is like the european court of justice most notably has helped date prissie by its rulings against facebook various american firms sending british and european data to america where it can be intercepted so the european court of justice has been quite in my experience but nine and shouldn't really supportive of the rights of individual europeans they've been very good for example on pollution and on interpreted in the euro europe proves a complicated law and so very all of the thousands dead from pollution in this country the volkswagen diesel scandal i mean. laws do provide some protection against what would otherwise be the outrageous pollution on. he didn't see it as the end of this kind of fashion for international justice we need international justice the people who demonstrate around the world call for justice that's what the cry use of oppressed people and we are doing something against america's attempts to be relit to assist them charles taylor for example is in prison in britain. always african not always not alw

of a globalist court. trumps fans may call it the international of the european court of justice in which there's just been an appeal victory that they may be able to stop bracks it using westminster. why do you think tourism a wants to get out of the european court of justice or do you think actually as some of her opponent. say secretly she's actually gone with the by ratifying laws previously agreed although you see jail maybe eight years after twenty twenty britain will still be subject to luis e j which is different from the european court of human rights which is hanging in there. is a very benign court it's basically in i've been there i've appeared before it they're extremely nice there's a british judge a scottish judge from different countries of europe they have basically untangle even for us. all regulations they know what germany says that may's priority in backing them is to tie the european union to britain to evade laws permanently in force privatisation and have blocked support for industry that's what the european court of justice is like the european court of justice most notably has hel

parliamentary sovereignty over the government it would destroy if it came forward from the european court of justice and then the call to session saying that that could be the vest by parliament would that in that self be a for the underlining of parliamentary sovereignty oh absolutely i think it would dovetail the supreme court lay down in parliament scott its rights in a protected and this made sure that there was an alternative to the in the blink picture been painted by today's and me and it would empower parliament so at the present moment the supreme court to say to the parliament has the power that you keep a minister is trying to pretend that there's nothing left to decide other than her options are new deal if the european court courses we hope and expect then i think parliaments and powers to be able to not just decide did it or not but to actually withdraw article fifty couldn't lead to these or me has been struggling between a backstop and some hard cases and the democratic unionist party and indeed with what little good abbott but this would open up potentially a whole new dimension com

european court because they have no say over poland it was question of national sovereignty and one should absolutely just turn away and sort of ignore the verdicts coming from the european court of justice and we don't know yet whether the government will really sort of stick to this hard line that has been announced liberal forces in at that point already talked about a poll exit meaning that. actively ignoring and defying the european court of poland would set itself on the way to leave the european union effectively barbara as we all know poland's right wing government commission have been clashing over a number of issues including press freedom what does this verdict now mean for the larger dispute between poland's government and the e.u. . it means of course terry that the heat rises because we also know that there's already an article seven. procedure underway against poland something that procedure that means that the used sees a systematic threat so the route to the rule of law in poland and this is what it's in brussels called the nuclear option because it could in taking away the voting rights of the country in the european council there it's quite away till then but this proc

about the court of session ruling i ship peered in the commons a mere three days later the government lodged a last minute appeal to try and stop that a final to the european court of justice the government clean confidence that is of the view of many political and legal observers one person with a foot in both of these counts is a form of scottish justice secretary kenny macaskill alex spoke to him from edinburgh kelly welcome back to the alexander i'm sure her oh thank you pleasure to my bike but this case that has been to the court a session i was no be the same to the luxembourg court of justice this could be a really big deal could you explain it to us. well it's almost unprecedented retired to teach says it had been sent by the scottish court to luxembourg for clarification minimum unit pricing on alcohol was one and there's been other things but i write my brains i can't think of anything that wasn't restricted to the scottish to distraction and it's something we are scotland's going to be pivotal for the whole of the new key source a fast track procedure that will clarify the law in scotland but the law in scotland will have application across the whole of the u.k.

back from one side of the desk brussels to the other but poland would sort of to find the european court of justice that would really come up on the agenda and then of course the two sides would really low koreans otherwise what we hear now and there is a fee seems to be feeling that they one don't want this at the moment and they might be stepping down but reversal in brussels thank you so much. i set you up to date small at the top of a cow i was around the clock of course on the website that's t w dot com good to. see school in the jungle. first climbing lesson and then tours grandma was arrives. joining a ring and chain on her journey back to freedom. in our interactive documentary tour of an orangutan returns home in the long t w don't come to tang.

