national senior crisis response advisor donna tyler rivera actually responded to those numbers and what you said is while all admissions of responsibility by the u.s. led coalition for civilian casualties are welcome burn the coalition remains deeply in denial about the devastated scale of the civilian casualties caused by their operations in both iraq and syria so an investigation by amnesty international and air wars who as an independent watchdog group reveal that more than 600 civilians were killed in the 2017 rocka offensive alone so when we were doing the big lie you were told when the boat was 7 going bottom and we're just going to murder of a of people and then we're totally done and terrorism is over right so when's very good that's essentially what it sounds like after 20 years but. they went in there and you're talking about 1600 civilians and for every one of those 3 for family members to see this. devastation and you know we're going to leave that that's was so funny. they claim 1300 and as you pointed out 1600 just one off and when you write when you go to people outside o