it didn't say you couldn't use your own e-mail, it said use of e-mail had to be preserved.violate? if we can get those e-mails now and they were preserved, there's no law broken. >> the question for me is, how do we know that she plowreeserved all of them and how do we know that she turned all of her e-mails over to the state department? >> on a technology basis, there may be a way to tell. if all of a sudden she's turning over and they have dates and times and there's some big gap, she was giving e-mails, and then there's a day or three days. >> she's the top dog at to the state department. >> i'm talking about now who's investigating it. they're looking for approximate approximate -- they're looking for benghazi e-mails. they're going to look at the sequence of what is turned over, this is what they do in a criminal case if you're just a regular person. was there a crime? you can't be convicted of a crime that didn't exist at the time that you committed it. >> but going over all these e-mails, a lot of people are sitting at home saying there's got to be more to this. why

instead, she used a personal e-mail account. the clinton camp says she followed the letter and the spirit of the law. others say that using a personal e-mail is like hiding e-mails. we'll debate that next. plus reaction pouring in to benjamin netanyahu's controversial speech including strong words from president obama just moments ago. two jewish democrats are going to join me live. one who boycotted the speech and one who supported it as the reaction continues. use listerine® and over 21 days you'll experience a transformation. take the listerine® 21 day challenge and start your transformation today. shopping online is as easy as it gets. ♪♪ wouldn't it be great if hiring plumbers carpenters and even piano tuners were just as simple? thanks to angie's list, now it is. we've made hiring anyone from a handyman to a dog walker as simple as a few clicks. buy their services directly at angiealist.com. no more calling around. no more hassles. and you don't even have to be a member to start shopping today! angie's list is revolutionizi

ambassador to kenya, various not just e-mail, but in part because he was using personal e-mail for official business. >> if the "times" story was sloppy and a little bit -- let's just say not giving hillary clinton the benefit of the daughter why did all the network newscasts cover this three straight nights, not just fox. >> because hillary clinton is stone walling the media. she is not giving answers. and that's why they're pushing forward. margaret sullivan acknowledged a story that you had written and basically saying that they were a bit sloppy in not the providing the regulations and clarifying why she might have possibly broken the rules. >> as much coverage as this has gotten, very interesting set of comments on msnbc's morning joe about what if it wasn't hillary clinton. let's take a look. >> can you imagine if this was dick cheney and he had a server in mcclain, virginia? i'd go crazy. i'd be completely off the hook. and i'm trying to be because i do think sometimes there is a little bit of bias that sneaks in to this. but this is wrong. >> a little bit of bias? she's being honest

speaker john boehner will reportedly announce a new congressional probe into hillary clinton's e-mail use while secretary of state. at issue, hillary clinton's claim that more than 3,000 e-mails were destroyed because they were personal. it was clarified yesterday that each e-mail was read before deleted. >>> british police hope a new media campaign will deter young people from traveling to syria. police announced the new campaign after a man was arrested. the arrest follows that of three london teens

e-mail. she didn't use any e-mail. >> right. colin powell used an e-mail. there were private e-mails. so i'm saying that now we'll be able to see, turned over, taking the act of actually turning over the e-mails to the public. i think let's, you know, it's hard to imagine, but let's take a breath, she what are in those e-mails and then decide. >> well the e-mails she's chosen to give the state department. >> just to be clear about this. if a secretary today was using private and public e-mail, they're making the decision when they decide to use public e-mail. that's the decision they're making. there's no private -- there's no public record of their private e-mail. >> which is exactly why the obama administration said use your government e-mail. >> where appropriate -- and she's -- >> these e-mails belong to the public. they don't belong to them. >> exactly. and she's turning them over. so that's what we'll see. >> the ones she chose -- >> again like any other cabinet secretary. >> if i'm going to ask you the question the folks keep asking me. how big a deal is this? and given the fac

