. >> so, gibbs, carney and the rest of the obama liberal royalty you owe governor palin an apology. bob, let's start with you. it wasn't just mark halperin, it was also drward dean who recently earlier in the year said there are death panels. >> if she's waiting for an apology from me she will wait a long time. i'm going to get a lobbyist to go work that death panel to make sure i'm not one of the thing that gets the death thing marked on them. it's the most ridiculous -- >> hold it. >> mark halperin? >> what's ridiculous? the ipad board will decide who gets what? >> they will get together, bring all the millions of americans together, look at their health situations, die, live, die, live. get out of here. can you go to a lot of places. this is the bottom of barrel. have we not beat up obama care enough? let's say they have these death camps they will send them to and let them die. >> can anyone dispute that they will ration health care? >> what happened. palin used the wrong words. president obama is all about cloaking it in a different kind of language. it was a little too negative death panels. should have been called burden lifters or after life tre