the foreign office desk.you would hope though — foreign office desk. yes, you would hope though a _ foreign office desk. yes, you would hope though a risk— foreign office desk. yes, you would hope though a risk assessment - foreign office desk. yes, you would hope though a risk assessment of l foreign office desk. yes, you would i hope though a risk assessment of the scale at _ hope though a risk assessment of the scale at which a hostile power could take over _ scale at which a hostile power could take over a — scale at which a hostile power could take over a country where british troops _ take over a country where british troops are — take over a country where british troops are stationed and whether british— troops are stationed and whether british citizens, who might need evacuation, you would hope that some of that— evacuation, you would hope that some of that detail we get to the top, even _ of that detail we get to the top, even if— of that detail we get to the top, even if the report wasn't read and f

— inspires much faith in our foreign office is another matter.- inspires much faith in our foreign officedian also does _ office is another matter. okay. the guardian also does it _ office is another matter. okay. the guardian also does it lead - office is another matter. okay. the guardian also does it lead with - office is another matter. okay. the guardian also does it lead with the| guardian also does it lead with the same story. the headline, foreign office warned of rapid takeover by taliban. and i'm dugan had obviously was key in the questioning, bringing out this report. obviously he's got all the on ground experience himself. do you think that this is a row now. we've heard that rob is going to the region, talking to pakistan and other nations in the coming days. isn't the failure here to afghanistan a much longer term one? in the end the existing afghans, the success of afghan debate garnered huge level of support. pakistan has back the taliban, created the taliban as many other nations see for years. this is a very complex problem that the us, uk, western eyes failed to deal wi

i league, it is not the foreign office. .., league, it is not the foreign office. . office.oners and ambassadors and extraordinary capable people who are genuinely world—class and fantastic but when you see secure documents, or rather personal information, left in the embassy in kabul, when you see the senior civil servant remain on holiday at the moment of extraordinary foreign policy crisis, you wonder what matters to you? what is it that drives you? if you forgive me... what is it that drives you? if| you forgive me... politicians, most politicians _ you forgive me... politicians, most politicians have - you forgive me... politicians, most politicians have not - most politicians have not dedicated 30 years of their lives to a single institution, grown—up through it and taken on its values and orthodoxy and to me more shocking is the us foreign secretary. in to me more shocking is the us foreign secretary.— foreign secretary. in other words, foreign secretary. in other words. the _ foreign secretary. in other words, the senior - foreign secretary. in other words, the senio

yes, i have contacted _ with the foreign office here?ere? yes, i have contacted mps here. they i with the foreign office here? yes, i have contacted mps here. theyjust| have contacted mps here. theyjust say there is a scheme that has started, and this scheme hasn't started, and this scheme hasn't started but this is an urgent matter with the home office. but they can't do it with the scheme �*s carts, which i have no idea when that will be. —— untilthe which i have no idea when that will be. —— until the scheme starts. i have written a letter to the prime minister, but they say they have to stay where they are due to the attacks happening. you stay where they are due to the attacks happening. you written to the prime minister, _ attacks happening. you written to the prime minister, have - attacks happening. you written to the prime minister, have you i attacks happening. you written to the prime minister, have you had| attacks happening. you written to l the prime minister, have you had a reply? the prime minister, have you had a rel ? .

so i don't know what the foreign office is thinking. well, his handling of the crisis in afghanistan has really gone from bad to was in fact, he's now saying and advising that. anybody that still need to leave ask on a stone, would probably be better off, going to a neighboring country to try and return to safety. here in the united kingdom. however, of course, i easier said than done considering the taliban operating board checkpoints and really is putting a lot of trust in the taliban to uphold that side of the deal. allowing any safe passage to anybody that wishes to leave. it does come. of course, the britain promised that all you case citizens all u. k. nationals. i'm indeed all the, those assisted and the occupation assisted the british army and the occupation of the last 18 years would be able to return to the united kingdom. however, as the weeks and days then passed, many ministers in parliament was saying, not everybody would be able to get out. and now dominic rob, as we heard, is it missing? he has no idea how many british c