e-mail server or using your own personal e-mail address with the president? >> i did not e-mail any classified material to anyone on my e-mail. there is no classified pearl. so i am certainly well aware of the classification requirements and did not send classified material material. >> [ inaudible question ]. >> because they were personal and private about matters that i believed were within the scope of my personal privacy and that particularly of other people. they had nothing to do with work. but i didn't see any reason to keep them. >> when did you delete them? >> at the end of the process. >> [ inaudible ] who was forced to offered to two years ago because of his personal e-mails. [ inaudible ] from al jazeera. >> david i think you should go online and read the entire i.g. report. that is not an accurate representation of what happened. thank you. thank you. >> thank you very much. we thank you all. >> you've been listening to former secretary of state hillary clinton addressing the controversy over her exclusive use of a private e-mail address when she

e-mail at all. colin powell and condoleezza rice. both told us they had official government issued e-mail accounts but colin powell did say that he sometimes did use a private e-mail account, though david, his spokesperson said it was a very different time. many of the desks at the state department evendidn't have computers on them. >> jon karl, thank you. >>> now, to the world leader that spoke before congress taking on president obama's foreign policy. israeli prime minister benjamin netanyahu warning of the president's strategy with iran. and you will hear the reception netanyahu received from congress today in a moment. but not a welcome from president obama, who said he did not watch and as far as he could tell netanyahu offered, quote, nothing new. abc's chief global affairs correspondent martha raddatz. >> reporter: it was a rapturous welcome for another country's leader. israel's benjamin netanyahu did not disappoint, dramatically denouncing the obama administration's negotiations with iran, easing sanctions in exchange for curbing iran's

personal e-mail in addition to government e-mail. she used

is hillary clinton the only secretary of state to use a personal e-mail account for official business? >> reporter: well david, only condoleezza rice and colin powell used e-mail at all. spokespeople said they did have official government-issued e-mail accounts as does the current secretary of state, john kerry. colin powell said he also used sometimes, personal private e-mail. though his spokesperson said it was a very different time. in fact, most desks at the state department didn't have computers on them. >> all right, jon karl at the white house. jon, thank you. >>> now, to the world leader that came to the united states today and spoke before congress, taking on president obama's foreign policy. israeli prime minister benjamin netanyahu warning of the president's strategy with iran. only winston churchill speaking before congress like this before, three times. and you will hear the reception netanyahu received from congress today in a moment. but not a welcome from president obama, who said he did not watch and as far as he could tell, netanyahu offered, quote, nothing new. abc'

tomorrow on the fox business ne >>n >> on the buzz beater, a bomb shali on hillary clinton using only a private e-mail account as secretary of state triggers an uproar and media commentators ripping the undeclared democratic chan date. >> if it is true she never used a state department e-mail address we have something that at first read has no conceivable rational explanation that is legitimate. >> it is kind of a dumb move on hillary clinton's part because surely she knew this would come out at some point in time. >> why has the story struck such a nerve? is she is in much political and legal trouble as the news organizations are making? and this this is narrative she does not play bit rules? >> time calls him the most interesting man in politics but rand paul gets bad press and loses his cool with the journalists. >> i am human. i get mad. i tried to be even keel but like everyone else there are interviews i would do differently. >> a conversation with a likely presidential contender but whether he is deliberately provocative and why the media try to link him to his popular. >> why is the coverage o

e-mail? and all cabinet secretaries other than than janet napolitano used e-mail. this story has legs and certainly as hillary is moving closer to it announcing her bid for presidency. and there is a sekress from the clintons. >> the special committee in the house, democrats have prodded them to wrap up their business saying there and there is no smoke or fire and all of the sudden, you found out a central player didn't submit e-mails because they didn't know they existed. >> yeah it raises so many questions of who knew she was using her own internet system. did the white house know? what e-mails were deleted and so are we going to it get the answers to the questions? i doubt it. but it is telling that john podestan is playing a lead role in her campaign and critized the bush administration in a similar controversy. the story continues because of the relationship between the media and clintons hasn't been cordial. this is going to make it more frosty. the media doesn't like the secrecy or lack of transparency and that will be a hurdle for hillary clinton's case for

