unfortunately it looks like we have lost enver solomon, l like we have lost enver solomon, gremlins anddown by parliament according to the court of appeal. parliament according to the court of a- eal. , parliament according to the court of aueal. , , ., ,, appeal. yes, absolutely. thank goodness- _ appeal. yes, absolutely. thank goodness. since _ appeal. yes, absolutely. thank goodness. since the _ appeal. yes, absolutely. thank goodness. since the last i appeal. yes, absolutely. thank goodness. since the last time | appeal. yes, absolutely. thank goodness. since the last time i | goodness. since the last time i spoke to you, i have had a chance to read thejudgment twice. spoke to you, i have had a chance to read the judgment twice. it is true even as we relate live on bbc news, it was slightly confusing because of theissue it was slightly confusing because of the issue of the first of all you hear what the majority is, the descent is... anyway, let us strip it away. essentially the ruling by the court is very simple and bad news for the government on the face of it because absolutely t