if that applies to the top civil servant in the foreign office, then it surely applies to the foreigniday in august and when this happened — that was it. i was doing 20—hour days. there is a sense that this is personal between you and dominic raab. it was heard, there was applause at the end of your speech and when he wound up the debate, it is traditional for ministers to praise. not a word. i apologised and i was not going to be there for the wind ups, so he knew i was not going to be there. i don't think it is personal. as you know, i've given a pretty hard time to three foreign secretaries now. i hope i am respectful of the office and the individuals. i have to say, i think dominic raab is a highly intelligent man who has demonstrated some very good judgment in some areas and, you know, in other areas, it is my job to challenge him. and if there were not that challenge function, that wouldn't be good for democracy. you mentioned you challenge previous foreign secretaries, not least boris johnson, with whom you've clashed repeatedly. you once said something very interesting, which

offices a scroll down. i agree, i think it is appalling. i, i do not believe that a foreign minister or a general or chief of police all the company would ever oh, should ever be away from the desk at a time of potential crisis. that is going to need a captain. steer the ship such a dominic, rob was away, but you know this and i'm not excusing it what, what i'm going to say now the problem in the foreign office has always been one of complacency. it's always been one of, well, it'll be all right on the day. and this also reluctance to get to involved the very keen on letting other nations, other governments take the lead rather than showing any initiative themselves. so the reason for lot is because on the foreign policy stage, if you like the quarterback stage, it's a very embarrassing thing if you make a mistake or if you upset another country. so there is a lack of courage and political will both ministerial level senior and secretary of state and junior ministerial level and throughout the, the, the entire civil service of the foreign commonwealth and development office.

but if that criticism applies to the top civil servant of the foreign office, it surely applies to thee stayed on his holiday, when your committee quizzed him about when he'd take his holiday and he refused to tell you! we were all on holiday in august. i'm sure you were. i was. and when this happened, you know, that was it, i was doing 20—hour days. there is a sense somehow that this is personal between you and dominic raab. you gave this very moving speech and it was heard in silence, there was applause after it, and when he wound up the debate it is traditional for ministers to praise the good speakers on their own side and there was not a word, you were not mentioned. many others were. i had texted him earlier and apologised i would not be there for the wind—ups so he knew i wasn't be there. i don't think it was personal. as you know nick, i've given a pretty hard time to three foreign secretaries now and i hope i am respectful of the office and individuals. i think dominic raab is a highly intelligent man who has demonstrated some very good judgements on some areas and in other ar

. �* , ., ., , what is going wrong with the foreign office? . �*, . ., , office?s a really good question because it - office? that's a really good question because it is i office? that's a really good question because it is quitej office? that's a really good i question because it is quite clear that, you know, you lift up the bonnet of the rolls—royce and not sure what the engineers but wasn't made in coventry. to use your analogy they may be wearing red shirts with are not your team. that shirts with are not your team. at the even in the premier league? i can most high commissioners and ambassadors and... extraordinarily capable diplomats who are genuinely world—class and fantastic but when you see secure documents of other personal information left in the embassy in kabul, when you see the senior civil servant remain on holiday at the moment of extraordinary foreign policy crisis, you wonder, what matters to you. what is it that drives you? i mean, if you will forgive me, politicians, most politicians, have entered do is make dedicated 30 years of their lives t

the international trade secretary and this trust is replacing dominant rob the foreign office and he has been moved to the justice department. let's get some reaction to this now. from a former home of his minister, no one baker had kindly joined me this evening to speak to norman. now, as i said, the racial was expected. has it gone down how you would have anticipated the surprise? and changes was clearly sensible that govern williams has been rooted education secretary, he was completely useless and it's also wrong. the doubling rabbit john from the foreign office given the failure i think, to deal with, against on any sensible and effective way. however, the trouble is we've, we've had a capital of the inadequate, at the moment because that does concern the party has refused to have people in the capital or on staff who don't believe impressions and eliminates a whole range of people who are quite challenges. and therefore, we've had people who been up a logical reasons rather than because they're really good at the jo. so we'll see what happens. but i don't think rob coach remain

what is going wrong with the foreign office?is quite clear that, you know, you lift up the bonnet of the rolls—royce and i'm not quite sure what the engine is but it wasn't made in coventry. to use your analogy, they may be wearing red shirts but they're not your team. they're not manchetser united any more. are the even in the premier league, the performance of the foreign office? i can list high commissioners and ambassadors and, extraordinarily capable diplomats, who are genuinely world—class and fantastic, but when you see secure documents of other personal information left in the embassy in kabul, when you see the senior civil servant remain on holiday at a moment of extraordinary foreign policy crisis, you wonder, what matters to you? what is it that drives you? the foreign secretary? 0n holiday as well. yes, but i mean, if you will forgive me, most politicians haven't dedicated 30 years of their lives to a single institution so what is more shocking is the pus. in other words, the senior official. can you imagine...? can