government e-mail systems. >> why was clinton not abiding by that? >> when personal e-mail is used to conduct u.s. business those e-mails are official government records and should be turned over to the state department which is what i understand secretary clinton's team has done. >> she didn't have an official e-mail account. all her e-mail, personal, official was done on a non-government e-mail account. >> state department is the one responsible for maintaining their e-mail. >> we were told that government work was done on government e-mails. that, i guess, was not correct. >> that's the guidance we give to employees. because it's just more, it saves you a step. federal employees work very hard. the last thing we need to do is ask them to take an additional step. >> she didn't take that step until almost two years after she left office. >> she benefits from something most federal government employees don't have which is team around them that can review those e-mails and make sure the e-mails that were related to her official government work can be spent to the state department. s

personal e-mail in addition to government e-mail. she used personal e-mail in lieu of government e-mail. you do not need a law degree to have an sunsing of how troubling this is. >> the times reports that other questions for e-mails were also never fulfilled. the question remains whether her e-mail practice followed precedent and the letter of the law? yesterday, kondcondoleezza rice used a government account. general powell used a personal e-mail account during his tenure as secretary of state. he wasn't aware of any restrictions nor does he recall being made aware of any over the four years he seshd as secretary of state. the reporter who wrote that piece the 2009 relations that applied to hill kri clinton weren't in effect when colin powell at the state department. clinton in using her personal address was following the practice of previous secretaries. but here's what white house press secretary josh earnest had to say. >> very specific guidance has been given to agencies all across the government. specifically employees of the obama admi

e-mails and asked the state department to release them. this follows word that a house committee subpoenaed the e-mails as the uproar of using private e-mail simmered. susan mcginnis is in washington. susan, hi. >> reporter: good morning. the clinton tweet says the state department will review her e-mails for release as soon as possible. angry critics want answers. they say the private e-mail system she used allowed her to avoid scrutiny. news that clinton used a private

e-mails? we know she did use those private e-mail servers for her official government business as well. more vulnerable than the state department official e-mail accounts? >> the problem with using a previous e-mail account and a home brew network is it's got to be constantly monitored. it's going to be under attack from other governments, from hacker groups and all kinds of different groups. you have to be constantly monitoring it constantly updating it. you can make it secure but you have to work really hard at doing that. >> and do we have any information that they were working full time around the clock? we know her husband, the former president, he was also apparently using that e-mail server. >> the answers right now we just don't know. until we have more information, you have to start with the assumption that the e-mail was not secure unless they can prove it was secured. >> in 2012 when hillary clinton was secretary of state, the inspector general of the state department issued a blistering report about a u.s. ambassador in kenya, and one of the many things he was hammered for w

their official government e-mail address. >> so are you saying her use of her personal e-mail saleh was appropriate or was it in violation? >> you should check with the state department who was responsible for managing this policy but the policy as a general matter allows individuals to use their personal e-mail address as long as those e-mails are maintained and sent to the state department which if you ask secretary clinton steam that is what they completed in the last month or two. >> she is not the first person to use a personal e-mail. is there a system for archiving personal e-mails for governor -- government officials? >> it does establish clear guidelines for how individuals if they are using their personal e-mail to conduct official business can ensure that those records are properly maintained. official guidance that we offer to administration employees and certainly the guidance that i follow when i have been the white house is that i use my official government e-mail address when i'm conducting official government business. it seems the addit

e-mails or a hybrid . people suggested that secretary rice do not use e-mail, or very rarely used e-mail.o that is an important question about where the historical record stand. what secretary clinton did though, still stands alone a bit because it was much more explicitly designed to be a parallel system. and she opted completely out of the system, and did it presumably with full intent of avoiding or personally managing who could have access to her information. host: the headline this morning the tally of clinton's e-mail accounts disputed. here is a quote, by our account there are at least 18 lawsuits that are directly impacted by this. and who knows how many have requested to -- that how the lawsuit wednesday seeking e-mails from clinton and her jeopardy's -- deputies chief of staff, saying these a department failed to respond to its request. an out the associated press is considering a lawsuit to force the release of clinton e-mails. guest: one of the things that was so disconcerting when the news came out is that the white house didn't immediately condemn it. and then when they were

