first of all, the 16th of december, 2005, which is our page -- that the and elizabeth freud. known him since then. i'm trying to find the page but i think it was a social occasion. >> now elizabeth freud, how long have you known her? >> i suppose since they got married but i can't put a date on it. >> your first meeting here with rupert murdoch as your witness statement made earlier account before your leader. the first of february, '06 drinks. is it unfair to ask you one particular case which was six years ago, do you think that was a one on one as a work, or were there people their speakers i don't remember. it was a long time ago, but the meetings i've had with paul dacre i would say most probably would've been a one and one drink, occasioned a lunch. he has done some where there's been a ranger journalist from "the daily mail," number one or two of those but a mixture but i think one on one. >> if one were to look at one of the with mr. dacre the 18th of december '06. which is page 04205, dinner actually. about the time that the information commissions second report came o