u.s., nsa, edward snowdan, who, let me remind you, 11 years ago, revealed many dirty secrets of this ce of all electronic communications in the world. let's listen to edward snowden. the arrest of durov is an encroachment on basic human rights, on freedom of speech and association. i am surprised and deeply saddened that macron has stooped to the level of hostage-taking as a way to gain access to personal messages. this humiliates not only france, but the entire world. here so, elena vladimirovna, your comment on all this. edward snowden, juliana, now pavel durov, this is all a trend, the world oligarchy, represented by the main countries. the united states of america, and the same france, as it now turns out in the case of durov's detention, it acted in many ways in close coordination with washington, there was a request from america, and this raises questions not only about freedom of speech, which is being violated, but about the russian origin of pavel dorov, because here , in my opinion. history is related not only to the encroachment on technology, on freedom of expression, but