and ask it a criminal offense that she used private e-mail and did not use government e-mail while shewas secretary of state for state business. >> it would depend what's on her e-mails, if on her e-mails is classified information, say information about the raid to capture and kill osama bin laden, something of the highest level of classified, and she had that on her personal e-mails, she arguably koumtdcould be charged for the same crime for which the government announced general petraeus will plead guilty, which is the improper storage, improper removal, improper placement of classified materials. >> >> hillary clinton must have known, judge, she signs up for a personal e-mail account, she becomes secretary of state. she had to make that personal decision in her mind that this would come out and that she would have had to be secretlyive secret tiff -- >> this is apparently the way mrs. clinton thinks in her mind what you and i and everybody else in the media is talking about this afternoon is a political question, it's not a question of her personal ethics and her personal judgment.

your own e-mail server and using your personal address to e-mail with the president? >> i did not e-mail any classified material to anyone on my e-mail. there is no classified material. i'm certainly well aware of the classification requirements and did not send classified material. >> [ inaudible ]. >> because they were personal and private, about matters that i believed were within the scope of my personal privacy. and that particularly of other people. they had nothing to do with work. but i didn't see any reason to keep them. >> [ inaudible ]. >> at the end of the process. >> -- forced to resign two years ago because of his personal use of e-mails. >> david, i think you should go online and read the entire ig report. that is not an accurate representation of what happened. thank you. thank you. thank you, all. >> all right. so there you hear the secretary of state. she spent about 21 minutes there making a statement and answering reporters' questions insisting she did nothing wrong. she complied with all of the rules, going in detail on specific questions. jake t

e-mails. she complyied and sent back 55 pages of e-mails that she sent out. when she usedl e-mail to do government business, she sent those e-mails to government accounts with the total expectation they would be retained. this is a lot of fury about nothing. >> the government is focused on the recordkeeping and transparency aspect of this. your thoughts on how much of an issue this is for hillary clinton moving forward and her ability to shed the veneer of controversy relating to records? >> i got to say first and foremost, i had a clinton staffer in 2008 tell me that ed randle was their best surrogate. this is much ado about a lot. i think one of the main things that the state department said yesterday, i think it was, was that secretary clinton did not use any of the private e-mails for public korcorrespondence or for official correspondence. that's impossible. i can't keep my e-mails apart. while that number 55,000 seems impressive as a raw number how many other tens of thousands of e-mails predated that two-month period? even if this turns out to be less than meets the

private e-mail. >> he wasn't secretary of state. >> colin powell used private e-mailn't secretary of state! >> john kerry is the very first scketed to even use ansecretary of state to even use an official e-mail account. >> dallas, 15 second.to secretary of state to even use an official e-mail account. >> dallas, 15 second.secretary of state to even use an official e-mail account. >> dallas, 15 second. >> unwillful misconduct. as a former first lady and secretary of state she knows the value of records. what happens now is all of those e-mails need to be public immediately because they are public to some people the people who own the server that is not in government hands and she has to answer for this. >> the clinton's are on the server and that is the problem. brad and dallas thank you very much for joining us live. >>> he took on insurgents in iraq but now this vet turned high school principal is taking on bullies by calling them cowards. you will meet him next. ♪ reaching out with both hands got to feel the kick inside ♪ i love life, whether i'm on the go, spendin

whose e-mailed secretary clinton during that time that her personal e mail address was a personal e-mail. >> someone in the west wing had an e-mail to send to the secretary of state did they just use her private e-mail? how did they get in contact with her? did that never raise a flag?

she used her own e-mail address. ring a gathering last night, she did not address the conversations about her e-mail use. >>> and most low-income children in the united states get to school hungry. >> yes, and that hassen impact on how they learn. the nonprofit no kid hungry says three out of four teachers agree hunger attends students. many children feel breakfast served in the cafeteria because they don't want it to make them look needy. he offered a solution. >> our recommendations lean on breakfast in the classroom and removing that stigma by providing breakfast to all students. so everyone is eating at the same time during the school day. >> numbers are fueling the problem. for the first time more than half of public students in american are from low income. >>> heading into the rest of your wednesday, we'll see rain come down and temperatures will be mild pushing into the 40s. by tomorrow we'll drop down to the 20s, but the rain will change over. we are tracking how quickly the changeover is going to happen and

