duthie about that. >> thank you. -- i will ask mr. duffy about that. >> thank you. >> good evening. i spoke earlier with the chief putting -- plumbing inspector. he wants to keep the penalty at nine times. some of the reasons are -- this was filled observation which -- failed observation. they saw during inspection of a building, sinks without traps, toward the front, plumbing supplies were thrown and new gas and water pipes were installed without permit. and there was no access to the restaurant upstairs. on august 19, 2010, the first notice of violation was issued. and on december 13, 2010, the second notice was sent. and on december 16, 2010, a final warning was sen. on december 29, 2010, we referred it to code enforcement as there had been no response from the person who got the notice of violation. it was received by code enforcement and it went to a director's hearing. the case did get continued. and that was in may 2011. in june 2011 it was a plumbing permit. the proper inspections were given and the case has been debated. -- abated. the penalties i believe are [unintelligibl