we should also remember about the fact that european union did not approve the presidential election.e won on 9th aweing last year. right now european leaders are meeting with leaders. he's not handling the situation in a good manner. so he's sending those good people. >> will he prevail? will he bruce any suffering of the line. which were aimposed in june and so on? >> i think that there's still lacking off -- that that's in the european union. >> personally, i don't see here any area of discussion because we should not discuss anything with terrorists. in this case, i don't see any -- any area to discuss it in the normal way as we do. and for example. european down downon. >> let me bring on victor because you had something to comment on, didn't you? your analysis, basically that this will backfire on mintz? >> it actually makes belarus a singular loser in this situation because first of all there's little chance to put it mildly that the european union is going to soften the sanctions regime that it introduced against belarus fold -- following the last election as this migrant cris

and i've always said that the european union is much more similar to you because lobby that a few nice states of america on top a week on the stable on democratic international body like you're been union with its own military force. and they determination to be belligerent. now look, i'm going to say this job. you know, i don't agree with the russian government. i don't like vladimir putin, but i have to say it takes 2 to tango. and i think we've seen in georgia and ukraine. the danger of your foreign all is a tremendous thrice, such as this place now in, in poland. salaries i think is incredibly dangerous. ok, let's go to john. an admiral, i'm, well, since russia has been brought up, i mean, in the current draft of this, you know, the strategic compass for europe document. russia is not even mentioned, which is really quite interesting. i mean, what i draw from that is that the morale know is that if he throws russia into the mix of we mixed reactions to how to proceed. russia as a threat or a friend or something in between here. i mean, this is the whole reason why we're doing this

the european union was opposed. right. and so when you were talking about good faith actors in the world, you've got to remember the european union as a solid track record of the solar state. when it comes to international diplomacy. i solid track record of winding up european complex. admittedly, along with vladimir putin as well, i've actually track record of opposing people intervening to prevent genocide. you know, do you want these guys to be the key decision maker on the safety and security in your i would say no. okay, well the talk about decision makers, john, i mean it who ultimately defines what a threat is and who'd ultimately know defines go in taking action against the threat. i mean, who are these people? i'm elected bureaucrats. go ahead, john? well, and it's the, the r annuity bureaucrats oversee the boast of the near support of emanuel macaroni in particular, and also the anglo medical. she's no longer offers. these are the cry, movers of this initiative and always have been. but we have to understand, and

constitutional court in poland that key elements of the european union's laws are not compatible with�* constitution. this is a serious matter, ursula von der leyen, the head of the european commission says this really calls into question the foundations of the european union, it is a direct challenge to the unity of the european legal order. what you say to that? yes, indeed, some brussels politicians are saying this and this actually brings us back to what we have been discussing before. we have solid and firm commitment to remain of the european union the one we agreed and the treaty there is one basic principle, the principle of conferral. which means if there are some conferred upon the union then obviously the union can act in this regard. but also there are some that remain at the sole responsibility of members. 0ne one of those is organisation of the judiciary. we are having our debate and some people trying to expand the confidence effectively without changing international law. they want to transfer the union into one superstate. no, no no, no, no no. (crosstalk). we believe

so what all is doing, we are protecting the european union. we are protecting it. so i think that should be stressed out. and also why doing it? we should also remember about european union did not approve the presidential election. it went to one my team on the 9th of last year. so right now your opinion leaders are meeting with, i'm not right. so the question. # really is handling situation in a with monitor so he's just sending those people to the well will he prevail? will his policies produce any softening of the you line or all back of the sanctions which were imposed in june and so on. i think that they're still lacking off the convoys from the european union about you know, personally i don't hear. # any area discussion because wish not discuss anything with it. so in this case, i don't see any, any, any or young to discuss it in a normal way. ask you in, for example, your opinion, let me bring in vix. if you had something to comment on didn't you about that your analysis, victor? is that basically this will back foreign minsk? well, it actually makes bill

if fortune has been a very mild autumn, but european union has also aces to play. one of them would be to refuse the entry or aircraft which, which bring migrants to minsk ah, ban them from the europe in union or another would be to stop the export of potash, refined or none of the things that exports european union. and therefore, is a game is a poker game. lucas shanker was saying that also if he cuts the transmission of oil from, from your mouth in northern russia, he will lose revenue as well because be roast ends, revenue from late, the transport or that, or from of gas, from yamaha to the union. so therefore, it's the 2 sides. he will, he will have his card on the table. we can do damage to europe in union. european union can say, right, we can do some damage and somebody is going to work out who's going to lose more. and remember, lose more shoot, in fact, to note. but if he cuts off the field for him, and that also puts russia in a tough position, doesn't it? well, they will lose. they will lose revenue because they, a lot of oil goes through a lot of gas, g