ambassador fired when like hillary clinton, he used a private e-mail service? as hillary clinton looks set to make a 2016 run for the white house, she's facing growing questions about why she may have used personal e-mail for official business while she was secretary of state. the controversy is being further fueled by new scrutiny of america's former ambassador to kenya, scott grash shonn. he's a retired air force general. his support of barack obama's campaign was there. a report by the state department inspector general in 2012 cited gration using a private e-mail account and he had to resign from a job all on hillary clinton's watch. the ambassador has lost the respect and confidence of the staff to lead the mission. he joins me from nairobi, kenya. given that which has been revealed about hillary clinton's use of a private e-mail account, do you view that as a double standard? >> as i look back i may have. as i was going through it i did not perceive that it was a double standard because i did not know of secretary clinton's use of a commercial e-mail accou

were thoos e-mails accounts being used to shield stuff for foyer requests. me like the most serious violation rather than the archiving and stuff like that. i'm sure we'll hear more about the e-mails the next 18 months of our lives. thanks. >>> in a short time hillary clinton, probably heard of her, she'll speak publicly for the first time since this story broke. we'll talk to two people who were there in the room, ahead. denver international is one of the busiest airports in the country. we operate just like a city and that takes a lot of energy. we use natural gas throughout the airport - for heating the entire terminal generating electricity on-site and fueling hundreds of vehicles. we're very focused on reducing our environmental impact. and natural gas is a big part of that commitment. why are you deleting the photos? because my teeth are yellow. oh yeah, they are a little yellow. hey! why don't you use a whitening toothpaste? i'm afraid it's bad for my teeth. try crest 3d white, it's actually good for your teeth. introducing the new crest 3d white diam

i sent an e-mail to the staff here at "all in" asking what kind of crazy person uses their personal e-mailat sort of crazy person. you no why? because i hate, i mean really hate microsoft outlook. hate it. so i'm somewhat sympathetic to hillary clinton that she exclusively used a personal e-mail account to conduct government business as secretary of state. it turns out she didn't even have a government address. that said, i'm a cable news host, not the secretary of state. while there are a bunch of possibly problems here. one is that whether her personal e-mail address was secure from hackers interested in u.s. state department business. clinton was asked about her e-mail use in a 2011 interview. >> i have a lot of security restraints on what i can and can't do. but i do try to stay in touch as much as possible. and electronically is by far the easiest way to do that. >> another big question is whether her use of personal e-mail to conduct state business violated from requirements. collin powell said he used personal e-mail at the time, but federal regulations have changed since then. it a

two separate phones and two e-mail accounts. i thought usingevice would be simpler. and obviously, it hasn't worked out that way. >> reporter: clinton waited nearly two years after leaving office to turn over 55,000 pages of e-mails to the state department, which will make them public. but clinton admits she deleted her private messages. >> no one wants their personal e-mails made public. and i think most people understand that. and respect that privacy. >> reporter: in a news conference at the u.n. the former secretary of state insisted she never e-mailed classified information. and defended using a private e-mail server in her home. >> it had numerous safeguards. it was on property guarded by the secret service. and there were no security breaches. >> reporter: but some say this could be considered a breach of trust for potential voters if clinton runs for president in 2016. >> in underscores a story line that has been difficult for the clintons. there seems to be drama. she needed special rules for her e-mail. >> reporter: she did not commen

e-mails on that morning. i'm confident there are other e-mails that other e-mail accounts he was using that he did not release. we have taken steps to find out if there were and obtain those e-mails. >> let's hear from tony sugarland, texas. independent line. >> i'd like to thank john cook. without the organization most of the americans wouldn't know what was happening in the country. my question is two parts. what's the difference between petraeus what he did and what allegedly hillary did? that's question number one. number two, as a former government employee, i did have to, when i retired sign a clearance form and now the clearance form came up i believe the other day from a lawyer and i'm reading it it does say that as far as you could be guilty and on and on. i'll take your answer offline. thank you. >> in terms of what preetraeus released information that he knew to be classified to someone cleared to see the information. i believe he also stored classified information on an insecure system. it will be very interesting to me to see whether any of the information in the 55000 pages of e-mails that hilla

