. >> and his book the making of americans democracy and schools, e.d. hirsch argues using charnel senter teaching methods instead of focusing on academic content is a problem with early education. the manhattan institute in new york city posts this 45 minute event. >> i have this -- i didn't choose this picture. it just happened to be one of put on for the discussion period, which by the way is always valuable here at the manhattan institute and so i'm not going to exceed my 20 minutes. i want to be sure we have plenty of time for a question period. but that was an awfully pleasant picture to put up before i have my more sober graphs, and that -- i don't know whether any of you have actually seen it. it is a 42-foot wide mural that dominates shepard hall city university, and it was done by ed wim slash field in 1904. it's called the graduate. and you can get the image of the idealism that expired particularly new york state at the turn of the century and how successful it was then. some of the themes of this new book, the making americans are new to my riding