allison festival that was shed widely across international partners and certainly not the the, the foreign offices lead responsibility, but we've course planned accordingly. but the former head of the army has hit back at the foreign secretary over suggestions that thousands of afghans who are eligible to come to the u. k were left behind and the government were pre warned about the situation. other critics, including the shadow foreign secretary, blame raw for failing to live and for throwing the ministry of defense under a bus. the foreign secretary had 18 months to prepare, but was missing in action as a result on his watch, which has become weaker in the world and faces greater risks from terrorism. 45 senior officers, including myself, wrote an open letter to the government in july to say that a large proportion of british nationals and interpreters and other locally engaged civilians where at risk from the taliban. weird, great to generosity and speed because time was not on our side. the response to that was very disappointing. while a senior foreign office saw st says rob had been talking

of curtis dawn, was complaining to me that anytime he had something serious to discuss with a foreign office here in london, he was unable to speak to anybody but a junior desk officer. that is simply unacceptable. meanwhile, the u. k. foreign secretary has denied a claim in the us media that britain may have been indirectly responsible for getting a suicide bomber into common port last thursday. last happened at one of the airports entrances. when afghans waiting in line to be brought to be processed to fly out, at least 170 people killed. a pentagon document leak 2 political magazines suggest american ford, who's kept the apple. it's main gate, open the spot, knowing it was a prime target for terrorists. in order to let british personnel evacuate or u. k. foreign secretary says that allegation is just not true. while another government minister has accused us of indulging in a blame game. there is an underlying current of blame which is unhelpful. it's a distraction from the main efforts of what is happening on the ground. if the scale of this attack was known beforehand, old gate should h

well, a senior foreign office. so since this rob had been talking more broadly about the intelligence provided as denies rob was seeking to blame the m o. d. but other issues all like you to be raised by the committee. rob was on holiday is the afghan situation was unfolding and he returned only evening article fell from the taliban . rob also delegated a key telephone call to the afghan foreign minister to junior minister, a call, which didn't ultimately happen. and rob has blamed the home office to the lack of a plan in relocating african refugees. in other words, blaming to other departments and not his own foreign office. well, the daily mail has grounded the foreign secretary mister deluded. it could be an uncomfortable off today to dominate rob, under the spotlight of the select committee for any okay, i may have missed something, but i haven't had anybody in westminster or washington just put their hands up and say, sorry, we could have done this better. so i was bringing, i don't feel like a partridge thank

to be just the forest —— foreign office to bejust a the forest —— foreign office to be just a prime minister, a title not awarded since 2015. it was a good day forfour since 2015. it was a good day for four health ministers. dories is very happy to be the new culture secretary. also smiling, is a hurry who led the vaccine rollout. the former education secretary gavin williamson was among those to be sacked from the government completely. a widely expected move after he was heavily criticised for his handling of exams and schools during the pandemic. michael gove a minister known for getting things done is now in housing and communities, a key role in the levelling up promise. the reorganisation of the most senior ministers of cabinet is now done and it has been much more wide ranging than many had expected. attention will now turn to the more junior ministers. will we see as much change there?— ministers. will we see as much change there? the reshuffle has already started. _ change there? the reshuffle has already started. boris _ change there? the reshuffle has already starte

you mentioned there were 500 foreign office staff in the uk. i 500 foreign office staff in the uk. the hold-up. sorry, i want to answer your question _ that was the hold-up. sorry, i want to answer your question really - to answer your question really quickly. i am to answer your question really quickly. iam not to answer your question really quickly. i am not sure... the time ofthe quickly. i am not sure... the time of the processing, _ quickly. i am not sure... the time of the processing, in _ quickly. i am not sure... the time of the processing, in the - quickly. i am not sure... the time of the processing, in the last - quickly. i am not sure... the time of the processing, in the last two | of the processing, in the last two weeks where we spent desperately trying to get people out, how many foreign office staff were on the ground trying to process people? brute ground trying to process people? we peaked at 20, and of course just to be clear we absolutely need the front facing staff, but the decision making was via bsc do persist response team because you could get decision mak