we should also remember about european union did not approve the presidential election. it was one my team on the 9th of last year. so right now, you know, a leaders are meeting with i'm not right. so. # really it's not handling situation in a with monitor, so he's just sending those people to the well will he prevail? will his policies produce any softening of the you line or all back of the sanctions which were imposed in june and so on. i think that they're still lacking off the convoys from the european union about you know, personally i don't see here. # any area discussion because wish not discuss it with there are so in this k i n, n a n e are young to discuss it in a normal way. ask you in, for example, your opinion, let me bring in vixen. you had something to comment on, didn't you about that your analysis, victor, is that basically this will back fire on minsk? well, it actually makes bill or was a singular loser in this situation because 1st of all, there is little chance to put it mildly that the european union is going to soften the sanctions regime. that it

let's remind ourselves something about the european union. european union, consistently size. that is prevented war in europe. what a load of rubbish. there's been a war. new crime has been a war in georgia. there's been the collapse. i'll be because lobby and always remember when picture the america, we're talking about intervening in bosnia, the european union remained solid in the states. it was, it wanted no action to be taken when the largest genocide, 2nd world war was taking place. and then when pitching came in to defend the cost of ends, i guess the aggression of serbia, specifically slot with the last page. the european union was opposed. right. and so when you were talking about good faith actors in the world, you've got to remember the european union as a solid track record of the solar state. when it comes to international diplomacy. i solely try quick hold of winding up your appeal conflicts. admittedly, along with vladimir putin as well, i've actually track record of opposing people intervening to prevent genocide. you know, do you want these guys to be the key

and this is redolent over european union that is no longer fit for purpose as if it ever was. and it does not really, you know, for them that need to know is seen as a us. i us project european project, but i was told i didn't go further than that. i would go further than that. my aunt human chase with this i think actually when you were talking about the disastrous intervention in libya, when you're talking about the disastrous intervention, the rock, isn't they stone to make things worse? not better, because at least nato was interested in channel. sorry, european security. what does this is about european flip your flexing, it's muscle. it wants to be a superpower. that doesn't bother me. particular. but the fact that the weight it will, the weight will generate its reputation as a superpower. if intervene militarily its neighbors or not could make what has been a disastrous period for foreign policy even was when you know, we have to wonder, you know, if there is a problem, many european union country are that those people of that country get a wealth in a welcome german tr

and also why we should also remember about the european union by team online last year. so right now you're, you're arguing with people. i'm not right, so. # really it's not happening in a minor just sending those poor people to their will he prevail with his policies produce any softening of the e. u line or role back of the sanctions which were imposed in june and so on. i think that there's the lack of the common lawyer into your opinion about you know, personally, i don't hear any discussion with there is. so in this case i don't see any or young to be in a normal way in for example, european union. let me bring in vixen because you had something to comment on. didn't you about that your analysis, victor? is that basically this will back foreign minsk? well, it actually makes bill or was a singular loser in the situation because 1st of all, there is little chance to put it mildly that the european union is going to soften the sanctions regime. that it introduced the guest bill that it was following last year's force for the elections. and so if man's care, then you d

i mean, this is early cert and critical development of the idea of the european union. and looking back to history, to our personal history in germany and europe, europe was divided into 2 parts until the 1989. and we all have overcome this. that i impossible situation historically speaking, impossible. and now, 30 years later, we are considering, or some of the politicians in europe are considering to build up a new world for whatever purpose and they're buy ever but which, which ever causes that to be justified. but this is a completely unnatural situation to divide a continent into 2 parts. we should rather try it because they put it another way. is it an idle threat or do you think it could happen soon? because of course, time is not in anyone's side here on this board or at the moment it's certainly not a short term solution. is it? it's right. i mean we're building a wall is that it takes time. of course it takes money. but now the european politicians are discussing how to get the money and whether or not they should afford the money and then it must be planned.

