dorsey; ronen and safai. dorsey; ronen and safai. dorsey; ronen and safai. dorsey; ronen and safai. banners on up to 200 city-owned poles within that cultural district; and to codify the existing exemption of the soma pilipinas - pilipinas - pilipinas - pilipinas - district;and affirming the planning department's determination under the california environmental quality act. act. ordinance waiving the fee required under public works code, section 724.1(b), for temporary street space occupancy permits on san francisco streets on november 25-27,december 2-4, and december 9-11, 2022, to promote sidewalk sales of merchandise season; and affirming the planning department's determination under the california environmental quality act. thank you, madam city clerk please call the roll. on item 12 and 13. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> xhrnldz, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> super

dorsey; ronen and safai. dorsey; ronen and safai. dorsey; ronen and safai. dorsey; ronen and safai. banners on up to 200 city-owned poles within that cultural district; and to codify the existing exemption of the soma pilipinas - pilipinas - pilipinas - pilipinas - district;and affirming the planning department's determination under the california environmental quality act. act. ordinance waiving the fee required under public works code, section 724.1(b), for temporary street space occupancy permits on san francisco streets on november 25-27,december 2-4, and december 9-11, 2022, to promote sidewalk sales of merchandise season; and affirming the planning department's determination under the california environmental quality act. thank you, madam city clerk please call the roll. on item 12 and 13. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> xhrnldz, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> super

so much chair dorsey. i had a question about something in your presentation about the shuttle service for seniors and disabled. is the thinking this we will you know put whatever monies needed into the city's paratransitit or are we thinking we will create a separate system for treasure island. >> the early phase of the treasure island program. the treasure island transportation implementation program approve in the 2011 envisioned on island circulation shuttle. and ac transit to the east bay. while the demand is low, because there are fewer people living on the island we thought this would be a way to use state funds to initiate that service. >> you said that it would serve both sudden fran and the east bay? this is only in island shuttle? >> it is on island yerba buena and treasure and the east bay. we could talk about whether it should also go to san francisco. i'm just questioning. i'm asking a question. why we are creating a new shuttle and decide third degree in 2011. and tell serve just the island t

>> chan. >> supervisor dorsey? >> mandelman. >> supervisor engardio. >> mandelman. >> supervisor mandelman. >> mandelman. >> supervisor melgar. >> chan. >> supervisor peskin. >> walton. >> supervisor preston. >> walton. >> supervisor ronen. >> walton. >> supervisor safai. >> walton. >> supervisor stefani. >> mandelman. and supervisor walton. >> walton. >> no member again reached the threshold to be the president. chan, 2, mandelman 4 and walton has 5 votes. menames on the roster. the forced ballot is imnan there are 3 in nomination with supervisors walton, chan and mandelman. in nominations. on the question for the fourth round. supervisor chan. >> chan. >> supervisor dorsey. >> mandelman. >> supervisor engardio. yeoman man. >> supervisor mandelman. >> mandelman. >> supervisor melgar. >> chan. >> supervisor peskin. >> walton. >> supervisor preston. >> walton. >> supervisor ronen. >> walton. supervisor safai. >> walton. >> supervisor stefani. >> mandelman. and supervisor walton. >> walton. >> supervisor chan has 2,

dorsey; ronen and safai. dorsey; ronen and safai. dorsey; ronen and safai.y; ronen and safai. banners on up to 200 city-owned poles within that cultural district; and to codify the existing exemption of the soma pilipinas - pilipinas - pilipinas - pilipinas - district;and affirming the planning department's determination under the california environmental quality act. act. ordinance waiving the fee required under public works code, section 724.1(b), for temporary street space occupancy permits on san francisco streets on november 25-27,december 2-4, and december 9-11, 2022, to promote sidewalk sales of merchandise season; and affirming the planning department's determination under the california environmental quality act. thank you, madam city clerk please call the roll. on item 12 and 13. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> xhrnldz, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor

