here they are and this week gary smith, john layfield and along with susie and emily sesman. okay. the tax cuts is that the best way? >> i think that they are brenda. look there's -- research comes out everyday and the latest says that there's a positive correlation between tax cuts and jab growth. even if we look back at real life examples. every major economic expansion that we have had for the last 50 years has been spurred by the tax cuts. kennedy in the 60s, reagan in the 80s and clinton in the 90s. each of them saw robust jobs. i think that the evidence is very clear. i don't know why you would not cut taxes. >> emily, you have a different view. >> yeah i think that we should put the job numbers out to p perspecti perspective. they may be low, but i think there's a little bit of perspective on that. as to the gop moving forward, they're catching on to something of this messaging and the populace sense in america. they're throwing a little bit of a bone towards symbolic really in the tax kucuts to the middle class. when we look at the job proposal and the hole, what they're do