there have been peer reviews of the process implemented by dph. it has been concluded time and again that the shipyard does not pose a risk to human health or the environment. as recently as last year, the epa concluded that dph were utilizing best practices. there was no risk to the community on the site. opponents have been using false claims about the scientific realities of the site to intimidate decision-makers in the community in an effort to stop the economic revitalization of bayview-hunters point. the regulation is never perfect, but we must have multiple, independent regulatory agencies. supervisor campos: thank you, sir. let me read a few more names. [reading names] good afternoon. >> it is clear in every area that we have people that are battling ethical issues. supervisor campos: speaking to the -- >> somebody was a bustedtweetib -- busted tweeting, emailing. she needed judgments based on evidence. she was dismissed. she told us plainly that she did not have to prove with scientific facts or presidents -- precedents. she said she did

it looks like a managed retreat from dph. i know there have been proposals put out there. i don't know how well those proposals have been vetted. the impression i have been given is that because there had been a decision to move forward on the decision on contracting out, that stops short of looking at anything else. >> i believe the controllers office should respond to that. >> yes, we have spent a fair amount of time reviewing the different proposals brought forward and comparing them to the proposal in the budget before you. we continue to refine his numbers, but generally speaking, in that ip only model, on an annual basis, we would expect it would reduce the cost versus the current model by somewhere between $600,000 and $900,000 annually. for half a year, that would yield about $300,000 in savings versus the current model. offsetting that in the first year would be significant implementation costs but we have to model during the coming year -- modeling employees before the effective stop -- the of -- potentially there would be some savings in years beyond. i should s

i think there is someone from dph here as well. i was going to ask about the multi-phase out allocation. $321,000 savings from the park presidio -- 19th avenue signal upgrade. what is the total cost of this project, including other departments? commissioner mirkarimi: to direct skirt -- director mosque in which moscovich. >> the answer to your question is on page 37. the total cost is $361,000. this does not include outreach or enforcement. this is just the physical work, getting ready for it. commissioner mar: are there other expenditures included beyond that $361,000? >> that is essentially what we have. planning is part of that. for $1 and dollars for planning. about the same amount for design -- $41,000 for planning. about the same for design and construction. commissioner mar: according to research, it seems like that may save lives, and that would be a minimal cost for the tremendous benefit. hopefully, we can have some pilot projects beginning before the school year. supervisor we raised the question. i hope it is not delaye

nextg went through the proper processes, they submitted their application to dpw, it was vetterd by dph, it went through the planning department. i don't think mr. flanagan, it does not seem as if nextg submitted and the misleading photographs. it appears date followed all of the appropriate processes, and i will move that we uphold the permit. on the basis that all proper processes were followed. >> that it went through the planning department review required by the application process at the time. vice president garcia: thank you. >> if you could call the roll, please? >> so to recap, the motion from the vice-president to uphold this permit on the basis that all proper processes occurred, including planning department review. >> that it underwent the planning department review required -- >> at the time of issuance? >> at the time of the permit application, that applied to this permit application. >> ok, on that motion, what that basis -- b-- with that basis -- [roll-call vote] >> thank you, the vote is 3-1. the permit is upheld on that basis. vice president garcia: adam director, i k

we brought to you today a five- year agreement between dph and the aids foundation for rent subsidies and subsidies related to its subsidies for people living with hiv/aids. this is a five-year contract, therefore, we are going over the $10 million mark, and i leave this item to you. i am year to answer any questions that you have. supervisor chu: thank you. why don't we go to the budget analyst report? >> madame chair, members of the committee, the existing contractor is the only contractor that responded to the rfp. the authorized amount for this proposed five-year contract -- the existing contract is two years. the average annual amount is $3.9 million, and that is the same amount -- same average annual amount for the new proposed five-year agreement. of the total $19,685,000.2009- 2010 contract, the amount budgeted each year will be $17.5 million. there was also a contingency amount of approximately $2.1 million, but that cannot be expanded unless there is an amendment or modification to the agreement, which must be approved by the board of supervisors -- of the totaled $19,685,00

now, dph is coming before you and telling you that they should only report on a yearly basis, instead of a quarterly basis. two medical doctors lost their positions at laguna honda hospital for identifying fraud and abuse with a patient. secondly, the presenter from the comptroller's office -- i am sorry, i forgot her name. several days ago, she was referred to the district attorney's office, the ethics commission, and the mayor's office, for willfully violating sunshine orders of the termination regarding lagoon on the hospital and the whistleblower program. i urge you to read the grand jury's report. the whistleblower program out of the controller's office. thank you. supervisor campos: thank you very much. next speaker please. >> good morning. i am walter. this city has the money shining like a silver plane the goddess of everything i know we want better change city, you have got it yes, city, you have got it. you are ready audit yes, city, you have got it you are the audit you are the city pride and joy the goddess of the city changed and you know i want some better change and i a