i'm supervisor dorsey. you to john carroll of clerk's office for staffing today's committee meeting and thanks also to sfgovtv and matthew igno of the sfgovtv team for broadcasting today's meeting. >> thank you acting chair. the board of supervisors and committee are convening hybrid meetings. the board recognizes equitable public access is essential and will take public comment as follows. public comment taken on each 4 item on today's agenda. those attending in person room 250 will be allowed to speak first and then we'll take public comment from those on the telephonic line. those watching 26, 28, 78 or 99 or watching the meeting through sfgovtv.org the public comment call in screen is streaming across your screen at this time. the number is 415-655-0001. when you are prompted enter the meeting id for today's meeting that is 24846961927. press the pound symbol two times. when you are connecting you will hear the meeting discussion but your line will be muted and in listening mode. when your item comes up

supervisor dorsey. >> supervisor mandelman i want to thank supervisor mar for four years ago for serving excellently for working along with the staff trying to do and doing tonight especially you made a mark around the city's commitment to the environment to advancing is environmental agenda around transportation and um, you know, often i observed some of the things you've be able to do i wish i was doing that so um, i outcome, you know, wanted to commend and thank you for that and being could i person and someone that i could in disagreement never been personal always been like that is okay. so i issue wish you all the best you'll continue to serve for the rest of our life. thank you. >> supervisor mandelman and . >> commissioner chan and supervisor dorsey express any growled four leadership on public safety and role my work with you and your office on those issues preceded my time during the couple of years with the police department and had the opportunity to work with you and appreciated the excellent questions and detail you brought to things like police staffing and violence during

. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> mrpd, aye. >> supervisor safai eyes. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton, aye. >> there are 11 i's without objection this ordinance is passed unanimously (gavel) and madam city clerk, call item 37. >> supervisor ahsha safai, term ending january 31, 2025, to the golden gate bridge, highway and transportation district board of directors. (clerk of the board) through 42 specific to three 7 was recommended and supervisor ahsha safai, term ending january 31, 2025, to the golden gate bridge, highway and transportation district board of directors. (clerk of the board) >> thank you i'd like to entertain a motion to excuse xhrmd seconded by supervisor mandelman. >> on the motion to excuse supervisor safai supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> su

and seconded by supervisor dorsey. >> on the minutes for december 13th presented supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor engardio, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> you supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor walton, aye. >> and supervisor chan, 11 i's. >> thank you without objection the minutes are approved after public comments at presented (gavel) madam city clerk, to the unfinished business unfinished business unfinished business project area to increase bulk limits on block 2 of zone one of the tranbay redevelopment project area (assessor's parcel block no. 3739, lot no. 014 >> thank you i don't see none on the roster please call the roll. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor engardio, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton, aye. >> and supervisor chan there are 11 i's.

and seconded by supervisor dorsey. >> on the minutes for december 13th presented supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor engardio, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> you supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor walton, aye. >> and supervisor chan, 11 i's. >> thank you without objection the minutes are approved after public comments at presented (gavel) madam city clerk, to the unfinished business unfinished business unfinished business project area to increase bulk limits on block 2 of zone one of the tranbay redevelopment project area (assessor's parcel block no. 3739, lot no. 014 >> thank you i don't see none on the roster please call the roll. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor engardio, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton, aye. >> and supervisor chan there are 11 i's.

one of the tyre nichols in new jersey is carl dorsey. carl dorsey was unarmed.n indisputable fact. no one disputes the fact that carl dorsey was unarmed when he was shot and killed at point-blank range by detective rod simkins. in new jersey, we have this independent prosecutor bill where if a police -- local police person kills someone, then the state attorney general must take over that investigation. the state attorney general had this case for two years and we did not hear anything publicly posted this week, almost on the same day that the officers that kill tyre nichols were charged, that day the grand jury came back with no bill. no indictment for the officer that killed carl dorsey. so today at 11:00 a.m., together with the family, members of the carl dorsey, their attorney, we're going to have a press conference at 11:00 a.m. in front of the federal building in newark 970 broad st to demand that the u.s. attorneys, the united states attorneys for the district of new jersey launch a civil rights investigation into the death of carl dorsey. amy: larry hamm