while questions are being directed, mister rob, big questions need to be asked over the british foreign office. i don't believe that in the field of national security, defense, foreign affairs, the should be too much transparency. it's very important, for example, in the diplomatic discussions and negotiations. so you to be very tight about what's actually being said and done. but, but i think in this particular case, dominate, rob needs to be able to answer certain questions. and i, you know, the question is, can, when he was on leave, it's not particularly serious question in my mind. he should have been at his desk . i don't care when he went to lee, be sure to be know that he says, and if he was on leave, he should have got straight back from the lady's return. there's a systemic problem. deep seated systemic problem in the, in all foreign ministry on a foreign office. it came up the question, when was the last time a secretary of state visits specs done? well, probably never. and i know for a fact having worked across central asia for some years on a diplomatic level, on the international

i think is the foreign office up group? i think is the foreign office up to thejob? group? don't grasp that change and if it will sit out the town for the next few years. watching this very carefully is russia and china, there will be in jointly western demise and the growth of global of volunteerism.— and the growth of global of volunteerism. . ., ., , ., ., volunteerism. what do you mean when ou sa the volunteerism. what do you mean when you say the foreign _ volunteerism. what do you mean when you say the foreign office _ volunteerism. what do you mean when you say the foreign office isn't - volunteerism. what do you mean when you say the foreign office isn't up - you say the foreign office isn't up to thejob and you say the foreign office isn't up to the job and given that dominic raabis to the job and given that dominic raab is the man at the top? are you think he should go? i’m raab is the man at the top? are you think he should go?— think he should go? i'm saying that britain has become _ think he should go? i'm saying that britain has become to _ think he should go?

did you achieve a similar process for the foreign office? >> what i did was make sure that we had cover, a decent lotus system, we were pressing for an extension of the window. in which case, you need to make sure your team theater you are able to resort those properties but also make sure you can retake because otherwise you've got a greater risk. >> many would think that if all military leave was canceled on the 23rd of july it was a bad idea for yourself, the prime minister and other officials to take breaks at that time. i will leave it to that. >> thank you, chairman. [indiscernible] >> for a longer period of time. everybody knows what comes next. access to international monetary systems to put pressure on the taliban. how do you propose to do that? do you think that will have an impact on the afghan people? >> we've got to try. we have seen pressure. [indiscernible] we of course want to get humanitarian aid to those who needed host. the question about what kind of -- for countries, records to that. for example, refugees that went to ot

and liz truss becomes only the second woman in british history to take charge of the foreign office. ce. prime minister has put together a the prime minister has put together a strong and united team which is going to deliverfor the uk. we are determined to deliver on the people's priorities. a new pecking order, and a new phase as borisjohnson refreshes his team. more from laura in a short while about the political direction laid down by today's changes. also tonight... shamim begu who left the uk tojoin the islamic state now offers to help the islamic state now offers to help the uk's fight against terrorism. a report from one of afghanistan's biggest cities — on how taliban rule is having a profound effect on everyday life. and 14 goals in a thrilling night of champions league football. good evening. borisjohnson has reshuffled his government — making far more radical changes than many had expected — and set the government's direction — with a view to the next election. he's fired his education, justice and housing secretaries — and demoted others — as he reshapes his senior team.

a while ago. marriage with the foreign office a while aio. ., ., ., ., while ago., now— while ago. nadhim zahawi, the former vaccines minister, now education - vaccines minister, now education most are. a lot of spec versions of the future of gavin williamson for a while now but he's out? took a talk i think it was widely anticipated he would be going in this reshuffle, he had come under a lot of criticism for of exams in the summer of 2020, and has also made a number of gaffes, most recently appearing to mix—up having spoken to the rugby player maro itoje thinking he had spoken to the footballer marcus rashford. so these gaffes have not helped and it was widely anticipated helped and it was widely anticipated he would go in this reshuffle and of course he did. nadhim zahawi appears to be a bit of a rewards, he has been the vaccines minister before this, he was very much front and centre of the government's vaccine roll—out, fronting up some of the statements, some of the downing street news conferences, and it appears this is potentially better for award for nadhi