and again, this is exactly what would have his sign out to want to join the european union in 2004, quickly becoming europe's favorites. prodigal son accused over the years of all possible sins against democracy. how does the orb and government feel about its place? and future in the european family. well, to discuss that i'm now joined by hon. grace, minister of foreign affairs and trade. there is here though, it sounds great to see you again. thank you very much for the time. now you heard me referring to that folk wisdom about not putting everything under one hat, but i know that there is another saying in the hungarian language is kind of been advised about stretching. only as far as your blanket goes and i think the hungarian blankets, so to say goes pretty far these days, your freakin guests and russia. you have a solid relationship with china and many other countries. but it says that in the european union, your home, your family, your country is still treated a little bit like on foreign terrible. why do you think that is a little bit? you know, there's a big debate in the european

in fact, the, for anything, the european union or specific european union countries are likely to introduce even crusher sanctions against the misc. at the same time, ah, and so the question arises, is this is the economic and political damage wars. the information campaign that bill says, waging the up again, the campaign that's, that's a question for the bill. russian authorities to answer. but there is another interesting winner in this situation. and that's in the way russia because as the economic for shows of billows, decline because of man's position towards this crisis, including this crisis. so does the russian influencing economic influence in, in billers increase? because bill was, has to get the resources that it was getting from the e u a through the 2nd relations with you countries, it has to somehow get, it seems to get those resources from somewhere else. and basically look shanker at this point. can point, can ask for those sources in russia and to some degree in china with which villa was, has a fairly good, but it could save pretty good relations. and of course, the main

the treaty of the european union.— masters of the treaty of the european union. massive l the neighbourhood, massive tensions with moscow, massive tensions with moscow, massive tensions with moscow, massive tensions with minsk as well, with belarus and huge tensions with belarus and huge tensions with brussels. whereas poland's home? ., h with brussels. whereas poland's home? ., �*, ., , with brussels. whereas poland's home? ., �*, ., home? politt's home is an transatlantic _ home? politt's home is an transatlantic community . home? politt's home is an| transatlantic community as home? politt's home is an i transatlantic community as part of the european union, of course, but also there are not only good guys around europe. —— poland's home. and is why that poland is not only a very solid member of the european union but we have somehow better knowledge of what is going on in belarus, ukraine, russia, and we can be a kind of warning, this is what we are doing. polish prime minister, mateusz morawiecki there, speaking to our europe editor katya adler. a volcano on

policy of the european union. because as marcus is pointed out, here is a process is basically just dropped the bone because, you know, they're not particularly happy with the holes in the 1st place right now for a lot of other internal union issues here. so it really kind of puts them in a bind and then we, we have the european union trying to communicate to russia to communicate bear with the russian, things that are problem. it's your problem and look a shank and say, well let's talk but they don't want to. i mean it's, it shows the weakness of the european european union foreign policy, immigration policy, even leadership here, because this can be resolved because we do have an example that maybe go err on. okay. i mean, they're willing to talk to turkey, not a member of the european union about legal immigration, but they're not willing to talk because what are they too proud? go ahead. right, well i think there are, there are 2 lessons to, to learn for the europe from the crisis and anything so far they have

and you know, in the european union, we have the so called shang and zone. once you cross the external body of the you, you can move around the european union without passports without visas, without any checks whatsoever. for this system to work. the external perimeter has to be controlled, you know, the countries have visas. countries said have the right to regulate who comes in and who doesn't. but of course, there should be these receptions centers at the border crossings where people should be able to apply for asylum. so how, how do you see this crisis being resolved? the polish government has said, is experiencing what is called a hybrid war and led by beller, bruce and russia. is that a view also shared by the european commission in brussels where you are? and if so, how then do you resolve it? yes it is. the president of the commission has given strong public support to from texan to poland in protecting the e u. a border. and remember, lucas shinkel said publicly that he will give poland a hot nose as he put it. this is a deliberate operation to r,

the european union is stepping up sanctions against belarus. targeting airlines it says are trafficking migrants to the belarusian capital, minsk. and migrants are heading from that city to the border with poland. the european union is saying this. >> from now on, we will be able to sanction all pple according with their activities and the organization of these people from several countries going to belarus and from there to the european union. at the same time, we have agreed to an adoption of a new package of sanctions which will be finalized in the coming days. >> the pressure point in the story is the border between poland and belarus. thousands of migrant most of them from the middle east, have been stuck in freezing conditions, and at least eight have died from hypothermia. the situation escalated earlier when hundreds of migrants moved toward one particular border crossing. police, water cannons and razor wire reduced to stop people coming across the border. steve rosenberg was with them as they reach this border crossing. >> in the migr