on item 47. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> and supervisor dorsey, aye. >> and supervisor mandelman, aye. >> and supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor melgar aids. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton, aye. >> there are 11 i's how (gavel) madam city clerk, call 20 years as leader of the house democratic caucus, and 35 years of dedicated service to the city and county of san francisco and to the united states of america. madam city clerk. >> supervisor stefani like to continue this to the next meeting speaker pelosi office asked we continue it to iron from their office can be present. >> motion to january 5th supervisors and seconded by supervisor dorsey madam city clerk, on the motion. >> on the motion to january 10th fy23, supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor s

supervisor dorsey? >> thank you. i'm new guy here and know we have been in one community meet and my reaction when i was like he is not retiring is he. i'm glad that is not the case we are honoring you that was my reaction the possibility you may to the continue. keep doing great work and looking forward to working with you. the nishgd i representative you serve so well. thank you. why thank you for your service to the people of the city and county of san francisco and if you would like to share a few words with the board of supervisors and the public the floor is yours. >> i will say it is an honor to be recognized. i have the privilege of working with a lot of dedicate exclude smart people who are often unrecognized and under appreciated. so despite the nice words i'm hesitant to celebrate because we have a language way to go. >> humble and lovely and share it with your colleagues who are under appreciated we are trying to express thank you to supervisor mandelman some of this appreciation through you. with that! [

on item 47. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> and supervisor dorsey, aye. >> and supervisor mandelman, aye. >> and supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor melgar aids. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton, aye. >> there are 11 i's how (gavel) madam city clerk, call 20 years as leader of the house democratic caucus, and 35 years of dedicated service to the city and county of san francisco and to the united states of america. madam city clerk. >> supervisor stefani like to continue this to the next meeting speaker pelosi office asked we continue it to iron from their office can be present. >> motion to january 5th supervisors and seconded by supervisor dorsey madam city clerk, on the motion. >> on the motion to january 10th fy23, supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor s

nichols and we'll have to see what happens with the other four. >> all right, and sergeant dorsey, i want you to listen to this message from the police chief. you heard it as we played it earlier in the show. what did you think about how she directly answered this, really speaking directly to the camera and talking to the community? >> well, i think what she is trying to express is her discomfort, her disgust, if you will, with the way her officers conducted and comported themselves in the midst of whatever this was, trying to take mr. nichols into custody for what, pleaing from a driving infraction, it makes no sense and i believe she can relate to that black mother as i can being the mother of four black men and so she did the right thing and she acted swiftly. >> and i think we have bernarda with us. i want to ask about, you know, what these officers could be facing and what the prosecutors are weighing here. on the one hand there's a lot of public interest in this case. they are bracing potentially for really explosive reaction from the community. what are prosecutors weighing, i

as well as congratulate supervisor dorsey on his election. he has been a tremendous asset to the body and i'm sure many of you appreciated working with him the past couple months and look forward to the great work he will do. i want to welcome supervisor engardio and congratulate you on being a part of this body in the work you all will do for the city of san francisco. it is definitely has been a challenging few years. and i think i have not been back in the chamber in the past couple years because of the pandemic it is grit to be here and welcome the guests and family members of members of the board of supervisors. our stay is an amazing city. and at the end of the day, the people here the leaders of the city represent the very best san francisco from all aspects and i think that as we move forward with the important w that we will have to do my hope is that this gives us an opportunity to come together like never before to work together. to think about the decisions that we make to put the people of the city before a lot of the petty polit