>> looking back it would have been better for me to use two separate phones and two e-mail accounts. i thought using one device would be simpler. and obviously, it hasn't worked out that way. >> while clinton insists recipients of her work-related e-mails all have dot-gov accounts so they were automatically archived skeptics brought in a third party to analyze her server and make sure she did turn over anything relevant. >> i won't trust the clinton people to be the last word on what's in those e-mails. >> i think we're way past an explanation. i think she has to produce all the e-mails. that probably means her server. >> others say it's nothing more than a full scale attack on the leading contender for the white house. >> total disclosure and there's no efforts made to deny the access. >> except, that is for what clinton deemed personal. >> no one wants their personal e-mails made public. and i think most people understand that and respect that privacy. >> the state department says it had eventually post those e-mails on line. although many wonder if they'll include e-mails with the

e-mails public for everyone to see. again, looking back, it would have been better for me to use two separate phones and two e-mail accounts. i thought using one device would be simpler and obviously it hasn't worked out that way. the server contains personal communications from my husband and me and i believe i have met all of my responsibilities and the server will remain private and i think that the state department will be able over time to release all of the records that were provided. >> what do you think about this republican idea of having an independent third party come in and examine your e-mails? >> first of all, you'd have to ask that question to every single federal employee. the laws and regulations in effect when i was secretary of state allowed me to use my e-mail for work. that is undiesundies puted. >> i would be happy to have someone talk to you about the rules. >> good evening, sir. >> good evening, how are you? >> very well. that was most of what she had to say, but your response. are you satisfied with what she said? >> no ma'am if possible i have more questions than i did this time yesterday. before

ike secretary of state sending out memos and internal memos around the world saying do not use personal e-mails yet she, for convenience, get to use personal e-mails and she gets to decide what is personal and dee least it. the clintons are sometimes not totally forthcoming. there are a lot of questions that hillary clinton did not answer. there are a lot of questions about the foundation and foreign money that the clinton foundation has received that she did not answer, and this is very much to control the environment. this was not a former news set up, per se. this was a hundred reporters jammed in a hallway with cameras on the back, and this was an effort by the former secretary of state and staff to control the questions and how many. it was not a full-blown news conference where you sit down and answer every question like she did in the white water cancel scandal in 1994-59. it was not that. >> the fact that the former president also was using that server she said it was his is that going to carry water? >> well, i mean, it was in their home. they were the two people who had access to it,

we know she's not the oem person to use personal e-mail. why do politicians use personal e-mail. >> it's interesting. as a journalist it means they are going to be more open because they are less worried about that getting captured and becoming public. as a journalist generally, though somebody who is pro transparent, in this situation hillary clinton wanted full control over her e-mails. so even now they are issuing a subpoena. if they issued a subpoena to g-mail she would have less control over what was released. the clintons have always been people who have felt unjustifiably so under attack. you know by the right wing and so i think they set up you know, these extra walls from the outside may end up looking like paranoia. >> jamal, after the news broke, jeb bush tweeted "transparency matters, unclassified hillary clinton e-mails should be released" but nbc reports, former florida governor jeb bush owns the server that runs the personal e-mail he used to conduct political and personal business. both of them have servers. is this normal? >

her husband, the former president, even though bill clinton's office said today that he did not use e-mail at all. another potential kron tra diction. she said she used one e-mail account, because she wanted one device, even as you know, you can have one device with multiple e-mail accounts. a few weeks ago, she suggested after leaving the state department she has more than one device. listen. >> i want to ask the big question. >> okay. >> iphone or android? >> iphone. okay, in full disclosure, and a blackberry. >> the good news for the secretary, she has a lot of democrats on capitol hill tonight rallying behind her saying she's already turned over 55000 pages of e-mails, and they insist there's nothing there. >> ed henry, thank you. you heard hillary clinton say she fully complied with every rule. i spoke with judge andrew napolitano. >> she took unprecedented steps all right. she is the first secretary of state in history to use exclusively her own personal e-mail at least in conjunction with the report, and now she says, judge she followed every rule. that is not true. >> that is absol