because gus problem in russia are trying to pressure the european union. there are concerns russia, disputes with ukraine and other european partners could these lies in or just supply. russia provides about 45 percent of the european union, natural gas, ne, but demand is growing, and it appears russia can't or won't keep up. if the look at what is happening in terms of energy security and some fluctuations of energy. pro, prep provision of energy sources and just apply to some countries in europe for example. and as a bridge, i'm being able to deliver its natural gas to europe enables these countries, this consumers to access to alternative source of energy. european leaders, fear to energy crisis may get worse before it gets better, as john hope it will turn into an opportunity that will secure its rule in the market. so, you know, sort of back to us or by john now, a jury in the state of georgia has begun its deliberations and the highly charged armored aubrey mad at trial defense attorneys for 2 of the 3 white men charged with killing the black man. hav

the european union wishes to take the floor, i give the flow to the european union. thank you.t is no secret to this gathering that the european union would have wanted to go even further than the initial text in the cover text on coal. this is a consequence of our own painful experience with coal. we all know that european wealth was built on coal and if we don't get rid of cole, european death will also be built on coal. we know full well that coal has no future. and this is what we are working on with our own plans, to put an end to coal in europe in the foreseeable future. having said that, of course it will be no surprise to you that what was just read out to us is a further disappointment. not because we want to be right, but because we know the longer you take to get rid of coal, the more burden you put on a natural environment, but also the more burden you put on your economy because coal is not a smart economic proposition either. that is why we want to speed up the exit out of coal. having said all that, if i look at the conclusions we are going to be drawing today we

look, i am a passionate believer in membership of the european union for ireland.eople to leave the european union but, to me, britain has contributed a lot to the european union — and to europe more generally has an awful lot to contribute. we need britain — we need britain's heft in terms of the geopolitical situation globally and that is why i genuinely believe there has to be greater harmony and a really strong, constructive alignment of interests between european union and the united kingdom and then in terms of the british—irish relationship, it is a wonderfully rich relationship — in sport, in families, i mean, i have many cousins living in the uk. my uncle fought with the british army in world war ii, was a prisoner of war injapan for three years in the changi prison in singapore, when singapore fell. these are the kind of normal, natural ties between ireland and britain that have been there for decades and centuries so we do really, ithink, need to overcome this brexit challenge which has been a blip in all of that and move on. thank you very much. thank y

member states, european union members, they traded more. we china then the united states. so we have to take into consideration reality not to speak about the fact that the biggest threats are there in the world has been established in the east again. and 70 percent of all investment globally have been financed by eastern capital last year and only 40 percent by western capital. so. so these kind of hypocritical approach, which is unfortunately represented by the european union many times, hurts the european interest. and we as an integrated part of the european union, our interests are being hurted, as you mentioned, the united states. and as far as i know hungry didn't get an invitation to the upcoming summit of democracy. something by an administration is so eager to host. and in fact, hungry is the only e, remember to be sort of left out. and one of the 2 natal numbers does it hurts. i mean, you know, we are a country with a one falls and year long statement one, the falls and the are long christian statewood. our history is full of fights for freedom, liberty, and to

and again, this is exactly what buddha has sign out to want to join the european union in 2004, quickly becoming europe's favorites. prodigal son accused over the years of all possible sins against democracy. how does the orb and government feel about its place and future in the european family? well, to discuss that, i'm now joined by a hungry minister of foreign affairs and trade various here. i don't mean to say it's great to see you again. thank you very much. for your time now you've heard me referring to that folk wisdom about not putting everything under one had. but i know that there is another saying and be hanging language. is kind of an advice about stretching only as far as your blanket goes. i think the hungarian blanket to say goes pretty far these days. here are for some guests in russia. you have a solid relationship with china and many other countries where it says that in the european union, your home, your family, your country is still treated a little bit like on foreign terrible. why do you think that is a little bit? you know, there's a big debate in the european u

all right, so why are the migrate so motivated to cross into the european union? lydia, can you give us a perspective? this is something that you've been reporting on for quite a long time. yeah, so i right now i, i am back in greece, but a spent about a week on the poland, beller reporter on the, on the polish side. and i think that i, you know, this, this question is key because despite all the difficulties, ah, that have been reported widely at this point. ah, for refugees to be able to actually cross into the you through beller ruse. you know, people were stuck for for weeks. so some 4 or 4 months ago in freezing temperatures with little food, with, with no water. ah, with that, you know that without the basic get things that you need to survive. essentially there have been several deaths reported i, i was just seeing a, a headline from the guardian right before coming on this panel about a one and a half year old or one year old from syria that is reported was reported dead. i was there with the baby, was there with their family and, and has just died. and so

