that concludes my remarks i'll be happy to answer any questions i'm joined by john ramming and emily rogers and scott sanchez the zoning administrator thank you. >> thank you very much next speaker budget analyst. >> oh, i had a. >> - sorry supervisor campos. >> thank you, madam chair have a couple of questions for the planning staff to director ram for quite a number of months many members of your staff testified xhugd testifying in committee before this board they couldn't endorse that would you say correcting the data from average and other platforms so can you explain what happened then how is that that planning went from saying that data was four months to all of a sudden changing it's tune. >> supervisor director ram what we've been saying the difficult is helpful to our data enforcement and what's not clear how best to get the data while it is our experience we've had from other cities you've seen from other cities is it so challenging to get the data if rent requiring it there are a number of ways to get the data and staff said in previous hearings requiring the data from the legisl

airbnb platform alone they know their listing unit and making money off the illegal activity and emily rogers of the planning department has received to the penalties i quote as the lynch pin felt city's plan i want to acknowledge that the planning commission didn't ultimately recommend this affliction a 3 4 split even with pleading with the staffers i'm sorry the commission didn't listen to its own staff the 3 board appoints i see commissioner richards supported this i'm grateful he did that you know those of us who follow what happens in city hall probably shocked to read in the examiner how that vote went down it is sad that is how it happened second point in any legislation inquires the hosting platforms to provide data to the planning department i understand that the plant has a different position now but for the first if i months for the last few months of this debate planning department has staff has been clear that they're now going to be able to enforce the law without the data the budget analyst came to the same ku klux klan conclusion i think that is correct i disagree with the new

how to get those units other than the marketed before the board the airbnbs and rb o your staff emily rogers honed on, on the way to regulate short-term rentals i guess i'm going to reader from the steementd unless we have partnerships with the hosting platforms sharing the dictated and enough data it is almost very, very difficult to enforce i think from our staff they've suggested penalties for hosting platforms that list unregulated unit and better booking data for each short-term rental is critical to having the enforcement mechanism that could potential work i'm wondering if you could respond. >> certainly we've been clear that enforcing this challenging ludicrously is a key issue; right? the champion fundamentally is that a short-term rental unit didn't look any different from any unit one cannot walk both a unit and say this is a short-term rental it is how it is occupied and who is living there and so forth we thought it was important from staff level requiring a platform have a registration number that ordinances was you reviewed by the commission last week and felt it was not a pra

tom rogers: thank you for having me. emilyis the strategy to keep growing in the age of disruption in the cable industry and how we are all consuming content? tom rogers: well, your little bite on youtube said it all. it is all about getting content from traditional tv sources from recording, which we have done for a long time, and then streaming services netflix, hulu, being able to get all of that on demand. the issue is you have so much content coming of people from so many ways there is real chaos for the consumer. what our position is how do you put all that together easily and elegantly so you only need one remote, one user experience, one way to search across everything no matter what you're trying to wind to get on tv, one way it is also for your -- no matter what you are to get on tv, one way. whatever you want to watch on demand, whether recorded or streaming is sitting there for you. that is the tivo proposition. emily: let's talk about what is happening. charter buying time warner cable. is this good for consumers?

bristol oxford valley road is closed between emily and mill creek roads because of a funeral for a lower makefield detective. use 413 new rogersou meaner more land one on davisville road and another on gulph road. >> center city philadelphia, lots of sunshine out there david murphy has the forecast. still bright for now matt, as we head into the afternoon we're likely to see more clouds, 52 degrees for now the temperature similar to what we've seen the last couple of mornings, this afternoon a cool flow off the ocean will suppress the temperatures. we'll e we're going for mainly cloudy skies and sunny breaks, 63 degrees, chance of shower. 70 tomorrow, 78 sunday, the 80s early next week. >> take it, take it, take it. >>> the second and third rounds of the nfl draft are tonight. watch our draft breakdown after "action news" at 1 # p.m. there's over two hundred thousand students in philadelphia. jim kenney and tony williams are fighting over public schools versus charters. i think they're both wrong...it's making sure they all get a good education. teachers should have their contracts respected. they also should be held accountab

emily, but one better, jess mcintosh. guys, thank you all for being here. you take all of it into consideration, is the nfl's punishment fair? >> i think it's flabber gastingly overboard. i think rogertyrant. i think he reminds me of one of these "game of thrones" leaders that thinks if you cut off everyone's head -- >> but he didn't cut off ray rice's head. i mean that figuratively. >> four games for deflating a football seems -- and a first round pick. that's gigantic. >> and a million-dollar fine. >> and the similarity with ray rice isn't that he thinks beating a spouse or a girlfriend is worse than deflating a football. i think you should punish someone for lying and cheating and the evidence is pretty clear that he did lie and cheat. however, the bad thing is it's all based on roger goodell's whim. there is no rule of law. he seemed to get in a fit that tom brady did not cooperate with the defense. which is his right to. he didn't try to get in the way of it but he just said you're not having my cell phone. i suggest this record this ted wells report must have cost 700 to a million dollars. maybe the nfl should say we're going to take that amount of money and donate it to eithe