i have very strong matrix of work with a foreign office will pass that hello. well anyway, so i went, i had a what do you call it? and the audience with el presidente, where he lied through his teeth to me. and i actually went on the radio the next day and explained he did this thing. i was slightly passing on messages that i've had from student organizations saying why the military eyes militarized police out in the streets, murdering students, protesting against me, a liberal economics in this country. and pineda said to me that i have been searching 100 casualties in the projects around the universities and 1100 of them which the late and i feel f may wow, i look at that's how they do it. they do it with a smile. and it's obviously nonsense, you know, because they were quite a number of young people killed back in the day in 2012, as they have been recently, they shoot their eyes out now in santiago. and they've been printed, as you know, they're in protest all over south america. that's one of the things that encourages people like may to believes that ther

she was the international development secretary before that robber scrapped and brought into foreign officery. there been some other promotions this afternoon, nadhim zahawi has been promoted into cabinet, he is now the education secretary. has colic at the department of health, nadine dorries, she has also had a promotion into cabinet, she will now become the new cabinet secretary. other moves as well, some staying put, ben willis, the defence secretary, stays where he is. a move for steve bartlett, the chief secretary to the treasury, he now becomes the cabinet office minister, the chancellor of the duchy of lancaster. there is sajid javid, the health secretary, i think it would be extremely unlikely that they would be moving sajid javid in this reshuffle. he'sjust gone into downing street. steve bartlett, the former chief to the secretary has become the chancellor of the duchy of lancaster, taking overfrom michael gove, who was moving to the department of housing and community is moving to the department of housing and communities. quite a lot of movement in this reshuffle. it’s of movem

's and charities here to the foreign office with cases who needed to get out of. i've gone, his don went on and said, when ignored the shadow foreign secretary lisa 90 of the labor party says that she wants answers on things going back far further than the last couple of weeks suggesting that dominic rob had 18 months to prepare. knowing that that would be a u. s. withdrawal and had called him missing inaction. other pe, you say that he's unlikely to actually go even some in the labor party is saying that they're not calling faith resignation, but they want a major recognition that the initial involvement with us and us forces in afghanistan was misguided without an exit strategy and calls into question the way the u. k. should work in military operations in the future. okay, keep us updated on how that all unfolds. nadine barbara, joining us live at from london. appreciate them. thank you. morehead, on this news hour, including $300000000.00 a day for 20 years, will look at what the us spends on its longest war. israel eases restrictions in gaza, days after the hi

belittle —— belittle the work in the ministry of justice, the court backlog, but going from the foreign officeof the big offices of state to that, even if you added in the office of the deputy prime minister which we haven't heard for a while, let's see what it means in practice, it is, i'm afraid, a demotion. it’s what it means in practice, it is, i'm afraid, a demotion. it's been really interesting _ i'm afraid, a demotion. it's been really interesting looking - i'm afraid, a demotion. it's been really interesting looking at - i'm afraid, a demotion. it's been. really interesting looking at social media this morning and reaction to nadine dorries, her appointment as culture secretary. it seems a bit more might, people either love her in that role or a hater in that role. ., . , ~' in that role or a hater in that role. ., . , ,, ., ., role. correct, but i think again, this is a deliberate _ role. correct, but i think again, this is a deliberate strategy. i role. correct, but i think again,| this is a deliberate strategy. the government is also keen to pursue its agenda particularly on as it w

can ijust say to him that the coordination between the foreign office _ coordination between the foreignel as _ suggested those who had been cleared to travel as part of operation pitting — to travel as part of operation pitting would now have to undergo security— pitting would now have to undergo security checks before they were accepted — security checks before they were accepted onto the arap scheme? where there is— accepted onto the arap scheme? where there is checks not done, or is he now— there is checks not done, or is he now reneging on his promise? both those _ now reneging on his promise? both those scenarios are of concern. these — those scenarios are of concern. these are — those scenarios are of concern. these are practical issues within his gift. — these are practical issues within his gift, and the fact we have still not been — his gift, and the fact we have still not been dealt with sends a strong message _ not been dealt with sends a strong message that he has been more focused — message that he has been more focused in — message that he has been more focused in recent d

l required and i am sure that home office _ required and i am sure that home office lawyers, foreign office they have really looked at this carefully and they have decided that it _ this carefully and they have decided that it is _ this carefully and they have decided that it is perfectly legal. so we will see — that it is perfectly legal. so we will see what happens. whether it stops _ will see what happens. whether it stops the — will see what happens. whether it stops the flow of illegal crossings, i am stops the flow of illegal crossings, i am not _ stops the flow of illegal crossings, i am not sure it will. as stops the flow of illegal crossings, i am not sure it will.— i am not sure it will. as we head into autumn _ i am not sure it will. as we head into autumn and _ i am not sure it will. as we head into autumn and the _ i am not sure it will. as we head into autumn and the recent - i am not sure it will. as we head i into autumn and the recent period i am not sure it will. as we head - into autumn and the recent period of good weather and calm seas comes to an end, the number of mig