e-mails or a hybrid. people suggested that secretary rice did not use the e-mail, or very rarely used e-mail. so that is an important question about where the historical record stands for previous secretaries. what secretary clinton did though, still stands alone a bit because it was much more explicitly designed to be a parallel system. and she opted completely out of the system, and did it presumably with full intent of avoiding or personally managing who could have access to her information. host: the headline this morning, the tally of clinton's e-mail accounts disputed. and the report that the use of the e-mail system would make it impossible for the request for e-mails from the congressional committees. here is a quote, by our account, there are at least 18 lawsuits that are directly impacted by this. and who knows how many have requested, that how the lawsuit wednesday seeking e-mails from clinton and her deputies chief of staff, saying these a -- saying that the department failed to respond to its request. an out the associated press is considering a lawsuit to force the release of cl

your own e-mail server and using personal address to e-mail with the president? >> i did not e-mail any classified material to anyone on my e-mail. there is no classified material. so i am certainly well aware of the classification requirements and did not send classified material. [ inaudible ] >> because they were personal and private about matters that i believed were within the scope of my personal privacy, and that particularly of other people. they had nothing to do with work, but i didn't see any reason to keep them. >> reporter: when did you delete them? >> at the end of the process. >> reporter: forced to resign because of his use of personal e-mail. by the way david shuster. >> i think you should go online and read the entire ig report, that is not an accurate representation of what happened. thank you. thank you. thank you all. liz: former secretary of state hillary clinton wrapping up a 21-minute news conference addressing the e-mail scandal that plagued her for days why. did she use a private e-mail server at home while serving as

e-mail us at booktv@c-span.org. >> any of you have done research, especially graduate level research, know that it's very slow and i found myself struggling with the equipment and vacuum bombs and so the progress was incremental at best. writer in the time so it was very dear to me developed a severe case of lupus -- right around that time. in an effort to help her i ended up going to support group meetings and talking to doctors come and just gradually got more interested in medicine as a way to help her but also what was i thinking he was how much was uncharted in medicine, how little was known about, for example, lupus or chronic diseases in general. being a physicist i had this idea that if i dug deeply enough i could figure things out for her. but it became very clear that medicine is really is a science of incredible uncertainty. and is largely uncharted. that was appealing to the scientist in me but the biggest appeal was that you know i started these medicine as a way to help people. i know it sounds a little naÏve but it was really, the biggest motivating factor for me was. a

hillary clinton was not widely known that she did not use government e-mail. eryone jeb used jeb.org. public access -- they both have public access but the biggest difference is hillary clinton's failure to turn in e-mails led to denial of complete responses of public record requests. jeb bush did not meet the florida archive deadline. it is unclear if hillary clinton did. they both deleted e-mails and they both, in terms of whether the e-mails were public, hillary requested that jeb be public. the biggest issue is the national security front. she was the head of the state department, dealing with national security matters. she did not have a system that would secure her government e-mails whether it was classified information or not. john: i agree with that 100%. i will say three other things. one, secrecy -- this notion of widely known matters. the fact she did not tell anybody she was doing this including a lot of people in government. mark: people should have protested jeb's practices. john: correct. two is consistency. she was the only one in the governmen

nbc news has learned, colin powell used his personal e-mail and former secretary of state condoleezza rice rarely used e-mail but when she did, she was using it under a government account. joining me now is the reporter who broke the story michael schmidt. explain why this is an important distinction to make whether or not she was using personal e-mail or government issued account. >> what it is if she wasn't ugsing a government account then the state department had no way of cataloging and retaining all of her e-mails for record keeping purposes for congressional oversight, for freedom of information act requests and for historians to go back and look at it. essentially, it was shielding her communications from those things. >> so that gives the interpretation that it looks like she was trying to hide something xgt i want to read a statement from a clinton spokesman, both the letter and spirit of the rules permitted state department officials to use nongovernment e-mail as long as appropriate records were preserved. that's the big distinction there because now according toize say i c

