rec and park report on the mclaren park by removing the dye evasive trees and adding plants md 5 mclaren park a part of the biological heritage doing everything we can to improve the health of mclaren park and the eco system are healthy we're healthier please continue ma clarion park and for the celebration please consider adding left lane trees and plants instead of adding the one hundred and fifty trees that the people

the fact is that poor disabled and elderly tenants have no other options other than dbi that may or may not result in novs and if novs were suppose to fix the issue, then the residents at cadillac hotel did not have to wait five years to get the elevators fixed. all landlords deserve dignity and all landlords are responsible for providing safe and dig fied places for the people that they collect rent from. that's why we stand can the union and faith in action, behind tenants with serious life and safety issues the right to slum lords? to do we should not have a two-tier system with tenants getting rights while nonprofit having no rights. and by the way, leonard will draft some legislation and her office instead of doing for the plan. >> thank you, next speaker, please. >> taken a long time for these funds to get disbursed. seniors and people with disability are trapped in their rooms because they don't have kitchens or living room, the only fresh air we get is outside. people don't have living room so they need to socialize outside. when the elevator is down, they lose their independenc

cheeks, that does not foreclose that when this project is built, that somebody may come and go to dbind say, i would like to have the privacy screen increased and height, it does not prevent that from happening. the six feet would be permitted at the rear. okay. so the second books are out later. yeah. we are concerned about privacy regarding the bedrooms, as mr. commissioner brown and couple itemized and, leave the rest for the future people to work out with each other. okay, commissioners, there is a motion that has been seconded, to take dr. and approve a three unit configuration with three separate open space decks with a six foot privacy wall that directly faces a bedroom on that motion. commissioner williams, i, commissioner brown i commissioner imperial i commissioner copple i. commissioner moore i and commissioner. president diamond i so move commissioners that motion passes unanimously 6 to 0. zoning administrator would say i'll close the public hearing on the variance, and i likely to have my arm twisted on this scenario. i will i will point out that the interior, the privat

. >> dbi? >> good evening, commissioners. birmingham representing the building department with mr. corey i concur no in the evidence offered and the hearing should not be granted. >> okay. thank you, any public comment on this item anyone in the room? >> anyone on zoom please raise your hand okay. i don't any public comment commissioners it is submitted. >> let's start at the hear what commissioner swig says. >> my feeling the standard has not been metaphor this been offered and no manifest injustice i see, so my motion to deny the request for the hearing request. >> and didn't meet the standards for a rehearing. >> do i hear any further comment on this motion? >> seeing none. >> okay. we have a motion from commissioner swig to deny this based on no new evidence foreman festive injustify. >> president lopez, aye. >> vice president lemberg, aye. >> that carried 5 to zero and the requests are denied i want to make an announcement i believe the sfpuc represent is higher would you like to continue this to may 8th we having a high volume of people? >> oh, you want to stay? okay. all rig