has been printing money to buy out forms from the euro crisis countries european court of justice will reach a final ruling before the end of the year. for more on this we can speak to our financial correspondent in frankfurt power question but it is tracking the story for us part explain to us why there was doubts over the galaxy of the e.c.b. these actions. yes i want to turn to stand that we first have to understand what it what it does so the e.c.b. is a mandate is a monetary policy in effect keeping prices pretty much at the same level so stability and it's key a measure to do that is interest rates but of course after the financial crisis those interest rates drop and drop and drop and once there are zero there's hardly anything you can do so another means to get more money into the market is to buy these bonds effectively what the city does as it goes to banks and says hey we're going to buy these mines from you so they will have more money available to put in riskier assets to give out to companies or to private citizens to then invest which hopefully will create some more econ

on the train two sets of november the twenty seventh of november is the same day as the european court of justice will hear the scottish court's referral on the question of whether article fifteen can be to latch really revoked my question for the prime minister is is she afraid of m.p.'s knowing the answer to that question before we have a meeting can. thirty three on the latest making assumption about the data meaningful version of course mr the negotiations and secondly no because the point about the article fifty of whether a lot of cool fifty can be withdrawn result is that this government will not be revoking article fifty we're going to keep politics but the prime minister may not have been as complacent about the court of session ruling i ship in the commons a mere three days later the government lodged a last minute appeal. to try and stop the defile to the european court of justice the government clean confidence that is of the view of many political and legal observers one person with a fit in both of these counts is a form of scottish justice secretary kenny macaskill alex spoke to hi

in the brics it drama the court of session in edge of russia was no less than the lord president presiding the first to case an article fifty to the european court of justiced luxembourg this case was brought by a cross party group of any peace m s p's and one m.p. to ask for a ruling on whether the infamous article fifty by which the u.k. government signalled its withdrawal from the european union last year could be reversed. by the flooding the key is to europe the scottish judges opens up the possibility that m.p.'s me by law have a new choice on breaks it to evoke article fifty and go back to square one this ruling arrived in the middle of the party conference season and it is fair to say was little reported in london news outlets however its potential significance is far reaching and just in case a prime minister was in any doubt she ran a charity of the s.n.p. the so m.p. support in the case reminded her of it last week thanks mr speaker it's reported today that the prime minister wants the meaningful bullets to take place on the trente seventh of november the twenty seventh of november is the same day as the european court of justice will hear the s

critics say is aimed at replacing them with judges supportive of the current regime the european court of justice says all judges who have lost their jobs under the ruling must now be reinstated. the controversial law had already come into force here at the country supremes court in warsaw many of the twenty seven newly appointed judges began their work just days ago for you with the e.c.g.'s ruling holt's the forced retirement of judges with immediate effect and reverses the retirement of those already forced to leave their posts. speaking in brussels the polish prime minister said warsaw would consider its response. but the justice minister signaled poland would accept the ruling. as we see if we are part of the european union and we will respect the e.u.'s laws so far i only know about this ruling from media reports that we will analyze the decision and then make a statement poland is a strong member state of the e.u. and we will honor. the president of poland supremes court mug shot against off refused to step down when the government tried to force her to retire. personally i'm pleased that

has been printing money to buy out bones from euro crisis countries in the european court of justice will reach a final ruling before the end of the year for more on this we can speak to our financial correspondent in frankfurt but it is tracking the story for us pound explain to us why there was doubt over the galaxy of the e.c.b. actions. yes i want to turn to stand that we first have to understand what it what it does so the e.c. bees amanda is a monetary policy in effect keeping prices pretty much at the same level so stability and it's key a measure to do that is interest rates but of course after the financial crisis those interest rates dropped and dropped and dropped and once there are zero there's hardly anything you can do so another means to get more money into the market is to buy these bonds effectively what the e.c.b. does is it goes to bangs and says hey we're going to buy these bonds from you so they will have more money available to put in riskier assets to give out to companies or to private citizens to then invest which hopefully will create more economic dynamic yo

stands and when european judges a piece like you hide the details of the expose expenses instead of practicing transparency the european court of justice is just rude it would be a breach of any peace prevent see if they had to provide the public with details of expenses invoices repeats you know like normal people. want to call this is a delay message you can get away with anything here which is a reading of the european court of justice this is a debate which has been where we're now following for several years in this european parliament the member states have different national standards you have some countries where any piece have to reveal every detail of the monthly allowance they get in other countries this is different than four hundred sixteen your m.e.p. in general expenses which they don't have to go to the. public. i wouldn't have any problem if the rules were changed on this issue but in the moment this is a situation that this is something really which will have to be decided between the group leaders of the presidency and i would be falling to follow any rule which is given on this issue in this decision do anything exc

