must descend from god the existence and belief in the whole of palestine, this is the spirit of edward saeed it was natural for me to see the oslo incident as an obstacle to the supreme ambition of recovering the whole of palestine. last time i saw him in lebanon was in the spring of 82, he was in bed, i went to visit him in one of his mysterious residences. he seemed very, very ill, and i said, it's quite clear to me that the israelis are going to attack, and he, i'll never forget what he said, if he said, if they want to attack, welcome to them, let them come, suggesting that he could deal with it, this is where my and saaf's paths diverged , after a member. time i really understood how sick he was when he was playing the piano once and i heard him make mistakes which he which was unusual for him, he was playing the piano with a friend, they were playing a shobert peace four hands and he kept making mistakes and she was very patient with his colleague and she told him okay okay she had been dead for about a year, just to put in writing uh feelings that i would like to have shared with her.