supervisor dorsey. >> supervisor matt dorsey: thank you, president peskin and i will accept responsibility for not accepting the fast draw on the request to speak. i did want to address on the merits of president cindy elias. i wanted to say this is going to be so far my political career this will be the nicest and appreciative no vote. i just wanted to express to president elias, my appreciation for her dedication. i will say if there is a commission that deserves salaries is a police commission as much as any other. police commission meetings for those who haven't been through them are often long and contentious. you are only seeing the public portion of it because there is a lot that goes on behind-the-scenes in closed sessions and there is not a single person that hasn't said that president elias is a hard worker. this precedes me in the city attorney's office and wayne who was a mentor to me, an lgbtqia plus member with harvey milk whose desk i sit on. who created a great lgbtq plus community. i believe that commissioner elias is worthy of being a commissioner, but there are times tha

by dorsey. mr. clerk call the roll on the item. why commissioner chan. >> aye. >> commissioner dorsey. >> aye. >> commissioner engardio. >> aye. >> commissioner mandelman. >> aye. >> commissioner melgar. >> aye. >> commissioner peskin. >> aye. >> commissioner preston. >> aye. >> commissioner ronen. >> aye. >> commissioner safai. >> aye. >> commissioner stefani. >> aye. >> commissioner walton. >> aye. >> there are 11 aye's it is approved. >> thank you mr. clerk. call item 3. >> item 3 approve the minutes of december 13 of 22 meeting this is an action item. open up to public comment. anyone in the chamber. seeing no one. is there remote comment on item 3? checking for remote public comment on item 3. and there is no public comment. >> great. public comment is closed. colleagues, is there a motion to approve the minutes moved by peskin seconded by dorsey mr. clerk, call the roll. >> commissioner chan. >> aye. >> commissioner dorsey. >> aye. why commissioner engardio. >> aye. >> commissioner mandelm

back with us, elliot williams, van jones, sergeant cheryl dorsey. don't know if it is always apparent to people or abundantly clear, talking about the idea of so-called script, the performing for the body cams , knowing they might be viewed later on. let me play for everyone a moment from the videos that we saw where the officers are talking about and making statements about what they say tyre nichols did to justify their force. listen. >> i sprayed, he sprayed. he tased. use the taser. >> is a criminal. >> he was going for my gun 2- pack too. >> my wallet. >> listen, got him out of the car. hey, bro. you good. dennis warm, powell. reach for my gun. he had his hand on my gun. >> they are saying, it was audible, he had his hand on my gun, he reached for my gun. he swung, powell, almost hit me. sergeant dorsey, when you hear this, in light of what we have seen, what is your reaction? >> this is how the officers get down. this is not new to them, this is what they do. they did it too effortlessly. every thing they said was to create audio record becaus

my name is matt dorsey the supervisors for thisdistricate. welcome to district 6. it is honor to go here with united playas. when i was appointed to it board of supervisors about 7 months ago the headlines tended to focus on the fact i spent 2 years in the police department working for my former boss and friend bill scott. there were 14 years i spent thin san francisco city attorney office that taught me a lot about city government and lot about the law and during that time there were a couple cases that went up to the u.s. supreme court. one called heller, one called mcdonald that made any meaningful gun control very difficult in the united states of america. what bhakes it more difficult is the political dinomic in washington that makes gun control virtually impossible and we will change that in years to come but until then, community based organizations are the best hope we got and there isn't a finer organization doing the work of anti-violence then united playas. honor to be here. it is important to do this and was pleased to hear from the chief that these kin

so much chair dorsey. i had a question about something in your presentation about the shuttle service for seniors and disabled. is the thinking this we will you know put whatever monies needed into the city's paratransitit or are we thinking we will create a separate system for treasure island. >> the early phase of the treasure island program. the treasure island transportation implementation program approve in the 2011 envisioned on island circulation shuttle. and ac transit to the east bay. while the demand is low, because there are fewer people living on the island we thought this would be a way to use state funds to initiate that service. >> you said that it would serve both sudden fran and the east bay? this is only in island shuttle? >> it is on island yerba buena and treasure and the east bay. we could talk about whether it should also go to san francisco. i'm just questioning. i'm asking a question. why we are creating a new shuttle and decide third degree in 2011. and tell serve just the island t