has been let's say taken has been diluted and this was actually the reason why the what a european court of justice decided to immediately stop this reform and to say freeze everything down and say we cannot go like this because. independent judiciary is a basic of every european democracy so it cannot touch that this is an interim ruling as i understand there's. poland likely to accept it there's no appeal beyond easyjet is a no no this is only that said the interim decision until you know it's like in every cards you need to have some time to have to fool information or fool explanation off the decision so this just a disciplined nation will be done in the next few weeks. i do not think that there will be other decision and they say yes you are your rights poland cannot appeal from this so we can be sure that this decision will be made ballot what happens it poses no. do you think poland would do it i think there were there was more say well we are absolutely unhappy with this maybe you know put it down nowadays because now we have elections on the local level in the next two days and then anothe

critics say is aimed at replacing them with people more supportive of the current regime the european court of justice says all of the people who lost their jobs under the ruling must be reinstated potence says it will appeal the controversial law had already come into force here at the country supremes court in warsaw many of the twenty seven newly appointed judges began their work just days ago before the e.c.g.'s ruling holt's the forced retirement of judges with immediate effect and reverses the retirement of those already forced to leave their posts speaking in brussels the polish prime minister said warsaw would consider its response. but the justice minister signaled poland would accept the ruling. as receive we are part of the european union and we will respect the e.u. slow so much so far i only know about this ruling from media reports that we will analyze the decision and then make a statement poland is a strong member state of the e.u. and we will honor. the president of poland supremes court malgorzata gas doff refused to step down when the government tried to force her to retire. passive

of hide nitrogen oxide levels in some regions that's why several german cities have threatened to ban older diesel vehicles the european commission has also taken action in the european court of justice to force germany to comply with the pollution limits that have been binding since two thousand and ten. in other european countries governments are already thinking about restricting diesels in cities or banning them altogether. make sense of all this is within the story and i didn't really go from the german environment association now thank you very much for joining us in the studio do you think from your board a few from your organization's point of view do you think this is a viable agreement do the government's plans go far enough no i wouldn't say this is definitely not a breakthrough i mean the agreement consists on two pillows first of all car owners can get a discount for if they exchange the old car into a new one but we had that in the past and it didn't work out what we need and that is what all the experts including the german e.p.a. the says we need a retrofitting of hardware in the consisting cars but this is only a little part of the agreement we saw today is this all

there have been reports today the government is willing to degree -- agree the european court of justicem brexit as of this would be inconsistent with the previous commitments to be denied. mr. speaker: prime minister. prime minister may: i would say i haven't seen those particular reports. i see quite a few reports about claims about brexit. if they are as he suggested, they are wrong. we have a clear particulars. -- we have been clear in the work they have been doing in the future, the european court of justice does not have jurisdiction. >> thank you, mr. speaker. this week's quality committee report on sexual harassment in public places the use of mdas , recommended, bearing the brunt of budget cuts to services. the quality is stalling in this government. how is the prime minister going to address this? mr. speaker: prime minister. weme minister may: can i say do see women with greater opportunities today. we see more women in the workplace and we see crucially through the work we have been doing on the gender pay gap and requirement on companies to report on gender pay that we are s

the european court of justice has ordered poland to suspend the lowering of retirement age.protests when it came into effect which means judges will have to retire when they turn 65 unless exempted by the president. it says the reforms make the court more efficient. he was convicted in 2016 of encouraging support for the so-called islamic state group and radicalizing young people through his terror network. he served less than half of his 5.5 year sentence and now under strict supervision. ut korea has suspended a joint air defensee exerc part of diplomatic efforts to encourage north korea to give up nuclear weapons. it was agreed after defense secretary james mattis met his south korean counterpart on friday. hundreds of migrants from denduras broke through a b barrier in guatemala today as riot police try to keep them from advancing into mexico. members of the caravan were seen scaling fences an opassing babirhead through the crowd. mexico beefed up its police presence along the southern border after president trump threened to use military for to completely close the u.s.