that personal e-mail account to conduct official business. >> there was no prohibition on using a non-state e-mail account for government business. >> the state department does not have all of secretary clinton's e-mails. only she has a complete record. >> this is also an unclassified e-mail. no classified business was done on it. >> we've learned details are expected to be released tomorrow. >> this investigation looked at how the ferguson department conducts their business. >> the fight over dhs is over. house speaker john boehner told congress today they are going to call for a vote. >> better late than never. >>> today, as rachel reported in the last hour, former cia director david petraeus negotiated a plea deal and avoided the possibility of a high profile trial and possible jailtime. the retired army general pled guilty to one count, punishable by one year in prison, $100,000 fine and five years probation. he supplied classified material for a book being written about himself. petraeus was willing having an extramarital affair with her at that time. today, hillary clinton

ambassador fired when, like hillary clinton, he used a private e-mail service? as hillary clinton looks set to make a 2016 run for the white house, she's facing growing questions about why she may have broken government rules by using her personal e-mail for official business while she was secretary of state. the controversy is being further fueled by new scrutiny of the firing of america's former ambassador to kenya, scott gration. he's a retired air force general. his support of barack obama's in 2008 was among the campaign's important endorsements. a report by the state department inspector general in 2012 cited gration using a private e-mail account for government business as one of many criticisms that rs forred him to resign from the job, all on hillary clinton's watch. that report said in part "the ambassador has lost the respect and confidence of the staff to lead the mission." ambassador gration joins me from nairobi, kenya. mr. ambassador given that which has now been revealed about secretary clinton's use of a private e-mail account, in retrospect do y

the issue goes back to e-mails sent and received when hillary clinton was secretary of state. she has acknowledged using the personal e-mail account exclusively as secretary. and it comes as she prepares to potentially announce a presidential bid next month. we start with julianna goldman in washington, d.c. >> i am thrilled. >> reporter: appearing in miami last night at an event for the clinton global initiative, hillary clinton made no mention of the e-mail controversy, but her silence is giving more questions and leading others to answer. ñrÑcontroversy chelsea clinton was asked about her private e-mail use. >>Ñi weiÑi e-mail about things like thanksgiving dinner and plans toÑ'içó watch a movie on friday night. you'll have to watch her. >> bill clinton did make a plug for transparency on a matter that is dog hillary hillary clinton's bid for the warehouse. acceptance of money from foreign governments. >> my theory about all this >> my theory about all of this is, disclose everything. and then let people make their judgments. >> the policy of my administration is to, complete transparency. >> in an in

private and public e-mail any other secretary are making the decision when they useblic and private e-mail a decision they are making. there is no public record. >> that is why the obama administration said to use the government e-mail because the e-mails belong to the public, fought to them. >> and she is turning them over. >> the ones she we chooses to turn over. >> like any other cabinet secretary. >> how big a deal is this? given we are in man of 2015, how big a deal is this when we are talking about an election that isn't until november of 2016? >> big because the worst political scandals be those that reinforce a pre-existing negative perception which kim has documented at length. the clintons have clouds of entitle mit and concealment and legalistic reasoning, the people would can find a loophole in a stop sign. her motive was to conceal and that is what makes this orwellian. in "1984," the regime had an edict, he who controls the past controls the future and he who controls the present controls the past. this is a way of controlling what will know of the hist

>> there are questions tonight about hillary clinton's use of her private e-mail account while she was secretary of state. a clinton aide said there was nothing improper about the secretary's refusal to use a government-issued e-mail account. federal law requires all official government communications including e-mails be preserved. >> raises serious questions about adequate documentation of the historical record. >> an aide said clinton e-mailed employees on their department accounts believing the messages would be retained. the state department said clinton handed over 55,000 pages of e-mails when she stepped down in 2013. n.s.a. leaker edward snowden wants to return to the u.s. his attorney says he'll come home if he's guaranteed a fair trial. his attorney says any charges under the u.s. espionage act would not be considered fair. russia granted smoe eded snowden asylum after he leaked thousands of top secret government documents. former maryland governor martin o'malley will not run for the seat of retiring senator barbara mikulski. mikulski announced yesterday she will not seek a