video to talk about this, i'm joined by the "washington post's" silicon valley correspondent elizabeth dwoskinyou fonebeing with the hour. let me start with these internal discussions in 2012, and we now have these emails. facebook was figuring out how to make money. mark zuckerberg writes the following in october 1212: does that show zuckerberg thinking about users' data as some sort of bargaining chip? >> i think it does. you have to see the big picture here. this is right after facebook has gone public, and the media sto they can't pivot to mobile? are they going to make money? their stock prices dropping. so they have at the time this whole developer com know, tens of thousands of apprentices that are literally riding off the social graph. it,obama campaign did cambridge analytica did it. and they're looking and saying, "we need to mak so they're looking at these relationships with thousands of developers, and you can see this intense bargaining that's going on beten zuckerberg and facebook's top brass over who should get access and how while at the same time, what they're publicly telling