dr. payne collected these books that relate to some marines and submarine warfare over the course of many years and there are 3500 volumes. dr. payne was the third minister of nasa and under his watch, seven of the apollo missions were launched and in 1992 the collection was offered to the academy by his widow. he died in may and in the fall she offered this collection to the academy and after making arrangements to take such a large collection, the gift was finalized in 1996, he served in world war ii and was in seven cruises in the pacific during world war ii and i presume that is where his interest in submarines developed although perhaps he was interested prior to that but i would imagine that was an impetus for him to start collecting books related again to submarines and submarine warfare, books that go from the late 1800s up through the time of dr. payne's death. having served in the submarine service in world war ii that was an impetus for collecting these books. afterwards he graduated

dr. robert payne. for being here. >> i am a busy man these days and since you obviously cannot understand complicated world issues, here i am. >> i appropriate that. >> and i want to say that everybody in our audience self included we all heard president obama set the red line in 2012. if chemical witnesses are used that is a red line. did you hear that if>> no, i was not in the room. i know this. we have iks a notion and what we have seen so far. >> i, i. no offense dr. payyne. i don't understand what you are saying. >> oh, what a surprise. >> doctor, the president needs to send a chlor message to the american people and the rest of the world. did the president did he or not draw a redline? >> i don't know. i don't know how i could be much more clear what the president is saying is. this all and written notes and something we so as a development and carry that further. and like when you go, there you are. hello? i don't you understand that governor? >> no, i don't. let me try and let me judge you dr.

dr. robert payne.hank you for being here. >> i am a busy man these days and since you obviously cannot understand complicated world issues, here i am. >> i appropriate that. >> and i want to say that everybody in our audience self included we all heard president obama set the red line in 2012. if chemical witnesses are used that is a red line. did you hear that if>> no, i was not in the room. i know this. we have iks a notion and what we have seen so far. >> i, i. no offense dr. payyne. i don't understand what you are saying. >> oh, what a surprise. >> doctor, the president needs to send a chlor message to the american people and the rest of the world. did the president did he or not draw a redline? >> i don't know. i don't know how i could be much more clear what the president is saying is. this all and written notes and something we so as a development and carry that further. and like when you go, there you are. hello? i don't you understand that governor? >> no, i don't. let me try and let me judge

dr. robert payne.ou for being here. >> i am a busy man these days and since you obviously cannot understand complicated world issues, here i am. >> i appropriate that. >> and i want to say that everybody in our audience self included we all heard president obama set the red line in 2012. if chemical witnesses are used that is a red line. did you hear that if>> no, i was not in the room. i know this. we have iks a notion and what we have seen so far. >> i, i. no offense dr. payyne. i don't understand what you are saying. >> oh, what a surprise. >> doctor, the president needs to send a chlor message to the american people and the rest of the world. did the president did he or not draw a redline? >> i don't know. i don't know how i could be much more clear what the president is saying is. this all and written notes and something we so as a development and carry that further. and like when you go, there you are. hello? i don't you understand that governor? >> no, i don't. let me try and let me judge you dr

dr. keith ablow is here, and he's going to weigh in whether money has morality. by the way, charles payne. does he still love tesla. he responds to the guy, the guest who says the stock is way overvalued. the president gets a huge tax revenue raise, but he still wants a whole lot more. here is my take on it's never enough. first the numbers. an extra 284 billion dollars float into the treasury this fiscal year, that's up 13%, it's the biggest gain since '06. break it down. revenue from income tax up. revenue from corporate tax up. social security tax up. you name a big tax, and the revenue went straight up. the treasury is raking it in. a couple of problems with that. first, all that money taken out of private hands has hurt the economy. where is the growth. 2% is all we've got. the president doesn't care about growth. his priority is spreading it around. but this redistribution is not working. middle class incomes in real terms are down. so, that's problem number one. tax hikes do not bring growth and prosperity. problem number two. the president is pushing for higher taxes and senator r