. >> all right we'll leave it there thank you both diane swonk, and our own steve liesman. >>> my next guest is optimistic, saying it's increasingly likely october marks the low. joining in is urian timer. it's great to see you. you know, in light of the weakening macro back drop, what do your observations actual you? >> the market has been -- whether it was the recession or, you know, the drawdown in liquidity as the treasury replenishes its cash balance at the fed. the market has now been in a state of limbo, if you will. and then, of course followed a mini bubble during 2021, when the fed pushed rates way, way down, and kept them there for a long time. it created an asset bubble it elevated the market above the trend channel, so it's good we fell back into it, but 18 months is a long time, ten months of declining, another eight months of just sitting around doing nothing. june of last year was the momentum low, and october was the final low. so i think the market is just getting impatient. the revisions are starting to get better the estimates could be all wrong, but the consensus e