this is the reason why the european court of justice decided to immediately stop this reform. and to freeze everything and say we cannot go like this, because independent judiciary is basic of every european democracy. phil: this is an interim ruling as i understand it. it is poland likely to accept it? there is no appeal beyond the court is there? >> this is only an interim decision. you will need to have some time to have full information or full explanation of the decision. this explanation will be done in the next weeks. i do not think that there will be other decisions. you are right, poland cannot appeal from this, so we will be sure that this decision is made valid. phil: what happens if poland says no? >> do you think poland would do it? i think they will more say, we are unhappy with this. nowadays we have elections at the local level in the next two days and another in the next two weeks. they'll maybe push back a little -- push down the talks for a little, but later they will keep to the decision. otherwise they have to pay a lot of money, which as a fee for the cour

court judges into early retirement more than twenty judges were forced out of their jobs after poll and introduced an age gap of sixty five triggering international condemnation and widespread protests european court of justice ruled that judges must be reinstated to their positions for a time it's a part of sweeping reforms introduced by the country's conservative government. to macedonia now the parliament has formally approved constitutional changes which allow it to change its name to the republic of macedonia eighteen members of the hundred twenty seat parliament voted for the change off the days of debate which could open the way to entering nato and the e.u. a change and a long running dispute with greece. it says it has an ancient claim to the name macedonia and has been blocking its neighbors membership applications we keep founder julian assange is suing ecuador the nation that has given him sanctuary in its london embassy for the past six years songes filed a lawsuit in the south american nation after new terms were drawn up requiring him to pay for medical bills and phone calls and to clean up after his pet cat is taking legal action against ecuador in farming is still was a valentia last year ec

will no longer send money annually to the european union, we will take control of our borders and there will not be jurisdiction of the european court of justice in this country, the free movement will end and protect jobs and livelihoods and protect the european union of the united kingdom and that is in the national interests and what the government has proposed. >> order. >> wednesday at 7:00 a.m. eastern on c-span two or sunday night here on c-span. c-span.orgo go to and find video of past prime minister's questions and other british public affairs programs. thehis week on communicators, university of pennsylvania annenberg school for communications professor joseph touro on web privacy issues. >> most privacy policies are not designed to protect your privacy. they are designed to give you or at least the lawyers an idea of the kind of information the company can use about you or share about you. if you go to a retailer, say target, or walmart, they will tell you that they use just everything, they use your information, share parts of your information, and even by information about you that will ent the complem information they have. >> wa

parents don't make headway with authorities in banja luka they say they will turn to the european court of justice now it's been called the new space race billionaires competing to explore the universe with their own space flights now the ideas of people like you and me could buy a ticket to the galaxy and back if you have enough money that is but how do we get from here on earth up there while one company's planning a spaceport in a little town in southern italy to catapult space shuttles into the cosmos from the heel of italy's boot all the way into the void. toronto google tahlia is a sleepy little airport it has no commercial airline service the check in counter sit idle. why they're numbered ten to sixteen is anyone's guess as no other counters exist i still antonio vassili has big plans for his airport. we're thinking about doubling capacities here because we can't keep up with the demand for this. this is going to talia's latest vision for the future space travel. from here space shuttles would carry wealthy tourists into the cosmos. and the company planning to do this is virgin galactic th

court judges into early retirement more than twenty judges were forced out of their jobs off to poland introduced an age gap of sixty five triggering international condemnation and widespread protests european court of justice ruled that all the judges must be reinstated to that positions forced retirements were part of sweeping reforms introduced by the country's conservative government. when asked the us for thousands of prisoners in california could seek parole under a new system focusing on nonviolent offenders seven life sentences the controversial so-called three strikes law in place in twenty eight states means many people convicted of three relatively minor crimes of automatic jailed for life but as rob reynolds reports the kind that has changed since the mill was brought in twenty four years ago. three strikes and you're out the term taken from the american sport of baseball has been the life behind bars for thousands of nonviolent repeat offenders in california studies indicate nonviolent inmates imprisoned under the law which was enacted in one nine hundred ninety four are disproportionately black and many are mentally ill some are serving life sentences for offenses as trivial as shoplifting ste