and liz truss steps into the foreign office. - afghanistan.teps into the foreign office. what - afghanistan. and liz truss steps i into the foreign office. what would the world need to know about her? liz truss, there was a white speculation she would be the person picked up that will afford secretary here. she does already have an international profile, she has been the international trade secretary has been overseeing those lot of those post—brexit trade deals of the less you're so, so she certainly has some brought some international recognition. she is popular in the party. a fairly colourful picture, it is fair to say, but quite a popularfigure among the it is fair to say, but quite a popular figure among the party here, so that is likely to be a reasonably popular appointment.— popular appointment. helen, stay there, as popular appointment. helen, stay there. as we _ popular appointment. helen, stay there, as we look _ popular appointment. helen, stay there, as we look at _ popular appointment. helen, stay there, as we look at some - pop

replacing her at the foreign office.net as the new culture secretary, she replaces oliver dabney becomes conservative party co—chair. those are all the changes. joining me now is lauren mcevatt, a former special adviser to the conservative government during david cameron's administration. hello to you. thank you for being with us. i was speaking tojustine, the former education secretary little bit earlier, saying that what brycejohnson seems to be doing is replacing a co. that cabinet with a leveling up cabinet. does that make sense? i leveling up cabinet. does that make sense? ~ . ., sense? i think gavin williamson was an appointment _ sense? i think gavin williamson was an appointment that _ sense? i think gavin williamson was an appointment that predated - sense? i think gavin williamson was | an appointment that predated covid. it took a lot of his failures happen during the covid era, and i think that's part of the reason why he has been moved. but i think his appointment at the education department is a very good o

my brother is a 30 year foreign service officer. he served in embassies throughout the middle east during his career. he is outraged by what happened and he resigned the administration last week because of it has nothing to do with politics. but having said that, i think that this administration is going to go down as the worst administration and going into the 2022 election. that's not good for any party, for your president to be put in that situation. and the democrats in congress are going to lose house and lose the senate accordingly. well, we'll continue that conversation there. thank you, doctors. and that's all the time we have to show. but i promise the conversation will continue to follow me on twitter as guardian use. like, always thanks for watching. ah, ah, ah, i don't know. i mean there are some steps in there were rescuing the food that they were not scabbing or were rescuing resources that are still good. this is best by march 21st which is in today's all these potatoes, paula daniels onions. all of these came from wa

. -- france 24 to say look at the woman who will take the top desk at the foreign office. >> she is theew face of british diplomacy. she is one of the key winners from the latest cabinet reshuffling in the u.k. she will be serving as the foreign secretary. she began her career in the business sector before she was elected counselor in the london borough. under david, she was added to the conservative party's a list, a list of potential candidates for tory seats. she quickly continued climbing the ladder, becoming international trade secretary in 2019. it's not to move on from brexit. -- it sawed to move on saught to move on from brexit. >> i support the prime minister's deal. >> she secured a series of deal since exit the knot with the united states. chino has a bigger stage to pursue boris johnson -- she now has a bigger stage to pursue boris johnson's vision. >> france's health professionals have a clear choice, either get a job by this wednesday or risk being suspended without pay. those doctors, nurses, and care workers who do not want to be inoculated are up in arms. this was the s

my brother is a 30 year foreign service officer. he served in embassies throughout the middle east during his career. he is outraged by what happened and he resigned the administration last week because of it has nothing to do with politics. but having said that, i think that this administration is going to go down as the worked administration and going into the 2022 election. that's not good for any party, for your president to be put in that situation. and the democrats in congress are going to lose the house and move the senate accordingly. well, we'll continue that conversation there. thank you, doctors. and that's all the time we have to show, but i promise the conversation will continue to follow me on twitter as guardian hughes. like always, thanks for watching. the me you know, one thing we don't talk about america is class or other countries from class war like re, britain is a prime example. but in america typically, you know, take step now. yeah. mainly cost involved the 3rd some focus bittman. no volunteer. got me. oh ye