for now, lida stanford, justin dorsey, -- live at stanford, dustin dorsey, abc 7 news. dan: thank you, doesn't come as the three people wounded so badly are treated. ama: j.r. stone has been on top of things with his photographer, edgar. he happened to be at a great location to see the suspect being taken into custody. we assume that that was indeed the suspect. j.r., what is the latest where you are? j.r.: yeah. and just to talk briefly about the suspect, that is a suspect who matched the description of the man that they were looking for in connection to those other cases, but they have not confirmed if that is the same man at this point. however, his vehicle matched the description, and he matched that description, and we watched that arrest unfold right before our eyes. we are the only tv crew that was set up outside, waiting for a possible 5:00, 5:30 press conference, and then, all of a sudden, as i walked back from the community center -- it happened in this area here. i will step out of the way so you can see the parking lot i am talking about. when i came back to

supervisor dorsey. >> supervisor matt dorsey: thank you, president peskin and i will accept responsibility for not accepting the fast draw on the request to speak. i did want to address on the merits of president cindy elias. i wanted to say this is going to be so far my political career this will be the nicest and appreciative no vote. i just wanted to express to president elias, my appreciation for her dedication. i will say if there is a commission that deserves salaries is a police commission as much as any other. police commission meetings for those who haven't been through them are often long and contentious. you are only seeing the public portion of it because there is a lot that goes on behind-the-scenes in closed sessions and there is not a single person that hasn't said that president elias is a hard worker. this precedes me in the city attorney's office and wayne who was a mentor to me, an lgbtqia plus member with harvey milk whose desk i sit on. who created a great lgbtq plus community. i believe that commissioner elias is worthy of being a commissioner, but there are times tha

by dorsey. mr. clerk the roll. >> commissioner chan. >> aye. >> american dorsey. >> aye. >> commissioner engardio. >> aye. why commissioner machine man. >> aye. why commissioner melgar. >> aye. >> commissioner peskin. >> aye. >> commissioner preston. >> aye. >> commissioner ronen. >> aye. >> commissioner safai. >> aye. >> commissioner stefani. >> aye. why commissioner walton. >> aye >> there are lefrn aye's it is approved. >> thank you. call consent agenda items 4-6. staff is not plan to present on these but available for questions. >> thank you. is there a motion to approve the consent agenda? moved by preston. a second by ronen. mr. clerk call the roll. why commission charge. >> aye. >> commissioner dorsey. >> aye >> commissioner engardio. >> aye >> commissioner machine man. >> aye. >> commissioner melgar. >> aye. >> commissioner peskin. >> aye. >> commissioner preston. >> aye. >> commissioner ronen. >> aye. why commissioner safai. >> aye. >> commissioner stefani. >> aye. >> commissioner walon. >>

by dorsey. mr. clerk the roll. >> commissioner chan. >> aye. >> american dorsey. >> aye. >> commissioner engardio. >> aye. why commissioner machine man. >> aye. why commissioner melgar. >> aye. >> commissioner peskin. >> aye. >> commissioner preston. >> aye. >> commissioner ronen. >> aye. >> commissioner safai. >> aye. >> commissioner stefani. >> aye. why commissioner walton. >> aye >> there are lefrn aye's it is approved. >> thank you. call consent agenda items 4-6. staff is not plan to present on these but available for questions. >> thank you. is there a motion to approve the consent agenda? moved by preston. a second by ronen. mr. clerk call the roll. why commission charge. >> aye. >> commissioner dorsey. >> aye >> commissioner engardio. >> aye >> commissioner machine man. >> aye. >> commissioner melgar. >> aye. >> commissioner peskin. >> aye. >> commissioner preston. >> aye. >> commissioner ronen. >> aye. why commissioner safai. >> aye. >> commissioner stefani. >> aye. >> commissioner walon. >>