send money annually to the european union, that we will take control of our laws control of our borders, and , there will not be jurisdiction of the european court of justice in this country. the free movement will end, and also protects jobs and livelihoods and projects the union of that united kingdom. that is in the national interests and what the government has proposed. mr. speaker: thank you. order. [inaudible conversations] on : we leave the british house -- announcer 1: you have been watching prime minister's questions from the british house of commons and watch sunday -- 9:00dical eastern eastern on c-span. go to c-span.org and find video of past prime minister's questions and other british public affairs programs. ♪ announcer 1: "washington journal," live every day with news and policy issues that impact you. monday morning, washington examiner political reporter al weaver and jams fitzpatrick talk about how congress leaders might change after the midterm elections. maya mcguiness of the committee for responsible federal budget on fiscal policy and the growing federal deficit. watch "washington journal live at 7:00 eastern monday morning. join th

and they have been very clear in the work they have been doing in the future, the european court of justice does not have jurisdiction. >> this week's quality committee report on sexual harassment, the use of mdas recommended, bearing the brunt of budget cuts services. he quality is stalling in this government. how is the prime minister going to address this? >> it is not what she said out, we see more women in the workplace and we see crucially the work on the gender pay gap and requirement on companies to report on gender pay but we see action being taken to that and the take-up over the years has been coming down and i absolutely take seriously the issue of sexual harassment in the workplace. it is important anybody in any workplace is able to be treated and feel they are treated with respect and dignity and action is taken to ensure that we eradicate sexual harassment and bullying in the workplace. >> there henry bellingham. >> does the prime industry agree with me when veterans are investigated by military authorities they should never be handed over and less there is overwhelming evid

british people that would ensure that we would enter the movement and jurisdiction of the european courts of justicest amounts of money to the every year.on agricultural policies, common fisheries policies, but to protect the integrity of the union of the united kingdom -- that is a proposal that i believe is good for the u.k., but also would be good for the european union. tom? >> thank you, prime minister. past 24 hours, if you don't mind me being a little blunt about this -- >> you have been blunt before, tom. >> you have angered brexiteers, you have angered remain ners, and you appear to have angered your leaders by not bringing forward any concrete proposals, and they even met without you last night. these were always going to be tough negotiations and they were going to be tougher before we got to the closing stages. yes, there are some difficult issues that we are still working through. crucial among those is this issue about the northern ireland backstop, making sure we can provide for a solution, which is not the solution that was produced by the european commission initially, which would h

european court ofjustice. when limited role by the european court of justice. ip is, the less of a state or no say, the ec] will have. but european negotiators are in mind that we need a deal anyway with the european union because they think it is to the uk's economic advantage. and the ecj role will have to be bashed out like everything else after brexit day. i am going to tease our viewers because they need to listen to your brexit podcast if they want more because you are then everything brilliantly. loads of stuff on brexit obviously and loads on food. cake. we got you eccles cakes, local ca kes, cake. we got you eccles cakes, local cakes, but i am told they look better in threes so i took one!” love cake! do you think that eccles ca kes love cake! do you think that eccles cakes will be subject to any form of eu... will brexit deals is that eccles ca kes ? eu... will brexit deals is that eccles cakes? you always laugh but these other questions i get asked. will it affect the amount of goods we have in our supermarket and the cost of food in a supermarket aft

parties which defined brexit as leaving the market, leaving the customs union, and leaving the european court of justice. the principle remain party, the liberal democrats actually saw its numbers of votes fall. since then, the government has published its most disappointing chequers agreement. setting out the proposals for the future uk/eu relationship. this document, however, fails to deliver the conservative brexit manifested pledge in anything but now. it's even opposed, and i quote by the eu's chief negotiator, a former president of the dutch customs association as expressed his dismay the plan does not even explain how cross border value added tax would be handled. it is completely unacceptable and i will vote against it. the paper proposes that the uk remains as if in a quote, "combined customs territory" with the eu alongside a commitment to a common -- trade and goods this would see the uk collecting tariffs apart from the eu and worst bound to european rules on all goods including food an agricultural products. in common rule is a complete misnomer. it's nothing but the european rule. over whi

your rules, not ours they're adjudicated upon by the european court of justice. super dan is a real opportunity, very interesting if you list zwroen what the chancellor was saying on the "today" program this morning he was saying the obstacle is the border how do you deal with the irish border question? so the government should deal with that which the e.u. has rejected nkts is it time for someone else to lead the party in. >> no, it's rhyme for the prime minister to stay >> finally, sir, do you believe the e.u. given the aftermath of soltzberg, do you think things has taken a wrong attitude in the negotiations >> to be fair, you're absolutely clear that chequers had parts that didn't work, the common rule book and the customs arrangement were things that he had said were impossible from the e.u.'s point of view some time ago and i think he's been absolutely clear your interlock cuetism is tough. >> finally, if he does reach a deal based something along the lines of chequers, you and the group, the rg, would vote against? >> i would vote against and so would many

