speakers include university of california irvine law school dean erwin chermerinsky and constitutional accountability center chief counsel tran 11. this is about an hour and 45 and it. >> if everybody here from the breakouts? welcome to the planner program of the afternoon which hoped to land with a bang and discuss whether the supreme court is a failure. and if so what can be done about it? this program is recorded by c-span. you may find it at any random day or hour for the next five years. [laughter] before introducer distinguished panels i'll have to go through my marching orders here, one of which is to introduce myself. i am transcending. i'm a member of the acs board and i'm happy to be a member of the acs board because i view our mission as helping to grow and sustain the next generation of progressive lawyers. i've been delighted to see how many students there are piazza that is why we are all here. but we have a diversity at all. not everybody is necessary on the same page and that is a good thing. cell phones, please mention cell phones must be turned off. .. okay we will ha