well, one clearly a european union is in a, it's in dire straits. in many ways it's an identity crisis, so to speak. who are we to europeans, what do we want to. busy deliver from our nation states to the super national level of the european union. what is actually, what are actually the borders of europe? i think this is what i should even say, historic conflict between russia and the rest of europe. so that is actually the question which need to be clarified and this you need to be need to be done in the intellectual way, of course, historians and all of that, but also primarily politicians. and there i think, to come down to the level of talking with each other, exchanging what is my national interest speaking as smith to put in or russia and what is the national so called national interest of europe. and i think a compromise is possible. whereas the barton's is one park, i think the real dividing line goes through ukraine. so therefore, i think to start out in bosnia and to find a solution to give in a little bit from all sides, will be a very im

the european union has called nicaragu an autocratic regime. astronaut has come the first chinese womano complete a spacewalk. she walked for six hours outside ina's space station alongside her colleue. the estimates performed tests and installed equipment. russia and the u.s. had the first women working in space back in 1984, the first all-female duo. that did not happen in outer space until 2019. back here on earth, the top leaders of china's ruling communist party are holding a key meeting that is expected to further tighten president xi jinping's grip on power. he is said to be laying the groundwork for an unprecedented third term in office that would cement his position as china's most powerful leader in recent history. ♪ reporter: president xi jinping has not left china for over 21 months, partly because of the pandemic, but also because he is focused on building his legacy. the party meeting is an opportunity to make it clear he is firmly in the driver's seat at home and abroad. >> the chinese people will never allow any foreign forces t

algae there is it stat larson has more now dramatic scenes here exactly at the gate into the european union. of course, these images are not going down well with many european so right now. and poland actually is accusing barrels of provoking this whole clash of riot that happened at the border crossing pointer 3 kilometers behind me. it started this morning. it's not clear exactly how and why it started. the poland sas said they were attacked basically by a migrant asylum seekers. it's not clear who they were, but people were throwing stones and also locks at the border and they were going for the border, trying to cross and poland polish border troops have responded really violently with the tear gas with the water cannons. what we also hear from witnesses on the scene is that it looked like people who are actually throwing of of stones and locks were covering their faces. so that's it. that's why it's not exactly clear who was doing that. it could be very well that migrant and asylum seekers have been used because these pictures, these images were exactly what many here think about ocean

they have a huge energy crisis in the european union. skyrocketing gas prices. if the simcoe were to turn the taps off, it would be a massive issue for the eu. they are going to have to walk down this type wrote -- tight rope of being firm on the issue, trying to have humanitarian angle and still have this all go well. the situation on the ground is so far removed from those conversations about gas and the international aspect of it. the people on the ground are in a difficult situation. >> thank you, jack. let's look at some of the other stories making headlines around the world. people have taken to the streets of warsaw. the annual march has attracted far right roots under the current right-wing government. this year's event past largely peaceful. the government of the czech republic has agreed to step down. the populist by minister said he submitted his resignation to the president. the allies lost last month's election. they already agree to form the next government. a court in hong kong has jelled a protester called captain america 2.0. he gained his nickn

the fir, the i european union, could accept her. ah lucas shank, present. look a shank as elegy ledger demise president. and then i'll look at shanker, could start the negotiation sir. are with the european countries just to defuse the crisis, and 2, ah, have a compromise and there, but russia actually, i would like her to say again, that these crisis is of 1st serious concern for, for russia and russia. russia actually has nothing to do itself with this crisis, but ah, it's a equity lee and say, sorry to interrupt. choose, been, rush has been quite clear in saying that it believes this is all actually been manufactured by western countries. so there is some antagonism there, plus as you pointed out, they could be compromised. alexander lucas, shank, a could do something like that, but he's not likely to. he's not that kind of guy and rusher. is happy to back him . ah, that is. that is not true. actually not, i mean, a, just look at the e o a year or so. sorry, back to 3 to 2 years. i'll look a shunt actually present. luca shanker is sir more ah say, ah, eur