we would be out of the european court of justice. position we could negotiate that long—term relationship that we will not get to start negotiating properly until after we have left. that has always been the eu‘s position. they will not discuss it in detail until we have actually left. in the eee a we would be able to have that position and the truth is that there are probably 200 conservative mps who would support that, labour, even maybe the snp might support it, it just seems to me that what the prime minister needs to find a way to do is to admit that the approach that she has been following has not been successful. she has all good faith and attempting it but it not succeed. she will not secure a majority at the house of commons. moved to a position that does take us moved to a position that does take us out of the eu, delivers the result of the referendum and get a clear majority in parliament. what happens if she doesn‘t do that? clear majority in parliament. what happens if she doesn't do that?” think ultimately parliament wil

wrong, we have been clear in the work we have been doing about insuring in the future the european court of justicehis? can i say, the position is not as she has set out in her question. we do see women with great opportunities today. we seek more women in the workplace and we seek, crucially, through the work we have been doing, for example, on the gender pay gap, we are seeing action being taken in relation to that and that's pay gap has been coming down. cani that's pay gap has been coming down. can i also say to her, i absolutely ta ke can i also say to her, i absolutely take seriously this issue of sexual harassment and bullying in the workplace. it is very important that anybody in any workplace is able to be treated and feel they are being treated with respect and dignity and action is taken to ensure that we eradicate sexual harassment and bullying in the workplace. does the prime minister agree that when veterans have been investigated by both military and authorities whether they should never be... i'd like to thank the prime minister for heran like to thank the prime minister for her an

of hide nitrogen oxide levels in some regions that's why several german cities have threatened to ban older diesel vehicles the european commission has also taken action in the european court of justice to force germany to comply with the pollution limits that have been binding since two thousand and ten. in other european countries governments are already thinking about restricting diesels in the cities or banning them altogether. makes sense of all this is within the story and from the german environment association now thank you very much for joining us in the studio do you think from your board if you from your organization point of view do you think this is a viable agreement do the government's plans go far enough no i wouldn't say this is definitely not a breakthrough i mean the agreement consists on two pillows first of all. owners can get a discount for if they exchange the old car into a new one but we had that in the past and it didn't work out what we need and that is what all the experts including the german e.p.a. that says we need a retrofitting of hardware in the consisting cars but this is only a little part of the equipment we saw today is this all a storm in a teac

the single market, excluded from cost dems and trade deals with the uk and subject to the european court of justicee uk and subject to the european court ofjustice make education is in northern ireland, is totally u na cce pta ble to education is in northern ireland, is totally unacceptable to us. all we are saying to her is, on your promise that you have made time and time again to the people of northern ireland in the house of commons and publicly, and we will stand by the agreement we have with you. break that promise agreement no longer stand. there have been a lot of suggestions today that the prime minister has sugar—coated pill as far as you're concerned but the truth of the position was actually revealed in the talks with michel barnier were the reality was revealed, is that their destruction? it is. michel barnier was absolutely brutal as far as the eu side was concerned, he made it quite clear that he did not care what the impact was on the unity of the united kingdom. he was only concerned that northern ireland would stay within the single market and that northern ireland would be exclud

would be inside the european economic area, outside the european economic area, outside the european court of justiceea, outside the european court ofjustice, outside the common agricultural policy. in the common agricultural policy. in the limbo transition, we would still be inside them. we would be paying less because eea states pay less. and there would be free movement of people and many leave voters would say they voted leave to stop that. there would be free movement of people in the transition period, we are both talking about interims, staging posts to the final deal where we will be free of things like free movement of people. she has one proposal which is very expensive and does not release us from any of our obligations of eu membership, the alternative proposal of going to a position like norway, halfway out of the eu, substantially cutting our contributions and it would not extend free movement for any longer than she is already proposing. thank you for talking to us, unhappy conservative mp this morning. annita mcveigh is in the bbc newsroom with a summary of the rest of the day's news.

jazeera live from doha also ahead the international court of justice calls on the us to lift some of its sanctions on iran plus. i have treated the european union with nothing but respect the united kingdom expects to say.