dr. dukan was so offended by the criticism, he fought back and last week sued dr.ohen for libel in a paris courtroom. a move dr. cohen thinks will backfire. do you think this lawsuit will hurt him? >> probably yes, because this is the issue for all these type of diets. -- the soul lucian to a very big problem and a very difficult problem. >> reporter: i sat down with dr. dukan last month when his wildly popular book began a six week run on the best-seller's list. there are some critics who say it can't be a healthy diet. perhaps if you're only eating protein, that could damage the kidneys. >> if you have normal kidneys and if you drink minimum six glass of water and you don't practice the diet too long, months and months, you have no kidneys problem. >> reporter: dr. dukan's diet has four stages. phase one is a speedy weight loss, nothing but lean protein and his special ingredient, oat bran. phases two and three add veggies and fruit and two slices of weight bread. in the final phase, he claims you can reasonably eat whatever you want but once a week pure prou tee