but the european union, security and foreign affairs representative disagrees. he said that he doesn't see a risk of a conflict with by the roost. but what they do want to do now is once the airline situation, as we bought in the control, is to concentrate on the humanitarian situation. and we do understand that the european union, human rights commissioner, is on her way to poland, to head to that border table. make sure you keep us updated asset bag live for us in the border of poland and belarus. thank you. moving on now and e, u foreign affairs ministers, ad brussels will also be discussing recent developments into jan. it comes a day after general abdel, such a albert han shade, the 1st meeting of the new sovereign counsel that he appointed. it's been criticized by the un for excluding the recently asteroid civilian leadership. for more on the story, wrestle satta joins us live now from the capital cut soon. hello, there were still. what is the latest on the diplomatic efforts that we would just referring to? what protested describing as the military. kurt

to expect more from the european union, which is supposed to be a union of values rather than, you know, as cynical instrumentalists zation of the situation and saying that because this is bella bruce's, you know, orchestrated threat and we, we only need to focus on that and we don't need to look at our own responsibility for the suffering which is being experience turkeys, currency. the lever has hit a record low against the us dollar a day after presenter ship typo on defended his policy of shop interest rate cuts. many critics have called on to on to reverse cor size inflation source to nearly 20 percent. the currency has lost almost half its value this year. let's take a look at how we got here while presenter wants 1st decade in power from 2003 saw strong growth thanks to major investment in infrastructure drum forward to july 2016 after our fail school attempt. and the currency tumbled to 3 lears against the dollar. in august of 2018 us present. jo donald trump and imposed tires on feel an aluminum and the currency crash 20 percent. it had already fallen 40 percent the previous 12

and that is to cross into the european union. they would have given up everything sold everything wherever they had been before in order to do that, what necessarily have anything to go back to. and the other thing we simply don't know is how much and how far, alexander lucas shanker, is willing to go to press his ames in this crisis. so in easing of sorts, but certainly not the game out. there was a whole reporting live that from poland inside of the border with baler is joining many things. emilia says the rushing mediated cease fire with as a by john is mostly holding following violence. earlier this week. it was the worst flare up since fighting of the disputed. know, going to come back border region last year. well, the 6000 people were killed in that conflict. to do as robin for us here. walker reports nation tbilisi and they bring georgia official footage from armenian defense ministry shows strikes on what it claims were as a, by johnny armored vehicles in armenian sovereign territory. as a by john said armenia provoked t

they don't want to stain, bella rose, but all and doesn't let them into the european union, refusing to consider their asylum applications. at some point, almost everyone at the scamp lined up along the barbed wire fence over there, and people chanted open the border in a desperate attempt to bring attention to their plight. and i didn't take any immediate effect though, as the polish security forces stood still and just idly looked at these people through the layers of barbed wire. in a wall that humanitarian assistance is being haunted at a group of nobel prize winners of appeal, the institutions to take action to an open letter published on tuesday. they said, europe has no right to take their eyes off the tragedy demanding. the polish authorities allowed journalists and human rights organizations to, to enter the border area from the e. u side. next te shall, ado button ski with more on that side of the story. comes as the european council president shaw michelle is in war. so to have talks with the polish prime minister in a show of solidarity over what's happening at the moment

and we as an integrated part of the european union, our interests are being hurt. and as you mentioned, the united states, and as far as i know, hunger and didn't get an invitation to the upcoming summit of democracy. so they by the administration is so eager to host. and in fact, hungry is the only e. remember to be sort of left out and one of the 2 natal numbers does it hurts. i mean, you know, we are a country with a one falls and year long statement one, the falls in the are long christian statewood. our history is full of fights for freedom, liberty, and to or anything. and we don't need any external actor or factor to judge our, the state of our democracy. we are not, you know, students in the 4th grade in the high school to be prepared for you and it's unfair. it's unfair and easy if you're no human being, it should. huh. yeah, but i mean, you know, once again, we don't need a judge. we don't need to judge, we are absolutely aware of our situation. we are proud of our democracy, proud of our fights during our history for freedom. we are proud of the last 100

but it's also what the european union of the european commission as the driver off there's put as the top priority. and this bottom line, the russian business model that is massively dependent on having partners that are still willing to burn fossil fuel. of course, it is a transition matter and it's a question of how long it's going to take. but it will certainly change no mutual relationship between russia and the european union. if the queen and your changes the energy mix towards more renewables, quite fascinating as the story unfolds, that many people are thinking that the u. s. could step in and offer an alternative to supply for the europeans in case they decide to part ways with the russians. maybe banks will be seen whether the shale capacity and whether the americans will be able to fit in the gap and the void left by the bushes. if there is a split, a rick broke. now a hollow canadian. my, i really appreciate your insight. thank you very much. thank you to for what you can see the program again, any time by visiting our website. i'll just, you know, the call to further disc